Merged U.S. ambassador to Libya, 3 others killed in rocket attack, witness says

<snip>
Marksman says the cleric "lied" to incite the riot. But the film's producer said he intended to film to be hateful against Islam. From the CBS/AP article: I haven't read enough yet on Terry Jones' involvement in the film to comment. Clearly he is as hate inciting as the Islamic clerics. They are on the same level.

I'm not sure I'm totally with you on that statement, SG. While I find it rather distasteful to offer any sort of excuse for Terry Jones, you can apply your same logic to this situation.

An Imam in (insert your favorite Islamic backwater country here) knows full well that if he incites hate among his followers, there will be violence & people will die. Terry Jones is at least one step further removed from that culpability. His own FOLLOWERS are (not yet) engaging in the violence & killing. The violence & killing his particular brand of hatred incites will be directed back on TJ's followers, from the Muslims.

So TJ is definitely an asshat. But I don't put him on the same 'level' of vileness as extremist Muslim imams.

I really object to these types of movies, because they generally are done in some attempt to justify / raise the believability factor of another set of fairy tales, at the expense of another set. I would far prefer it if an atheist would produce an insulting move to all major religions - THAT is something I would go and see.
 
...Whether it is Salman Rushdie's book, some cartoons, or a crap movie put out by a Dutch politician, the REACTION is the crime, not the content....
I agree with you. The question for me is just where to draw the line on where the reaction started.

Rushdie, clearly an author, wrote a legitimate book. I don't put him in the inciting category anymore than the Dutch cartoonist (political cartoons that piss people off are in a unique category).

But the filmmaker here wanted to create hate. You could argue, that's still too far from the action. It might be a legitimate argument. Then you have this idiot, Jones who wanted 15 minutes of fame by burning a Koran. He knew it could cause riots and people could be killed. Does he differ from the cleric who incited the riots over the movie trailer? Is the cleric part of the "reaction", or just the mob? This is where it gets muddy for me.
 
The diffeeence that has been accepted for more than a century is that "Islam is a horrible religion that condones pedophilia" while untrue, is free speech even if you know it will anger people prone to riot. While saying "Americans should be punished for allowing this film toexist" even if the facts are true, is incitement that is not protected. I think that is the right line to draw.

The rioteea did not believe the film to be accurate. The film deceived nobody. The rioters chose to riot and murder becuase of.lies the imams told. The rioters are responsible. The imams share responsibility. The filmmaker does not. Nor does Youtube, which made it possible for the imams even to learn about it. (Certainly, if Jones is to blame, then Youtube is as well.)
 
It's a dilemma even if there are lots of differences between shouting fire in a crowded theater, drawing a cartoon image of Mohammed, burning a Koran to get attention, and making a hate speech or film against a group.

It's been decided the fire call crosses the line. And a political cartoon surely is free speech.

But the other two examples, and one should include the cleric who riled a few radicals up over the film, are extremists pissing off other extremists. Innocent people suffered the consequences. This is a bit more tricky.

I lean toward ignoring the free speech aspects here and look at the inciting a riot issue. I get it our culture says the film is free speech. So was the cleric who incited the rioting also exercising free speech? We convicted a couple of white supremacists for inciting murder in their sermons.

Here, let me explain it for you:

OK Speech:
"These guys suck"

Not OK Speech:
"Kill these guys"

Simple really.
 
.
The "Reverend" Terry Jones should get all the recognition/prosecution his hateful products incite.
Like Manson.

Granted, Jones is a POS who deserves to be sent to whatever Hell he believes in. On the other hand, burning embassies and killing ambassadors is not a reasonable response to speech that offends you. The cultural practices of one group of people are not the natural laws of the universe. The Muslim world must be made to understand that they do not have the right to define the limits of free speech of people living in other societies. It is wrong to encourage the idea that they do.
 
.
Exactly what did happen.
Manson didn't kill anyone himself, but he incited others to kill.

Specifically, Manson told them that words hidden in the song Helter-Skelter told him that people needed to be murdered.

So, going after the film-maker is a bit more like going after the Beatles. In this case, the imans in Libya and Egypt are the ones using the material to incite violence - they are the Manson analogues, not the film maker.
 
Specifically, Manson told them that words hidden in the song Helter-Skelter told him that people needed to be murdered.

So, going after the film-maker is a bit more like going after the Beatles.

Maybe if the song Helter-Skelter was actually about killing people, you'd have a point.
 
Except the film didn't exhort anybody to violence. It said mean things about their Prophet.

Manson didn't think the songs actually told him who to kill either.WP. He just interpreted the lyrics as if they were prophetic.

In this instance, the imams found something insulting and then actively lied about it to get people to riot. Had they just pointed out that there was an offensive youtube video, they might not have achieved the riots they wanted. So they told people it was slated for national release, with the aid or consent of Obama.

That seems to be quite analogous to Manson. He took some sort of vague lyrics and lied about them get his followers to commit murder. The filmmaker, as hateful as he is, is no more responsibly for the deaths in Benghazi than the Beatles are responsible for the deaths in California.
 
Stupid movies & the people who make stupid movies don't kill innocent US civilian public servants. Stupid people who can't figure out a more productive way to express their displeasure at a stupid movie kill innocent US civilian public servants.

I agree with almost everything you say. The problem, however, is that for them their actions are productive. They really can get what they want by doing such horrible things. Which says a lot about what it is that they want, but that's the ultimate problem here. Calling them stupid is rather beside the point, because it's not like they can be convinced to act differently if they could just be shown a better way to express themselves. They aren't interested in expressing themselves.
 
The diffeeence that has been accepted for more than a century is that "Islam is a horrible religion that condones pedophilia" while untrue, is free speech...

Here, let me explain it for you:

OK Speech:
"These guys suck"

Not OK Speech:
"Kill these guys"

Simple really.
The world is not so black and white and apparently that nuance in my post was missed by you both.
 
How many riots and murders do you suppose would ensue?
.
Zero, or none.
We've been dissing christianity for a couple thousand years, and within the past 300 we've come to accepting that people can do that, and not be killed.. Mostly.
Islam is at least 300 years, more like a 1000 years deficit to fix and to grow up to become suitable for the world.
 
The world is not so black and white and apparently that nuance in my post was missed by you both.
No, the world isn't black and white. But this issue, is pretty straightforward. You're just struggling to find a way to blame speech you don't like. But the whole point of freedom of speech is to protect unpopular speech. Once you eliminate that distinction, you eliminate the freedom.

I hate Terry Jones' message and the message of that movie. But he has every right to make it and, as long as he doesn't actively advocate violence, he shouldn't be blamed when other people choose to react violently to it.

Tolerating hateful speech makes people uneasy. I get that. That doesn't mean the intolerant people have a more nuanced worldview.

@I Ratant: Islam is over 1400 years old. Assuming religions have a natural rate of maturity -- a dubious proposition -- I guess we can look forward to their Enlightenment in... 400 more years? No thanks. They should join the cause of tolerance immediately and use the mistakes of prior religions to advance their maturity. Of course, I don't actually blame all of Islam. I only blame the actual rioters and the imams who spurred them on.
 
Last edited:
Granted, Jones is a POS who deserves to be sent to whatever Hell he believes in. On the other hand, burning embassies and killing ambassadors is not a reasonable response to speech that offends you. The cultural practices of one group of people are not the natural laws of the universe. The Muslim world must be made to understand that they do not have the right to define the limits of free speech of people living in other societies. It is wrong to encourage the idea that they do.
.
I'd love to see some way to dis-encourage rioting when anything in Islam is disrespected.
One step would be to not provoke them deliberately.
Another would be to educate them into a more tolerant acceptance of criticism that is meant to be helpful.
But the basic combination of Caesar and God without distinction in Islam makes that very difficult to accomplish.
 
Granted, Jones is a POS who deserves to be sent to whatever Hell he believes in. On the other hand, burning embassies and killing ambassadors is not a reasonable response to speech that offends you. The cultural practices of one group of people are not the natural laws of the universe. The Muslim world must be made to understand that they do not have the right to define the limits of free speech of people living in other societies. It is wrong to encourage the idea that they do.
.
Rioting and murder is reasonable to them... when they're in their Stone Age countries, and are incited to riot and murder.
I haven't heard of any similar responses in the real world about this.
Those smart enough and capable of leaving the Stone Age seem to appreciate the lack of control over their lives by the religious nuts they enjoy away from them.
 
No, the world isn't black and white. But this issue, is pretty straightforward. You're just struggling to find a way to blame speech you don't like. ....
That's your confirmation bias, not mine. I don't need to demonize speech I don't like. The speech speaks for itself.

So Jones burns a Koran knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A cleric drums up fervor over an anti-Islamic movie trailer knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A White Supremacist gives sermons and passes out literature encouraging murder which then happens.

Bill O'Reilly calls Dr Tiller a baby killer over and over on the public airwaves and Dr Tiller is then murdered by an incited nutjob.

So, are you are certain your opinion, whatever it is on these 4 men, is clear, absolute and any opinion that disagrees with you just can't see the obvious?
 
Last edited:
.
I'd love to see some way to dis-encourage rioting when anything in Islam is disrespected.
One step would be to not provoke them deliberately.
Another would be to educate them into a more tolerant acceptance of criticism that is meant to be helpful.
But the basic combination of Caesar and God without distinction in Islam makes that very difficult to accomplish.

The problem with the "not provoke them deliberately" part is that anything can be (and has been) seen as a provocation. Even the idea of trying to educate them into a more tolerant acceptance of criticism can be seen as a provocation. That's really what is going on here. Another culture is demanding that we limit our speech in accordance with their beliefs. What we have to do is make them understand that it will not work.
 
It has occurred to me that some Muslims seem immune to irony.

Actually that seems to be a common trait among radicals.

"How dare you call us reactionaries! We'll kill you for that!"
 
That's your confirmation bias, not mine. I don't need to demonize speech I don't like. The speech speaks for itself.

So Jones burns a Koran knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A cleric drums up fervor over an anti-Islamic movie trailer knowing full well it will incite a few riots.

A White Supremacist gives sermons and passes out literature encouraging murder which then happens.

Bill O'Reilly calls Dr Tiller a baby killer over and over on the public airwaves and Dr Tiller is then murdered by an incited nutjob.

So, are you are certain your opinion, whatever it is on these 4 men, is clear, absolute and any opinion that disagrees with you just can't see the obvious?

I can see that you obviously only support free speech when it is, in your opinion, "responsible" speech.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom