Urine Injection Results In One Dead

Is no one else reminded of the scene in "Catch 22" when "The Soldier In White" has his IV drip and urine collection bottles rotated periodically by the nurses?

Cheers,

Dave

I've heard the rumor that we did something similar in Europe after WWII.
Penicillin supplies couldn't keep up with demand, so we reclaimed penicillin from our GIs, and re-cycled it to German soldiers/POWs.

I guess it maybe possible, but it is probably an urban myth. Probably fostered by anti-American Germans, much later.
 
Is no one else reminded of the scene in "Catch 22" when "The Soldier In White" has his IV drip and urine collection bottles rotated periodically by the nurses?

I think I just saw that on the Simpsons, when Grandpa complains that his catheter bag is full and his IV bag is empty.
 
I've heard the rumor that we did something similar in Europe after WWII.
Penicillin supplies couldn't keep up with demand, so we reclaimed penicillin from our GIs, and re-cycled it to German soldiers/POWs.

I guess it maybe possible, but it is probably an urban myth. Probably fostered by anti-American Germans, much later.
I've heard a similar story, but somewhat earlier with the first test patients for penicillin. They couldn't produce it in sufficient quantities so, as you say, they took the piss.

Florey s first patient was a policeman, who in February,
1941, was lying in the Radcliffe Infirmary at Oxford, desper
ately sick of generalized septicaemia caused by two kinds of
microbe, both sensitive to the action of penicillin. Twenty-
four hours after the first injection the change in his condition
was astonishing.

But, after continued administration, the stock of penicillin
was almost exhausted.

Some was recovered from the patient s urine ; its properties
were intact although it had been expelled from his body.
There was every evidence that his life could be saved by
penicillin : his temperature had dropped, the sores on his
face and head were healing, his appetite had returned. For
ten days " this forlorn case " as Florey called it, hung in the
balance. But there was no more penicillin and the constable
died. When they had replenished their meagre reserves,
they tried it out again on a few more patients.
http://www.archive.org/stream/flemingdiscovere000032mbp/flemingdiscovere000032mbp_djvu.txt
 
I think I just saw that on the Simpsons, when Grandpa complains that his catheter bag is full and his IV bag is empty.

Joseph Heller wrote "Catch 22" in 1961 and Mike Nichols made the film in 1970 (Art Garfunkel of Simon and Garfunkel fame even played a small role).

Very anti-war, anti-bureaucracy, anti-authority. Very '60s.

The Simpsons writers were, I'm sure, doing an homage to the film.

You should rent it sometime.

Cheers,

Dave
 
If we take oral or IV antibiotics to treat kidney/bladder infections, then we know the meds can come through the system intact. Recycling ought to be feasible. Actual, I don't know.

But it does bring up another possible cause of death in the OP- allergy. Anaphylactic shock, caused by meds or other components in the urine. It would happen fast enough for somebody to know the source- the injector would still be in the room, syringe and bucket still in hand.
 
I know that urine is antibacterial because you can use it to sterilize and clean a wound before binding it, if you're really hard up. Don't leave it sitting around though. You might think 'ewww' but if you're in the woods and tore open your arm, it beats the hell out of cleaning it with any water you find, or not cleaning it at all.

But this is just... stupid.
 
Perhaps if a chiropractor had been on hand it would have all ended very differently.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom