Urine Injection Results In One Dead

I believe this happen in Vietnam (and other places) where they will set up traps with stakes covered or coated in feces and urine. Thus if the person survive getting stab they will still be poisoned by the waste. I do not know how Urine therapy got start but common sense should tell people that urine and feces are waste, and not to be taken in any form. Waste does have toxins which a lot of alternate therapies seek to remove from the human body.
 
I think the word you're looking for is toxins.
Exactly, it's the precise opposite of what most CAM people are trying to achieve - detoxifying. The only real (as opposed to woo) way we've got of detoxifying is by pushing toxins out through the urine and faeces and these people want to inject it all back in again - retoxifying! Bonkers.

Sensible urine therapists drink their urine at homeopathic dilutions (seriously, I jest not).

Yuri Nalyssus (somehow I felt destined to post to this thread)
 
So what is the supposed mechanism of death? Terminal yuck factor?

Urine is usually sterile, due to the ammonia content. Except the possible UTI. And the waste products are pretty common amongst us all, should lead to kidneys working a bit harder with double the load? Probably not fatal. So that leaves, umm, anaphlaxis? Or what? .
 
So what is the supposed mechanism of death? Terminal yuck factor?

Urine is usually sterile, due to the ammonia content. Except the possible UTI. And the waste products are pretty common amongst us all, should lead to kidneys working a bit harder with double the load? Probably not fatal. So that leaves, umm, anaphlaxis? Or what? .
I wonder too, though I would imagine that main-lining ammonia is probably pretty bad for you... Especially if you're already sick enough that you're hospitalized in the ICU :)
 
Unless I missed something later, the OP mentioned she died of INFECTION from the urine. Now as to whether the infectious agent was In the urine, or caused by the injection itself, who knows, though I suspect the former.

TAM:)
 
Unless I missed something later, the OP mentioned she died of INFECTION from the urine. Now as to whether the infectious agent was In the urine, or caused by the injection itself, who knows, though I suspect the former.

TAM:)
And what I don't understand is what caused the infection, as urine is generally sterile. Unless of course, there was something wrong with the UTI of the person/animal that produced the urine that allowed the proliferation of an infectious substance...

So, I still wonder -- what was the actual mechanism of the infection?
 
I suspect the urine probably had traces of the infectious agent within it. It is either that, or the infection came from the injection site itself.

TAM:)
 
Urine is usually sterile, due to the ammonia content.

Urine doesn't have a lot of ammonia in it. It contains urea, which will hydrolyze upon long standing to give ammonia, but the ammonia's not there when it comes out.
 
I suspect the urine probably had traces of the infectious agent within it. It is either that, or the infection came from the injection site itself.

TAM:)
The injection site was the IV bag/line, not the person's body.

I'm curious what the infectious agent was, as (like I keep saying) urine is usually rather sterile.
 
I'm curious what the infectious agent was, as (like I keep saying) urine is usually rather sterile.

So what? Urine is not sterile because of antimicrobial action; it's sterile because it happens to be produced that way. Unless it was collected under sterile conditions and prevented from people sneezing into it and all other kinds of contamination, there's no reason it must be sterile by the time the nutjob injects it.

WTF is urine therapy supposed to treat? What in God's name does the reapplication of a waste product to the body accomplish therapeutically?

Hmm... perhaps if you were stranded on an island, and suffering from a serious disease, and had only a very limited amount of drug to treat it, readministering urine could in some cases extend the time the drug remains active in your organism and potentially save you. That's about as close to therapeutic as I can think of.
 
I was struggling to figure out why a urine infusion killed her too. It's astounding how uraemic and even hyperammonaemic kidney failure patients can get, and still not die. Dialysis will of couse sort them out. In an individual with normal kidney function, no treatmemt but fluids should be necessary. It would be a bit of an analogy for a lower urinary tract obstruction, but without the obstruction, as it were. She shouldn't have died of that.

If it was infection, well, change the story slightly.

Madwoman contaminates hospital patient's i/v drip. Patient succumbs to infection despite antibiotic treatment.

Doesn't quite make the same headline though, does it?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
From the naked science forum:
Urine directly from the bladder is normally sterile. However, on its passage from the bladder to the outside world, urine becomes contaminated by bacteria normally present in the lower urethra and external genitalia.

This all makes sense. From what I have read the general opinion appears to be is that blokes who haven't had the snip at birth will put a pretty high load of bacteria into the urine due to high bacterial counts on the foreskin.

OK? Excuse me while I go and up-chuck. This concept is bloody disgusting.:eek:
Next they'll be using pooh as facecream to pull the toxins out of the skin.
(And NO, don't you dare even think of checking this on Google. We don't need to know the truth. NO, REALLY, we DON'T need to know.)
 
Last edited:
In related news:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/food_and_drink/article5707554.ece

From Times Online
February 11, 2009

India to launch cow urine as soft drink

India's Hindu nationalist movement apparently has the answer: a new soft drink made from cow urine.

...

In 2001, the RSS and its offshoots – which include the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party – began promoting cow urine as a cure for ailments ranging from liver disease to obesity and even cancer.

...etc. etc.


:covereyes
 
So what? Urine is not sterile because of antimicrobial action; it's sterile because it happens to be produced that way. Unless it was collected under sterile conditions and prevented from people sneezing into it and all other kinds of contamination, there's no reason it must be sterile by the time the nutjob injects it.

Amen. Thabiguy's right; to the best of my knowledge, there is no inherently antibacterial property of urine. On top of that, as a practical matter people need to realize that urine may be produced in a sterile manner, but by the time it's excreted it is not necessarily so any longer. Otherwise healthy people can have a small amount of bacteria along the urinary tract from insufficient hygenic practice after using the bathroom, or from sex (no, sex isn't dirty, I'm merely pointing out one possible infective route. Due to his medical eduation, T.A.M. could probably tell us all about "Honeymoon Cystitis" and other UTI's. They're hardly rampant, but they're hardly rare either).

On top of that, what are the cleanliness practices of the collectors for this sort of treatment? The infective agent could have easily been introduced at that point.

Hmm... perhaps if you were stranded on an island, and suffering from a serious disease, and had only a very limited amount of drug to treat it, readministering urine could in some cases extend the time the drug remains active in your organism and potentially save you. That's about as close to therapeutic as I can think of.

Yeeech!... Man, that'd have to be one hell of a serious disease to consider the risk of kidney damage to be a fair exchange for the effect of the drug. That would also have to assume that a fair amount of the drug remains unmetabolized by the time it's excreted, but that's a question for someone more familiar with that sort of thing than I am. All right... well, the situation's extreme, but I guess that would be a plausible situation. Uncomfortable and unpleasant, though.
 


Think I'll stick to Dr. Pepper thank you very much.
redface.gif
 
.
It's in the Book!
. A verse in Proverbs advises: "Drink waters from thy own cistern, flowing water from thy own well."
And isn't that far-out, many famous have done it for various reasons.
Coprophagy also.


I don't know about other dictionaries, but my Wordweb Pro has this:

Noun: coprophagy

1. Eating feces; in human a symptom of some kinds of insanity

I've heard of taking the piss, but this takes the cake. :)


M.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom