Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Some reports that the army's moving into Cairo now, but doesn't seem to be actively joining in on the crackdown. They may just be wanting to break everything up, protesters and police alike, to calm things down.

The Egyptian President is to speak in the next hour
 
Al-Jazeera's offices there have apparently been raided by security forces.

CNN international have a guy on a roof getting some images out

Whatever is going down, the Egyptian people are clearly NOT Happy
 
Apparently the protestors are cheering the arrival of the army in Cairo, so it seems they're expecting them to protect them from the police. I hope that is the case. Edit: It may be notable that the arrival of the army trucks more-or-less coincided with the 1600 GMT start of the curfew.
 
Last edited:
You would have a hard time convincing me that any religion is genuinely a "religion of peace".

But that's kinda the point. I don't see the local gang of Muslim-bashers go "well, mind you, Christianity is stupid too." Invariably it's the Muslims being the bad guys, and the Christians being the good upright guys. It's always Islam being evil because some verse taken out of context kinda sounds like approving violence, but Christianity being ok in spite of similar or even worse verses in there.

That's what bothers me.

Someone who can go "You would have a hard time convincing me that any religion is genuinely a "religion of peace"" is not my problem. My problem are the lemmings who insist on singling out Islam for any imaginable problem, and a few made up ones too.
 
http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742179,00.html

Mubarak can address 'his' people any minute now. Since a few minutes there is a curphew. Soldiers are reported of changing sides with the population. Mubarak is 82 and should face the facts and forget to try to hand over Egypt to his son. He will never be accepted.

The Dutch foreign minister, the Jew Rosenthal, just said that the situation is grave (he is right about that) and that Mubarak needs to address the concerns of the population. No kidding! It simply means that there will be an interim period headed by Mohamed ElBaradei, so he can prepare general elections and effectively hand Egypt over to the muslim fundamentalists. The American Era is evaporating before our eyes.

Neocons are out, open the curtain for Samuel Huntington please.
 
Last edited:
But that's kinda the point. I don't see the local gang of Muslim-bashers go "well, mind you, Christianity is stupid too." Invariably it's the Muslims being the bad guys, and the Christians being the good upright guys. It's always Islam being evil because some verse taken out of context kinda sounds like approving violence, but Christianity being ok in spite of similar or even worse verses in there.

That's what bothers me.

Someone who can go "You would have a hard time convincing me that any religion is genuinely a "religion of peace"" is not my problem. My problem are the lemmings who insist on singling out Islam for any imaginable problem, and a few made up ones too.
Are you seriously claiming that Christian terrorism is even in the same league as Islamic terrorism these days?

Not even in Alabama are Christians threatening to kill unbelievers or anyone who insults Jesus.
 
Do not for a minute think that this cannot happen in the US as well. Starting from a nice little oil crisis with skyrocketing food and fuel prices and the same scenes can happen in bankrupt cities like Detroit or states like California.
 
Last edited:
Are you seriously claiming that Christian terrorism is even in the same league as Islamic terrorism these days?

Not even in Alabama are Christians threatening to kill unbelievers or anyone who insults Jesus.

That's got nothing to do with anything inherent in either religion, though.
 
Do not for a minute think that this cannot happen in the US as well. Starting from a nice little oil crisis with skyrocketing food and fuel prices and the same scenes can happen in bankrupt cities like Detroit or states like California.

And how are you preparing for the eminent fall of Western civilization?

By driving a compact car?

Shouldn't you be stockpiling guns in Utah?
 
And how are you preparing for the eminent fall of Western civilization?

By driving a compact car?

Shouldn't you be stockpiling guns in Utah?

I am still driving the gas guzzler sportscar I bought without consideration for fuel efficiency many many moons ago.
My next car, if any, will be this VW 1L or a similar one. Until that moment arrives I will remain in the 'Havana mode'.

No, I prepare by writing blogs.

waroneurope.blogspot.com
how911wasdone.blogspot.com

And by being married with a woman from a convenient location.

Keep guessing. :D

Just in case Amsterdam (Geenstijl: Gaza-020) will become 'too hot to handle'.
 
Last edited:
I had an observation today about the Egyptian protests.

See anything missing from the photos? Any women present?

Some revolution. Meet the new boss....
 
I had an observation today about the Egyptian protests.

See anything missing from the photos? Any women present?

Some revolution. Meet the new boss....

Apparently you're looking at the wrong photos.

And here are some other reports of women participating in the protests. The number of women involved is generally described by everyone as unprecedented, with the reporter in the last link estimating the split between men and women protesters as a surprisingly equitable 60/40, with about half of those women being un-veiled secular protesters.
 
A madrassah need not be elaborate.

True. It could just be somebody's house. But would it then get counted in the stats?

And this isn't just an issue for Pakistan, by the way. 80% of British locally-trained Islamic scholars and clerics are trained in British Deobandi Madrassahs.

But, if you're going to assume this is in response to supply and demand, then the numbers don't add up. In the UK:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom

The majority of mosques are Sunni; in 2010, the affiliation of the mosques was 47% Deobandi, 25% Barelvi, 6% Salafi, 3% Maudoodi-inspired; of the remainder many were part of other Sunni traditions or unaffiliated, while 66 were Shi'a (4%).

80% of scholars, 47% of Mosques.
So it doesn't seem to be supply and demand. It seems like someone is flooding the market with their product. So I wouldn't be surprised to find that the number of Deobandi mosques is also an over-supply.

It's not your source, I got the link via wiki:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article2402973.ece

But it gives the same numbers you give and the Times claims to have made the discovery. And what does the article say towards the end?

TimesOnLine said:
Khaled Ahmed said: “The UK has been ruined by the puritanism of the Deobandis. You’ve allowed the takeover of the mosques. You can’t run multiculturalism like that, because that’s a way of destroying yourself. In Britain, the Deobandi message has become even more extreme than it is in Pakistan. It’s mind-boggling.”

In some mosques the sect has wrested control from followers of the more moderate majority, the Barelwi movement.

So the Deobandi have taken control of Mosques where they are the minority. So I think I'm right in saying that there is an over-supply of Deobandi scholars in Britain. And I think the same will be true in Pakistan.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barelvi#Presence

wiki said:
India Today estimates that the vast majority of Muslims in India adhere to the Barelvi movement,[7] and The Times (UK) writes that a majority of (South Asian) Muslims in the United Kingdom adhere to the movement as well.[8] Similarly, the conservative think tank The Heritage Foundation gives such estimates for the vast majority of Sunni Muslims in Pakistan.[2]

So there goes your "majority of Pakistani Muslims are Deobandis" claim. You based it on nothing but the number of schools. And you were wrong to do so.

Here's wiki's source's source:
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Re...stans-Pluralist-Traditions-to-Fight-Extremism

The Heritage Foundation said:
The Barelvis were founded by Ahmed Raza Khan of Bareilli (1856-1921). Most Pakistanis adhere to this school of thought, which also draws from Sufi traditions.

[...] Deobandis are closely linked with a religiously intolerant interpretation of Islam and have established several hundred Islamic seminaries in Pakistan, many of which abet militancy.

[...] On June 2, 2008, Darul Uloom, a Deoband madrassah in India, issued a fatwa (Islamic edict) against terrorism calling it "the most inhumane crime." Pakistan political party Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazlur Rehman (JUI-F), which is ideologically linked to Darul Uloom, endorsed the fatwa.[28] Darul Uloom is one of the most important Islamic schools in the world, but has become notorious in recent years because many Pakistani extremist groups and the Taliban claim to be Deobandi adherents. Schol*ars of Islam have pointed out that a significant divide separates Deobandi scholars and clerics from mili*tant groups such as the Taliban. Observers say the Taliban has oversimplified the original Deobandi teachings and note that Deobandis living in India support the secular government, while the Taliban support a violent anti-state agenda

So it seems that the Deobandis aren't monolithic, either.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom