Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

<snippage by TjW>
yeah I guess you could come up with something that was more believable than the plane was shot down by something that shattered it into thousands of teeny tiny little pieces which don't resemble anything seen in any aviation crash ever in history.

I'm not an expert on air to air combat, but what sort of weapon would shatter a huge airplane into teeny tiny little pieces? Missiles generally separate the airplane into a couple of large pieces. Since the large pieces can't fly independently, this is generally Good Enough.
Did people find unexplained bits of Boeing all over the county? That's what I would expect if an aircraft were shattered into teeny tiny little pieces while it was still in the air. Compare to the size of the debris fields of the Lockerbie crash or the TWA 800 explosion.
Why didn't all this scattered debris show up on Ebay?
 
I'm bored, so I will address some of these points, even though, ironically enough, there is no point.

Yeah it would be totally unreasonable to think the government shot down a plane on 9/11 after 3 hijacked ones killed thousands of Americans.

No, it's unreasonable to think the government would do so then LIE about it.

Dismiss Felt's call from the bathroom, dismiss the fact that most locals believe it was shot down because they live there and well in these area's they say "people talk",

Gladly.

forget about the plane hitting at a 40 degree angle despite the official story is it nose dived into the ground which would be more consistent with the imprint,

The official story is more consistent with the imprint? So, why bring up 40 degrees?

dismiss the fact that the wingspan is nowhere near the size of a 757's,

The wingspan of what? The hole in the ground?

Holes in the ground do not have wingspans.

dismiss the fact that there was no fuel contamination in the soil or water,

According to you.

dismiss the fact that no body parts or blood were found at the scene,

Yes, there were body parts, although they were so badly damaged that they were difficult to recognize. Why you would expect to find blood in the aftermath of such an energetic crash is beyond me.

dismiss the fact that there were no raging jet fuel fires burning the grass near the crater yet somehow managed to annihilate a whole section of forest but the fires were out before anyone arrived on the scene which is good because Stoystown would not have been able to handle such fires,

I suppose you have performed computer simulations that lead you to the conclusions that the fire didn't behave as it should; otherwise, you would just be talking out of your hat. Could you share with us the methodology you used?

dismiss the fact that debris scattered over an 8 mile radius,

Again, I assume you have some sort of model that demonstrates such a debris field is impossible. I assume that you know better than to rely on common sense, since an airliner hitting the ground at over half the speed of sound is not a common occurance.

dismiss the fact that no one is allowed to hear the final 3 minutes of the CVR,

Obviously, someone is allowed to hear it, or we wouldn't know what it contained.

dismiss the fact that there was a white jet, C-130, and 2 fighter jets all within the vacinity,

Thanks, I will.

dismiss the fact that locals say their lights "flickered" - their houses "rattled" - and then the plane "hit"

So they SAW the plane hit? From inside their houses? Or did they see the houses rattling and lights flickering from a distance?

and yeah I guess you could come up with something that was more believable than the plane was shot down by something that shattered it into thousands of teeny tiny little pieces

Why wouldn't hitting the ground at several hundred miles an hour shatter the plane into thousands of pieces? You realise that planes aren't built to withstand ground impacts, but to avoid them?

which don't resemble anything seen in any aviation crash ever in history.

According to you. Perhaps you'd like to share with us your expertise in investigating crash scenes?
 
Okay then:

Evidence people on this thread have dismissed it?

Evidence?

Whiskey Tango Foxtrot?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?

Evidence?


Since you obviously have no knowledge whatsoever in regards to this event let me suggest you remove yourself from this discussion until you catch up with the rest of the class. Now go do your homework. Come back when you've read up on everything regarding this flight including the EPA reports and the FDR pdf.
 
Since you obviously have no knowledge whatsoever in regards to this event let me suggest you remove yourself from this discussion until you catch up with the rest of the class. Now go do your homework. Come back when you've read up on everything regarding this flight including the EPA reports and the FDR pdf.
In other words, you don't have any evidence, you believe what you believe and don't need any. I think you forget where you're posting. This isn't your little CT fanboy forum where little tykes gush over their fav CT.

Thanks
 
(Logical respectfully-phrased analysis followed by reasonable question)

TC329 said:
(dead silence)

How 'bout it, TC? Any flaws in my reasoning or evidence I've overlooked? Do you disagree with my conclusions, and if so, on what basis? And can you answer the question I asked? (The right-arrow button next to "Myriad" on the quote above will link you to the post I'm referring to.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Error cell
if you would return to the topic of this thread you started. Go up a few postings and if you wouldnt mind. Place the location of the "'crater'" within the hi resolution image of the garage posted.
 
He's urging US to look at the FDR report? The one that shows the plane being flown into the ground with all systems functioning normally?

When TC329 first posted here in October, he spewed all the same falsehoods. He was corrected then, but those corrections had no effect. He hasn't learned a thing or taken a moment to study.

I have to go out and buy a less sensitive irony meter. I'll be back later.
 
Tell you what, I'll concede all your points and say, for the sake of argument, that flight 93 was shot down by the US govt.

So?

Don't you think they were entirely justified in doing such a thing, considering the airliner was to be used as a weapon against sensitive targets in Washington DC?

Why in the world would they keep such a thing secret? When the navy accidentally shot down an Iranian airliner back in the mid-80's, the govt. immediately took responsibility, apologized, and offered reparations to the survivors. If they did this for a country they weren't even on friendly terms with, then why would they try to cover up a completely justified, although traumatic, shoot-down over Pennsylvania?

Is a shoot down still justified if the final 3 minutes of the cvr prove the passengers took the plane back?
 
I can easily dismiss most of those "facts" because you either made them up or you are quoting them verbatim from CT websites. For instance, "no body parts found" -- ridiculous. This is simply a misinterpretation from a medical examiner who was shocked to find no bodies at the scene -- because the destruction was so complete, there was nothing recognizable left.

But, of course, you know this already. Troll.

How am I troll? I said there was no blood or body parts at the scene. Now here is your words pointed right back at you :

"This is simply a misinterpretation from a medical examiner who was shocked to find no bodies at the scene"


You repeat what I say and call me a troll. Insults will prove you're right and I'm wrong. Keep up the great work!
 
P.S.: Well, the more I look at the video, the more obvious the parallax is. The dark thingy is not a crater at all, as a hole in the ground would not show a parallax relative to the ground, it's gotta be something sticking up above the ground. There appear to be four or five more prominent "limbs" sticking out from the main smudge. One to the left and two on the right. There also appear to be a couple of smaller ones right at the back. Those seem interesting, since there is an even darker spot in this area as well. To me, the smaller "limbs" show a parallax against this darker spot and this can only mean that the dark spot has to be farther away from the camera and thus behind them. How can anything be *behind* a hole in the ground?


Absolutely, and since taking two images from different angles is the basis of stereography (3D pictures like a ViewMaster) the easiest way to see it is as a stereo pair. I've captured two images and aligned them with StereoPhoto Maker, then slightly sharpened and enhanced them. Below are two different sizes (since some people have difficulty viewing larger pairs), which are the pairs in left-right-left order. That means you can view the left and center pair with "parallel free-viewing" (adjusting your eyes as as if looking at something far in the distance until those two image converge and form a stereo pair), or you can view the center and right pair with "cross-eyed free-viewing" (crossing your eyes as if looking at something about half-way between you and the image until that pair converges. This method is sometimes easier if you look at your fingertip about half-way between, but still noticing the pair in the background, and then move your finger back and forth until the two image are approximately converged, then shift your focus to the images without changing the cross-eyed angle of your eyes.)


image34sm.png


image34s.png



I still can't tell what it is, but we can say some of the things it isn't: Probability of crater = 0%. Your description is accurate: It's some 3D "blobject" definitely sitting on top of the ground.
 
Last edited:
In other words, you don't have any evidence, you believe what you believe and don't need any. I think you forget where you're posting. This isn't your little CT fanboy forum where little tykes gush over their fav CT.

Thanks

Because you haven't looked at the evidence and have done no research on this topic yet choose to argue with me that I am wrong I am supposed to post everything for you to dismiss? Waste of my time. If you actually care about "truth" you will do your own research instead of asking or demanding others do it for you.
 
Is a shoot down still justified if the final 3 minutes of the cvr prove the passengers took the plane back?

Do you have any proof this happened? Or is this unfounded conjecture on your part? I know what I'm betting on.

I would still say yes, because there would have to be other proof that they did manage to do that. It would be a tragedy, but it would still be justified.
 
How am I troll? I said there was no blood or body parts at the scene. Now here is your words pointed right back at you :

"This is simply a misinterpretation from a medical examiner who was shocked to find no bodies at the scene"


You repeat what I say and call me a troll. Insults will prove you're right and I'm wrong. Keep up the great work!

Medical Examiner says no bodies. You say no body parts. Big difference.

There were body parts...lots of them. But there were no bodies.
 
How 'bout it, TC? Any flaws in my reasoning or evidence I've overlooked? Do you disagree with my conclusions, and if so, on what basis? And can you answer the question I asked? (The right-arrow button next to "Myriad" on the quote above will link you to the post I'm referring to.)

Respectfully,
Myriad

I agree with your assessment it is not an ATV or a shadow. I don't know exactly how you come to the conclussion that it is flat, that I disagree with. And I have stated that I do consider the possibility of it being a large chunk of debris. This would be the largest piece of debris from the plane ever seen and wouldn't you agree that it would be quite strange that this wouldn't have been photographed and documented better? Shouldn't this have been used in the trial as evidence as well?
 
Medical Examiner says no bodies. You say no body parts. Big difference.

There were body parts...lots of them. But there were no bodies.

There were no body parts nor blood at the "crash" site. Period.

In fact, Miller says only roughly 8% was recovered. it is not stated where that 8% was recovered but from those at the crash site that morning we can determine where they weren't recovered.
 
He's urging US to look at the FDR report? The one that shows the plane being flown into the ground with all systems functioning normally?

When TC329 first posted here in October, he spewed all the same falsehoods. He was corrected then, but those corrections had no effect. He hasn't learned a thing or taken a moment to study.

I have to go out and buy a less sensitive irony meter. I'll be back later.


True or False?

According to the FDR pdf Flight "93" impacted the ground at a 40 degree angle.
 
Since you obviously have no knowledge whatsoever in regards to this event let me suggest you remove yourself from this discussion until you catch up with the rest of the class. Now go do your homework. Come back when you've read up on everything regarding this flight including the EPA reports and the FDR pdf.

You are the one making the extraordinary claims.
You present evidence to substantiate your claims for others to scrutanize.
We are not here to do your work for you.

My prompting you to present your supporting evidence in no way reflects my knowledge, or lack thereof, of the incident in question. The fact that you take it as such, and attempt to use that assumption as a dodge from answering my call for you to support your claims causes me to question the veracity, objectivity, and soundness of your claims.

And seeing as how you are not a moderator on this forum(1) I'll partake in this thread if I so feel like.

(1) Oh how that must frustrate our visitors from some sites such as LCF.
 
Is a shoot down still justified if the final 3 minutes of the cvr prove the passengers took the plane back?

What final three minutes?

Oh these.................

168. Ibid., pp. 23­27.We also reviewed a report regarding seismic observations on September 11, 2001, whose authors conclude that the impact time of United 93 was "10:06:05±5 (EDT)."Won-Young Kim and G. R. Baum, "Seismic Observations during September 11, 2001,Terrorist Attack," spring 2002 (report to the Maryland Department of Natural Resources). But the seismic data on which they based this estimate are far too weak in signal-to-noise ratio and far too speculative in terms of signal source to be used as a means of contradicting the impact time established by the very accurate combination of FDR, CVR, ATC, radar, and impact site data sets.These data sets constrain United 93's impact time to within 1 second, are airplane- and crash-site specific, and are based on time codes automatically recorded in the ATC audiotapes for the FAA centers and correlated with each data set in a process internationally accepted within the aviation accident investigation community.

Furthermore, one of the study's principal authors now concedes that "seismic data is not definitive for the impact of UA 93." Email from Won-Young Kim to the Commission,"Re: UA Flight 93," July 7, 2004; see also Won-Young Kim,"Seismic Observations for UA Flight 93 Crash near Shanksville, Pennsylvania during September 11, 2001," July 5, 2004.

http://www.faqs.org/docs/911/911Report-478.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom