USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

"Hope and change".
You are missing the point. mhaze attacks others for slogans and then immediately issues slogans.

  • "Hope and change" ISN'T mine.
  • I don't denounce rhetoric and then only engage in rhetoric.
If I do please bust my balls the way I bust mhaze's. It's really the height of arrogance to lecture others about slogans and then rely only on slogans to make a point. And then, as if that chutzpa isn't quite enough, appeal to the authority of Chomsky to justify using slogans.

Can you see my problem here?
 
Last edited:
Time for a reality check. Social security is not a ripoff and saying so is just dishonest. Social Security is funded for the next couple of decades even if we assume poor economic conditions. If economic conditions improve, the problem keeps moving to the future. If it doesn't, adjustments to benefits or payroll taxes will be needed. Similar to the adjustments that have been made to SS in the past.

.....

No, it is not funded for the next couple of decades. It is simply predicted that revenue collections will be adequate for payouts. Or maybe that's what you mean? One arm of the government pays the other arm.

this guy said it well:

“What people sometimes forget is that when somebody my age goes to collect on their Social Security I want money, cash,” Bowles, who is 65, replied. “And I go to present that obligation to the Social Security trust fund and it doesn't have cash. What it has is the government IOUs there which are as good as gold. But the government has to go out into the marketplace and borrow the money. And so it increases the national debt.”
 
It is. The problem is that Congress spent the money. That's not the fault of the people who paid into the system.
pretty much my point in #673, but the blame game is irrelevant.

I was just pointing out the logical steps going forward given the present fiscal situation. That's an action orientation. "Problem" and "fault" have no part in it.
 
....appeal to the authority of Chomsky to justify using slogans. ....
What is wrong with that? He is a noted authority on propaganda, and has lectured and written on it's use in furthering left wing politics. Essentially, if I have read Chomsky extensively, I've already heard all the arguments the useful idiots will bring to the table.

Do some on the left think they are intellectually superior, and not just part of a mob psychology? Chomsky discusses this. More useful idiots.

Does this mean I've heard all the arguments in this forum. Not if someone uses some creativity and thinks independently, or critically.
 
What is wrong with that? He is a noted authority on propaganda...
mhaze, I have tried for at least a dozen posts to explain to you why using "irregardless" (not a word) makes you look foolish.

How on earth can I possibly have a discussion with you about propaganda? I don't even know if you can parse the words to this sentence sufficiently to understand what I'm saying now.

Let me ask you this, and I will concede that it is completely off topic, do you understand why using "irregardless" is nonsensical?
 
"Morning in America"

Ever noticed almost all "slogans" are from the left?

Bush Lied, Kids Died! Our Bodies, Our Selves! No Blood for Oil! No Justice, No Peace! Save the Whales; Love Your Mother (Earth); Ban the Bomb; Make Love, Not War; Friends Don’t Let Friends Vote Republican; Diversity Is Our Strength! Save the Planet! Pro-Choice, Pro-Child! Support Our Troops, Bring Them Home! Co-Exist! Hey, Hey, LBJ, How Many Kids Did You Kill Today? Dissent Is Patriotic! War Is Not the Answer! Go Green! Health Care Is a Right, Not a Privilege! Imagine Peace; Celebrate Diversity! Beat the Bushes for Peace! No Nukes! Give Peace a Chance; Think Globally/Act Locally; No Tax Cuts for the Rich; Save the Planet! Venceremos! One, Two, Three, Four, We Don’t Want Your F—King War! Bush = Hitler; Hell No, We Won’t Go! Off the Pig! Eat the Rich! Die Yuppie Scum! Peace Now! We Are the Ones We’ve Been Waiting For! Solidarity Forever! Bring America Home! You Can’t Hug a Child with Nuclear Arms; Meat Is Murder! Books Not Bombs! Fight the Power! Yes We Can!

mmm mmmm mmmm
 
mhaze, I have tried for at least a dozen posts to explain to you why using "irregardless" (not a word) makes you look foolish.

How on earth can I possibly have a discussion with you about propaganda? I don't even know if you can parse the words to this sentence sufficiently to understand what I'm saying now.

Let me ask you this, and I will concede that it is completely off topic, do you understand why using "irregardless" is nonsensical?
I understand where you are coming from with that misunderestimation.:)
 
Ever noticed almost all "slogans" are from the left?
No.

Ever notice that you --

  1. Lecture others about using "slogans".
  2. Use slogans.
  3. Justify your use of slogans.
 
Last edited:
I understand where you are coming from with that misunderestimation.:)
Cool. Hey, I'm happy to try and resolve things and have a discussion. I'm not as arrogant as I come off. Sorry for busting your chops on all of this. Perhaps we can work it out.
 
,,,,How on earth can I possibly have a discussion with you about propaganda? I don't even know if you can parse the words to this sentence sufficiently to understand what I'm saying now. .,..
Generally speaking, you'd use references to the body of knowledge on the subject, and look at it's use in modern day political discourse.

This would be more difficult IF one was engaged in the propagation of the material, since the propagators are naively often not consciously aware of they doing so, and thus are somewhat in a state of denial.

But even so in the abstract, I'm certain that you will agree about the use of demonizing and stereotyping the opposition, as well as building huge lies based on shards of truth, then endlessly repeating these things...that these are essential tools in the propagandic method.
 
Generally speaking, you'd use references to the body of knowledge on the subject, and look at it's use in modern day political discourse.

This would be more difficult IF one was engaged in the propagation of the material, since the propagators are naively often not consciously aware of they doing so, and thus are somewhat in a state of denial.

But even so in the abstract, I'm certain that you will agree about the use of demonizing and stereotyping the opposition, as well as building huge lies based on shards of truth, then endlessly repeating these things...that these are essential tools in the propagandic method.
Okay,

I'm going to try and engage you on this. And I apologize for my patronizing tone. Forgive me if I ignore your post for just a moment.

Is it okay for you to use propaganda but not others?
 
Generally speaking, you'd use references to the body of knowledge on the subject, and look at it's use in modern day political discourse.

This would be more difficult IF one was engaged in the propagation of the material, since the propagators are naively often not consciously aware of they doing so, and thus are somewhat in a state of denial.

But even so in the abstract, I'm certain that you will agree about the use of demonizing and stereotyping the opposition, as well as building huge lies based on shards of truth, then endlessly repeating these things...that these are essential tools in the propagandic method.

Randman said:
Look, if in your opinion, it's okay to use slogans because Chomsky thinks it's so dandy then why in the sam hell do you give a damn that other people use slogans?
I don't. I only note that the use of slogans by the Left is quite heavy because of their incorporation of the principles of propaganda, as specifically laid out by Chomsky for the left.

There is no demonizing or stereotyping of the opposition in calling Barack Hussain Obama the "skinny one with big ears".

It's pure comedy. If you like, categorize that as Alinsky tactic #5, argument by ridicule. Ridicule is also of course incorporated in skilled propaganda dissemination, but I am not doing that.
 
Last edited:
It is. The problem is that Congress spent the money. That's not the fault of the people who paid into the system.

Children often believe that when you deposit money in a bank, they simply store it for you in their vault. Adults should understand that Scrooge McDuck's Moneybin and Gringotts in the Harry Potter novels do not represent how a real bank functions.

So why do so many adults expect the Social Security trust fund to be in cash instead of investment grade bonds?
 
First, I like words. I like them a lot. However, you are unnecessarily a bit heavy on the use of jargon IMO.

...I'm certain that you will agree about the use of demonizing and stereotyping the opposition....
It's not all demonizing but I'll agree.

...as well as building huge lies based on shards of truth, then endlessly repeating these things...that these are essential tools in the propagandic method.
Yes, and?

No. You do. You do it a lot.

I only note that the use of slogans by the Left is quite heavy because of their incorporation of the principles of propaganda, as specifically laid out by Chomsky for the left.
For the sake of moving the discussion forward I'll concede that Chomsky justifies the use of propaganda. It doesn't justify your use of it while condemning others.

Regardless, screw Chomsky, seriously, this is a skeptics forum. You should rely more on logically valid argument than prose or rhetoric to persuade. If all you have is slogans then you really don't have anything.

There is no demonizing or stereotyping of the opposition in calling Barack Hussain Obama the "skinny one with big ears".
Anyone can use that justification. It's easy to see malevolence in your opponents and innocence in yourself. Your means of persuasion should be above that. There is nothing wrong with wit or humor from time to time. But you repeat it so often it becomes trite and sounds mean spirited. That's fine but if you are going to engage in such sophomoric rhetoric then STOP lecturing others. It's really hypocritical. Yes, I get that you think that there is no smell to your feces. That's human nature. Rationalizing is what humans do best. It's not critical or skeptical.

It's pure comedy. If you like, categorize that as Alinsky tactic #5, argument by ridicule. Ridicule is also of course incorporated in skilled propaganda dissemination, but I am not doing that.
(emphasis mine). I'm sorry to be rude. I beg your forgiveness but I can assure you that your rhetoric is anything but skilled. It's childish. "your fat".

You can do better. Either stop lecturing others about slogans or stop using slogans. Come up with some better material or find a means that is better to your abilities. If you think you are funny then use your zingers sparingly, otherwise they come off as stale and mean spirited.
 
Last edited:
Children often believe that when you deposit money in a bank, they simply store it for you in their vault. Adults should understand that Scrooge McDuck's Moneybin and Gringotts in the Harry Potter novels do not represent how a real bank functions.

So why do so many adults expect the Social Security trust fund to be in cash instead of investment grade bonds?

"No, but you...you... you're thinking of this place all wrong. As if I had the money back in a safe. The, the money's not here. Well, your money's in Joe's house... that's right next to yours. And in the Kennedy House, and Mrs. Macklin's house, and, and a hundred others. Why, you're lending them the money to build, and then, they're going to pay it back to you as best they can. Now what are you going to do? Foreclose on them?" --George Baily, It's a wonderful life.
 
And the near collapse of American capitalism in 2008 didn't signal an end to predatory capitalism?

Capitalism, being based on a market economy, goes through periods of boom or bust. In my memory, again, every time there was a bust it "proved" the "end of capitalism" to the communists: in 2008; 1992; 1977-1981 (the academic world was then absolutely certain the USSR is winning, and the buzz word was that we are living in a world of "late capitalism" -- just before one of the biggest economic booms in US history, of course); the great depression, the stock market crashes in the late 1800s, the riots in the 1850s Marx used as evidence... etc., etc. etc.

In that century and a half, meantime, the one economic system that had utterly, totally, and murderously failed -- at the cost of 100,000,000 lives or so and the destruction into miserable poverty of billions more -- is communism.

The truth is Communism, Capitalism, and all those other garbage terms need to be thrown away for good.

Somehow I doubt you'd say that if communism had emerged the winner.

There needs to be a complex balance between the needs of individuals, their communities, governments, and corporations. Without a delicate balance between all of these underlying forces then any economy will fail. If you think privatization is the solution to anything then I only ask you to look at a few South American countries.

I certainly don't think privatization is the answer to everything. But on the whole, if it's the free market or the government trying to create the complex balance, the free market usually (not always) works far better.

Forget about re-engineering society in general for a minute and let's talk about, say, milk. In the USSR there was a "milk commissar" (not offical title, but the job description): a government official whose job was to try and estimate as well as possible how much milk is needed, to make sure enough is produced, delivered, and so on.

Needless to say, half the time there was no milk to be had, or too little, or too much. Because with the best will in the world of this commissar and his underlings, managing the economy this way is impossible.

Now look at the capitalist system. Milk producers, distributors, sellers, and customer all work for their own private interest -- which managed to make sure there is rarely, if ever, lack of milk. And there is no need at all for government-sponsored (that is, tax-money sponsored) fleets of milk-distribution drivers, for example.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom