USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

GOVERNMENT POLITICIANS MUST STOP SPENDING MORE THAN THEY HAVE TO SPEND.

That would be the goal. Of course, spending less than you have can be achieved by spending less or having more. Or in this case, it will most likely have to be a combination of the two.

But don't worry, it won't happen.

Not if the Democrats believe that they can achieve the goal without raising taxes on the middle class and without changing social programs, and the Republicans believe that they can achieve the goal without raising taxes at all.

The question is whether both parties are going to compromise (cutting taxes across the board and making serious spending cuts including to social programs and probably military) in order to achieve the goal. So far, the Democrats seem more willing to make the difficult compromises than the Republicans, maybe because they haven't signed ideological pledges.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
does your plan
I don't have a plan. I'm nobody.
include dramatic cuts in your military?
If I had a plan, there would definitely be room for very significant cuts in military spending.
In fact, I would demand them as well.
...or bringing all of your troops home from foreign lands?
All? Certainly not. Many? Certainly.
...or closing your many hundreds of military bases in foreign lands?
All? Certainly not. Many? Certainly.
 
Last edited:
Making any reasonable effort whatsoever to live within our means.

What a radical, Tea Party extremist racist notion!?

Stop putting more and more on The Credit Card.

It is a house of cards Ponzi scheme.

GOVERNMENT POLITICIANS MUST STOP SPENDING MORE THAN THEY HAVE TO SPEND.

Government is not forever and eternally immune from the same economic laws and realities we routinely face in our individual lives.

Period.

Simple.

Painful, yes, very, but there is no other way without financial/economic disaster.

But don't worry, it won't happen.

Catastrophe on the way straight ahead, it's only a question of when, if not how soon.

does your plan include dramatic cuts in your military?
...or bringing all of your troops home from foreign lands?
...or closing your many hundreds of military bases in foreign lands?
 
So far, the Democrats seem more willing to make the difficult compromises than the Republicans, maybe because they haven't signed ideological pledges.
Those difficult compromises include dramatic changes to SS, Medicare, & Medicaid. Dems are adamantly opposed to doing that, and have said so.
 
What you ignore—and I suspect quite deliberately—is the comparative rates of taxation between the time periods. High growth achieved in the 1980s and 1990s with tax rates higher than those seen in the 2000s

What you ignore … and I suspect quite deliberately … is that the 80's and 90's were periods when the US was still preeminent worldwide in many high-growth technologies (medical devices, electronics and then software). You heard of the internet boom, didn't you? That might have something to do with why the average Real GDP growth during those periods was higher than in the 2000's, when the rest of the world caught up in those technological areas. Problem is we didn't move on to the next technology … perhaps because democrat controlled schools have been pumping out community organizers, *actresses*, defense lawyers, and political science majors, rather than more conservative scientists and engineers. :D

What you ignore—and I suspect quite deliberately—is that the U.S. also began posting budget surpluses from the mid-1990s onwards. Fairly substantial surpluses in a couple of cases.

LOL! Like I've told you before when you made that claim, you've been deceived. There were no substantial surpluses in the 90's. Treasury Department data (which you can link through here http://www.craigsteiner.us/articles/16 ) clearly shows the national debt going up each and every year of Clinton's term. Here is that Treasury Department data AGAIN:

FY1993 $4.411 trillion
FY1994 $4.692 trillion, deficit = $281 billion
FY1995 $4.973 trillion, deficit = $281 billion
FY1996 $5.225 trillion, deficit = $250 billion
FY1997 $5.413 trillion, deficit = $188 billion
FY1998 $5.526 trillion, deficit = $113 billion
FY1999 $5.656 trillion, deficit = $130 billion
FY2000 $5.674 trillion, deficit = $18 billion
FY2001 $5.807 trillion, deficit = $133 billion

As you can see, the deficit went down but there never really was a surplus. Clinton just played games by shuffling the debt into different accounts to hide it. As that source notes, "he paid down the public debt by borrowing far more money in the form of intergovernmental holdings (mostly Social Security)." And then he lied through his teeth (which he often did) to turn those $130 and $18 billion dollar deficits into $120 and $230 billion surpluses for the media to regurgitate to a naive public: http://archives.cnn.com/2000/ALLPOLITICS/stories/09/27/clinton.surplus/ . You and the mainstream media drank the koolaide, Corsair. And this has all been pointed out to you previously. Are you unable to learn?

The truth is that ONLY GDP growth accounts for the drop in debt as a percent of GDP that occurred in the 90s. And that growth was stimulated not by raising taxes or keeping them high, but by lowering them as well as cutting government regulation … precisely the opposite of what Obama and democrats have been calling for now. Can liberals EVER learn? I have my doubts. :D

But during Bush 43's years there was a return to budget deficits (substantial deficits, in fact)

What you ignore … and I suspect quite deliberately … is that the internet boom went bust towards the end of Clinton's term, sending the US into a recession. That was followed by 9/11 which further damaged the economy. Then Bush had to fight the WOT which required rebuilding a military and intelligence apparatus that Clinton and democrats had trashed. All those costs naturally led to higher deficits. What would you have done any different, Corsair? Seriously? Hmmmmm?

and the continued lowering of tax rates did not lead to even better GDP growth.

LIAR. I've already proven on several threads that the Bush tax cuts resulted in several percent better GDP growth than what GDP growth was in 2001 and 2002, when the above negative events occurred. Or do you, like RF, believe there is such a thing as "before deflator" Real GDP and "after deflator" Real GDP? :rolleyes:

Bush 43: 2.0%.

LIAR. I clearly proved that GDP growth averaged at least 3% for about 10 quarters after the 2003 tax cut. It was only when democrats took control of Congress and the mortgage mess that democrats in large part created began to spiral out of control that the growth rates went south.

Since, however, you are an ideologue first and foremost

No, an ideologue is someone who ignores and lies about what the historical data clearly shows. That's seems to describe YOU.

I personally have no dog in this fight

And yet here you are. Bet you're a socialist and that's your dog.

But the data points to what it points, and I accept what it tells me.

No you don't. You've been lying about the data as this post clearly proves. Another reason I know that you are now lying is because we've had this sort of discussion previously and all that I just noted was pointed out to you. In this thread, for example:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=162505&page=9

Starting at post #333, you made claims about Clinton's surplus which I debunked over the next dozen posts or so (look at post #337, for instance), along with all the rest that you claimed here. You've just been regurgitating material that I already proved was false. Which makes you a LIAR.

:D
 
Last edited:
Those difficult compromises include dramatic changes to SS, Medicare, & Medicaid. Dems are adamantly opposed to doing that, and have said so.

Some Democrats have said so, but not Obama. In fact, he's said the opposite -- that difficult cuts to SS, Medicare, and Medicaid are on the table, but that it has to be a balanced approach, meaning that the Republicans are going to have to put tax increases on the table. Seems reasonable to me.

-Bri
 
Making any reasonable effort whatsoever to live within our means.
Like raising taxes?

GOVERNMENT POLITICIANS MUST STOP SPENDING MORE THAN THEY HAVE TO SPEND.
How much is that?

Government is not forever and eternally immune from the same economic laws and realities we routinely face in our individual lives.
No government is. But other govts do more on less. And they tax more.
 

I admire and agree with much of what Stockman has said concerning this crisis. He certainly has demolished the claims of the Obama administration that the Stimulus has helped unemployment and the economy.

And I told Bri before he, like Randman, decided to stop debating (but at least Bri hasn't been so foolish as to think putting me on ignore accomplishes anything) ... I'll agree with Stockman's assertion that Paul Ryan's solution to this crisis is too "non-radical". I'll agree that Ryan's solution would let things grow worse before they turned around and started to get better. Perhaps worse enough to become unfixable. I'll agree with Stockman that we have to find a quicker solution to reducing the debt as a percentage of the GDP. I agree with him that we have to massively cut government spending (far more than democrats have been willing to do). And I'll agree with him that this alone will not reduce the national debt as a percentage of GDP, not unless revenues significantly exceed spending or the GDP grows.

But here's where Stockman goes astray. In the past, Stockmen has said the way to force lower spending is to cut taxes. He called that tactic "starving the beast." Now Stockman is advocating an increase in taxes. He apparently thinks we can tax our way into a surplus that will significantly lower national debt as a percentage of GDP.

But that's a pipedream. He underestimates how difficult it is to get government to actually spend less than revenue. He ignores 65+ years of history. Historically, our government has almost always spent more than it took in as revenues. Here, see for yourself: http://static8.businessinsider.com/...345/us-government-spending-versus-revenue.jpg .

He also overlooks the effect of higher taxes on GDP growth. Why he is doing this now I don't know, but nevetheless he is. In any given period, what has made all the difference historically is whether there was economic growth or not. The share of the economy that has been seized by the government has gone down at times because of economic growth … not because government spent less than it took in as revenues (because they've rarely done that).

Relying on government to spend less than it takes in as revenue is a pipedream. And Stockman should know this. It's why he used to advocate "starving the beast". His new approach rarely has and rarely will work. It has certainly never done that long enough in the US to measurably shrink the deficit/debt as a percentage of GDP … which is what matters. What has reduced the deficit/debt as a percentage of GDP has been economic growth. Almost every time.

That's why I say that the ONLY way to fix the current economic mess is to cap spending so that government can't keep borrowing and thus increase the debt without bound, and then grow our way out of this by encouraging economic growth. By keeping taxes low and reducing needless government regulation of our lives. Just like the Tea Party advocates.

If we do that, we will see the size of the debt as a percentage of GDP shrink. THAT will get our economic house back in order. And a look at the period from 1995 to 2001, shows how rapidly that could occur:

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_QxBGECHec...4YsgU/s400/D.+National+Debt+as+percent+of+gdp

But it will never happen with Obama in the Whitehouse and Pelosi/Reid style democrats controlling Congress. Never. History proves that their type of economic thinking simply does not work.

So don't be deceived by RandMan's latest red herring. It's just as bogus as the "before deflator" Real GDP nonsense he posted the other day and then put me on ignore for pointing out as bogus. :D
 
who forced through a prescription benefits bill that not one dime was paid for

I agree that was foolish. Funny thing, democrats later tried to strengthen it further and obviously not one dime would have been paid for if they'd succeeded. :D

who added more to the debt than all previous presidents combined?

But debt as a percent of GDP is what matters and that went up only modestly. Here:

http://libertyworks.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/Debt-percentage-GDP.gif

That indicates that ratio had leveled off without even coming close to what it had been under Clinton (before republicans gained control of Congress and reduced it through economic growth). It might even have headed back down under Bush had the democrat created mortgage crisis (say, did you hear that Fannie and Freddie got downgraded today?) not occurred (so Obama could take advantage of it with media complicity to become President). Then look where it went. Now isn't that a "howler"? :D
 
[FONT=arial,verdana,helvetica][SIZE=+7]
[/SIZE][/FONT]
[FONT=arial,verdana,helvetica]Barackalypse Now!!


;)
[/FONT]
 
Some Democrats have said so, but not Obama. In fact, he's said the opposite -- that difficult cuts to SS, Medicare, and Medicaid are on the table

Obama's rhetoric is meaningless. It's actions that matter. And he's done nothing since the beginning of his Presidency to prove he means what he says. He's spent and spent and spent. In fact, he's made those specific problems worse if anything. And now he want's to give back 10% of what he and his party have increased in order to get higher taxes from those he's already saddled with most of the expenses? A compromise? No thanks. He's just going to set his catastrophic socialist agenda in concrete and then wait for the next crisis so he (or the next socialist/communist who follows) can bump government social spending up even further No thanks, Bri. Maybe you are buying that koolaide, but then remember what P.T. Barnum was alleged to have said (although he apparently never actually did). :D
 
The question is whether both parties are going to compromise (cutting taxes across the board and making serious spending cuts including to social programs and probably military) in order to achieve the goal. So far, the Democrats seem more willing to make the difficult compromises than the Republicans, maybe because they haven't signed ideological pledges.

-Bri

I've lost any optimism in seeing the two parties bridge all of their ideological gaps. So many party supporters are incapable of holding their own parties responsible for their contribution to this mess. Between Bachman's driving me batty with her placing all the blame on Obama, and the teaparty downgrade/terrorist BS is driving me crazy from the democrats. Both Obama, his party, and the republicans in congress are voting on their base ideology, not so much on compromise.

Politics has become a little kids fight since this debt mess erupted in flames.

It's almost entertaining to see people's political biases go through the roof.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom