What's the difference if gov't gets the ball rolling, or private enterprise?

..yes, that is part of the point. If you have to destroy something, you have to spend money replacing it which benefits the economy. Which is what he's saying: you need to take that into consideration.

Some of these arguments ....

Let's see - I paid x amount of dollars on my house. Destroyed it - now I paid y amount on my house. Now the economy is better off? And I'm better off? I just paid x + y and only have one house to show for it instead of two.

This is some basic math.

I'm beginning to think maybe it's to simple for some people to see ...
 
Let's see - I paid x amount of dollars on my house. Destroyed it - now I paid y amount on my house. Now the economy is better off?

yes
Edit change that to "possibly" This would not help an overheating economy

And I'm better off?

Probably not


Of course neither of your questions is really the righe one. The correct question if you and a million other people built 2 houses to get 1 are you better off, and the correct answer is: maybe.
 
Last edited:
Let's start with yours. You're such a big advocate of destroying valuable assets for the alleged good of the economy, let's start by destroying YOUR assets.

You just offered to buy a new and better house for me? Great! When can you start!

Will you buy me a better car to replace my old 2003 beater, too?

Bear in mind the the original proposal was not just to destroy, but to replace as well. So if you're offering to deplete your own savings to improve my local economy, go ahead.


No, I do not consent to pay for a new house or a new car for you. Nor did I consent to pay for new cars for all the recipients of “Cash for Clunkers” handouts. I certainly never consented to being forced to help buy for others better cars than what I can afford for myself.
 
Maybe?

Please explain how.

Because the builders that rebuilt your and your neighbors houses were able to keep the local Home Depot in business, so it didn't have to close down. This, in turn, kept the local mall that it anchors from closing its doors. As a result, there are about 500 more jobs in retail in your town than there would have been if the houses had not been replaced.

There are also 500 more jobs in supply than there would have been, because these stores that didn't close down still need goods. The builders themselves have similarly been able to stay in business, so there's about 250 jobs in construction. The people who work in these jobs are still making money, so they're still buying flowers for their special someone at your florist shop.

And, of course, you get the convenience of being able to hire local contractors if you need something done in your house, or of being able to shop locally for stuff instead of having to travel to the next county to get lumber and paint.
 
I certainly never consented to being forced to help buy for others better cars than what I can afford for myself.

Actually, you did. It's part of the burden and obligations associated with the privilege of citizenship. If you want to live in a society where there are no such obligations, Somalia awaits.
 
Because the builders that rebuilt your and your neighbors houses were able to keep the local Home Depot in business, so it didn't have to close down. This, in turn, kept the local mall that it anchors from closing its doors. As a result, there are about 500 more jobs in retail in your town than there would have been if the houses had not been replaced.

There are also 500 more jobs in supply than there would have been, because these stores that didn't close down still need goods. The builders themselves have similarly been able to stay in business, so there's about 250 jobs in construction. The people who work in these jobs are still making money, so they're still buying flowers for their special someone at your florist shop.

And, of course, you get the convenience of being able to hire local contractors if you need something done in your house, or of being able to shop locally for stuff instead of having to travel to the next county to get lumber and paint.

Except - I'm short a house and out all the money for the first house. All what you describe would have happened if I bought / built a second house but in addition there would be a second house ALSO.

So why is having one less house BETTER than having one more house? Why is having one less house WEALTHIER than having two house? Please explain.
 
Last edited:
Except - I'm short a house and out all the money for the first house.

Without the money the builders earned rebuilding the houses, they wouldn't have been able to remain in business; the secondary effects would have been a disaster for the local economy.

So you get to trade "being out the money for the first house" with "being out all the money you put into your now-failed florist shop."

All you describe would have happened but in addition there would be a second house ALSO.

Not if there's no room for a second house.
 
Last edited:
Except - I'm short a house and out all the money for the first house. All what you describe would have happened if I bought / built a second house but in addition there would be a second house ALSO..


Yes you are out the first house, but in it’s place you have a good paying job without which you have no house at all.
So why is having one less house BETTER than having one more house? Why is having one less house WEALTHIER than having two house? Please explain.

You are the one who needs to explain that as you are the one who is completely discounting the case where you have no house at all without the program. (You are guilty of the broken window fallacy because you fail to consider all the spin off effects)
 
Yes you are out the first house, but in it’s place you have a good paying job without which you have no house at all.

OK - I'll be sure to thank the next arson I meet for keeping me employed.

You are the one who needs to explain that as you are the one who is completely discounting the case where you have no house at all without the program. (You are guilty of the broken window fallacy because you fail to consider all the spin off effects)

People here are arguing the economy is better if my window is broken or better yet my house is burned down.

And I'm the one guilty of the "broken window fallacy"?

I'm totally beginning to understand now!

What some are saying is that I should be grateful as my property is dystroyed. Whether it's the government or a vandal - I should be grateful that my window or house was destroyed because not only is it helping everyone else and keeping the economy afloat, but I'm still employed.

I wish some of you would stop be so selfish and burn your house down already - to help out the economy. The longer you postpone burning down your house the more damage you are doing to the economy.

It's not the paradox of thrift that's holding back the economy - it's the paradox of not-burning down your house. The longer any of us postpone burning down our houses the worse off the economy will be!

It's that simple - if we all burn down our houses simultaneously we will improve the economy multiple time over!!!!!

It's so simple - I'm so amazed that I never saw this before.
 
OK - I'll be sure to thank the next arson I meet for keeping me employed.

You are still guilty of falling into the broken window fallacy. It says you have to look at all the consequences rather then presuming an event is either bad or good.
People here are arguing the economy is better if my window is broken or better yet my house is burned down.

And I'm the one guilty of the "broken window fallacy"?


You shouldn’t try to invoke the broken window fallacy if you don’t understand it.

You have been told multiple times that it’s a caution that all the spin off effects need to be considered. You are trying to ignore the spin off effects altogether and go right to making your conclusions. Yes, you are guilty of exactly what the broken window fallacy is advising against.

I wish some of you would stop be so selfish and burn your house down already - to help out the economy. The longer you postpone burning down your house the more damage you are doing to the economy.

See the prisoners dilemma. Individual will not, cannot, rationally volunteer to do the things that are in common best interest without assurance that the other parties will do the same. Those people who prefer to leach whenever they can make this impossible.
 
You are still guilty of falling into the broken window fallacy. It says you have to look at all the consequences rather then presuming an event is either bad or good.



You shouldn’t try to invoke the broken window fallacy if you don’t understand it.

You have been told multiple times that it’s a caution that all the spin off effects need to be considered. You are trying to ignore the spin off effects altogether and go right to making your conclusions. Yes, you are guilty of exactly what the broken window fallacy is advising against.



See the prisoners dilemma. Individual will not, cannot, rationally volunteer to do the things that are in common best interest without assurance that the other parties will do the same. Those people who prefer to leach whenever they can make this impossible.

You need to re-study the Broken Window Fallacy.
 
People here are arguing the economy is better if my window is broken or better yet my house is burned down.

No, people are arguing that if the process of repairing your window or rebuilding your house fixes the economy, you can get a net benefit.

Obviously there are some tradeoffs here. The cost of your window is X; the benefit from not losing your florist shop and having your house repossessed is Y. If Y>>X, then having your window broken actually helped you.

Or are you really suggesting you would prefer to be living out of a refrigerator box looking at the still-intact window that the bank now owns?

And I'm the one guilty of the "broken window fallacy"?

Absolutely. The broken window fallacy is simply not taking into account both sides of the equation. "Normally" people forget about X, the cost of the window (more formally, the opportunity cost of the resources that went into fixing the window) but notice Y, the economic benefits to be gained by replacing it. In this case, you're fixating on X but ignoring Y.

And, of course, there's also a situational aspect as well. Under "normal" times, the builders aren't running close enough to the edge that a marginal slowdown in business will cause them to shut down, or that a marginal increase could bring them back and start them hiring again. But, of course, these weren't -- aren't -- "normal" times, as evidenced by the credit crunch and unemployment numbers.

What some are saying is that I should be grateful as my property is dystroyed.

Not really. You would probably prefer that someone else's property was destroyed, just as you would prefer that someone else buy the abandoned crack house across the street from you that's lowering your property values. If someone else bought the house and tore it down, your house might be worth another $10,000. (That's a well-documented effect; ask any realtor. Abandoned houses lower property values in the neighborhood.)

But that's the paradox of thrift. Everyone wants it to happen, but no one is willing to spend the money to make it happen, even when everyone as a whole would get more out of it. If everyone on the block chips in $5,000, you can buy that house and tear it down as a group. Or you can wait until someone ponies up the $30,000 themselves, but in that case the crack house is likely to be there for a while.

Or the city can buy it, using your tax money to do it.
 
No, people are arguing that if the process of repairing your window or rebuilding your house fixes the economy, you can get a net benefit.

I get a net benefit even though I've paid for two windows (or two houses) and only have one window or house? :rolleyes:

Absolutely. The broken window fallacy is simply not taking into account both sides of the equation. "Normally" people forget about X, the cost of the window (more formally, the opportunity cost of the resources that went into fixing the window) but notice Y, the economic benefits to be gained by replacing it. In this case, you're fixating on X but ignoring Y.

The whole Broken Window Fallacy is about X. Sorry about fixating on X.:boggled:

Not really. You would probably prefer that someone else's property was destroyed, just as you would prefer that someone else buy the abandoned crack house across the street from you that's lowering your property values. If someone else bought the house and tore it down, your house might be worth another $10,000. (That's a well-documented effect; ask any realtor. Abandoned houses lower property values in the neighborhood.)

No I don't, because I don't agree that we are all better off if property is destroyed. All you're doing is wasting money. time, effort - spending money to recreate what was already created and you're left with less as an end result.
 
I get a net benefit even though I've paid for two windows (or two houses) and only have one window or house?

That's right. If it's a choice between paying for two windows and having one house, or paying for only one window and losing your house because your job evaporated, you have a net benefit.


The whole Broken Window Fallacy is about X.

No, it's not. It's about not keeping track of all the effects.

No I don't, because I don't agree that we are all better off if property is destroyed.

Would you be willing to pay $5000 to destroy something that's lowering your wealth by $10000?
 
That's right. If it's a choice between paying for two windows and having one house, or paying for only one window and losing your house because your job evaporated, you have a net benefit.

I'd rather keep my window, keep my house, and buy a third thing - maybe even add a new window.

NOT pay for TWO windows and only end up with one window.

BECAUSE THOSE are the two options. And only the second one makes me and everyone else better off and wealthier.


No, it's not. It's about not keeping track of all the effects.

Nope - but it's clear you're set in your way of thinking about the fallacy.

Knowing all you know - do you live by it or not? Do you periodically destroy your own property to help out the economy or not? (I should add - that you've been arguing destroying any property - not just the equivalent of run down, abandoned, crack houses.) And if you're not willing to destroy your own property why are you so willing to destroy someone elses? Never mind - I know the answer.
 
Last edited:
What some are saying is that I should be grateful as my property is dystroyed. Whether it's the government or a vandal - I should be grateful that my window or house was destroyed because not only is it helping everyone else and keeping the economy afloat, but I'm still employed.


…or someone else's property destroyed, but you forced to pay for it.

I can't help but be reminded of Romans 1:22: “Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools.” We have here, in this thread (and a few other similar threads) people preaching the Broken Window Fallacy at us, and professing to be smarter and wiser than those of us who can see these preachings for the foolish nonsense that they are.
 
I certainly never consented to being forced to help buy for others better cars than what I can afford for myself.

Actually, you did. It's part of the burden and obligations associated with the privilege of citizenship. If you want to live in a society where there are no such obligations, Somalia awaits.


No, I did not. See the last phrase of the Fifth Amendment. “…nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.”
 
That's not an option. Perhaps you missed the whole "economic crash" thing?

It absolutely is too an option - by your own admission.

You are saying

A) I have X amount of money that needs to be spent.
B) It is better for the economy on the whole for me to spend the money
C) If I spend the money it will be a net benefit to me because I will stay employed and keep my house.

But then you say

D) Someone should break my perfectly good window so I spend my money for the greater good and I should just be greatful because the spent money now keeps me employed and keeps me in a house.

SO ...

If all I need to do is spend the equivilant of a window to keep me employed and keep me in the house I'm better off not having to replace an intentionally broken window, but spend it on something else.

If me spending my money is all that needs to happen to help the economy (and the greater good) - who the hell are you (in the general sense, of course) to dictate how I spend the money? The money is spent one way or the other - which is all you say matters - the paradox of thrift is not happening. Get your nose out of my wallet. And quit stealing my window by breaking it. And quit breaking other peoples windows and then forcing me to pay for it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom