What's the difference if gov't gets the ball rolling, or private enterprise?

Iamme

Philosopher
Joined
Aug 5, 2003
Messages
6,215
I have heard if gov't initiates it, that the gov't has to print up phoney-baloney money in order to do it.

So? Why is that so bad? Who cares who pushes the ball if then it causes contracts to be let to private businesses who then create a huge chain down effect from things that then become needed.

Suppose the gov't thinks one of the best ways is to build up our infrastructure. Suppose they want to do it to the tune of trillions of dollars. What is so bad say if the gov't puts contractors to work, and pays the contractor, but then the money from there flows freely(no more gov't fianncial involvement)through the private sector, from that initial general contractor paying off subcontractors that include all the trades involved, suppliers, miners. manufacturers, truckers, clothiers, etc., etc.

Why can't we do that if say we do not have to use our unbacked phoney money to pay a foreign country for materials in order to pull this off? If we have all the materials to make steel, concrete, glass, plastics, etc., etc., why can't we simply do make-work projects that gets the entire country going?

Why not carry it even a step farther and demolish existing houses and cars and put people back to work making new ones. Why wouldn't this work?

Maybe this is how the pyramids were built. Maybe the gov't employed all the workers and look what they created? Look what all of mankind, even millenia later, get to see - something of lasting substance. Who cares that say private investors did not put up the capital needed to fund the pyramids. So it was done by the gov't.? So what?

In our case, if this caused us to get oil wells up and pumping HERE (not abroad), and OUR steel mills to produce more, etc., etc., how could not this make for vibrant economy? And like I said, so it "cost" the gov't trillions? Just print up the money.

But, but, but - "It wouldn't be backed", you say? So? Why does it have to be backed? What good does gold do anyone, anyway? You sit there at your kitchen table ,with gold on the table, going, "Ooooohhh, look what I have!" ? Ya. What does that get you? That's just a racket industry anyway, isn't it? It isn't like gold is valuable because it is finite, and who holds the most holds the most wealth. Heck, they keep mining more of it! So then why is it so valuable? The value should come down when they keep finding more of it, you'd think. I think it is all rigged, like diamonds.

Wouldn't you rather see everyone working, building great things, having something to show for it? Wouldn't that create GDP? And then more tax revenues would follow?

Sounds too easy. What's wrong with such a plan?
 
Last edited:
Not sure how serious this post is but what the heck ...

I have heard if gov't initiates it, that the gov't has to print up phoney-baloney money in order to do it.

So? Why is that so bad? Who cares who pushes the ball if then it causes contracts to be let to private businesses who then create a huge chain down effect from things that then become needed.

In addition to printing they could just take. They can also just borrow and default. My guess - at some point it will be all the above.

Curious - Why do you think counterfeiting currency is illegal? Or should it be made legal? Why or why not?

Why not carry it even a step farther and demolish existing houses and cars and put people back to work making new ones. Why wouldn't this work?

I'm totally not clear what your proposing here? You want the government to dystroy the house you live in the rebuild it? And just have the government pay to rebuild it?

But, but, but - "It wouldn't be backed", you say? So? Why does it have to be backed? What good does gold do anyone, anyway? You sit there at your kitchen table ,with gold on the table, going, "Ooooohhh, look what I have!" ? Ya. What does that get you?

when in the history of currencies has gold been worth zero? When in the history of currencies have currencies been worth zero?
 
Iamme actually has a good point.

Up to a certain point, and under certain circumstances, which I will explain, it can be helpful for the government to do exactly that: print up new money out of thin air and order it to be spent in certain ways to get people employed productively in a way that benefits society.

The circumstances are that certain prerequisites be true:

1) The government in question is actually a government for the people and not a government for the government or for a small clique of elites.
2) The government knows how spend the money in a productive way.
3) The government utilizes only idle productive capacity or productive capacity that underemployed or misallocated. If it takes productive resources away from more productive activities, it is bad.
4) The government doesn't create too much money because that would cause hyperinflation, which is bad.

So, I agree with Iamme, but only up to a certain point. There really do have to be limits on this or you will destroy the private sector, which is bad. If government offers better salaries than the private sector can afford to offer, those people better be more productively employed than they would be in the private sector.

There is a problem in poor countries when the UN comes in for example. They offer more money for drivers than doctors or lawyers make. So doctors and lawyers quit their jobs to work as drivers. That is counterproductive. This is what the government must avoid.
 
While gov't can certainly help inspire or support growth and change, I think that it is generally very poor at actually leading or guiding change.

A simple example that I like to use from my experience in China. When I was living in Shanghai, the taxis there generally had a very poor reputation...dirty taxis, drivers who treated passengers badly, and who didn't now even major locations in the city, much less smaller streets. Service was terrible, training almost non-existent.

The Shanghai gov't did many things to try to change this. They passed regulations proscribing minimum standards and imposing fines for certain behaviors. They offered economic incentives for companies that met certain standards. They did public awareness and education programs.

And yet the change was almost non-existent.

Then a Singaporean company started a new taxi company in Shanghai, "Da Zhong". They brought in all the high standards they used in Shanghai. All their drivers had to go through an intensive training and qualification program. They had to learn all the streets and locations. They were given strict training about conduct and service standards. Drivers were regularly checked by anonymous 'passengers' (who actually worked for the company), and if the taxi was found to be dirty, or the driver did anything that didn't meet company standards, he'd get a warning (first time) and then be fired (second time).

Within a few months, everybody in Shanghai knew about Da Zhong, and how superior they were to other taxi companies. Many of my friends there would intentionally ignore or send away taxis that didn't belong to Da Zhong, even if it meant waiting longer to find a taxi. The other companies faced a sudden, significant loss in business.

So...they changed, too. They copied the practices of Da Zhong, and two years later, most of them had similar standards and practices.

No matter what the gov't does, so long as the companies in a particular industry have similar perspectives (don't want to change, can't see other alternatives, etc.), it isn't gonna' change much. But if one company makes changes that significantly affect others...those others are gonna' have to change, also, or else they'll find themselves out of business.

Now, part of the reason for Da Zhong opening in Shanghai was the financial incentives the gov't offered for a 'good' taxi company. It made it more attractive to them. So the gov't actions did have some impact, in terms of encouraging and supporting a new company that otherwise might not have gone to Shanghai. But the actual, real change came about as a result of decisions and actions at the private level, not because of the gov't.
 
Well, the government has the option of compelling payment, even if nothing of value is being created: They can either run a deficit in the hopes that some future generation will be wealthy enough to pay it off, or they can force the present generation to pay more than they would otherwise pay (which is taxation), or they can do both.

Private enterprise, on the other hand, must rely entirely on the principle of offering people what they want, at a price they can afford. When they succeed, wealth is created and the economy thrives. When they fail, they are replaced by others willing to attempt the same.

When has the government ever admitted failure, and withdrawn its offering from the market?
 
The Shanghai gov't did many things to try to change this. They passed regulations proscribing minimum standards and imposing fines for certain behaviors. They offered economic incentives for companies that met certain standards. They did public awareness and education programs.

Correct me if I'm wrong, I haven't lived in China, so your expertise far outweighs mine, but they have a pretty poor reputation wrt effectively enforcing health, quality and safety standards. I wouldn't use their efforts at quality control as an examples of the limitations of government.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, I haven't lived in China, so your expertise far outweighs mine, but they have a pretty poor reputation wrt effectively enforcing health, quality and safety standards. I wouldn't use their efforts at quality control as an examples of the limitations of government.
Even with that being said...the motivations are entirely different. If its done by the gov't monitoring them, then they will do the absolute minimum to meet gov't standards, and nothing more. And will always be looking for shortcuts and loopholes. Whereas if it is competition, like that with Da Zhong, they now have a motivation to excel, as opposed to meet minimum standards.
 
Even with that being said...the motivations are entirely different. If its done by the gov't monitoring them, then they will do the absolute minimum to meet gov't standards, and nothing more. And will always be looking for shortcuts and loopholes. Whereas if it is competition, like that with Da Zhong, they now have a motivation to excel, as opposed to meet minimum standards.

Not entirely, they're just motivated to be enough better than the competition to be discernable by the customer base and nothing more. Excellence greater than that is highly inefficient and discouraged within capitalism. Chinese products are a great example of this. They compete brutally on price and try to get away with what they can in quality. That's market forces driving quality and safety downward.

And to clarify even more, they're just motivated to seem more excellent to their customers, and only in those facets that are noticable around the direct customer interaction.

If they were burning orphans in the engines to get good gas milage, capitalism makes it profitable to install soundproofing so customers won't hear the orphans screaming.

Customers are often not equipped or motivated to look past appearances and immediate benefits. I'll totally agree with you that for some things the profit motive is the best way to better results in goods and services, and there are inherent limitations in how governments can directly affect markets (although most 1st world governments do a better job than China in those areas I discussed before). But there are also limitations inherent in the market improving things.

Take your cab example again, what if those foreign cabs hadn't arrived? Often times even when market forces might conceivably lead to improvement, the market does not naturally cough up those conditions, it's a bit of a crap shoot. Why wasn't it a race to the top before the foreign cabs arrived? Market forces enthusiasts like to speculate that there is always pressure and reward for better quality within a market, why didn't he market generate that competition from within for all that time? Markets don't always compete in that ideal way.
 
Last edited:
Iamme actually has a good point.

Up to a certain point, .........So, I agree with Iamme, but only up to a certain point. There really do have to be limits on this or you will destroy the private sector, which is bad. If government offers better salaries than the private sector can afford to offer, those people better be more productively employed than they would be in the private sector.

The gov't would not offer better salaries, with what I had in mind. No gov't employees in this, other than overseers at best. They'd simply be the supplier of the money to general contractors. Once in the hands of the GC, the GC takes it from there and pays all the workers and suppliers. It would all be run like the free market, except the gov't would pay for it, without the taxpayer even paying it back(except in tax revenues that could grow because of this) because the gov't simply printed up enough money to pay for it.

Or is this some pie-in-the-sky plan?, ranking up there with perpetual motion machines? Am I forgetting some overlooked basic fact of economics. And if I am overlooking this, did Presidents F.D.Roosevelt and Obama overlook this too?

If we paid people to just dig holes and fil them up again, I can see hyper-inflation in that. But if we made tangible goods with the gov't fronted money, that would lead to more steel being made, more concrete being made, more light fixtures, wiring, workclothes, tires, vehicles, sheetrock...etc., etc.,etc.,all made inthe USA as much as possible ...WOULD this really lead to a super-inflation state? Or would the benfit of this outweigh the risk? Maybe we could fix the economy by next weekend! (Not quite, but you know what I mean)
 
I have heard if gov't initiates it, that the gov't has to print up phoney-baloney money in order to do it.

The "ball" is already rolling. The government has to slow the ball down for some before it speeds it up for others. The government doesn't always have to debase the currency, it can tax you directly, or it can sell debt in exchange for dollars paid for by the funny money of foreign central banks, like China.

So? Why is that so bad? Who cares who pushes the ball if then it causes contracts to be let to private businesses who then create a huge chain down effect from things that then become needed.

It's bad for the same reason that stealing $1000 from you and spending it on hookers and cocaine is - I shouldn't be entitled to the fruits of your labor. Note that it doesn't matter what I spend the money on, I could invest it in something incredibly productive, but it doesn't change the fact that you were robbed.

Suppose the gov't thinks one of the best ways is to build up our infrastructure. Suppose they want to do it to the tune of trillions of dollars. What is so bad say if the gov't puts contractors to work, and pays the contractor, but then the money from there flows freely(no more gov't fianncial involvement)through the private sector, from that initial general contractor paying off subcontractors that include all the trades involved, suppliers, miners. manufacturers, truckers, clothiers, etc., etc.

First of all, central planning is horribly inefficient. Read Hayek's The Road to Serfdom to understand why. What are the "contractors" supposed to build? I hope it's not houses, as housing inventories are sky high, not counting the shadow inventory which will undoubtedly cause further losses in real estate. How much more "infrastructure" do we really need? Are you qualified to determine this? Are most politicians? I doubt it. Most importantly, who pays for this? If your plan is to print more "funny money", that's just a tax, called the "inflation tax". If you want to borrow more, that's just a deferred tax which will further indebt the public and accelerate the total collapse of the US dollar (which is inevitable, and relatively soon). There is no free lunch. Your utopian plan won't work. Of course, that won't stop politicians from trying it (or, at least pretending to try it, and rewarding all of their friends and families with the "contracts" for a few kickbacks).

Why can't we do that if say we do not have to use our unbacked phoney money to pay a foreign country for materials in order to pull this off? If we have all the materials to make steel, concrete, glass, plastics, etc., etc., why can't we simply do make-work projects that gets the entire country going?

Because "make-work" projects are tantamount to malinvestment, which is why we're in the economic mess that we're in already. Also, there are too many looters and parasites (from the super-rich wall street bankers and politicians, to the impoverished welfare queens) for each productive person. All of the other waste that isn't fraud represents terrible investments, which need to be liquidated in a recession before the economy can move forward.

Why not carry it even a step farther and demolish existing houses and cars and put people back to work making new ones. Why wouldn't this work?

Really? With tent cities and the rates of homelessness mounting in cities across the US, you want to destroy real wealth? Why don't we instead stop propping up the real estate market and allow it to correct to where it should be, thereby allowing for more affordable homes?

Maybe this is how the pyramids were built. Maybe the gov't employed all the workers and look what they created? Look what all of mankind, even millenia later, get to see - something of lasting substance. Who cares that say private investors did not put up the capital needed to fund the pyramids. So it was done by the gov't.? So what?

The pyramids were built by slaves, and were superficial tributes to tyrannical rulers. The fact that they were really big and fancy didn't contribute much to the standard of living of those making them - which is of course the essence of the flaw of your manner of "thinking".

In our case, if this caused us to get oil wells up and pumping HERE (not abroad), and OUR steel mills to produce more, etc., etc., how could not this make for vibrant economy? And like I said, so it "cost" the gov't trillions? Just print up the money.

Because central planners, in addition to being largely parasites and looters, don't have enough good information to make economically beneficial decisions for everyone else. "Just printing up money" in the trillions would represent a hyperinflationary tax, that, in addition to arbitrarily rewarding certain special interests, would devastate the economy.

But, but, but - "It wouldn't be backed", you say? So? Why does it have to be backed? What good does gold do anyone, anyway? You sit there at your kitchen table ,with gold on the table, going, "Ooooohhh, look what I have!" ? Ya. What does that get you? That's just a racket industry anyway, isn't it? It isn't like gold is valuable because it is finite, and who holds the most holds the most wealth. Heck, they keep mining more of it! So then why is it so valuable? The value should come down when they keep finding more of it, you'd think. I think it is all rigged, like diamonds.

Gold is a currency with no counterparty risk that has served for thousands of years. It's good for preserving wealth, as well as being a hedge against negative real interest rates (not inflation, as most incorrectly assume). The paper gold market is indeed a racket, whereby the biggest banks have massive naked short positions and where each unallocated ounce is encumbered by roughly 45 ounces of paper claims. This has served to suppress the price, and the situation won't last forever. As far as the rate of gold inflation it's about 3% or less per annum.

Wouldn't you rather see everyone working, building great things, having something to show for it? Wouldn't that create GDP? And then more tax revenues would follow?

I'd rather the elite banking class stopped looting everyone else, and I'd rather the politicians let me, and everyone else decide what is "great" for us. GDP says nothing about standard of living, or quality of life.

Sounds too easy. What's wrong with such a plan?

Your plan sucks, and would make things much, much worse. Have you ever thought about running for office?
 
Start with the Prisoner's dilemma.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prisoner's_dilemma

Individual actors generally will not make the best possible choice if they are not offered assurance most others will as well. Across the entire economy it makes most sense for private industry to horde their cash if everyone else is hording or invest/grow if everyone else is investing.

When no one is investing/growing private industry needs to assume no one else is going to invest and make the safe choice, which is not to invest either. If everyone does this, and they should if they are smart, no one invests and the recession deepens.

With government action at least some industries know there is going to be demand and will invest top grab a share. Since other businesses know there is going to be investment it now makes sense for them to jump on the bandwagon and invest themselves.

IOW private industry cannot get the ball rolling on its own. It will only respond once someone else gets the ball rolling.

This is a fairly rare event, something that really only comes up in a particularly deep recession but there are much more common cases where an outside agency (government) plays a critical role in allowing private industry to choose the best outcome. Take the taxi example above. What do you think would have happened if everyone were free to label their cabs Da Zhong? Would there be any incentive to at all for the real Da Zhong to provide a better but more expensive level of service? Clearly not, so without the correct government regulations nothing improves because there is no confidence other players will follow the same rules.
 
Why not carry it even a step farther and demolish existing houses and cars and put people back to work making new ones. Why wouldn't this work?

Let's just address this one question for now.

This isn't an uncommon economic fallacy. So don't feel bad for making this mistake.

I've heard it in many forms, ranging from, "we should ban robots and automated systems so we can put more people to work," to "the best thing that could happen to the world economy is if aliens came down and engaged us in war, so that we could all get to work fighting back and rebuilding."

Both are 100% wrong.

See Broken Window Fallacy
 
Let's just address this one question for now.

This isn't an uncommon economic fallacy. So don't feel bad for making this mistake.

I've heard it in many forms, ranging from, "we should ban robots and automated systems so we can put more people to work," to "the best thing that could happen to the world economy is if aliens came down and engaged us in war, so that we could all get to work fighting back and rebuilding."

Both are 100% wrong.

See Broken Window Fallacy

You shouldn't just parrot catch-phrases that you don't understand (like "broken window fallacy"). It's more complex than that.

The broken window fallacy is simply a failure to take into account opportunity costs. "What else would be done with the money," in other words. If you spend $100 to replace a new window, you don't have that $100 to re-paint your fence. The glazier is up $100, the painter is down $100 that he doesn't get, the direct economic effect is more or less a wash, and your fence still needs repainting later (so you don't get a new paint job out of it).

But on the other hand, if what you were going to do with the money otherwise was simply to light it on fire (or bury it in your back yard), then the economy as a whole is actually better off if someone breaks your window and you have to replace it. The broken window fallacy doesn't apply because the opportunity cost is next to nothing.

And between the credit crunch (during which banks weren't lending money out, and as a result might as well have been burying their cash reserves in the back yard), and the increased savings of the "paradox of thrift" (in which people were putting their money into the bank, to be buried), forcibly tearing down houses and wrecking cars might well be a good idea.

Of course, now the credit crunch is over; what would have been a good idea in late 2008 is no longer necessarily a good idea. But we've still got a huge problem of companies sitting on cash (and banks lending out much less than "normal"), which is dragging on the economy, and encouraging people to spend instead of save is still a good idea.
 
If a government atempts to stimulate the economy using money they do it through taxation. The taxed citizens have less money to spend hence they purchase less. If the companies stimulate the economy its through advertisement and investments of their own money.
 
If a government atempts to stimulate the economy using money they do it through taxation. The taxed citizens have less money to spend hence they purchase less.

Er, no. Actually, the government tries to stimulate the economy through deficit spending; the idea is that they spend money now that they may or may not try to collect through taxation later (the other option is just to let inflation take care of it). The effect is that the citizens have more money in their pockets, not less.

Even if the government did try to stimulate the economy through taxation, it's easy enough to make sure that taxed citizens have more money to spend instead of less, by simply choosing the right structure of taxes. An obvious example of this is the proposed 0.1% tax on stock transactions. Buying stocks is not spending money, but investment (it's technically deferred consumption); if the tax were set high enough to actually deter investment, the other choice more or less is forced to be immediate consumption (i.e. spending). Similarly, a (higher) tax on corporate cash holdings would encourage companies to spend instead of retain cash, which would put more money into circulation and increase spending.

But the most egregious error is simply that the economy is not zero-sum; if the stimulus money results in increased economic growth, then the taxed citizens have more money to spend, not less. If a 1% tax increase results in an across the board 3% growth, then everyone's better off by 2%.
 
If a government atempts to stimulate the economy using money they do it through taxation. The taxed citizens have less money to spend hence they purchase less. If the companies stimulate the economy its through advertisement and investments of their own money.

Yes, taxes are a drain on the economy. But with deficit spending, you can spend the money now to get the economic growth you need in a downturn, then raise taxes later when the economy is moving on its own and can afford to be slowed down a little.

That’s the whole point of counter-cyclical financial policy. You are basically using government taxation and spending policies to shuffle economic activity backwards and forwards through time. Taking economic activity from periods of high growth, and moving them to periods of low or negative growth.

Of course, our problem for the last few decades has been politicians cutting taxes and increasing spending, then forgetting that things still have to be paid for later.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom