Merged What's happening in the Middle East?

That's got nothing to do with anything inherent in either religion, though.
It depends which sect you look at. "Inherent" is whatever that particular sect teaches. There's no central authority on Islam, such as a Pope or Archbishop. And it's an extremely violent and ruthless sect of Islam that has taken over much of Somalia, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. And much of that is a direct result of what is taught at Saudi-funded madrassas in these areas. The "moderate" Saudis who lop off hands and cut out eyes and lop off heads of those who violate religious laws.

And it's certainly been enough for Iran to survive as a fundamentalist Shiite theocracy for over 30 years, still capable of brutally repressing any challenges to its power, as we saw last year.

Watch what happens in Yemen if that government falls.
 
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...nocean/egypt/8288167/Egypt-protests-live.html

In Alexandria, according to Al-Jazeera, the army is shaking hands with protesters. The Guardian reports that a Human Rights Watch officer confirms that:

"The army has deployed in Alexandria but atmosphere is calm. Soldiers are talking to protestors. Confirmed that Alexandria governorate and many police stations burned down."

In Suez, as well, there are reports that the relations between army and protesters remain calm.

I'm beginning to hope this will be over quicker than I thought.

It might not be just a few people making individual choices if the army and protestors are getting along on this scale. But there's no word of any policy from an army bigwig.
 
It depends which sect you look at. "Inherent" is whatever that particular sect teaches. There's no central authority on Islam, such as a Pope or Archbishop.

That's exactly what I mean, though. There are sects and subsects of Islam that are extremely violent. But there are also sects and subsects of Islam that are not (along an entire spectrum ranging from "slightly less violent" to "pretty much pacifist and ecumenical", in fact).

There's nothing about Islam qua Islam that makes a violent (or even non-violent) religious doctrine among its adherents inevitable and inescapable. Just as there is nothing about Christianity qua Christianity that makes a peaceful and tolerant (or even violent) religious doctrine among its adherents inevitable and inescapable.
 
Last edited:
But that's kinda the point. I don't see the local gang of Muslim-bashers go "well, mind you, Christianity is stupid too." Invariably it's the Muslims being the bad guys, and the Christians being the good upright guys. It's always Islam being evil because some verse taken out of context kinda sounds like approving violence, but Christianity being ok in spite of similar or even worse verses in there.

That's what bothers me.

Someone who can go "You would have a hard time convincing me that any religion is genuinely a "religion of peace"" is not my problem. My problem are the lemmings who insist on singling out Islam for any imaginable problem, and a few made up ones too.

I disagree.

My concern over radical Islam is based largely on my personal experience growing up among Christians. Most of them are fine people, even good, but fundamentally the religion teaches us that what happens in this world isn't important except how it reflects in the next world. Combine that with a world-view that sees world events as a literal struggle between good and evil and an expectation that end-times are coming soon, where Christians will have to fight or be persecuted, and the potential for violence is obvious. That violence doesn't happen much isn't a testament to the religion, but to the overall society that contains it and waters it down.
 
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...nocean/egypt/8288167/Egypt-protests-live.html



I'm beginning to hope this will be over quicker than I thought.

It might not be just a few people making individual choices if the army and protestors are getting along on this scale. But there's no word of any policy from an army bigwig.

They are not going to shoot on their own people, I think it is likely over soon (before monday). The really interesting question will be who is going to be the next domino? Syria?
 
Another interesting question is, if indeed all the dominoes fall and fundamentalist regimes installed, who is going to be the leader of Islam?

Turkey, Egypt, Iran?
 
hmm reports of Tear gas cans with made in the US on them. Aparently china doesn't make everything.
 
They are not going to shoot on their own people, I think it is likely over soon (before monday). The really interesting question will be who is going to be the next domino? Syria?

Doesn't have to happen.

Even the French revolution didn't spill over to the rest of Europe.

The BBC just described the protesters as 'young, English speaking and not like old guard who supported the Muslim Brotherhood'.
 
Originally Posted by 9/11-investigator
who is going to be the leader of Islam?


....err...is there one now???
 
Don't you remember when Reagan stood up on the floor of the UN and said, famously, "I AM THE PRESIDENT OF CHRISTIANITY"
 
What about Charlie Sheen's hernia? ;)

Protesters form human shield to keep looters from Museum of Antiquity! ~Al Jazeera
 
Last edited:
What about Charlie Sheen's hernia? ;)

Protesters form human shield to keep looters from Museum of Antiquity! ~Al Jazeera

Don't worry. The army has formed a steel one. just hope the fire at the NDP HQ doesn't spread.
 
Doesn't have to happen.

Even the French revolution didn't spill over to the rest of Europe.

The BBC just described the protesters as 'young, English speaking and not like old guard who supported the Muslim Brotherhood'.

It was postponed until 1917.

That is what Bertus Hendriks from Clingendael said as well 5 minutes ago on Dutch television. He described the MB as a sort of muslim Christian Democrats aspiring for real democracy.

I am sceptical.

(Bertus Hendriks said that Mubarak is finished now that the army refuses to shoot)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom