Urine Injection Results In One Dead

The injection site was the IV bag/line, not the person's body.

I'm curious what the infectious agent was, as (like I keep saying) urine is usually rather sterile.

Yes, I get that.

SO a little clearer I will try to be.

Possible sources of bacterial agents in this case.

1. The urine itself (perhaps patient had a UTI) - Likely culprit E.Coli
2. IV site (regardless of whether Urine was injected directly or via IV, a needle is in the skin). - Likely culprit, Staph Aureus.

Yes urine is USUALLY free of significant bacteria (thank goodness), but not always, and this is one particular case.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
Yes, I get that.

SO a little clearer I will try to be.

Possible sources of bacterial agents in this case.

1. The urine itself (perhaps patient had a UTI) - Likely culprit E.Coli
2. IV site (regardless of whether Urine was injected directly or via IV, a needle is in the skin). - Likely culprit, Staph Aureus.

Yes urine is USUALLY free of significant bacteria (thank goodness), but not always, and this is one particular case.

TAM:)
:) I understand, but it still doesn't really give me what I'm looking for. However, I think it's most likely that my curiosity will go unanswered, as the only persons who can really say what the actual mechanism was (as opposed to speculations) are doctors, or other persons, involved directly in the case.
 
Irrelevant point. In discussion with Prester John, who is a bacteriologist, I recall him saying that urine is indeed mildly antibacterial. But considering how easy it is to get honking bacterial contamination of urine, the emphasis has to be on the mildly.

Rolfe.
 
Irrelevant point. In discussion with Prester John, who is a bacteriologist, I recall him saying that urine is indeed mildly antibacterial. But considering how easy it is to get honking bacterial contamination of urine, the emphasis has to be on the mildly.

Rolfe.
The explanations mentioned so far seem unlikely in that a/ the urine happened to be from someone with raging bacterial cystitis and b/ the level of infection in the urine caused sufficient bacteria to be injected to kill the patient. Surely you'd get a much higher population if the urine injected was stale, with a lot of contaminant bugs multiplying away.

Yuri
 
So what? Urine is not sterile because of antimicrobial action; it's sterile because it happens to be produced that way. Unless it was collected under sterile conditions and prevented from people sneezing into it and all other kinds of contamination, there's no reason it must be sterile by the time the nutjob injects it.



Hmm... perhaps if you were stranded on an island, and suffering from a serious disease, and had only a very limited amount of drug to treat it, readministering urine could in some cases extend the time the drug remains active in your organism and potentially save you. That's about as close to therapeutic as I can think of.
You can do this with recreational drugs also.
 
The explanations mentioned so far seem unlikely in that a/ the urine happened to be from someone with raging bacterial cystitis and b/ the level of infection in the urine caused sufficient bacteria to be injected to kill the patient. Surely you'd get a much higher population if the urine injected was stale, with a lot of contaminant bugs multiplying away.

Yuri

The article, as I read it, is unclear on whether the infectious agent came FROM the urine, or came FROM the IV site. For all we know, it could have been a particularly aggressive Staph Aureus infection from an infected IV site.

Skeptichick is right, short of the details published, only questioning the MDs etc..involved, or having access to the chart, would tell you the truth.

TAM:)
 
There are stories that the trip from the fly agaric mushroom can be shared by a whole tent of reindeer heerders by passing the piss.
 
The explanations mentioned so far seem unlikely in that a/ the urine happened to be from someone with raging bacterial cystitis and b/ the level of infection in the urine caused sufficient bacteria to be injected to kill the patient. Surely you'd get a much higher population if the urine injected was stale, with a lot of contaminant bugs multiplying away.


Well, you know and I know that the volume of urine you could inject via a drip bag couldn't possibly kill anyone with even half a healthy kidney. So we have to assume it was an infection.

Let's assume that the urine was indeed the source of the infection, rather than something else. I still don't see how someone in hospital managed to die of the resulting septicaemia unless the organism involved was an incredibly multi-resistant strain. And even if she did, it would have taken some time. She couldn't have dropped dead off the end of the needle, any way you slice it.

The more you think about it, the less sense there seems to be in this story.

Rolfe.
 
Thousands of patients die from post-surgical infections. Hospitals are a great place if you want to pick up MRSA. Without more info, we here don't know for sure it was the urine. I wonder if the hospital did a culture on the urine? And a culture on the patient? Or if the patient was unlucky, and the hospital lucky to be able to blame some kook for one of it's cases of post-surgical infection?
 
Thousands of patients die from post-surgical infections. Hospitals are a great place if you want to pick up MRSA. Without more info, we here don't know for sure it was the urine. I wonder if the hospital did a culture on the urine? And a culture on the patient? Or if the patient was unlucky, and the hospital lucky to be able to blame some kook for one of it's cases of post-surgical infection?
I think there's unquestionably more to this story than the 'facts' as reported.

Yuri
 
Well, the idiot who injected it has no clue. She probably stored it improperly and in unsanitary conditions. Think bucket in the garage. It probably degraded into the type of stuff you could bleach your clothes with.

Try injecting ammonia into the bloodstream and see what happens, along with some nasty microbes to poison the blood with.
 
You have to remember that direct IV injection of any fluid that is not closely isotonic with blood is likely to have serious and fatal consequences due to overwhelming intravascular haemolysis, irrespective of whether its sterile or not. Inject someone with 500mls of sterile tap water, and they are likely going to die, because the rapid changes in osmotic concentration will cause their red blood cells to swell up and burst. Other possible causes of death would be from particulate contamination - how was the urine collected and stored?
Bacterial contamination is of course possible, but only if the urine donor (oh what an awful phrase) had a pre existing infection, as urine, as others have said, is normally sterile. I don't buy the explanation that urine from the bladder is sterile but gets contaminated as it travels down the urethra; we test for urine infections by getting people to pee into a cup, remember.
 
I remember reading a fashion magazine years ago that listed one of the benefits of ingesting urine as a wrinkle reducer. I'll stick with using SPF 15 daily moisturizer.
 
I remember reading a fashion magazine years ago that listed one of the benefits of ingesting urine as a wrinkle reducer. I'll stick with using SPF 15 daily moisturizer.

You are supposed to suffer for beauty. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom