Urine Injection Results In One Dead

shawmutt

Squirrel Murderer
Joined
Jan 17, 2009
Messages
2,037
http://www.shortnews.com/start.cfm?id=76931

Thirty-five-year-old Bolivian veterinarian Gabriela Ascarrunz died on Saturday due to an "infection caused by urine that was injected by fashion designer Monica Schultz." Shults is well known in Bolivia for clothes.

Schultz also practices urine therapy; an alternative medicine where human urine is injected, drank, or rubbed on the skin. An arrest warrant was issued for Schultz who is in the U.S. promoting new clothing.

Scientists say there is no evidence urine therapy works. It is not clear whether Ascarrunz practiced the alternative therapy, or where the urine came from.

Seriously. What the **** is wrong with people?
 
To compound the stupidity: a veterinarian?!!!!!

You'd expect some sort of basic understanding of medicine, right?

Kee-rist!
 
To compound the stupidity: a veterinarian?!!!!!

You'd expect some sort of basic understanding of medicine, right?

Kee-rist!
.
It's in the Book!
. A verse in Proverbs advises: "Drink waters from thy own cistern, flowing water from thy own well."
And isn't that far-out, many famous have done it for various reasons.
Coprophagy also.
 
.
It's in the Book!
. A verse in Proverbs advises: "Drink waters from thy own cistern, flowing water from thy own well."
And isn't that far-out, many famous have done it for various reasons.
Coprophagy also.


DRINK!!! Solomon didn't mention mainlining it.

Also:
barf.gif
 
I had known about urine therapy but this is the first time I hear of injecting it. I wonder if it was an intravenous injection... also, do we know how many days passed between the injection and the death ?
 
I'll keep a news alert on it to see if there's any followup.

from http://www.nydailynews.com/news/us_...prosecutor_implicates_fashion_designer_i.html

Alfredo Romero, director of the Incor clinic in the eastern province of Santa Cruz, said Ascarrunz was admitted last Thursday in serious condition to have surgery for an intestinal obstruction.

The alleged fatal injection came two days later as she was being treated in intensive care. The urine apparently was administered into fluid, or serum, that Ascarrunz was receiving intravenously.

"The victim's father realized that that woman (Schultz) had injected the urine," Flores said. "She was immediately expelled from the hospital and the serum was ordered changed, but unfortunately it was too late."
 
Last edited:
I very rarely feel enabled, by sense of decency or march of calender, to say this, but...

200th ANNIVERSARY MEGA-DARWIN AWARD!

:bcake:
 
Last edited:
This is intriguing once you get passed the inherent ick factor. What's the previous association between Schultz and Ascarrunz - why was Schultz allowed in the intensive care unit originally? Can Schultz be tried for negligent homicide or is there a not guilty by reason of stupidity type defense available?
 
It seems that the woman might have been a pure victim and not responcible for her own death.

The second link provided by shawmutt seemed to imply otherwise when I first read it; that there was a 'therapeutic' relationship there already - now I'm less sure, and I hope I haven't been too hasty. :blush:
 
Last edited:
What in God's name does the reapplication of a waste product to the body accomplish therapeutically?

That's what I don't understand. Urine is one of the body's ways of removing "materials"(I'm not a scientist, I'm not sure what the best word would be) that it doesn't need. If the body needed any of the stuff that's in urine, it wouldn't then be in the urine, right? Again, I'm no doctor, I'm not even studying a science and I know this. You'd think a veterinarian would know better.

That's the other thing though. Is there any explanation why a person who has some medical expertise would trust a fashion designer when it comes to their own medical treatment? Why trust modern medicine for animals but not for oneself? Unless I missed somewhere that the fashion designer has some kind of academic medical training, something seems wonky there.
 
WTF is urine therapy supposed to treat? What in God's name does the reapplication of a waste product to the body accomplish therapeutically?

Huge placebo effect?

And some (possibly) mumbo-jumbo about "the immune system". Then again ... and I realize Wikipedia's Not A Reliable Source,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allergy#Hygiene_Hypothesis

Apart from the ego boost of "look what icky thing I just did!" I'm not aware of any other proven benefit.

Of course, some people with cyclic diseases that come and go by themselves claim that "it works every time! You just got to wait a little longer sometimes"...
 
That's what I don't understand. Urine is one of the body's ways of removing "materials"(I'm not a scientist, I'm not sure what the best word would be) that it doesn't need. If the body needed any of the stuff that's in urine, it wouldn't then be in the urine, right?

You're thinking scientifically. You need to think magically about this in order to understand where the idea comes from.

Alchemists used urine in a lot of their formulations, when attempting to make the philosopher's stone, etc. Their reasoning was that a person is always aging, and losing vitality. At the same time, a person is also pissing throughout their life. So maybe, just maybe, that urine contains some of the vitality that the person is losing. So maybe, just maybe, we can get that vitality back.

That's the kind of thinking that makes urine therapy a reasonable idea.
 
As I am constantly on the look-out for any stories of use for our very own Krelnik's WhatstheHarm.net, I confess my first thought was "Here's another one for the alternative medicine category!".

My second, third and fourth thoughts were what a sad story, how disgusting and how surprising it is that the victim was a vet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom