USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Venezuela? Chile?


So...let's have it... How much of what do you want to take away from the producers?

You are using well known buzz words and slogans of the looters. Heard all that before.

How much?

that depends entirely how much they have.
those that have the most, will give the most.
did you miss the bit about sharing in kindergarten?
 
Seriously how much junk do people need?
I don't have the numbers but I need to find them. I'll concede I don't have the evidence to back it up. However, studies have shown that poverty is (obviously) associated with stress and a lack of well being. Increase in wealth increases happiness but it levels off at about $70,000 per person per year (I think that was 2000 - 2005 dollars). Oddly enough as the wealth increases above that at some point the happiness begins to decline (these are averages).

In any event, I believe in capitalism. I believe in the free market. I say anyone ought to have as much as he or she wants. Who the hell am I to cap how much they can have. I just think there should be a progressive tax and the rich can pay more. How much? I don't know. There are very wealthy people in many nations that tax much more than we do.
 
I don't have the numbers but I need to find them. I'll concede I don't have the evidence to back it up. However, studies have shown that poverty is (obviously) associated with stress and a lack of well being. Increase in wealth increases happiness but it levels off at about $70,000 per person per year (I think that was 2000 - 2005 dollars). Oddly enough as the wealth increases above that at some point the happiness begins to decline (these are averages).

In any event, I believe in capitalism. I believe in the free market. I say anyone ought to have as much as he or she wants. Who the hell am I to cap how much they can have. I just think there should be a progressive tax and the rich can pay more. How much? I don't know. There are very wealthy people in many nations that tax much more than we do.

I've actually read a book awhile back called Wellbeing: The Five Essential Elements it states a lot of what you mention in the lines above. I completely agree that there is a level of finance in which individuals are happy and complacent with life. However, like you have mentioned above the accumulation of more stuff does not always equal more happiness. I like some elements of capitalism; I can do without all the mindless consumerism. Things like community and family have to become important again, that's what equals true happiness in my opinion.

Have people ever drew up a system that measures the total cost of our modern “progress” not just in wealth and or loss of wealth, but the emotional, social, mental, and physical detriments it would have on our society? In my opinion there will always be a cost to everything in life, nothing that we experience comes without a cost. I think the true problem with modern economics is that no system measures “all” of the costs, not just the cost in money.
 
I've actually read a book awhile back called Wellbeing: The Five Essential Elements it states a lot of what you mention in the lines above. I completely agree that there is a level of finance in which individuals are happy and complacent with life. However, like you have mentioned above the accumulation of more stuff does not always equal more happiness. I like some elements of capitalism; I can do without all the mindless consumerism. Things like community and family have to become important again, that's what equals true happiness in my opinion.

Have people ever drew up a system that measures the total cost of our modern “progress” not just in wealth and or loss of wealth, but the emotional, social, mental, and physical detriments it would have on our society? In my opinion there will always be a cost to everything in life, nothing that we experience comes without a cost. I think the true problem with modern economics is that no system measures “all” of the costs, not just the cost in money.
Agreed.

And here is the question, what good is a life in which others suffer? What of the Christian admonition to love they neighbor? If billionaires can help, why not? "How many boats can you water ski behind?" --Bud Fox

Look, people who want to be materialistic, fine, but stop this pretense of Christian BS.
 
Last edited:
Agreed.

And here is the question, what good is a life in which others suffer? What of the Christian admonition to love they neighbor? If billionaires can help, why not? "How many boats can you water ski behind?" --Bud Fox

Look, people who want to be materialistic, fine, but stop this pretense of Christian BS.

Unfortunately if this ever happened they would have to shut down just about all the Christian broadcasting networks :D.
 
In any event, I believe in capitalism. I believe in the free market. I say anyone ought to have as much as he or she wants. Who the hell am I to cap how much they can have. I just think there should be a progressive tax and the rich can pay more. How much? I don't know. There are very wealthy people in many nations that tax much more than we do.

I consider myself pretty liberal, but I agree with all of this. I don't want to cap what people can buy, or earn, or have. I just want to find a stable happy medium wherein the people at the bottom are kept from desperation, and this is best achieved by progressive taxation and a social safety net.
 
I consider myself pretty liberal, but I agree with all of this. I don't want to cap what people can buy, or earn, or have. I just want to find a stable happy medium wherein the people at the bottom are kept from desperation, and this is best achieved by progressive taxation and a social safety net.

^^This.
 
I consider myself pretty liberal, but I agree with all of this. I don't want to cap what people can buy, or earn, or have. I just want to find a stable happy medium wherein the people at the bottom are kept from desperation, and this is best achieved by progressive taxation and a social safety net.
Well put.
 

I used to be much more conservative about it. I used to genuinely believe that good people who worked hard wouldn't need to worry about a safety net. But, the truth is, that's not at all the case.

I've come to realize that while today I'm doing pretty well for myself, tomorrow, through no fault of my own, I may be relying on that very safety net. And the reasons for wanting those safety nets removed are nothing but selfish: "I don't want to pay for those people" with little regard for just how easily/quickly "I" can become one of "those".


ETA2: I would be interested in learning just how many Tea Partiers collect Social Security, Medicare or Medicaid benefits, Unemployment Benefits, etc. I'd be honestly surprised to find that not a single member of the Tea Party was willing to accept these "Gov't handouts". And I know the way the response will be phrased: "Oh, but it's ok for me to collect, I paid into these programs. I worked hard." with the implication being that everyone else didn't work hard or didn't pay in, etc.
 
Last edited:
I used to be much more conservative about it. I used to genuinely believe that good people who worked hard wouldn't need to worry about a safety net. But, the truth is, that's not at all the case.

I've come to realize that while today I'm doing pretty well for myself, tomorrow, through no fault of my own, I may be relying on that very safety net. And the reasons for wanting those safety nets removed are nothing but selfish: "I don't want to pay for those people" with little regard for just how easily/quickly "I" can become one of "those".


ETA2: I would be interested in learning just how many Tea Partiers collect Social Security, Medicare or Medicaid benefits, Unemployment Benefits, etc. I'd be honestly surprised to find that not a single member of the Tea Party was willing to accept these "Gov't handouts". And I know the way the response will be phrased: "Oh, but it's ok for me to collect, I paid into these programs. I worked hard." with the implication being that everyone else didn't work hard or didn't pay in, etc.

Exactly.

In fact we have a lot of cases on record of loudmouthed tea baggers who were collecting SSI.
 
How much do you want to take from the average people? How can we buy stuff if we don't have money? How much do you want to lower wages?

Seriously how much junk do people need? People need to grow up and become contempt with life. There has to be something more than material wealth and garbage being the driving force of our existence. If that is all there is to existence then I am sure we will exterminate ourselves by the end of the century.

People need to leave that oh no don't take from the producers. All producers do with the extra money is purchase a yacht or a new home. You already have 3 why do you need more? We have lowered taxes! It has actually made the economy worse!

What I want to take away from producers is their pig-headed sense of invincibility and abuse of the average man. Stop giving people the out to neglect their social responsibilities. All members of society have an obligation and duty to take care of society. That includes people who are rich, and who are poor. If that social contract between members of society is broken, then there is no reason for this nation to exist. It might as well be every man, house, and city for himself. That's where it's headed anyway.

It is you that said...

I only ask you to look at a few South American countries. .....

Which is all that I did.

But you do have a point, if we want to look at how one's possessions may be taken away at the point of a gun, by all means South America may be a model.

Now, stop your stern, silly lecturing. It's not going to convince anyone that your socialist utopia (not directly presented, of course, but cloaked, only the slogans and promises projected) is worth a crap. It's just in your head, a little fantasy there.

What South America teaches us is regardless of the idiocy of the political leaders, capitalism thrives, either above board or as a black market.
 
I used to be much more conservative about it. I used to genuinely believe that good people who worked hard wouldn't need to worry about a safety net. But, the truth is, that's not at all the case.

I've come to realize that while today I'm doing pretty well for myself, tomorrow, through no fault of my own, I may be relying on that very safety net. And the reasons for wanting those safety nets removed are nothing but selfish: "I don't want to pay for those people" with little regard for just how easily/quickly "I" can become one of "those".


ETA2: I would be interested in learning just how many Tea Partiers collect Social Security, Medicare or Medicaid benefits, Unemployment Benefits, etc. I'd be honestly surprised to find that not a single member of the Tea Party was willing to accept these "Gov't handouts". And I know the way the response will be phrased: "Oh, but it's ok for me to collect, I paid into these programs. I worked hard." with the implication being that everyone else didn't work hard or didn't pay in, etc.

Well, hmmm.....people collecting SS today paid into it during decades in which the system was solvent, and during which it did represent a "square deal", although somewhat socialist.

Today, when we pay into SS, we basically have no expectation of getting the money back. So today, it's not a "square deal" .... it's a complete ripoff, from the individual's point of view.

So I can see someone thinking they were entitled to the payments, while believing the SS system was totally corrupt and needed to be overhauled.
 
Well, hmmm.....people collecting SS today paid into it during decades in which the system was solvent, and during which it did represent a "square deal", although somewhat socialist.

Today, when we pay into SS, we basically have no expectation of getting the money back. So today, it's not a "square deal" .... it's a complete ripoff, from the individual's point of view.

So I can see someone thinking they were entitled to the payments, while believing the SS system was totally corrupt and needed to be overhauled.

Time for a reality check. Social security is not a ripoff and saying so is just dishonest. Social Security is funded for the next couple of decades even if we assume poor economic conditions. If economic conditions improve, the problem keeps moving to the future. If it doesn't, adjustments to benefits or payroll taxes will be needed. Similar to the adjustments that have been made to SS in the past.
 
Now, stop your stern, silly lecturing. It's not going to convince anyone that your socialist utopia (not directly presented, of course, but cloaked, only the slogans and promises projected) is worth a crap. It's just in your head, a little fantasy there.

What South America teaches us is regardless of the idiocy of the political leaders, capitalism thrives, either above board or as a black market.
It's funny how a person who rails so much against slogans spends so much time making bald assertions and engaging in slogans.
 
It is you that said...

Now, stop your stern, silly lecturing. It's not going to convince anyone that your socialist utopia (not directly presented, of course, but cloaked, only the slogans and promises projected) is worth a crap. It's just in your head, a little fantasy there.

.

So you don't advocate for members of society to have a safety net?
 
Right. Looters and producers. Nobody said some looting wasn't necessary to protect and defend the State.

Empty rhetoric. Slogans.
I should have added "spin" and "framing".

This guy truly believes that sloganeering and propaganda is only relevant when the other person does it. He will justify it in heart beat by appealing to Chomsky while attacking others for doing what he is doing. The mind boggles.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom