USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

What's up with all the conservative rhetoric? I've yet to hear any true solutions and or answers for phenomenon from the conservative side of the playing field. I hear all this blah blah blah, and yet I don't hear "this happened because of X and X was caused by Y, therefore Z occurred." I'm hearing 2+2= dogs and catfish, when we aren't having any discussions about dogs and cats.

I see tons of attacking individuals instead of key positions and ideas; furthermore, I have yet to see any legitimate support for your positions. Seriously guys step your game up and stop using either conservative and or religious rhetoric. You all are wearing suits you can fit right now.
 
Last edited:
Out of curiousity, did RandFan ever figure out that Real GDP is already adjusted for the effects of inflation?

Or have even his *friends* around here allowed him to remain clueless? :D
 
Even if true (and I'm not bothering to check your claim), how does that in any way change the assertion that tax cuts were responsible for the increase in revenue? Even the rich don't benefit from tax cuts if they make no money because the economy is weak. You, in fact, only prove my point. That you don't need to raise taxes to increase revenues because marginal tax rates in the top brackets, even with the Bush tax cuts in place, are already much higher than revenue as a percent of GDP has been for the last 65 years. All that raising taxes does … has been shown to do … is make it less likely that the wealthy (and mind you, the people you are talking about are the vast majority of small business owners) will take the risks necessary to start or grow a business, especially in hard times. That makes them more likely to simply sit on their cash, as many businesses are now doing, and wait for a more positive change in tax policy and government regulations ... a more positive business climate.
Let's take a look at tax revenue as a percentage of the GDP:
1996 - 18.8%
1997 - 19.2%
1998 - 19.9%
1999 - 19.8%
2000 - 20.6%
2001 - 19.5%
2002 - 17.6%
2003 - 16.2%
2004 - 16.1%
2005 - 17.3%
2006 - 18.2%
2007 - 18.5%
2008 - 17.5%
2009 - 14.8%

I realize these are big numbers, but those of us who passed 6th grade math can figure out that every full fiscal year since the first Bush tax cuts took effect had smaller revenues than any of the 6 previous years. That leads to a small problem with your theory that the Bush tax cuts led to an increase in revenue: namely, that the revenue didn't increase, it DECREASED.


As I've said many times before, you folks need to go back and learn what history has to offer. For example …

http://startthinkingright.wordpress...revenues-they-have-always-increased-revenues/
Neither the Kennedy/Johnson tax cuts nor the Reagan tax cuts led to an increase in revenue. There was a very slight general decrease after the Kennedy/Johnson tax cuts, except for his 10% surcharge and the years 1969 and 1970. With the Reagan tax cuts, the decrease was more pronounced, even though he partially compensated for the decrease in personal income tax revenue by raising Social Security taxes.

And the same thing happened following the Bush tax cuts. The burden of paying taxes fell increasingly on the wealth. And total revenues went up.
The rest of us consider a change from 20.6 to 17.6 to be going down, not up. But if you want to make up your own rules, I guess you have that option.
 
Last edited:
Let's take a look at tax revenue as a percentage of the GDP:
1996 - 18.8%
1997 - 19.2%
1998 - 19.9%
1999 - 19.8%
2000 - 20.6%
2001 - 19.5%
2002 - 17.6%
2003 - 16.2%
2004 - 16.1%
2005 - 17.3%
2006 - 18.2%
2007 - 18.5%
2008 - 17.5%
2009 - 14.8%

That leads to a small problem with your theory that the Bush tax cuts led to an increase in revenue: namely, that the revenue didn't increase, it DECREASED.
For a simple reason, the economy sucked.

economicgrowth2.jpg


Sources GDP DJIA
 
BTW: The DJIA at the beginning of Bush's presidency was 10,286 No where it is today? 10,828. Pathetic and these Einsteins will demand that, oh, the tax cuts work. It's just that the dog ate their homework when the Dems were in office. Riiight.

Silly nonsense. Either the tax cuts work or they don't.
 
Neither the Kennedy/Johnson tax cuts nor the Reagan tax cuts led to an increase in revenue. There was a very slight general decrease after the Kennedy/Johnson tax cuts, except for his 10% surcharge and the years 1969 and 1970. With the Reagan tax cuts, the decrease was more pronounced, even though he partially compensated for the decrease in personal income tax revenue by raising Social Security taxes.
And bear in mind, Reagan eventually raised taxes.

The rest of us consider a change from 20.6 to 17.6 to be going down, not up. But if you want to make up your own rules, I guess you have that option.
BTW: Can I get your tax revenue sources? I'm going to include that in my tables.
 
Let's take a look at tax revenue as a percentage of the GDP:

… snip …

I realize these are big numbers, but those of us who passed 6th grade math can figure out that every full fiscal year since the first Bush tax cuts took effect had smaller revenues than any of the 6 previous years.

FALSE. You've confused revenue with revenue as a percent of GDP. Different geese. Perhaps you didn't pass 6th grade English?

Do a little research and you'll find that federal revenue peaked in 2000 (well before the first Bush tax cut took place) at a little over $2 trillion. It then started falling due to a recession which began at the end of Clinton's term and due to the economic disruption caused by 9/11. Such that it was about $1.8 trillion in 2003. But it grew steadily from there on. By 2005, revenues exceeded the peak of 2000 at about $2.2 trillion. They climbed to $2.4 trillion in 2006. $2.6 trillion in 2007. It was only when democrats took over congress and the effects of the democrat policy inspired mortgage crisis/recession in 2008 that they started falling again. :D

That leads to a small problem with your theory that the Bush tax cuts led to an increase in revenue: namely, that the revenue didn't increase, it DECREASED.

False. Learn a little history. You might try here: http://www.usgovernmentrevenue.com/#usgs302a . :)

Neither the Kennedy/Johnson tax cuts nor the Reagan tax cuts led to an increase in revenue.

FALSE again. Let's just look at what Federal revenues did under Reagan.

1980 - $517 billion
1981 - $599 billion
1982 - $617 billion
1983 - $600 billion
1984 - $666 billion
1985 - $734 billion
1986 - $769 billion
1987 - $854 billion
1988 - $909 billion
1989 - $991 billion

Sorry, but contrary to your claim, that looks like pretty healthy growth in Federal revenue during Reagan's term … during the expansion caused by Reagan's cuts in taxes in 1981. :D

With the Reagan tax cuts, the decrease was more pronounced, even though he partially compensated for the decrease in personal income tax revenue by raising Social Security taxes.

I don't see any "pronounced" decrease. Income taxes were $549 billion and social security taxes were $359 billion in 1989. Whereas they were only $347 billion and $182 billion, respectively, in 1979. So again, you are wrong. Income tax revenue clearly went up, and went up more than social security taxes.

Quote:
And the same thing happened following the Bush tax cuts. The burden of paying taxes fell increasingly on the wealth. And total revenues went up.

The rest of us consider a change from 20.6 to 17.6 to be going down, not up.

Well then maybe I'm the only one at this so-called forum of *skeptics* who knows the difference between revenue and revenue as a percent of GDP? :D
 
Heaven help us. I wonder if RF will apply the "deflator" to it? :D
Show me wrong BAC?

Did the economy keep pace with inflation? If I made a mistake using the deflator can you tell me what the figures are? What figures did you use and can you post them?
 
Yes, it does. Referencing a noted authority on a subject is nothing but a valid argument.

  • Nonsense. Experts can and are often wrong.
  • His discussion of propaganda have nothing to do with your use of it.
 
BTW: The DJIA at the beginning of Bush's presidency was 10,286 No where it is today? 10,828. Pathetic and these Einsteins will demand that, oh, the tax cuts work. It's just that the dog ate their homework when the Dems were in office. Riiight.

Silly nonsense. Either the tax cuts work or they don't.

I also posted this in the other thread, but I think it actually fits here better; http://home.earthlink.net/~intelligentbear/com-dj-infl.htm

DJIA as adjusted for inflation. Read it and weep.
 
I also posted this in the other thread, but I think it actually fits here better; http://home.earthlink.net/~intelligentbear/com-dj-infl.htm

DJIA as adjusted for inflation. Read it and weep.
That's a part of what I was getting at. Total market volume averaged over a reasonable term, say 3 months rolling, discounted for inflation, might tell us a bit more than DJIA. It's just an index of a group of stocks, and they can drop out, then another is selected and put in. GM, for example.
 
That's a part of what I was getting at. Total market volume averaged over a reasonable term, say 3 months rolling, discounted for inflation, might tell us a bit more than DJIA. It's just an index of a group of stocks, and they can drop out, then another is selected and put in. GM, for example.
All of the indexes are bad. And 10 years. Year after year. There's nothing much to replace anything with. Why would they only choose lousy performing stocks over a 10 year period?
 
One more thing, the DOW is watched closely every day. Big swings are reported around the world. It is a leading economic indicator.

A Beginner's Guide to Economic Indicators

...

In most countries GDP figures are released quarterly (every three months) while the unemployment rate is released monthly. Some economic indicators, such as the Dow Jones Index, are available immediately and change every minute.
 
One more thing, the DOW is watched closely every day. Big swings are reported around the world. It is a leading economic indicator.
Is that so? You mean that it leads, and does not lag or be coincident with, other ecomonic indicators or changes?
 
FALSE. You've confused revenue with revenue as a percent of GDP. Different geese. Perhaps you didn't pass 6th grade English?

Do a little research and you'll find that federal revenue peaked in 2000 (well before the first Bush tax cut took place) at a little over $2 trillion. It then started falling due to a recession which began at the end of Clinton's term and due to the economic disruption caused by 9/11. Such that it was about $1.8 trillion in 2003. But it grew steadily from there on. By 2005, revenues exceeded the peak of 2000 at about $2.2 trillion. They climbed to $2.4 trillion in 2006. $2.6 trillion in 2007. It was only when democrats took over congress and the effects of the democrat policy inspired mortgage crisis/recession in 2008 that they started falling again. :D



False. Learn a little history. You might try here: http://www.usgovernmentrevenue.com/#usgs302a . :)



FALSE again. Let's just look at what Federal revenues did under Reagan.

1980 - $517 billion
1981 - $599 billion
1982 - $617 billion
1983 - $600 billion
1984 - $666 billion
1985 - $734 billion
1986 - $769 billion
1987 - $854 billion
1988 - $909 billion
1989 - $991 billion

Sorry, but contrary to your claim, that looks like pretty healthy growth in Federal revenue during Reagan's term … during the expansion caused by Reagan's cuts in taxes in 1981. :D



I don't see any "pronounced" decrease. Income taxes were $549 billion and social security taxes were $359 billion in 1989. Whereas they were only $347 billion and $182 billion, respectively, in 1979. So again, you are wrong. Income tax revenue clearly went up, and went up more than social security taxes.



Well then maybe I'm the only one at this so-called forum of *skeptics* who knows the difference between revenue and revenue as a percent of GDP? :D

Comparative tax revenues and govt. expenditures are normally discussed in terms of percentage of the GDP. Among other things, this accounts for inflation and population changes. Unless a political unit has no inflation and a constant or decreasing population, the absolute amount of tax revenue will always eventually increase no matter what changes are made to tax rates. Really, this is pretty obvious.
 
Last edited:
Is that so? You mean that it leads, and does not lag or be coincident with, other ecomonic indicators or changes?
Stock market returns are a leading indicator but that they are leading isn't relevant over a 10 year time frame. The important point is that there is very little good nrews out there and there has not been for 10 years.
 
Comparative tax revenues and govt. expenditures are normally discussed in terms of percentage of the GDP. Among other things, this accounts for inflation and population changes. Unless a political unit has no inflation and a constant or decreasing population, the absolute amount of tax revenue will always eventually increase no matter what changes are made to tax rates. Really, this is pretty obvious.

It helps to remember that inflation rates were in double digits during the first few years Reagan was in office. When corrected for inflation, tax revenues during this period show a rather clear dip.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom