"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

People that ply the grass is greener route move for a number of reasons between nations.

Right.

But I'm not asking what the reasons are. I'm asking how many of them there are.


There is no metric to be derived from that - plenty of central American's go to Cuba for free education including middle class sons and daughters.

The hell there isn't a metric to be derived from that. The fundamental measure of desirability is how many people desire something and how badly they desire it.

Predator friendly means just that - fewer controls so if you want to hustle some $ outside the "system" you can.

Ah, so by "predator" you mean "worker." Got it.

Millions would come to Canada as well but we restrict immigration to about 1/2 million a year and the process it get in is rather stiff.

The process to get into the US is rather stiff, too. And the number is highly restricted. And there are still millions of illegal immigrants each year, people who are willing to risk jail time to come to the States. That sounds to me like a) a hell of a lot of people b) want to come to the States very badly.

How many people are willing to risk jail time to come to Canada?
 
And people will adapt, just as New Englanders adapted to shortages of firewood.

Ah, you are an Adaptionist.

How did New Englanders adapt to shortages of firewood?

The only thing that has been predicted with more regularity by the chicken littles than gold going through the roof is oil going though the roof. Last year it was at $140 a barrel and everyone was sure it was going to $200. Now it is at $40. So once again the gloom and doom on energy--which remains a serious long term problem--proves premature. Supply and demand still function.

Oh, you are a "Chicken Little" chanter.

Volitile oil prices are extremely damaging to the economy and are a predicted result of peaking oil supplies. They indicate that the energy problem is not in the future.

By many. Perhaps the most telling is how people vote with their feet. How many people are trying to get in, and how many trying to get out. I don't see too many people in the US sneaking into Cuba looking for work.

Empires are resource hungry and people follow the resources. Is this what you mean by better off?

People sneaking into the US looking for work are going to be disappointed.

Cuba, a former plantation and hog-tied by decades of sanctions, recently devastated by storms, is a strange country to choose as a benchmark by which to judge Western wealth.
 
How did New Englanders adapt to shortages of firewood?

Obviously, they didn't. They all froze to death in the great winter of 1974, which is why the entire United States north of the Bronx is uninhabited to this day. Harvard Yard and Boston Common are but a fading memory of days gone by, like the Hanging Gardens of Babylon.

"By-y-y-y
the wa-a-a-ters,
the wa-a-a-ters,
of the Charles River,
We lay down and wept, and wept,
for thee, MIT.
We remember thee,
remember thee,
remember thee, Tech Square."
 
How is Toyota doing nowadays?


A lot better than General Motors.


So why do so many more Canadians move to the USA than the other way around?


Because the U.S. has a much bigger population base and economic capacity than Canada, and thus offers more avenues of opportunity for some than they might find at home. Consider the acting profession, for example. If a Canadian wants to make a living at that profession, they've got a better chance of it in the U.S. since its entertainment industry is vastly larger than Canada's.



How many people are willing to risk jail time to come to Canada?


The logistics of getting into the U.S. are a lot easier than getting into Canada. To get into the U.S., just sneak across the Mexico-United States border—and there's quite a large land border from which to choose. Getting into Canada is more difficult, as you'd either have to first get into the U.S. then proceed to the Canada-U.S. border, or else get into Canada via ship or aircraft. Either of these are more demanding logistically than using a land route.
 
Because the U.S. has a much bigger population base and economic capacity than Canada, and thus offers more avenues of opportunity for some than they might find at home. Consider the acting profession, for example. If a Canadian wants to make a living at that profession, they've got a better chance of it in the U.S. since its entertainment industry is vastly larger than Canada's.

I think you just proved my point for me.

Basically, what you just said is that "economic opportunities are better in the US." And if economic opportunities are better in the States than in Canada, which has one of the better developed and stable economies on the planet, then imagine how they compare to the various Nowheristani microstates.

Which in turn implies that the USA is doing something right compared to all of the Nowheristani strong men that JihadJane so admires for their sophisticated economic theories.


The logistics of getting into the U.S. are a lot easier than getting into Canada. To get into the U.S., just sneak across the Mexico-United States border—and there's quite a large land border from which to choose. Getting into Canada is more difficult, as you'd either have to first get into the U.S. then proceed to the Canada-U.S. border, or else get into Canada via ship or aircraft. Either of these are more demanding logistically than using a land route.

Only if you're starting in Mexico. Do you really think that the Cuban or Cambodian or Columbian illegals come in through Mexico?
 
Ah, you are an Adaptionist.

How did New Englanders adapt to shortages of firewood?
Coal and oil, predominantly.


Oh, you are a "Chicken Little" chanter.

Volitile oil prices are extremely damaging to the economy and are a predicted result of peaking oil supplies. They indicate that the energy problem is not in the future.
Really? I would have thought that shortages of oil, with falling supplies despite constant demand, would have led to continuous increases in prices, not a bubble followed by a crash.

Empires are resource hungry and people follow the resources. Is this what you mean by better off?

People sneaking into the US looking for work are going to be disappointed.
And yet, when they get here they don't turn around immediately and go back. And yet, when they are caught and deported they sneak back in. Strange way for disappointed people to act if you ask me.

Cuba, a former plantation and hog-tied by decades of sanctions, recently devastated by storms, is a strange country to choose as a benchmark by which to judge Western wealth.
I guess it's the closest we have left to a communist utopia. Do you have a better benchmark? North Korea, perhaps? Or are their problems all our fault as well?
 
Last edited:
Basically, what you just said is that "economic opportunities are better in the US."


No, what I said was for some professions it might be better. Heck, folks in the entertainment industry from all over the world go to the U.S. because of the opportunities the sheer scale of the U.S. entertainment industry has to offer.


And if economic opportunities are better in the States than in Canada, which has one of the better developed and stable economies on the planet, then imagine how they compare to the various Nowheristani microstates.


Of course, the comparison of opportunities of Canada (or other developed nation) as opposed to "Nowheristani microstates" is still going to be hugely favourable to Canada and other developed nations.


Which in turn implies that the USA is doing something right compared to all of the Nowheristani strong men that JihadJane so admires for their sophisticated economic theories.


Perhaps so. But you sure screwed up your financial system. With effects that have rippled around the world.

As to what JihadJane does or does not admire, I do not concern myself with it, as JJ is a 9/11 conspiracy believer.


Only if you're starting in Mexico. Do you really think that the Cuban or Cambodian or Columbian illegals come in through Mexico?


Crossing ninety miles of ocean to go from Cuba to the U.S. is a much shorter trip than to Canada. To go from Cambodia to the U.S. or Canada is the same distance. I assume you have some source which indicates the method of travel by Colombians to the U.S.
 
No, what I said was for some professions it might be better. Heck, folks in the entertainment industry from all over the world go to the U.S. because of the opportunities the sheer scale of the U.S. entertainment industry has to offer.

All right, I'll turn it around.

For what professions -- other than maple syrup producer -- does Canada offer greater opportunity than the US?
 
All right, I'll turn it around.

For what professions -- other than maple syrup producer -- does Canada offer greater opportunity than the US?

Given the doom and gloom about the US economy possibly most of them :)

On the other the denise of the US economy may have been exaggerated!

Steve
 
For what professions -- other than maple syrup producer -- does Canada offer greater opportunity than the US?

an average citizen......don't be an ass.....:mad:

Did you READ the article on why doctors are moving to Canada.

Your GINI scores suck - you have a predatory and inegalitarian society and you know it

You are the laughingstock of the world for what you spend on weapons and drugs and don't spend very wisely on healthcare........you let predators in at every level.and call it freedom......yeah right :eusa_doh:

Your political system is bankrupt and corrupt ( gerrymandered ) and needs monitoring like a third world nation.

Aside from that - you are welcome to the cess pool you've created......
 
Aside from that - you are welcome to the cess pool you've created.....

You have a spare bedroom do ya? Just a sofa maybe?

Yes, it's a mess here. A large part of the problem is allowing people to shift personal liability onto an imaginary entity, a corporation. We've thousands of microcosmic dictatorships that do not have a conscious. It encourages irresponsibility as the individual does not have to accept blame for much of anything. We recently saw a great example of this when the big 3 automakers went before congress. Yes, it's a mess. Hopefully we can make the necessary changes. In the meantime, how's the weather where you are? :p
 
Coal and oil, predominantly.

What is our equivalent of New Englander's coal and oil?

Really? I would have thought that shortages of oil, with falling supplies despite constant demand, would have led to continuous increases in prices, not a bubble followed by a crash.

High prices undermine economic activity which reduces demand. Prices fall. As demand recovers prices start to rise again but supply fails to keep up with demand. Prices rise again. High prices undermine economic activity, etc.

Then add market speculation.

Eventually, as the rate of decline in production becomes steeper, prices should settle into the scenario you envisage - continuous increases.

And yet, when they get here they don't turn around immediately and go back. And yet, when they are caught and deported they sneak back in. Strange way for disappointed people to act if you ask me.

Economic migrants are unlikely to have the resources to go back.

The predominantly inward movement will reverse when it becomes evident that the US has joined the Third World.

I guess it's the closest we have left to a communist utopia. Do you have a better benchmark? North Korea, perhaps? Or are their problems all our fault as well?

Is communist the opposite of Western?

With great power comes great responsibility. It does appear that the whole world is going down together, pulled down by the USA's and the UK's economic/financial folly. Who is to blame for Western banksters?
 
The criticism of the big 3 automakers would ring more true if all the other automakers in the world were not also in significant financial difficulty. Their major sin was making the cars (SUVs) that America wanted and not adequately preparing for a change in preference.
 
What is our equivalent of New Englander's coal and oil?
Coal isn't running out just yet. Nat gas, nuclear, wind, solar, geothermal, biomass, oil shale, tar sands, cellulitic ethanol...They may not be economically viable now, but with oil at $200 a gallon? Maybe.



High prices undermine economic activity which reduces demand. Prices fall. As demand recovers prices start to rise again but supply fails to keep up with demand. Prices rise again. High prices undermine economic activity, etc.

Then add market speculation.

Eventually, as the rate of decline in production becomes steeper, prices should settle into the scenario you envisage - continuous increases.
Ah. So I haven't seen it because it hasn't happened yet.


Economic migrants are unlikely to have the resources to go back.
And yet, when they get kicked out the have the resources to get back in. Probably just to pick up their stuff. :rolleyes:

The predominantly inward movement will reverse when it becomes evident that the US has joined the Third World.

When it happens I suppose you can tell me "I told you so" by carrier pigeon.

Is communist the opposite of Western?
No, communist is opposite of capitalist. But I ask again, who do you propose as the great champion of the non-western economic success story?

With great power comes great responsibility. It does appear that the whole world is going down together, pulled down by the USA's and the UK's economic/financial folly. Who is to blame for Western banksters?
The western bankers themselves, the regulators who were asleep at the switch, the bond ratings companies who inaccurately rated the bonds, and the politicians who were in charge of creating the lax regulatory atmosphere.

Or if you prefer, we can blame Lisa.
 
The criticism of the big 3 automakers would ring more true if all the other automakers in the world were not also in significant financial difficulty.

There's difficulty, and there's difficulty. For some, difficulty means a couple of lean years, for others, it means you need the equivalent of the annual budget of a small but not minute European country to get through 2009.
 
Gonna be interesting as these guys come back home looking for jobs.....:boggled:



over the next 19 months.
Why? Is the number of jobs fixed? I thought that idea had long since been discredited.

If you add some more workers to the pool, most of them will find new jobs, and output will grow (ceteris paribus).
 
Ah, you are an Adaptionist.

How did New Englanders adapt to shortages of firewood?



Oh, you are a "Chicken Little" chanter.

Volitile oil prices are extremely damaging to the economy and are a predicted result of peaking oil supplies. They indicate that the energy problem is not in the future.



Empires are resource hungry and people follow the resources. Is this what you mean by better off?

People sneaking into the US looking for work are going to be disappointed.

Cuba, a former plantation and hog-tied by decades of sanctions, recently devastated by storms, is a strange country to choose as a benchmark by which to judge Western wealth.




Jihad, are you aware the price bubble was driven by speculation not supply and demand.

Can you show any legit source that shows world demand doubled in 6 months or supply was cut in half in the first part of 08??

You bark about energy, yes we will adapt. We used to use the horse (i guess oats or grass) as our trans energy, then coal now oil. Have you not seen the solar grids or windmills??
 
The criticism of the big 3 automakers would ring more true if all the other automakers in the world were not also in significant financial difficulty. Their major sin was making the cars (SUVs) that America wanted and not adequately preparing for a change in preference.



Nonsense. Their sins were many but chief among them was the fact they couldn't make a profit by manufacturing and selling cars.

SUV's, which came about because of a Congressional mandate, do not enter the top 10 reasons for their collective failure.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom