Merged U.S. ambassador to Libya, 3 others killed in rocket attack, witness says

That's your confirmation bias, not mine. I don't need to demonize speech I don't like. The speech speaks for itself.
I didn't say "demonize". I said "blame".

So Jones burns a Koran knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A cleric drums up fervor over an anti-Islamic movie trailer knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A White Supremacist gives sermons and passes out literature encouraging murder which then happens.

Bill O'Reilly calls Dr Tiller a baby killer over and over on the public airwaves and Dr Tiller is then murdered by an incited nutjob.

So, are you are certain your opinion, whatever it is on these 4 men, is clear, absolute and any opinion that disagrees with you just can't see the obvious?

Except you mischaracterized the second instance. The cleric didn't "drum up fervor". He exhorted his followers to violence, which is exactly the line I said has been drawn between speech and incitement for a century.

That imam, like the white supremacist in your example are guilty of inciting violence and are not protected by principles of free speech. Jones and O'Reilly are. And rightfully so, as much as you don't like it and would like to search for some sort of nuance so you can blame Jones and O'Reilly for other people's actions.
 
The problem with the "not provoke them deliberately" part is that anything can be (and has been) seen as a provocation. Even the idea of trying to educate them into a more tolerant acceptance of criticism can be seen as a provocation. That's really what is going on here. Another culture is demanding that we limit our speech in accordance with their beliefs. What we have to do is make them understand that it will not work.

Exactly. And what's more, the imams clearly simply chose anything they could find and then supplemented it with lies in order to get the riots they wanted. They could just as easily have dredged up the Danish cartoons again. Or simple made up a story about American drones killing Palestinians. Or pretty much anything else. They happened to choose this YouTube video. But that choice appears entirely arbitrary.
 
.
Exactly what did happen.
Manson didn't kill anyone himself, but he incited others to kill.

"Hey, go kill them!" or even "Will nobody rid me of this priest?" are not anything remotely like, "You guys are ********!" "Oh yeah? I'll kill you!!!!!"
 
Last edited:
It has occurred to me that some Muslims seem immune to irony.

Actually that seems to be a common trait among radicals.

"How dare you call us reactionaries! We'll kill you for that!"

Even worse - it's "How dare you call us violent!"

Maybe the Arab street is running the world's biggest Poe?
 
I think folks are actually completely making that part up. I don't recall hearing about any of the rioting Muslims actually claiming to be upset at any depiction of followers of Islam as violent or reactionary.
 
I find it stunning the number of people -- not huge, but a greater number than I would have supposed -- on this forum looking to blame the speakers for their irresponsbile speech.

Have you actually *read* some of the posts here about Christianity, or Mormonism?

Do you recall Penn & Teller's "Second Coming of Christ"?

Remember how funny it is to make pedophilia jokes about the Catholic Church?

The difference appears to be that a violent minority of islamists have you cowed. Some are willing to abandon a long tradition that states "even hatemongers have rights in a free society" in order to make the mean people stop.

So I guess it's a clear signal to the wacky anti-abortionists to step up their game. Obviously, the other religions just need to arrange a few rocket attacks and beheadings and then, instead of mocking those other religions, everyone will be on board with locking up anyone who offers criticism that can be labelled "hateful" or "irresponsible." If the opponent can just get violent enough and raise the cost enough, all our high-sounding principles about freedom of expression will get tossed aside faster than you can say "please don't *hurt* me."
 
I find it stunning the number of people -- not huge, but a greater number than I would have supposed -- on this forum looking to blame the speakers for their irresponsbile speech.

Saying "You have no right to say that!" is much worse than saying "What you say has consequences."

No one here, AFAIK, has said these filmmakers do not have a right to say what they want about Islam. They are just pointing out that what these filmmakers say has very real consequences.
 
I find it stunning the number of people -- not huge, but a greater number than I would have supposed -- on this forum looking to blame the speakers for their irresponsbile speech.

Have you actually *read* some of the posts here about Christianity, or Mormonism?

Do you recall Penn & Teller's "Second Coming of Christ"?

Remember how funny it is to make pedophilia jokes about the Catholic Church?

The difference appears to be that a violent minority of islamists have you cowed. Some are willing to abandon a long tradition that states "even hatemongers have rights in a free society" in order to make the mean people stop.

So I guess it's a clear signal to the wacky anti-abortionists to step up their game. Obviously, the other religions just need to arrange a few rocket attacks and beheadings and then, instead of mocking those other religions, everyone will be on board with locking up anyone who offers criticism that can be labelled "hateful" or "irresponsible." If the opponent can just get violent enough and raise the cost enough, all our high-sounding principles about freedom of expression will get tossed aside faster than you can say "please don't *hurt* me."

I think that some of it is that. And some of it is that people are unwilling to hold people in other cultures up to the same standards as they would demand from people in their own culture (perhaps for fear of appearing culturally chauvinistic?).

So it's a mixture of (in some cases) fear of violence, and in other cases a rather condescending "we should magnanimously make all of the concessions because we can't expect those people to restrain themselves".

Either way, we are heading back to a world where free speech is regulated in a way that Galileo would have recognized.
 
Cnn is now reporting the protest was a diversion for the attack. Presumably rather than an organic outgrowth of mob behavior.
 
I find it stunning the number of people -- not huge, but a greater number than I would have supposed -- on this forum looking to blame the speakers for their irresponsbile speech.
Of course you blame speakers for their speech. Who else would you blame?

Have you actually *read* some of the posts here about Christianity, or Mormonism?

Do you recall Penn & Teller's "Second Coming of Christ"?

Remember how funny it is to make pedophilia jokes about the Catholic Church?

The difference appears to be that a violent minority of islamists have you cowed. Some are willing to abandon a long tradition that states "even hatemongers have rights in a free society" in order to make the mean people stop.
If anyone's going that far, I hope it's Europeans.

The speakers are responsible for their speech. The mean people are responsible for the riots and murders.

Obviously, the other religions just need to arrange a few rocket attacks and beheadings and then, instead of mocking those other religions, everyone will be on board with locking up anyone who offers criticism that can be labelled "hateful" or "irresponsible."
No, anyone who's advocating locking people up for saying hateful and irresponsible things (unless it violates the "clear and present danger" call for proximate violence) is un-American.

If we can't tear pages out of the Quran and use them to drain fresh-cooked bacon, or tear pages out of the Bible and use them to clean up after our dogs, then this isn't the country in which I grew up.
 
If anyone's going that far, I hope it's Europeans.

It's not an "if". They are going that far.

No, anyone who's advocating locking people up for saying hateful and irresponsible things (unless it violates the "clear and present danger" call for proximate violence) is un-American.

Also known as Belgian.

If we can't tear pages out of the Quran and use them to drain fresh-cooked bacon, or tear pages out of the Bible and use them to clean up after our dogs, then this isn't the country in which I grew up.

Damn straight.
 
Of course you blame speakers for their speech. Who else would you blame?
The people who choose to respond inappropriately to that speech. The speaker, no matter how hateful, is not responsible for their reactions.
 
No one here, AFAIK, has said these filmmakers do not have a right to say what they want about Islam. They are just pointing out that what these filmmakers say has very real consequences.

The film is a pretext, and a flimsy one at that. It's clear enough that the rioters were spoiling for any excuse to lash out. If not for this film, it would have been something else.
 
If we can't tear pages out of the Quran and use them to drain fresh-cooked bacon, or tear pages out of the Bible and use them to clean up after our dogs, then this isn't the country in which I grew up.
Legally you can do those things, but that doesn't preclude someone from having a negative (and possibly illegal) reaction to your legal actions.
 
Letting people silence other people because of offense breeds a feigned offense industry, whatever the real offense may have been.

Indeed, everyone take a breath -- it's precisely because politicians wield offense so effectively through the millenia that we're even in this position to begin with and have found the solution to it by forbidding legally silencing it.
 
Last edited:
Is there not a middle ground between "Remaining completely silent no matter what offensive things are said" and "Making offensive things that are said illegal and censoring them entirely"?
 
The people who choose to respond inappropriately to that speech. The speaker, no matter how hateful, is not responsible for their reactions.
I agree that everyone is responsible for his own actions, even when those actions are reactions.

Speakers are completely responsible for their speech. Murderers are completely responsible for the murders they commit. Rioters are completely responsible for riots.

No passing the blame, and no excuses.
 
Is there not a middle ground between "Remaining completely silent no matter what offensive things are said" and "Making offensive things that are said illegal and censoring them entirely"?
Yes, it's called "having a discussion". Whether that discussion includes offensive things on both sides or only on one side depends mostly on character.
 
Whether it is Salman Rushdie's book, some cartoons, or a crap movie put out by a Dutch politician, the REACTION is the crime, not the content.


Except that incitement itself can be a crime, too. I can't imagine that this film was created without knowing how Muslims tend to react to such insults.

And despite the supposed lies told by the imams, I don't see the delayed reaction as a good reason to absolve the creator of this film. I have to accept the possibility that very few people in the Middle East even knew about this film. I certainly didn't, and I'm an American living in America.

Creating this film, especially if it's full of inaccuracies as others have said, has a very obvious malicious intent. Knowledge that violent protests would be the likely reaction to the film should be considered when evaluating the level of blame the creator has in the outcome.

I'm not suggesting we all live in fear of Islam or end free speech; I'm suggesting that folks just stop being ********.
 
Last edited:
I didn't say "demonize". I said "blame".
So? :boggled: The point's the same.


Except you mischaracterized the second instance. The cleric didn't "drum up fervor". He exhorted his followers to violence, which is exactly the line I said has been drawn between speech and incitement for a century.

That imam, like the white supremacist in your example are guilty of inciting violence and are not protected by principles of free speech. Jones and O'Reilly are. And rightfully so, as much as you don't like it and would like to search for some sort of nuance so you can blame Jones and O'Reilly for other people's actions.
How do you know what the cleric told his followers? Were you there and you speak Arabic? What's your source for that imagined evidence?

You need to stop inserting what I like, don't like, want to blame, and want to search for a nuance to blame others. You have no clue what other people think. All you have is what they write.

Answer the question: So, are you are certain your opinion, whatever it is on these 4 men, is clear, absolute and any opinion that disagrees with you just can't see the obvious?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom