What's the difference if gov't gets the ball rolling, or private enterprise?

Start with the Prisoner's dilemma.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner's_dilemma

Individual actors generally will not make the best possible choice if they are not offered assurance most others will as well. Across the entire economy it makes most sense for private industry to horde their cash if everyone else is hording or invest/grow if everyone else is investing.

The big problem is that you, a would-be central planner, doesn't know what the "best choice" is for spending my money is, and far more importantly, neither are you entitled to spend it. First of all, you're using a loaded term like "hoarding" instead of the more innocuous "saving". Why is the private decision to save money so anathema? It merely represents consumption based on needs and wants, as opposed to unlimited, mindless consumption. How can the latter possibly be good for the economy, or even the environment? Demand should be driven organically by consumers, not bestowed by central bank/government policy as handouts at the expense of taxpayers and savers.

When no one is investing/growing private industry needs to assume no one else is going to invest and make the safe choice, which is not to invest either. If everyone does this, and they should if they are smart, no one invests and the recession deepens.

On the contrary, it's only smart to invest when you can obtain returns that are commensurate with, or higher than the risk taken. Thanks to the inflation tax, the choice to save is robbed from us, so "investing" is forced, no matter what the economic conditions are.

With government action at least some industries know there is going to be demand and will invest top grab a share. Since other businesses know there is going to be investment it now makes sense for them to jump on the bandwagon and invest themselves.

This ignores the cost of "government action", which requires that people get taxed first, in order that government can bestow it's favors on whichever industry best serves politicians or their friends.

IOW private industry cannot get the ball rolling on its own. It will only respond once someone else gets the ball rolling.

This is ridiculous, and by extension, wrong. Where did you get the idea that no investment can happen without central planning? The centrally planned educational system, perhaps?

This is a fairly rare event, something that really only comes up in a particularly deep recession but there are much more common cases where an outside agency (government) plays a critical role in allowing private industry to choose the best outcome. Take the taxi example above. What do you think would have happened if everyone were free to label their cabs Da Zhong? Would there be any incentive to at all for the real Da Zhong to provide a better but more expensive level of service? Clearly not, so without the correct government regulations nothing improves because there is no confidence other players will follow the same rules.

I agree, trademark law is important. You could also argue that were it not for infrastructure spending, the taxis wouldn't have roads to drive on, or they would all be slow moving toll roads. But it's a leap of logic to suggest that while central planning has its role, that it should be ubiquitous.
 
You shouldn't just parrot catch-phrases that you don't understand (like "broken window fallacy"). It's more complex than that.

Yes. Apparently only government subsidized pseudo-academic types can possibly hope to understand such arcane concepts as the broken window fallacy. Please, do enlighten us.

But on the other hand, if what you were going to do with the money otherwise was simply to light it on fire (or bury it in your back yard), then the economy as a whole is actually better off if someone breaks your window and you have to replace it. The broken window fallacy doesn't apply because the opportunity cost is next to nothing.

Really? Because someone elects to defer their consumption (and willfully subject it to the ravages of the inflation tax) by burying it, this actually serves as justification for destroying real wealth, in your little mind? How did you calculate that the opportunity cost is "nothing", without knowing the duration for which the money is buried? The opportunity for a saver would be lost in the future. If someone buried $10,000 for one year, and you discounted that by the risk-free rate, or the rate of inflation, it would still amount to a lot more than "nothing". Even if you discounted the money over thirty years, it would still be a lot more than nothing.

And all of this is beside the point that your warped analogy and use of the term opportunity cost are completely misunderstood by you. Lets say that unlike you, someone engages in something productive, and earns $10,000. If they elect to bury that in their backyard, not only have they already benefitted society by their production, but they have also deferred their consumption, that is, the scarce goods and services they otherwise would have consumed were available for someone else to consume. This has the effect of lowering the prices of goods and services for everyone else. It's good for everyone else if people produce more than they consume. Eventually production and consumption will reach equilibrium. This should be obvious.

You myopically focus on one effect of saving, which is less consumption now, and ignore the fact that this leaves more for you to consume now, as well as ignoring the deferred consumption by the saver in the future.

And between the credit crunch (during which banks weren't lending money out, and as a result might as well have been burying their cash reserves in the back yard), and the increased savings of the "paradox of thrift" (in which people were putting their money into the bank, to be buried), forcibly tearing down houses and wrecking cars might well be a good idea.

If nothing else, this is signature worthy material from a supposed PhD. Can I use it? It would be an honor. Lol.

Of course, now the credit crunch is over; what would have been a good idea in late 2008 is no longer necessarily a good idea. But we've still got a huge problem of companies sitting on cash (and banks lending out much less than "normal"), which is dragging on the economy, and encouraging people to spend instead of save is still a good idea.

So, destroying hundreds of billions of dollars worth of real wealth as real estate is no longer necessarily a good idea, but you're willing to entertain the possibility. Good to know.

I guess acknowledging the fact that a fiat-money driven boom cycle led to the speculation in and overproduction of homes, and letting the real estate market settle on realistic (lower) prices is out of the question. Nah. Lets just nuke the houses instead.
 
Er, no. Actually, the government tries to stimulate the economy through deficit spending; the idea is that they spend money now that they may or may not try to collect through taxation later (the other option is just to let inflation take care of it). The effect is that the citizens have more money in their pockets, not less.

Even if the government did try to stimulate the economy through taxation, it's easy enough to make sure that taxed citizens have more money to spend instead of less, by simply choosing the right structure of taxes. An obvious example of this is the proposed 0.1% tax on stock transactions. Buying stocks is not spending money, but investment (it's technically deferred consumption); if the tax were set high enough to actually deter investment, the other choice more or less is forced to be immediate consumption (i.e. spending). Similarly, a (higher) tax on corporate cash holdings would encourage companies to spend instead of retain cash, which would put more money into circulation and increase spending.

But the most egregious error is simply that the economy is not zero-sum; if the stimulus money results in increased economic growth, then the taxed citizens have more money to spend, not less. If a 1% tax increase results in an across the board 3% growth, then everyone's better off by 2%.

All "stimulus" is funded by taxation, make no mistake. Whether it is direct taxation, money-printing, or borrowing, it all represents a tax. In the case of borrowing, the principal and interest have to be paid via either more borrowing or taxation in the future. When you consider that much of the foreign exchange used to purchase the dollars that are used to purchase government bonds is merely the result of money printing by say, the Bank of China, it represents a tax on the Chinese.
 
All "stimulus" is funded by taxation, make no mistake. Whether it is direct taxation, money-printing, or borrowing, it all represents a tax.

In Tippit-speak where "tax" means "noun."

Taxation, money-printing, borrowing, elephant, licence plate, light bulb, they're all a "tax" from the point of view of Tippit's very specialist view of English grammar.
 
I'm not sure if this addresses Iamme's question directly, but I think the issue in today's economy is that "private enterprise" (or at least the financial sector) is sitting on their cash right now. If banks were lending (or at least lending more freely), there would be no need for government stimulus spending.

I think that's the main difference. As several people have pointed out, the government can run a deficit, so it can spend money just for the sake of stimulating the economy rather than based on real risks of not getting a return on the investment (or enough of a return or a quick enough return). The motivations of government and private enterprise in spending money are very different.

ETA: I should also mention that the difference in motivation also extends to what the money is spent on. Private enterprise seldom builds roads, bridges, dams and so on. I was merely speaking of stimulus spending above. Private enterprise never spends money just to stimulate the economy. They spend money to make a profit.
 
Last edited:
In Tippit-speak where "tax" means "noun."

Taxation, money-printing, borrowing, elephant, licence plate, light bulb, they're all a "tax" from the point of view of Tippit's very specialist view of English grammar.

It would be helpful for you to explain how money-printing (future inflation, devaluing of a currency) and borrowing (future tax payments) are not the same as an outright tax. The only difference I can see is that a tax happens now where those other two are deferred to the future.
 
It would be helpful for you to explain how money-printing (future inflation, devaluing of a currency) and borrowing (future tax payments) are not the same as an outright tax. The only difference I can see is that a tax happens now where those other two are deferred to the future.

If the economy recovers, the tax revenue makes up for the first two. If it doesn't, other measures are typically taken.
 
It would be helpful for you to explain how money-printing (future inflation, devaluing of a currency) and borrowing (future tax payments) are not the same as an outright tax. The only difference I can see is that a tax happens now where those other two are deferred to the future.

Monetary inflation happens immediately as the money is spent, the tax isn't deferred. As soon as anyone exchanges counterfeit or newly created money for scarce goods and services, it serves to bid up the prices of these higher than they otherwise would have been. Note that monetary inflation may not result in actual price inflation, because economic growth serves to offset (and obscure) this. The punitive effects on everyone else who don't get to spend the new money remain in spite of this, as we lose the opportunity to buy things at cheaper prices than they would have been.

Interest paid on government debt of course has to be obtained via taxation (or yet more borrowing), so the future interest payments represent corresponding future tax liabilities. If the buyer of our debt is a foreign central bank who is printing their own fiat money to be used in exchange for dollars for the purpose of buying it, then that reflects an inflation tax levied on the citizens of that country (or, more accurately, the holders of that country's currency).
 
Monetary inflation happens immediately as the money is spent, the tax isn't deferred. As soon as anyone exchanges counterfeit or newly created money for scarce goods and services, it serves to bid up the prices of these higher than they otherwise would have been. Note that monetary inflation may not result in actual price inflation, because economic growth serves to offset (and obscure) this. The punitive effects on everyone else who don't get to spend the new money remain in spite of this, as we lose the opportunity to buy things at cheaper prices than they would have been.

The printing is done right away, but is the inflation of the price of goods and services immediate? I would think it would be somewhat delayed until enough people have the extra printed money in order to begin all bidding on overlapping products, and then a delay for those spent dollars to trickle out into other areas. I guess that's what I meant by delayed to the future.

I can see why this route would be liked by politicians - they don't have to do a yay or nay vote on a specific tax.
 
The "ball" is already rolling. The government has to slow the ball down for some before it speeds it up for others.

Sounds profound. Give me one example as to what you mean.

The government doesn't always have to debase the currency, it can tax you directly, or it can sell debt in exchange for dollars paid for by the funny money of foreign central banks, like China.

Please only state examples of what can happen in our current bad situation here. You say the gov't can tax us directly? What if they run out of people to tax, because people no longer have jobs?



It's bad for the same reason that stealing $1000 from you and spending it on hookers and cocaine is - I shouldn't be entitled to the fruits of your labor. Note that it doesn't matter what I spend the money on, I could invest it in something incredibly productive, but it doesn't change the fact that you were robbed.

Why does my plan rob people? Is it the possible inflation aspect? The fact gov't money will be doled out, while the supplies that can purchased remain limited?

When infrastructure jobs are let out say for private bid, what is happening with THAT as far as the economy goes? Building interstate roads and bridges, etc. does not come from the private sector. It is financed by the gov't and forced on the tax payer. So then I guess even THAT must be bad, technically, and is technically ALSO stealing from the tax payer?



What are the "contractors" supposed to build? I hope it's not houses, as housing inventories are sky high,

What if we HAD to not build more houses, but replace houses. What if entire cities were bombed? Let's do that sort of thing, even though we have not been bombed. Have someone bulldoze all blighted homes and businesses, and put people back to work rebuilding the existing ones. Not adding MORE houses/businesses. Just replacing.

If a country was bombed, you mean that if that country, like the U.S., had all the resources to rebuild with, that the country would somehow get poorer?, if everyone was working, rebuilding the country? I'd think it would get richer. Look at all the brand new nice stuff it would have to show for it. And look at all the other businesses that once again would produce more goods, due to the fact more people were working and could afford to buy more stuff.
 
It would be helpful for you to explain how money-printing (future inflation, devaluing of a currency) and borrowing (future tax payments) are not the same as an outright tax. The only difference I can see is that a tax happens now where those other two are deferred to the future.

Levying taxes increases federal revenues (and decreases the federal budget deficit or increases the federal budget surplus). Borrowing money is pretty much the opposite. Spending/borrowing on the one hand and taxation on the other are pretty much the opposite of each other.

[ETA: To make an analogy: my mortgage is borrowing money. It is not the same thing as income. I will need to raise money--probably through income--to pay my mortgage, but the loan is not equivalent to income. In fact, in my personal budget, they're the opposite. One is a debit and the other a credit.]

I understand that increasing spending without specifying a revenue source means that at some point we will need to collect revenues to pay for that spending, which seems to be the point you're after.
 
Last edited:
Your plan sucks, and would make things much, much worse. Have you ever thought about running for office?

Maybe it DOES suck. I posted the thread to see if my reasoning is flawed, and to read WHY it is flawed.

Me thought about running for office? Surely you don't think I'd say yes.
 
What if we HAD to not build more houses, but replace houses. What if entire cities were bombed? Let's do that sort of thing, even though we have not been bombed. Have someone bulldoze all blighted homes and businesses, and put people back to work rebuilding the existing ones. Not adding MORE houses/businesses. Just replacing.

If a country was bombed, you mean that if that country, like the U.S., had all the resources to rebuild with, that the country would somehow get poorer?, if everyone was working, rebuilding the country? I'd think it would get richer. Look at all the brand new nice stuff it would have to show for it. And look at all the other businesses that once again would produce more goods, due to the fact more people were working and could afford to buy more stuff.

At least one problem with this approach is that housing is not fungible. There is a range of low- to high-rent/mortgage housing types. Rebuilding all the housing would mean there are no 100 year old buildings to buy or rent very cheap. That is, there are some structures that could not be rebuilt and rented at their current rates.

Also, there are issues of architectural and historic concerns. My city even has widespread housing conservancy districts (somewhat stricter inspections and such) to help preserve the character of these neighborhoods.

And there's also the big question of the specifics of such a transition. I for one would not want to be told I have to leave my house so it can be demolished and rebuilt. (My house is 117 years old.) I definitely wouldn't want to be paid a fair market value for my house (especially right now!!) Even if I were, who would pay that?

ETA: However, your basic idea is similar to the idea behind massive public spending for rebuilding infrastructure. In this case, we'd have the stimulus benefit (lots of workers getting a job right now) plus the indirect economic stimulus of sorely needed infrastructure improvement, plus the long-term economic benefit of making more infrastructure more efficient (more "green") when possible.
 
Last edited:
drkitten is right. You can't sustain an economy that way - it's a net loss - but you might kick-start a stalled economy.
 
Let's start with yours. You're such a big advocate of destroying valuable assets for the alleged good of the economy, let's start by destroying YOUR assets.

You just offered to buy a new and better house for me? Great! When can you start!

Will you buy me a better car to replace my old 2003 beater, too?

Bear in mind the the original proposal was not just to destroy, but to replace as well. So if you're offering to deplete your own savings to improve my local economy, go ahead.
 
It would be helpful for you to explain how money-printing (future inflation, devaluing of a currency) and borrowing (future tax payments) are not the same as an outright tax.

Because words have meanings?

As Joe pointed out, you'd not be foolish enough to think that wages paid to you are the same as a loan you put on your credit card.

You can think of it this way, if you like. You want to buy a $500 widget, but you only have $400 in your bank account.

You can : earn more money, via a raise or working overtime. This puts money into your pocket now, with no strings attached, just like taxes put money into the government coffers.
You can : put it on your VISA card. This puts money in your pocket now -- well, goods that you paid for with money now -- but you have to pay it back later. Just like the government borrowing.
You can : wait for the goods to go on sale or hunt for coupons so you can buy them more cheaply. This is essentially allowing external economic forces to do the heavy lifting for you, just like when the government allows the currency to inflate.
 
You shouldn't just parrot catch-phrases that you don't understand (like "broken window fallacy"). It's more complex than that.

I understand it quite well, thanks.

Yes, it actually is more complicated than that. More important than understanding the hidden costs to these make work or destroy to rebuild proposals, is understanding that true wealth is not about jobs or money, it's about productivity.

I could make my own economy speed up, and create more work for myself by ripping out the heating element in my dishwasher, so I have to create a new job, more hours of labor, doing the dishes by hand. All I've done is decrease productivity. If you destroy a functional asset, such as a home, you have decreased productivity. We now HAVE to build new ones. We don't GET to build new ones.

You like to mingle the concept of spending our way out of a deflationary spiral with the concept of the broken window fallacy. They are 2 different concepts. If you destroy assets in order to "make work," it's still the broken window fallacy, and it's still not productive. If it happens to be a viable solution to a deflationary spiral, that doesn't mean it's not still the "broken window fallacy."
 
..yes, that is part of the point. If you have to destroy something, you have to spend money replacing it which benefits the economy. Which is what he's saying: you need to take that into consideration.

/facepalm

No, it's not part of the point. It proves there is no point. Destroying viable assets is a lose/lose scenario for everyone. Robbing everyone through taxation to pay for the destruction and rebuilding of homes is utterly regressive, and would be devastating to the economy. If the population weren't taxed to begin with, they could buy more of everything they really need and want, encouraging the production of more things everyone needs and wants, as opposed to the production of what we have too many of - houses. When you hear the talking heads on CNBC joke about taking a wrecking ball to the housing inventory, that's with the intention of NOT rebuilding them, so as to prop up real estate prices.

We would be far better off simply inflating the currency and issuing welfare checks to everyone, than to actually destroy existing homes. At least then the spending would reflect what we need and want, as opposed to homebuilders wasting time building what is already in great supply. Homes don't need to be destroyed, the Fed has to stop propping up Fannie and Freddy and the housing market needs to correct so that the homebuyer at the margin can buy them and move in.

How a supposed econ professor would seriously consider destroying homes when we have tent cities and record numbers of homeless is astounding. The fact that presumably intelligent people on a skeptics forum would endorse this is mind-boggling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom