USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Here's a line from the introduction of that paper:



In other words, there's no actual date to support any of the assumptions, but we hope that the following is true.

There isn't any connection. Economic growth can occur with high taxes. Economic growth can occur with low taxes. If there were a connection, those PhD papers would cite the data that demonstrates the connection. They haven't. There isn't.
No, there is well understood to be a "sweet spot" in the Laffer curve. The debate is over what it's extents are and what the derivatives are for each variety of situation. As I mentioned earlier, some taxes may be understood to have more precise relations of tax %:resulting revenue than others.

One reason for this is substitution. Raise cap gains? I keep the building and have rents, which are sheltered by expenses and depreciation, or I pay rental income on them. The result of a change in one tax, up or down, is spread against the entire tax system. So raising capital gains tax may not "raise revenue from capital gains taxation".

Further, once it's known that cap gains change 12-31-20xx, lots of action goes into the time period before that date.

But I've focused on capital gains. The general broad brush as discussed here, "raising taxes! raising taxes!" is almost without meaning and is certainly futile with respect to actually raising revenue.

And it doesn't matter in any case. If you looked at the numbers and the conclusions I developed resulting from them in #756, you'll see a truer picture of the balance sheet effects of various revenue actions and the inevitable course of events. And of the futility of attempting to tax your way out of the problem.
 
Last edited:
No, there is well understood to be a "sweet spot" in the Laffer curve....

And no one knows where it is, and there is zero, that's zero, evidence that it is anywhere within the range of wherever US tax rates have ever been.

We know that if you get to 100% taxation, the economy suffers, and we have evidence to support it from communist countries. Other than that, there's nothing.

Indeed, it is not actually "well understood" that there is any meaningful thing called a "Laffer Curve" that has any bearing on real economic data. We know that it is a construct of academics, exploited by politicians, unsupported by actual data.
 
And no one knows where it is, and there is zero, that's zero, evidence that it is anywhere within the range of wherever US tax rates have ever been.

We know that if you get to 100% taxation, the economy suffers, and we have evidence to support it from communist countries. Other than that, there's nothing.

Indeed, it is not actually "well understood" that there is any meaningful thing called a "Laffer Curve" that has any bearing on real economic data. We know that it is a construct of academics, exploited by politicians, unsupported by actual data.
We're not in disagreement with the uncertainty, but a true-or-false 0-or-100 level of uncertainty isn't in accordance with known reality.... It's also not supported by the referenced CBO study, and it ignores my comments about well understood differences in the economics of different types of taxation.

That's part of my complaints about this type of discussion - economics of excise taxes are not the same as personal are not the same as corporate are not the same as capital gains and so forth.
 
We're not in disagreement with the uncertainty, but a true-or-false 0-or-100 level of uncertainty isn't in accordance with known reality....
Critically important. It's our baseline, something we can all agree on to start the discussion. Since we can all agree these are NOT realistic then the point becomes "how much"? The right is often saying "less taxes". Okay, if we both agree zero isn't going to work then what should the rate be and what will be the effect of that?

See, using zero as an unrealistic number helps us focus and avoid silly and vacuous claims like "cut taxes".
 
Critically important. It's our baseline, something we can all agree on to start the discussion. Since we can all agree these are NOT realistic then the point becomes "how much"? The right is often saying "less taxes". Okay, if we both agree zero isn't going to work then what should the rate be and what will be the effect of that?
.

I would ask two questions:

1) what if we increase taxes by $1, what would the government spend it on?
2) what if we decrease taxes by $1, what would the taxpayer spend it on ?

Pick the answer that has the highest return for that dollar. Note that the answer is highly dynamic, based on government and its policy, and the expected behavior of the taxpayer.
 
I would ask two questions:

1) what if we increase taxes by $1, what would the government spend it on?
2) what if we decrease taxes by $1, what would the taxpayer spend it on ?

Pick the answer that has the highest return for that dollar. Note that the answer is highly dynamic, based on government and its policy, and the expected behavior of the taxpayer.
Great questions. I don't pretend to know but I get your point.
Increase? Borrow less money to get out of debt.

Decrease? I would guess it depends in part on the bracket. But $1 doesn't buy much.
​
Of course there is always death by a thousand cuts. Incrementally increasing taxes will at some point have diminishing returns.
 
Increase? Borrow less money to get out of debt.

Wrong, if, as now, money is still borrowed irregardless, then debt increases irregardless, just at a slightly different pace.

And "borrow less money" isn't even necessarily true, as the appetite for spending may increase proportionally.
 
Wrong, if, as now, money is still borrowed irregardless, then debt increases irregardless, just at a slightly different pace.
I'll concede that.

And "borrow less money" isn't even necessarily true, as the appetite for spending may increase proportionally.
Agreed. You are on a roll.
 
Other than Republican wars, the one thing that has caused the debt to grow in a way that it has not historically is that we have controlled the rate of inflation, and kept it very low.

In the past, inflation has cheapened huge debts like WW-II and Korea and Vietnam so that over time they diminished to manageable levels.

I'm not saying that we should necessarily foster inflation, but that if we are not going to do that, we absolutely need to raise taxes to replace that effect.
 
Last edited:
Other than Republican wars, the one thing that has caused the debt to grow in a way that it has not historically is that we have controlled the rate of inflation, and kept it very low.

In the past, inflation has cheapened huge debts like WW-II and Korea and Vietnam so that over time they diminished to manageable levels.

I'm not saying that we should necessarily foster inflation, but that if we are not going to do that, we absolutely need to raise taxes to replace that effect.
So the Democratic wars were handled by inflation cheapening the debt, but the Republican wars should, according to BenBurch, be handled by raising taxes?

:rolleyes:
 
It's also not supported by the referenced CBO study,

Nothing is supported by the referenced CBO study, and the CBO study is quite explicit about that. The CBO study says, quite specifically, that there is no consensus on the effects of tax cuts. It goes on to say what assumptions they will make. You seem to be saying that those assumptions are supported by the CBO study, but they are not. They are assumed by the CBO study. To use the study as support for the assumptions would be circular reasoning.

and it ignores my comments about well understood differences in the economics of different types of taxation.

Is there some reason it shouldn't ignore the differences? Are they really "well understood"? Or have they just been repeated often enough that a lot of people stop questioning them?

Some of your comments dealt with short term effects, and of that there can be no doubt. Knowing that tax laws are changing will change people's behavior and cause businesses and consumers to make different decisions. However, no matter what decisions are made, there's still a way to get a robust economy out of it, just as has been done for the more than two centuries since the founding of the United States, with booms and busts occurring under the influence of all sorts of different tax policies.

What really is well understood is that if the government spends X% of GDP, there will be a budget deficit unless it taxes X% of GDP. For too long, Republicans have said that if we tax at X-Y% of GDP, GDP will be forced up and cover the shortfall. Meanwhile, Democrats have (recently at least) said that if we spend at X+Z%, GDP will grow and cover the extra spending.

There is 0% chance anyone is going to show that either of those strategies actually works. They are just two variations on getting something for nothing.
 
Nothing is supported by the referenced CBO study, and the CBO study is quite explicit about that. The CBO study says, quite specifically, that there is no consensus on the effects of tax cuts. It goes on to say what assumptions they will make. You seem to be saying that those assumptions are supported by the CBO study, but they are not. They are assumed by the CBO study. To use the study as support for the assumptions would be circular reasoning.



Is there some reason it shouldn't ignore the differences? Are they really "well understood"? Or have they just been repeated often enough that a lot of people stop questioning them?

Some of your comments dealt with short term effects, and of that there can be no doubt. Knowing that tax laws are changing will change people's behavior and cause businesses and consumers to make different decisions. However, no matter what decisions are made, there's still a way to get a robust economy out of it, just as has been done for the more than two centuries since the founding of the United States, with booms and busts occurring under the influence of all sorts of different tax policies.

What really is well understood is that if the government spends X% of GDP, there will be a budget deficit unless it taxes X% of GDP. For too long, Republicans have said that if we tax at X-Y% of GDP, GDP will be forced up and cover the shortfall. Meanwhile, Democrats have (recently at least) said that if we spend at X+Z%, GDP will grow and cover the extra spending.

There is 0% chance anyone is going to show that either of those strategies actually works. They are just two variations on getting something for nothing.
But since we need to take a forward oriented approach, in a situation with 15T debt, 1T individual tax revenue, and a variable future interest rate on that debt, it's necessary to toss the old slogans and spin, and actually start with a (fairly clean) piece of paper to work out what happens and how and when.
 
But since we need to take a forward oriented approach, in a situation with 15T debt, 1T individual tax revenue, and a variable future interest rate on that debt, it's necessary to toss the old slogans and spin, and actually start with a (fairly clean) piece of paper to work out what happens and how and when.
I agree and think the starting point should be the GOP blueprint of spending cuts and tax rate increases.
 
Well, Intrade shows the Republicans 70% to win the Senate (they only need four seats, 23 are contested and a lot of those are not deep blue states) and 50% for the POTUS.

So you might get to see what they do. But whatever it is, I'm sure that a lot of people would not like it because it's Republicans. Better point of view, is, hey dudes, the parties over, and the spending has to stop, and it's gonna be a long hangover in the morning.
 
Well, Intrade shows the Republicans 70% to win the Senate (they only need four seats, 23 are contested and a lot of those are not deep blue states) and 50% for the POTUS.

So you might get to see what they do. But whatever it is, I'm sure that a lot of people would not like it because it's Republicans. Better point of view, is, hey dudes, the parties over, and the spending has to stop, and it's gonna be a long hangover in the morning.
I don't think most people are particularly interested in this bit of ad hominem. I think most agree that we need to fix things and that's going to take back bone.

Sadly, every time the GOP has been in charge they just increased spending. I see nothing to convince me that now is different. I hope I'lm wrong.
 
I don't think most people are particularly interested in this bit of ad hominem. I think most agree that we need to fix things and that's going to take back bone.

Sadly, every time the GOP has been in charge they just increased spending. I see nothing to convince me that now is different. I hope I'm wrong.

I agree with all this, but I wondered a bit today whether running the kind of deficits again that they ran the last time they were in power after this little kerfuffle would make the Republican Party look so hypocritical that even mhaze might wince a bit.

My guess though is that the Republicans could live with the hypocrisy. The thing that would control their lust for unfunded spending is the practical fact that they just won't find people willing to loan money to sustain their looney tunes governance any time soon.

ETA: I thought meadmaker expressed what is the reality of US economic governance perfectly.
 
Last edited:
I agree with all this, but I wondered a bit today whether running the kind of deficits again that they ran the last time they were in power after this little kerfuffle would make the Republican Party look so hypocritical that even mhaze might wince a bit.

My guess though is that the Republicans could live with the hypocrisy. The thing that would control their lust for unfunded spending is the practical fact that they just won't find people willing to loan money to sustain their looney tunes governance any time soon.

ETA: I thought meadmaker expressed what is the reality of US economic governance perfectly.
Thanks Dave. Good post.

I've been hard on the GOP lately but I'd happily embrace a fiscally conservative, pragmatic Republican. I'm beginning to like John Huntsman. Truth is I honestly don't know if our problems can be solved without things getting worse. I hope not. I prefer to be an optimist rather than a cynic but sometimes it's hard.
 
Thanks Dave. Good post.

I've been hard on the GOP lately but I'd happily embrace a fiscally conservative, pragmatic Republican. I'm beginning to like John Huntsman. Truth is I honestly don't know if our problems can be solved without things getting worse. I hope not. I prefer to be an optimist rather than a cynic but sometimes it's hard.

I would like it if a GOP official got elected and actually cut down spending. I think one problem the GOP has is that it is too tied to our country's military-industrial complex and its private industries to accurately convey the interest of their party's slogans.

The most effective way to conduct spending cuts is to make industries more efficient, not simply cut services to those who need it. We need to make our system more efficient, this point can not be escaped.
 
I've found it useful of of late to simply consider that there will be a correction to spending about 40% less, because as the debt increases and the interest rates go up nobody will loan us money. This correction is either natural, which is painful but doesn't get "blamed" on politicians, or it is actively constructed by politicians.

There won't be any "Fix" that involves "big new programs" and a great many programs will shrink or plain go away.
 
I've found it useful of of late to simply consider that there will be a correction to spending about 40% less, because as the debt increases and the interest rates go up nobody will loan us money.

Sounds like wishful thinking to me. I don't think even the Republicans have the stomach for what will occur if we cut 40% in spending that largely benefits the poor and elderly. My guess is that any "correction" done will include a combination of spending cuts, revenue increases, the wind-down of wars and other limited-time expenditures, and (hopefully) an improved economy.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom