Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

A lot of them will be fooled (just like yourself) into thinking the reporter is referring to the 'hole', even though she indicates she does not know what portion of the video is showing.


They wouldn't be fooled just like I'm not "fooled" until you can come up with a rational explanation as to why on 9/11 this was the only footage shown and the media chose to focus in on this area instead of the plane imprint a couple hundred feet away I would say the only people being fooled are people such as yourself.
 
61974547713022614.gif
 
Your jref buddies say it's a shadow and/or an ATV.


So how did this seat cushion get all the way over there? It's almost as wide as the garage door, does that seem consistent with "seat cushions"?

Also, you ignored my question. Do you believe this garage is a cabin? Can you picture people "camping there"?

I see a 2 car garage. Used to store items. Not someplace people go for a weekend getaway. Have you ever gone camping in a garage?

The fact that we're looking at a garage and the object is almost the length of the garage door tells me it isn't a seat cushion. That's why thats not a rational response.

Seat widths on the Boeing planes appear to be 17-20.5". Heights are more difficult to come by so I will use an estimate based off of my personal experience: seat length ~17", seatback height ~36". This would put the overall length of the seat, if laid flat, at ~53" or ~4.4'.

The Kawasaki line of ATVs http://www.kawasaki.com/Products/SubCategory.aspx?id=1
have an overall length of ~86", or 7.1'
The Honda line of ATVs http://powersports.honda.com/atvs/utility/
have an overall length of 75-~83", or 6.2'-~6.9'.

Using Google Earth, I estimate the width of the building in question to be ~29'. Assuming that we have standard 10' garage doors on the building and using your image from the newscast we can confirm that the building is ~3 garage doors in width. The dark object in question is < 1 garage door in width. Taking the width of the object, the building is ~4.5 object widths in size.
29/~4.5 = ~6.4'
29/4 = 7.3'
29/5 = 5.8'
30/4 = 7.5'
30/~4.5 = ~6.7'
30/5 = 6'

7583459aa5edd099d.gif
 
They wouldn't be fooled just like I'm not "fooled" until you can come up with a rational explanation as to why on 9/11 this was the only footage shown and the media chose to focus in on this area instead of the plane imprint a couple hundred feet away I would say the only people being fooled are people such as yourself.

Theoretically, the number of explanations that are more reasonable than "the gubmint shot down its own plane then lied about it" is infinite.
 
from http://www.post-gazette.com/headlines/20010912crashnat2p2.asp
There were 20 FBI agents on hand yesterday, and another 30 were expected last night. The contingent of 100 state troopers was expected to swell to 150. They planned to spend last night spaced out along the crash perimeter within each other's eyesight to ward off curiosity seekers and prevent anyone from tampering with evidence. Two curiosity seekers were arrested for trying to get through the perimeter, one of them aboard an all-terrain vehicle.
 
They wouldn't be fooled just like I'm not "fooled" until you can come up with a rational explanation as to why on 9/11 this was the only footage shown and the media chose to focus in on this area instead of the plane imprint a couple hundred feet away I would say the only people being fooled are people such as yourself.

As Hey Leroy puts it

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/61974547713022614.gif[/qimg]

The very fact that this spot is only in one instance of all media coverage by definition means that they were NOT 'focusing' on this spot and given that there are a myriad of media images of the larger crater is is very much within the bounds of the definition of such to say that the media was indeed focusing on the larger impact crater.
 
Seat widths on the Boeing planes appear to be 17-20.5". Heights are more difficult to come by so I will use an estimate based off of my personal experience: seat length ~17", seatback height ~36". This would put the overall length of the seat, if laid flat, at ~53" or ~4.4'.

The Kawasaki line of ATVs http://www.kawasaki.com/Products/SubCategory.aspx?id=1
have an overall length of ~86", or 7.1'
The Honda line of ATVs http://powersports.honda.com/atvs/utility/
have an overall length of 75-~83", or 6.2'-~6.9'.

Using Google Earth, I estimate the width of the building in question to be ~29'. Assuming that we have standard 10' garage doors on the building and using your image from the newscast we can confirm that the building is ~3 garage doors in width. The dark object in question is < 1 garage door in width. Taking the width of the object, the building is ~4.5 object widths in size.
29/~4.5 = ~6.4'
29/4 = 7.3'
29/5 = 5.8'
30/4 = 7.5'
30/~4.5 = ~6.7'
30/5 = 6'

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/7583459aa5edd099d.gif


Actually the doors are probably a 2 feet smaller. Industrial doors are 10 feet. Typical residential garage doors are 8 feet by 7 feet. As a general rule every three courses of concrete block equals 2 feet being they are 8 inch modules. To the right you can count the courses at 12. In this image the doors are square. so the doors look to me to be 8 x 8
87904593497f50917.jpg
 
2
Actually the doors are probably a 2 feet smaller. Industrial doors are 10 feet. Typical residential garage doors are 8 feet by 7 feet. As a general rule every three courses of concrete block equals 2 feet being they are 8 inch modules. To the right you can count the courses at 12. In this image the doors are square. so the doors look to me to be 8 x 8
Which puts our object at between 4.8' (57.6") and 6' (72").

ETA: put another way, 64" +/- 11%
 
Last edited:
Another thing to consider is the placement of the mystery object. Using your image Arkan it looks like it is dead center of the right garage door and no more than the equivalent of a garage door width plus the right wall section (32 inches) away from the building. or approximately 10 feet 8 inches away. That would put it just about where that dark object is above the branch or bough obscuring the door in the image i posted. There is no sign of a crater being filled in where the mystery object was. It is undisturbed blue stone adjacent to grass.
 
My own analysis of the object in the video is:

It's not an ATV. The image is not sharp but it's not all that blurry either. If there were a real ATV parked in that spot it would be, I believe, distinct and recognizable as such. Also, in the video as the viewpoint apparently shifts rightward and the angle of view rotates a few degrees, the object remains flat-looking. (It might be possible to confim whether or not the object has any significant height by doing some frame by frame measurements of how the dimensions of its outline vary in comparison to other reference points on the ground as the view shifts.)

It's not a shadow. The whole garage and the area around the object is in shade, as can be seen in the video by comparing the ground with the tops of nearby trees which are clearly highlighted by direct sunlight. The shade, amid partially sunlit surroundings, probably accounts for why the zoomed-in image's contrast and color saturation is so low. Given the low contrast, the object must be very dark in order to appear as dark as it is in the image. A shadow in an already shaded location wouldn't be that dark or distinct. This also rules out the possibilities of it being a bush, unless it's a bush that was painted black, or an oil stain, unless it was very fresh.

Another reason for doubting the object being an ATV, shadow, shrub, or stain is that the cameraperson clearly zoomed in on and tracked the object for at least a few seconds, suggesting that it is more likely something of interest for the news story, such as a crater or debris.

By the same reasoning based on contrast, it's not a crater. Without direct sunlight impinging on the ground, in a low-contrast image, there's no reason for a crater to appear that dark, when viewed from above under diffuse ambient skylight, in comparison to the ground around it. It might appear that dark if it were lined with a dark material, but rather than postulate an irregular crater precisely lined with dark material that somehow didn't spill over the crater's edges, it seems much more reasonable to conclude that there's dark material on the ground, with no crater required.

That leaves debris. Which explains the object's every characteristic: its very dark color (quite similar to other smaller nearby objects in the video that are clearly debris), its flat appearance, its indistinct asymmetrical shape, the camera operator's interest in it, and its absence (matching the absence of other smaller nearby pieces of debris) in later photographs of the site.

But TC, if I said I think it is a crater, would that get you to explain what you believe the significance of such a crater would be? Are heavier chunks of debris ejected from a high-speed jetliner crash onto nearly bare ground not allowed to leave craters for some reason?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Your jref buddies say it's a shadow and/or an ATV.
As I already explained to you on the LC forum (TC329 is "Terrorcell" there), they suggested the possiblity. See the difference? Looking at the video, and at better-quality stills than those you posted, I disagree.

​

​

So how did this seat cushion get all the way over there? It's almost as wide as the garage door, does that seem consistent with "seat cushions"?
Your reading comprehension is lacking. I suggested that it might be the remains the seat cushion or other charred debris. Ever stamp out a debris fire with a shovel? It makes a mess. Looking at the video, I don't think it's likely to be the seat cushion remains. It does appear to have some 3-dimensional quality. My best guess is a piece of charred debris, as Myriad states above.

Also, you ignored my question. Do you believe this garage is a cabin? Can you picture people "camping there"? I see a 2 car garage. Used to store items. Not someplace people go for a weekend getaway. Have you ever gone camping in a garage?
You may have noticed the house directly across the road. My family has a vacation home. It is a house, not a camping cabin. Yet all the houses in that area are called camps and cabins. Go figure.

So what is this debris and how did it survive an impact that pretty much "vaporized" (since you JREF'ers DENY the original theory was it burrowed underground) an entire plane and this "seat cushion" (GRAVY) survived?
Please do not use the word "vaporized." I have never seen anyone here characterize the flight 93 crash in that way. In fact, most of the plane was recovered. When flight 93 hit the ground at 580 mph, most of the plane was reduced to small parts by the mechanical forces of impact and explosion. As you can see from the photos, the area was covered with debris. That debris consisted of hard things and soft things. Much debris was also buried. I have seen no one here "deny" that. Try to restrict your lying to one forum.

It must be magical like the red bandana that went untouched right off of one of the vaporized hijackers head, huh?
Your use of the word "magical" displays your lack of understanding of science and logic. Many "soft" things survived the impact: Lorraine Bay's flight log, personal effects, papers. If the bandanna was near the front of the plane it would likely have been buried, and not been singed by the fuel blast. It's not magic. It's not a miracle. It's simply what happens in the real world. The same is true of the crashes of flights 11 and 175. Many "soft" things survived. Airplane crashes are chaotic events.

Once again, I suggest that you contact the owner of the house in the photo for more information.
 
Last edited:
So you're saying this is that ATV?

Proof?

Hell, proof that it is an ATV?

The hypothesis was posited that the element on the image could be an ATV. The article A W Smith provided is circumstantial corroborating evidence, in that it shows that there was at least one ATV in the area at the time. A W Smith made no claim that this was a silver bullet but, I assume, provided it as supporting evidence to one possible explanation.

Additionally, your questions are nothing more than an argument from personal incredulity and do nothing to support your assertion, neither do they undermine the ATV hypothesis.
 
Theoretically, the number of explanations that are more reasonable than "the gubmint shot down its own plane then lied about it" is infinite.


Yeah it would be totally unreasonable to think the government shot down a plane on 9/11 after 3 hijacked ones killed thousands of Americans. Dismiss Felt's call from the bathroom, dismiss the fact that most locals believe it was shot down because they live there and well in these area's they say "people talk", forget about the plane hitting at a 40 degree angle despite the official story is it nose dived into the ground which would be more consistent with the imprint, dismiss the fact that the wingspan is nowhere near the size of a 757's, dismiss the fact that there was no fuel contamination in the soil or water, dismiss the fact that no body parts or blood were found at the scene, dismiss the fact that there were no raging jet fuel fires burning the grass near the crater yet somehow managed to annihilate a whole section of forest but the fires were out before anyone arrived on the scene which is good because Stoystown would not have been able to handle such fires, dismiss the fact that debris scattered over an 8 mile radius, dismiss the fact that no one is allowed to hear the final 3 minutes of the CVR, dismiss the fact that there was a white jet, C-130, and 2 fighter jets all within the vacinity, dismiss the fact that locals say their lights "flickered" - their houses "rattled" - and then the plane "hit" and yeah I guess you could come up with something that was more believable than the plane was shot down by something that shattered it into thousands of teeny tiny little pieces which don't resemble anything seen in any aviation crash ever in history.
 
Are you showcasing your observational skills when you say Gravy and I are the only people in this thread that think the object is debris?


No it shows how little time I wish to spend being sidetracked by keeping a poll on who believes what in regards to the anomaly in question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom