People here are arguing the economy is better if my window is broken or better yet my house is burned down.
No, people are arguing that if the process of repairing your window or rebuilding your house fixes the economy, you can get a net benefit.
Obviously there are some tradeoffs here. The cost of your window is X; the benefit from not losing your florist shop and having your house repossessed is Y. If Y>>X, then having your window broken actually helped you.
Or are you really suggesting you would prefer to be living out of a refrigerator box looking at the still-intact window that the bank now owns?
And I'm the one guilty of the "broken window fallacy"?
Absolutely. The broken window fallacy is simply not taking into account both sides of the equation. "Normally" people forget about X, the cost of the window (more formally, the opportunity cost of the resources that went into fixing the window) but notice Y, the economic benefits to be gained by replacing it. In this case, you're fixating on X but ignoring Y.
And, of course, there's also a situational aspect as well. Under "normal" times, the builders aren't running close enough to the edge that a marginal slowdown in business will cause them to shut down, or that a marginal increase could bring them back and start them hiring again. But, of course, these weren't -- aren't -- "normal" times, as evidenced by the credit crunch and unemployment numbers.
What some are saying is that I should be grateful as my property is dystroyed.
Not really. You would probably prefer that someone
else's property was destroyed, just as you would prefer that someone else buy the abandoned crack house across the street from you that's lowering your property values. If someone else bought the house and tore it down, your house might be worth another $10,000. (That's a well-documented effect; ask any realtor. Abandoned houses lower property values in the neighborhood.)
But that's the paradox of thrift. Everyone wants it to happen, but no one is willing to spend the money to make it happen,
even when everyone as a whole would get more out of it. If everyone on the block chips in $5,000, you can buy that house and tear it down as a group. Or you can wait until someone ponies up the $30,000 themselves, but in that case the crack house is likely to be there for a while.
Or the city can buy it, using your tax money to do it.