mhaze
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 15,718
No, there is well understood to be a "sweet spot" in the Laffer curve. The debate is over what it's extents are and what the derivatives are for each variety of situation. As I mentioned earlier, some taxes may be understood to have more precise relations of tax %:resulting revenue than others.Here's a line from the introduction of that paper:
In other words, there's no actual date to support any of the assumptions, but we hope that the following is true.
There isn't any connection. Economic growth can occur with high taxes. Economic growth can occur with low taxes. If there were a connection, those PhD papers would cite the data that demonstrates the connection. They haven't. There isn't.
One reason for this is substitution. Raise cap gains? I keep the building and have rents, which are sheltered by expenses and depreciation, or I pay rental income on them. The result of a change in one tax, up or down, is spread against the entire tax system. So raising capital gains tax may not "raise revenue from capital gains taxation".
Further, once it's known that cap gains change 12-31-20xx, lots of action goes into the time period before that date.
But I've focused on capital gains. The general broad brush as discussed here, "raising taxes! raising taxes!" is almost without meaning and is certainly futile with respect to actually raising revenue.
And it doesn't matter in any case. If you looked at the numbers and the conclusions I developed resulting from them in #756, you'll see a truer picture of the balance sheet effects of various revenue actions and the inevitable course of events. And of the futility of attempting to tax your way out of the problem.
Last edited: