Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

Obama to address the US within 5 minutes.

Prediction: He's going to (basically) side with the protesters, hope the Egyptian army does not harm civillians, and call on the protesters to refrain from "violence" but not mention non-violent vandalism against government buildings.
 
what's happening in the Middle East?

the people have finally said "no more!!!!".

good for them.
 
I wonder how deep he will climb into Mubarak's ass..........


Oh, they obviously had a nice chat already right after Mubarak`s speech with Obama confirming that he will be on his side, it seems.
 
What a bunch of crap. Obama just essentially said he's committed to working with Mubarak and just wants him to be a little less dictatorish.
 
Not a good move IMHO.

He would have been better off keeping his mouth shut and let Hillary yap about how she hopes nobody gets hurt.

Of course, the US has been in bed with Mubarak for so long that he can't just drop him like a hot potato. Unless he orders the army to fire at the crowds, that is.
 
Kelly, that's not the gist of the speech I got. It seemed to me that the implied message was, "Look, you're our ally and we'll do what we can to stand with you. So if you make actual reforms that help your people, we'll stay friends. If you hurt anyone, keep restricting communication, or crack down on civil rights, then have fun being exiled."
 


I wonder if it actually was the other way around. Mubarak called Obama whining something along the "please, please help me"-line, because I see no reason why Obama should have make a speech at this point and time.

Either way, the USG wants to keep Mubarak because they fear all the unknowns that would come with new leaders, including the ones concerning the relationship between Israel and Egypt. Freedom and Democracy probably didn't cross his mind as much as usual, me guesses.
 
Kelly, that's not the gist of the speech I got. It seemed to me that the implied message was, "Look, you're our ally and we'll do what we can to stand with you. So if you make actual reforms that help your people, we'll stay friends. If you hurt anyone, keep restricting communication, or crack down on civil rights, then have fun being exiled."

How is that different from what I said? "Be a little less dictatorish"?
 
How is that different from what I said? "Be a little less dictatorish"?

I guess I just don't think it was as supportive as I thought you perceived it. But that's a lot of assumptions for me to make in one sentence.
 
My advice to Hosni, take the first plane to some ZOG city like London or Washington, where you belong.
More likely Paris or Cannes. Better climate, more mondaine, and scores of ex-colleagues to have a chat with.

Even the French revolution didn't spill over to the rest of Europe.
Actually it did. It spilled over to Belgium, to the Netherlands and to various states in the Rhineland and in Northern Italy.

Kelly, that's not the gist of the speech I got. It seemed to me that the implied message was, "Look, you're our ally and we'll do what we can to stand with you. So if you make actual reforms that help your people, we'll stay friends. If you hurt anyone, keep restricting communication, or crack down on civil rights, then have fun being exiled."
That was my take on it too. But he couched it in very carefully chosen words.

But with these pictures, I doubt Mubarak makes it through the weekend.
 
I wonder if it actually was the other way around. Mubarak called Obama whining something along the "please, please help me"-line, because I see no reason why Obama should have make a speech at this point and time.

Either way, the USG wants to keep Mubarak because they fear all the unknowns that would come with new leaders, including the ones concerning the relationship between Israel and Egypt. Freedom and Democracy probably didn't cross his mind as much as usual, me guesses.

Yeah, I had the same thought, too.
 
But that's kinda the point. I don't see the local gang of Muslim-bashers go "well, mind you, Christianity is stupid too."

Could it be where you're posting? This is a politics thread. Let's face it, Christianity has the political power of a soggy paper bag. There's little of political interest to discuss regarding what is a dying religion. But if you go into the religion threads you'll have a feast of Christian bashing.

Islam, on the other hand, is a major political issue, and it's a rising power. That's partly a difference in the ideology of the two faiths - Christianity attempts to set itself apart from politics and earthly matters (render under Caesar what is Caesars...), where as Islam does the opposite, it argues that there's no such thing as separation. Secondly it's a practical thing - Islam has a bloc of the world where it's incredibly influential to politics.

Having said that, I have, on occasion, seen threads in US Politics that bring up religious influence in US politics, and they generally seem pretty damning of the religion.



Invariably it's the Muslims being the bad guys, and the Christians being the good upright guys.

I don't think you can actually back up that assertion. I think you'll have a hard time finding many people posting at JREF who consider Christians to be "good upright guys".


It's always Islam being evil because some verse taken out of context kinda sounds like approving violence, but Christianity being ok in spite of similar or even worse verses in there.

Yeah, okay I agree with you here, there can be some hypocrisy and some people don't apply critical thinking. Quote mining is a piece of cake when you're looking at a religious text. But the crucial difference is not what the books say, but what their followers are saying. For example the well known passage from one of the Hadith's in which it is said even the rocks will call out to Muslims to reveal the hiding place of Jews, so the Muslims can kill them.

The point, for me, that makes this worth raising is not that it has been written. The point is how it's perceived by Fundamentalist Muslims. This is quoted in Hamas' creed, for example. It's consistently and widely quoted by Islamic Fundamentalists - it's one of their favourite passages. It's not just that it was written, it's that fundamentalists are using it.



Someone who can go "You would have a hard time convincing me that any religion is genuinely a "religion of peace"" is not my problem. My problem are the lemmings who insist on singling out Islam for any imaginable problem, and a few made up ones too.

I'm interested in real potential problems. Christianity, particularly fundamentalist Christianity, doesn't pose any serious problems to my culture as far as I'm aware. It's not taken seriously enough. That's not to say they're not a problem at all, but the level of threat they pose is fairly minimal. And this might come down to background too. My country has never been particularly religious. Even when people say they're Christian, it's very low key and seems to consist of "I believe in God". Church attendance in my country has always been low by Western standards, and has dropped exponentially in recent years. The fastest growing census response to religion is "none". As such I see Christianity is basically irrelevant. It might be different in the USA where Christianity seems much more popular, and where there seems to be a broader swathe of fundamentalists.

The situation's quite different for fundamentalist Islam. It's a growing ideology, and they have substantial blocs of power in places like Pakistan and Saudi Arabia. And what concerns me most of all is that the West seems to be in denial. Saudi Arabia and Pakistan are supposedly best buddies with the USA. America's fixated on Iran (which poses no threat at all), North Korea (which might pose a threat to South Korea but the South Koreans would annihilate them IMHO), Afghanistan (which is actually just a byproduct of Pakistan), and a bunch of silly little conflicts in Africa that are pretty awful for the local people but have no global reach.

Meanwhile our "pals" in Saudi Arabia and Pakistan are exporting extremist ideology across the globe (and into the west) as fast as they can while playing lip service to the "War on Terror" (another example of the west missing the point), and the USA is turning a blind eye to Israel's illegal occupation of Palestine which is giving those extremists a huge amount of traction in the Muslim world.

What I'm interested in is trying to spread the word amongst westerners that terrorism is a tactic, not a threat, and that the real danger is Radical Ideology, and that currently our approaches are making the situation WORSE. Once you get westerners to drop the PC crap, be honest, and admit that Radical Islam is actually a danger (the danger), it's unavoidable that the west's attitude to Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Palestine/Israel, Iran, Afghanistan, Iraq and everywhere else MUST change.

There's no comparable issue with Radical Christians, so no, you won't catch me making similar posts on that theme around here, and I'm not apologetic for that and I don't consider it hypocrisy. Christianity and Islam do not occupy the same geo-political place in the world today. I don't seriously criticise Christianity, I go poke fun at it when I want some light entertainment.
 
I guess I just don't think it was as supportive as I thought you perceived it. But that's a lot of assumptions for me to make in one sentence.

The people want him OUT. GONE.

Responding to the people would be resigning. If the CNN coverage is accurate, at the beginning of the protests, a lot of people were like "Whatever" about the whole thing, but after he cut off cell phones and the internet, EVERYONE was like "Oh, wow, yeah, we need to boot the dictator." Committing to just be less dictatory is way too little too late now, and the US can either back the people OR the president. It's a zero sum game now and there's no way to turn that around at this point, I don't think.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom