Well if there is no crazy conspiracy theory....

Check it again, looks like the ticks are all 1 minute.

Manorexia's estimate uses the FDR air speed that is graphed with the pressure altitude but is difficult to see. I think the info is all there but requires careful analysis to make a good guess.

Yeah, I realized the ticks were one minute, but the spacing is uneven, and the last few seconds of the curve approach the vertical so that the slope is meaningless relative to decent rate (truly vertical would be infinite speed!). If the last minute were the width of the page, then I think we could get a good slope.
 
I am looking at the top section of this graphical display.

93_shot-down.gif

I can barely make out what this section is displaying but it seems to read “indicated deg".

Can somebody clear up what this angle is, I am assuming it is the roll angle of the plane rather that the pitch angle. If this is the rolling of the plane, are the spikes at the end indicators of the violent rolling that took place to ward off the passengers attempt to take back the plane?
 
Here is the full set of flight 93 graphs in much better quality:

http://www.ntsb.gov/info/UAL93FDR.pdf

Go to page 18 and at the very top(left), you'll see the "Pitch Angle - Capt (deg)" and the data stops at about -40 for this value..

The "Indicated AOA (deg)" refers to the AoA vane angle. This vane is used for stall warning and a few other things, but its not a good indicator of the aircrafts nose attitude, because even in a dive, the vane will tend to "zero" because of the airflow going over it. You'll notice that the range is +5 to -25 and when the data stops, this parameter is at -16 or so. That doesnt mean that the nose was only 16 degrees down with respect to the horizon, it means that the AoA vane was 16 degrees down with respect to the direction of the airflow...
 
Last edited:
Here is the full set of flight 93 graphs in much better quality:

http://www.ntsb.gov/info/UAL93FDR.pdf

Go to page 18 and at the very top(left), you'll see the "Pitch Angle - Capt (deg)" and the data stops at about -40 for this value..

The "Indicated AOA (deg)" refers to the AoA vane angle. This vane is used for stall warning and a few other things, but its not a good indicator of the aircrafts angle of attack because even in a dive, the vane will tend to "zero" because of the airflow going over it. You'll notice that the range is +5 to -25 and when the data stops, this parameter is at -16 or so. That doesnt mean that the nose was only 16 degrees down with respect to the horizon, it means that the AoA vane was 16 degrees down with respect to the direction of the airflow...


Well, it's a good indicator of AOA (the angle of the wing relative to the air), but not a good indicator of attitude (the angle of the wing relative to the horizon).
 
Well, it's a good indicator of AOA (the angle of the wing relative to the air), but not a good indicator of attitude (the angle of the wing relative to the horizon).

Yup, my mistake - poor choice of terminology on my part.
 
I could never relate to metric. and why are centimeters pronounced Sonnimeters in medical terminology? Its so.. well just wrong for my ears :( . (well i see theres no coverears smiley)

That's how I felt tonight watching "House Hunters International" with my wife. They were in NZ and the realtor kept pronouncing bedroom as "be-droom" not "bed-room". Took me forever to figure out what the drek he was saying.
 
Sorry to dig this thread out of retirement. I'm a little short on time lately and I seem to have missed a bit of the conversation.

Have you used StereoPhoto Maker?
No, just plain old photoshop and some elbow grease. I'm sure to check it out now, though.

I remember seeing those stereo WTC photos a while ago. Mixed feelings. Almost perfect from the geometrical point of view, but the featured theme doesn't provide any positive feelings. Are the source pictures video caps? If those really are two videos, one could probably make a stereo movie out of them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom