What's the difference if gov't gets the ball rolling, or private enterprise?

If me spending my money is all that needs to happen to help the economy (and the greater good) - who the hell are you (in the general sense, of course) to dictate how I spend the money? The money is spent one way or the other - which is all you say matters - the paradox of thrift is not happening. Get your nose out of my wallet. And quit stealing my window by breaking it. And quit breaking other peoples windows and then forcing me to pay for it.


Hear; hear! Alas, some people will never understand this, it seems. Or, more likely, it best serves their agenda to pretend that they don't understand this.
 
It absolutely is too an option - by your own admission.

You are saying

A) I have X amount of money that needs to be spent.
B) It is better for the economy on the whole for me to spend the money
C) If I spend the money it will be a net benefit to me because I will stay employed and keep my house.

Mostly. Try C) if you and your neighbors spend your (joint) money, it will be a net benefit to all of you and you will all (be more likely to) stay employed and keep your house.


And D) If you and your neighbors do not spend the money, you will not stay employed and lose your house.


If all I need to do is spend the equivilant of a window to keep me employed and keep me in the house I'm better off not having to replace an intentionally broken window, but spend it on something else.

Well, you'll need to persuade your neighbors to upgrade their houses, too.

But, yeah, you've basically got it right. The problem is that people weren't doing that in large enough numbers, which is why the government needed to step in and use public money to do it, since the government can act on behalf of you and your neighbors.

Re-read the "paradox of thrift." And look up "public good" while you're at it.
 
Hear; hear! Alas, some people will never understand this, it seems. .

Yes. Rational people make a point of never "understanding" things that are blatantly wrong, if they can avoid it.

That's how you can tell them from Republicans.
 
Couple of different things here:

1) Cash for Clunkers was a net loss. It still did the job it was supposed to do. Cars were destroyed before they otherwise would have been and the new cars that were purchased would have been purchased in the future anyway. It did accomplish the purpose of getting people to buy cars right now however. Yes, those cars will not be bought in the future, but we might not need that economic activity as badly in the future as we need it now. It short, it cost money, and it worked.

2) If America has ever been caught in the Paradox of Thrift, it is caught there now. Banks are sitting on large amounts of money because they would have to be crazy to lend people money in this economy. Businesses are not hiring until consumer demand picks up since it is crazy to hire employees if there is no demand. And consumers are trying to cuts costs and save money since it is crazy to spend money needlessly if you are facing an uncertain employment future. Everyone is waiting for someone else to move, and so no one is going anywhere.
The whole point of the Paradox of Thrift is not that government knows what it is doing better than the individual. The point is that the best course of action for the individual is to save money, but if everyone does this, everyone is worse off than if they had all spent money. Rational individual behavior leads to an irrational collective outcome.
 
Well, you'll need to persuade your neighbors to upgrade their houses, too.

Replacing the window you intentionally broke to force me to spend my money is not an upgrade to my house. It's theft of my money and manipulation of where my money goes. And it does not leave me better off - I'm out the cost of the replacement window.

Re-read the "paradox of thrift." And look up "public good" while you're at it.

I don't need to. You're very clear what you mean. Me saving my money to spend later combined with other people saving their money to spend later amplifies an economic downturn. Since you're operating on behalf of the greater good you feel fully justified in forcing me to spend when and how YOU want by breaking my window.
 
I don't need to. You're very clear what you mean. Me saving my money to spend later combined with other people saving their money to spend later amplifies an economic downturn. Since you're operating on behalf of the greater good you feel fully justified in forcing me to spend when and how YOU want by breaking my window.

Stop strawmanning.
 
Replacing the window you intentionally broke to force me to spend my money is not an upgrade to my house. It's theft of my money and manipulation of where my money goes. And it does not leave me better off - I'm out the cost of the replacement window.
·
·
·​
I don't need to. You're very clear what you mean. Me saving my money to spend later combined with other people saving their money to spend later amplifies an economic downturn. Since you're operating on behalf of the greater good you feel fully justified in forcing me to spend when and how YOU want by breaking my window.


It gets down to a belief that government is more qualified—and has greater authority—to determine what is to be done with an individual's property, than that individual himself has over his own property. This is a primary defining distinction between a free society, in which government exists to serve the needs of the people; and an oppressive totalitarian state in which the people themselves are effectively slaves to their government.
 
It gets down to a belief that government is more qualified—and has greater authority—to determine what is to be done with an individual's property, than that individual himself has over his own property. This is a primary defining distinction between a free society, in which government exists to serve the needs of the people; and an oppressive totalitarian state in which the people themselves are effectively slaves to their government.
The US Constitution specifically allows government to tax people and use the proceeds for the common good. Are you suggesting the US needs to abandon the constitution in order to change it from the slave society it's been for the last 200 years to a "free one" that bit could have if everyone did what you told them?
 
The US Constitution specifically allows government to tax people and use the proceeds for the common good. Are you suggesting the US needs to abandon the constitution in order to change it from the slave society it's been for the last 200 years to a "free one" that bit could have if everyone did what you told them?

The Constitution also contains specific, narrow definitions of what this “common good” is, and what powers are legitimately delegated to the federal government. The Tenth Amendment forbids the federal government from expanding outside those narrowly-defined powers, and the Fifth Amendment explicitly prohibits the taking of private property for public use without just compensation to the one whose property is thus taken.

The vast majority of us who have been robbed to pay for the fraudulent “Cash for Clunkers”*scam will never receive any benefit therefrom, nor be in any way compensated for what was taken from us to pay for this scam.
 
The Constitution also contains specific, narrow definitions of what this “common good” is, and what powers are legitimately delegated to the federal government. The Tenth Amendment forbids the federal government from expanding outside those narrowly-defined powers, and the Fifth Amendment explicitly prohibits the taking of private property for public use without just compensation to the one whose property is thus taken.

The vast majority of us who have been robbed to pay for the fraudulent “Cash for Clunkers”*scam will never receive any benefit therefrom, nor be in any way compensated for what was taken from us to pay for this scam.

What is Begging the Question. (Also, I'm pretty sure a case can be made for indirect benefits and compensation, but I'm not going into that as proving it is a) murky and b) unreliable.)
 
The Constitution also contains specific, narrow definitions of what this “common good”

It also contains very specific, narrow definitions for who interprets what's in the constitution, these definitions do not include blogs or random internet posters, they most certainly do not include you. So I ask you again why do you object to the US Constitution and system of government?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom