Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

Yes, exactly. What are you trying to get at here?

Did the plane get shot down? Or was the crash faked? Or is there some other twisted, convoluted scheme we all don't know about? If so, how about taking some of your precious time and filling us in?

Standard Troofer Procedure: Don't ever, ever reveal what you believe took place, because you will be instantly be branded a loon. Instead, try to find fault with reliable reports about what happened.

Don't dig too deep, though. As soon as you begin to realize you're wrong, stop all research IMMEDIATELY, and just keep repeating your claims until your opponents give up.

Right, THX329?
 
Anywhere there was debris is considered part of "the scene"/"the IMPACT SITE". Are you seriously claiming there was no "body parts" or "blood" in the crater, but only in the surrounding debris field?


You know if you look through all the Wiki aircraft crash entries, there are rather a few where bugger all is left of the plane.......
 
what exactly are you claiming happened to the plane and the people onboard Flight 93?[/COLOR


I'd like to know that too. TC seems to be angling for a couple of widely divergent senarios, neither of which include the plane crashing due to the efforts of the passengers to take back the plane and the reaction to that by the hijackers.

How any of this pertains to the 'mystery' dark spot in the video he started the thread with is also a mystery.

It has already been pointed out that a shoot down would not cause the plane or the people on board to splinter into small pieces,
 
Great stuff, William! Stereography never even crossed my mind. Which is kinda ironic, since I'd spent the whole summer taking two shots at every photo opportunity, trying to combine the pics for a 3D view. Family and pets got so annoyed, they practically disavowed me.

Your pics do show the exact same effect I'd noticed in the video. Dark thingies pointing upwards above the ground. TErrorCell, there goes your crater. Unless it's one of those classified above ground craters, which form when the soopah-seekrit-ueber-powerfull star wars beam machine discharges. But I don't know much about those, you better ask Ace or Wood...
 
Stereography never even crossed my mind. Which is kinda ironic, since I'd spent the whole summer taking two shots at every photo opportunity, trying to combine the pics for a 3D view. Family and pets got so annoyed, they practically disavowed me.

Have you used StereoPhoto Maker? It's a really nice piece of freeware, and one of the best features is an "auto-align" that works great. It saves a lot of work with single-camera pairs, which usually aren't aligned well. It uses another freeware program called AutoPano (originally intended for stitching together panoramas) to find common points in the pair, and then it does any resizing, rotations, perspective adjustments and horizontal/vertical shifting necessary to get them to line up, much better than I can do by hand with the manual controls. It also has an auto color adjustment to match the colors in the pair, which is nice for single-camera if the lighting isn't quite the same between the two shots. (I made a "twin" by mounting a pair of cheap 2 MP digital cameras on a bar with their shutter buttons wired together, which works pretty well for snapshots except that the vertical alignment is a little off and the colors aren't quite the same from the two cameras, but SPM fixes them just fine.)

There are a lot of opportunities for finding "unintentional" stereo pairs in press photos or using a pair of frames from a moving video camera, since it just takes two images of the same thing from two slightly different angles. I posted these a couple months ago, but here are some coincidental stereo pairs of Flight 175 hitting WTC 2, which I think are pretty astonishing. The left pics were from an amateur video that was included on a CNN DVD, and the right ones were taken by a lady with a digital still camera apparently just a few feet away. ("No-planers" need to explain to me how these "faked" pictures ended up with such a perfect stereo paralax for the fake plane.)

WTC2LRLs.jpg


WTC2-2LRLs.jpg
 
How about answering one of my questions before I continue addressing your posts?

*True or False - According to Flight "93" fdr the plane hit at a 40 degree angle.

What does it matter whether the aircraft rammed the ground at a 40 degree angle or some other angle? It hit the ground, creating a crater, shattering the aircraft and dispersing parts across a large area. I believe a 40 degree angle would certainly be consistent with this.

However, I see nothing in the FDR report that indicates a specific angle at impact. Do you have access to a different copy of the report?
 
Terrorcell, time to start making sense. You've gone from asking about a mysterious "crater" to regurgiataing every theory surrounding United 93 that ever made headlines at prisonplanet. Does that mean that you've given up on your "crater"? Do you concede that the reporter was NOT talking about your "crater" during the interview linked in your OP? Do you admit that this misconception is what led you yourself to believe the black thing was a crater? Please answer.

Another thing, if you believe UA93 was shot down, why are you asking where the blood and bodies are?
And if you think something other than UA93 crashed or was shot down, why are you asking about the "missing" 3 minutes of CVR recording?

How does a 5' X 6' 3-dimensional "crater" fit with either scenario? If you do have a theory, we'd really, REALLY love to hear it.
 
What does it matter whether the aircraft rammed the ground at a 40 degree angle or some other angle? It hit the ground, creating a crater, shattering the aircraft and dispersing parts across a large area. I believe a 40 degree angle would certainly be consistent with this.

However, I see nothing in the FDR report that indicates a specific angle at impact. Do you have access to a different copy of the report?

The 40-degree angle comes from the graph in the FDR report from the NTSB. As far as I know, there is no CSV file for that graph.
 
The 40-degree angle comes from the graph in the FDR report from the NTSB. As far as I know, there is no CSV file for that graph.
The only claim of 90-degrees I see in this thread is from this post
"spongy concrete" :

Initial reports were that the plane burrowed into the ground at a 90 degree angle, because of the "soft" dirt the plane burrowed down into the ground. The excavation went as deep as 50'. Version #2 states the ground was solid and the plane didn't penetrate but in fact "vaporized" for the most part which is odd because of one of the data recorders being recovered from about 25' deep.

I can envision it perfectly, what I can't seem to find is all this "broken rock" in the aerial shots or in the excavation shots. Do you have any images that support your claim?

Since TC329 did not provide a source, even after being prompted for one, for this claim does anyone else have a source for it?
 
There were several initial reports of 90 degrees from eye witnesses and others who saw the plane. None of them, that I know of, said "90 degrees", most said things like "straight down", which is exactly what you'd expect most people to say/think if they saw an inverted plane at -40 deg, from most lateral angles.

Killtown has several of these claims sourced (and a picture of 40-degree in the FDR report)
http://killtown.911review.org/flight93.html
 
The 40-degree angle comes from the graph in the FDR report from the NTSB. As far as I know, there is no CSV file for that graph.

Killtown has been busy discussing his 90-degree angle here.

http://z10.invisionfree.com/Loose_Change_Forum/index.php?showtopic=1924

He comes to his 90-degree angle based on this graph.

flight93altitude.gif


He sums up his understanding of this graph by these statements.

Killtown said.
Yeah, "look like" on that chart. What degree is it coming down at, a 40 degree angle?
and
Looks like it's coming down "nearly 90 degs" to me:

Only to be descimated by common sense and science.

Posted by manorexia.

It's about 39 degrees.

the plane was travelling at 25,520 ft. every half minute, and in the last half minute of the altitude readings the plane drops 8000 ft. of altitude. Imagine that this was a triangle, the altitude being 8000 ft. and the hypotunuse being 25,520 ft. These are the same values as our half second distances. The angle can be easily figured out by using the inverse sine function on the vertical drop divided by the airspeed.

sin^-1(8000 ft./25,520 ft.) is equal to approximately 39 degrees (rounded up).

and

posted by characterzero

Killtown, consider yourself lucky that JREF members didn't see this and that I'm going to be nice enough not to point this out to them. This is, to be generous, definitely not one of the smartest things you've said.

This is a graph of elevation. It says absolutely nothing of the horizontal distance that the airplane travels, thus it's really dumb to think that you can figure out the angle of travel based on this.

THINK about this, Killtown. Would you agree that an object traveling at 1 million miles an hour aimed 1 degree downward would hit the ground faster than an object released at the same elevation and is allowed to fall freely? Because it would. The vertical component of distance can't tell you anything about the angle at which the object is traveling.
Don't worry kk , I will tell them.:D
 
Last edited:
So now we know that Clowntown has absolutly no idea how to read a graph and did not know squat about keeping units consistent when adding(from his previous attempt to add unlike terms).

Mark Twain wasn't it, who said, "better to keep one's mouth shut and be thought a fool rather than to open it and remove all doubt"?
 
Well, reviewing the graph presented from the FDR data, I have to say, there isn't any way to infer an impact angle from that printout. The time marks along the bottom are uneven so that an guesstimate for the slope of the altitude graph is unreliable at best.

And a point about witness estimates of impact, it depends on their point of view just what angle they would see. If the path was directly toward or directly away, then no matter the actual angle, the descent would appear straight down. Only from a point perpendicular to the path would the real angle be seen (then that witness would have to be able to visualize the angle and accurately report that angle).

So, to have any reason to discuss that angle we'd need to have access to the full resolution FDR data and a nice computer program to put it all together. Meanwhile, that wouldn't really give us any information useful about the crash, since it was intentional and knowing all the gory details of the physics of the crash does nothing to prevent another one.

And creating fantasies about the Federal Government weaving a mystical NWO plot won't prevent the next attack either.
 
Well, reviewing the graph presented from the FDR data, I have to say, there isn't any way to infer an impact angle from that printout. The time marks along the bottom are uneven so that an guesstimate for the slope of the altitude graph is unreliable at best.

Check it again, looks like the ticks are all 1 minute.

Manorexia's estimate uses the FDR air speed that is graphed with the pressure altitude but is difficult to see. I think the info is all there but requires careful analysis to make a good guess.
 
Angle of plane is unrelated to angle of impact

Here's an experiment you can do at home.

Take a 12-inch ruler.

Put a mark on one end of the ruler. You can use the number "12" that's already printed on the ruler if you like.

Hold it vertically, so that it is perpendicular with the ground.

Drop it.

The whole ruler will hit the ground at a 90 degree angle. That's the "angle of the plane".

An imaginary line drawn by the 12-mark as it falls through the air will also make a 90-degree angle with the ground. Call this the "angle of impact".

So in this case they are the same. But do the have to be?

Try this experiment now.
Hold the same ruler horizontally, so that it is parallel to the ground.

Drop it again.

The angle of impact -- the line the 12-mark makes -- is still 90 degrees, but the angle of the plane is now 0 degrees!

You can even throw the ruler horizontally a little. The angle of impact will be less than 90 degrees if you do, but the angle of the plane can be whatever you want it to be.

The Flight 93 FDR captured the angle of the plane.
But from this experiment, we can see that the angle of impact could be something far different.
In fact, since the plane has maneuverability controls on its wings and tail, it's not just plausible that they would be different, it's likely.

So having the FDR record one angle of the plane and having the debris be consistent with a different angle of impact is evidence of absolutely nothing.
 
Here's an experiment you can do at home.

Take a 12-inch ruler.

Put a mark on one end of the ruler. You can use the number "12" that's already printed on the ruler if you like.

.


Note for European and British CTers: he means "30".
 
I'm confused. As bad as i am at math how could you determine slope with that graph? aren't there components missing? like a whole other graph of MPH and distance? without MPH there is absolutely no way to determine slope with the graph given. An example. Lets say a helicopter is hovering almost stationary and descends vertically in a time frame with the given graph above. And a plane traveling an unknown MPH drops altitude in the same amount of time. Wouldn't the graph above look identical? You would need a graph showing X Y and Z NO?
 
I'm confused. As bad as i am at math how could you determine slope with that graph? aren't there components missing? like a whole other graph of MPH and distance? without MPH there is absolutely no way to determine slope with the graph given. An example. Lets say a helicopter is hovering almost stationary and descends vertically in a time frame with the given graph above. And a plane traveling an unknown MPH drops altitude in the same amount of time. Wouldn't the graph above look identical? You would need a graph showing X Y and Z NO?

Airspeed MPH is in the graph as well as pressure altitude. It's difficult to read. But from that basic info you can calculate an angle. The guesses come in what average MPH and what average PA drop rate to use.

From the graph, you can calculate how far (angled distance) the plane traveled in the last 30 seconds of the graph and how far it dropped in those 30 seconds.

Think of a triangle with a 90 degree angle.

The travel distance give you the length of the hypotenuse(the longest side) and the altitude drop distance gives you one of the other sides.

Over the last 30 seconds, Manorexia uses 25520 for the distance traveled and 8000 for the distance dropped.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom