Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Again, talking Pakistan here, not the world, and this is only a reflection of Muslims enrolled in Madrassahs. 1.25 million of the 1.5 million Muslims enrolled in Madrassahs are following this extremist ideology. It's a useful tool for judging the religious ideology of the total population - if they were primarily progressive sufists we'd expect the majority of Pakistan's madrassahs to be progressive sufist schools.

Unless the Sufis don't have as much money to spend.

If 83% of US christian schools were Amish you'd be totally justified in judging US christians by what the Amish do.

Not if the Amish had 83% of the money. Or if their foreign backers provided most of the money used for religious schools.
 
Al-Jazeera were saying earlier that their live satellite channel was jammed in Egypt. They've also had occasional problems with other satellite feeds. They're still managing to get news out, though.
 
Apparently the clashes have started in Cairo between police and protestors.

Edit: "police and thousands of protestors", so despite efforts to clamp down on communications it sounds like everyone's out.
 
Does anyone have an opinion on whether the protestors are likely to succeed in their aims? Looking at the link Kellyb posted earlier reminded me of watching videos from Iran a while back. It looked then as thought they might succeed... but ultimately they didn't. Tunisia did succeed in getting the president replaced.

How likely is change in Egypt?
 
Algeria is real candidate for this scenario.

Not sure about SA though. The population may not be happy, but I understand that they are developing at breakneck speed to be able to compete once they run out of oil.
So the population is looking at a real chance of economic development under the current system. And as the saying goes; Hope shines eternal.

Happened to talk to a Saudi this weekend, so my information may be a lot rosier than is warranted.

A large part of the reason for the rumblings are the most basic and common reason for a revolution, people are hungry and poor, and getting hungrier, with not much in the way of prospects for work. SA has plenty of wealth, and looks after it's own in terms of basics. Don't know if a Spartacus type of uprising would be on the cards.
 
I haven't got the video they link to to run, but:
http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Back...-s-Mubarak-no-dictator-he-shouldn-t-step-down

Asked if he would characterize Mubarak as a dictator Biden responded: “Mubarak has been an ally of ours in a number of things. And he’s been very responsible on, relative to geopolitical interest in the region, the Middle East peace efforts; the actions Egypt has taken relative to normalizing relationship with – with Israel. … I would not refer to him as a dictator.”
 
'Protests in Egypt - live updates':

12.59pm: In another extraordinary audio report Jack Shenker in Cairo reports on signs that the police are siding with the protesters. He saw a senior police officer discard a teargas canister to signal to protesters that he was on their side. Will the regime fall he asked a state journalist. "It's already falling, it can't stop," Jack was told.
 
Unless the Sufis don't have as much money to spend.

A madrassah need not be elaborate. Most of the schools in India prior to the establishment of the Deoband Madrassah were very small and informal. Even if the Deobandi Madrassahs were the flash expensive ones pulling in the most students, if it really was a teeny tiny minority of the population there'd be thousands more tiny little low-budget garage-job Madrassahs teaching one or two students (just like there is in India). But there isn't. Not in Pakistan. There's only love for the Deoband, there.



Not if the Amish had 83% of the money. Or if their foreign backers provided most of the money used for religious schools.

Let's just pretend for a moment that the majority of Pakistanis didn't want Deobandi Islam, but had no choice. What do you think happens when virtually all of your formally educated clerics adhere to a particular ideology in your country? What do you think the ideology is that they pass on to the population?

And this isn't just an issue for Pakistan, by the way. 80% of British locally-trained Islamic scholars and clerics are trained in British Deobandi Madrassahs. It's this whole world wide craze going on. But yeah, I'm sure they're just this teeny tiny insignificant minority. And where do the majority of Britain's Muslims come from? Oh yeah, PAKISTAN.

Never mind that it's pretty self evident that the Deobandi brand of Islam is hugely popular in Pakistan. These guys have massive demonstrations in support of mass murderers like Osama Bin Laden. Charming.

But hey, you're probably right, they're all just hanging out for some peace and it's just a teeny million or so (and counting) bad apples that produced the Sepoy Mutiny, and the Hindustani Fanatics, and the Taliban, and Al Qaeda, and... well yeah... most of the death and murder and misery in that part of the world for the last two centuries or so. Bring on the peace, they cry.

:rolleyes:
 
Oops,

they are arresting opposition leaders, ElBaradei included.

There were tens of thousands of protesters, at least, on the streets of Cairo and Alexandria, Egypt's second largest city. Al Jazeera reported that democracy figurehead and Nobel Prize winner Mohamed ElBaradei was detained by police, but Al Arabiya was reporting that he and supporters in Cairo were simply penned in by riot police near the mosque in Cairo where they had attended noon prayers.

Link

Looks like they're cracking down hard on the protests.
 
'Protests in Egypt - live updates':

12.59pm: In another extraordinary audio report Jack Shenker in Cairo reports on signs that the police are siding with the protesters. He saw a senior police officer discard a teargas canister to signal to protesters that he was on their side. Will the regime fall he asked a state journalist. "It's already falling, it can't stop," Jack was told.

You still want to maintain that Maghreb wide regime change is a 'paranoid rubbish', with islamic fundamentalism as the final outcome?

Where is your sense of Jihad, Jane? :cool:
 
Last edited:
Oops,

they are arresting opposition leaders, ElBaradei included.



Link

Looks like they're cracking down hard on the protests.

ElBaradei is now apparently out of the mosque where he was penned, and is now part of a peaceful march. Some of the protestors are shaking hands with the police.
 
There's quite an interesting running commentary from the BBC.

1453: Some of the most serious violence has been in Suez, where protesters seized weapons stored in a police station and asked the policemen inside to leave the building before burning it down, according to the Associated Press. They also set about 20 police vehicles parked nearby on fire.
1458: BBC technology correspondent Mark Gregory says: "Something unprecedented has happened: virtually the entire internet infrastructure of an electronically sophisticated nation has been switched off. Pulling the plug in say the US or a European country would be virtually impossible as there are so many different channels that carry electronic traffic. Parallels are being drawn with Iran during the democracy protests 18 months ago where, as in Egypt over recent days, the authorities' restricted access to services like Facebook and Twitter and cut parts of networks for periods of time. But Egypt has gone a step further. This is believed to be the first time a government has engineered an almost complete shut down of electronic communications to deal with political dissent."
 
Last edited:
Some reports that the army's moving into Cairo now, but doesn't seem to be actively joining in on the crackdown. They may just be wanting to break everything up, protesters and police alike, to calm things down.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom