Merged U.S. ambassador to Libya, 3 others killed in rocket attack, witness says

Saying "You have no right to say that!" is much worse than saying "What you say has consequences."

No one here, AFAIK, has said these filmmakers do not have a right to say what they want about Islam. They are just pointing out that what these filmmakers say has very real consequences.

Equating it with inciting violence or riots -- a criminal offense -- goes further and does suggest that they have no right to say things. But I'll hope that is just a case of overstatement or unclear writing or me missing some contextual clues.
 
The people who choose to respond inappropriately to that speech. The speaker, no matter how hateful, is not responsible for their reactions.

I hope for your sake that if you're ever in a foreign country surrounded by scores of furious and ostensibly armed rioters demanding an explanation from you that you don't attempt to lecture them about how the world all needs to just be tolerant of offensive speech like America is.
 
Except that incitement itself can be a crime, too. I can't imagine that this film was created without knowing how Muslims tends to react to such insults.

Galileo had it coming. He knew how the Inquisition tended to react to outrageous heliocentric ideas!

He coulda shut up and lived a long, happy life. And not provoked the Church into looking like dolts. What a jerk!
 
Except that incitement itself can be a crime, too. I can't imagine that this film was created without knowing how Muslims tend to react to such insults.
It's time for Muslims to drag the troglodytes among them into the 21st century. If you're going to throw a tantrum every time someone says something you don't like, there are people who will be only too happy to say things you don't like, so your actions can demonstrate what they've been saying all along -- that Islam is a violent, hateful religion.

I'm not suggesting we all live in fear of Islam or end free speech; I'm suggesting that folks just stop being ********.
Or Muslims grow the **** up.
 
Equating it with inciting violence or riots -- a criminal offense -- goes further and does suggest that they have no right to say things. But I'll hope that is just a case of overstatement or unclear writing or me missing some contextual clues.

But those words did incite the violence and/or riots. It's a simple fact. Indeed, the same words have incited violence multiple times, historically, meaning that the speakers could not have been unaware of the consequences. I would say its reasonable to say that they fully anticipated those consequences. We can't simply choose to pretend that's not true in order to avoid making it sound like we're attacking "free speech".
 
But those words did incite the violence and/or riots. It's a simple fact. Indeed, the same words have incited violence multiple times, historically, meaning that the speakers could not have been unaware of the consequences. I would say its reasonable to say that they fully anticipated those consequences. We can't simply choose to pretend that's not true in order to avoid making it sound like we're attacking "free speech".
Free speech is too important to let a lot of lawless thugs control what can and cannot be said.
 
But those words did incite the violence and/or riots. It's a simple fact. Indeed, the same words have incited violence multiple times, historically, meaning that the speakers could not have been unaware of the consequences. I would say its reasonable to say that they fully anticipated those consequences. We can't simply choose to pretend that's not true in order to avoid making it sound like we're attacking "free speech".

But in every case, the violence was completely unjustified. To stop the speech is to implicitly accept that there are areas of politics/philosophy/religion of which we may not speak or question.

We wouldn't (I hope) accept that if it was the Inquisition threatening us, or a secular dictatorship... we shouldn't accept it from other areas either.
 
But in every case, the violence was completely unjustified. To stop the speech is to implicitly accept that there are areas of politics/philosophy/religion of which we may not speak or question.

We wouldn't (I hope) accept that if it was the Inquisition threatening us, or a secular dictatorship... we shouldn't accept it from other areas either.

So like the King of Siam, we allegorically now must continue to order executions because the English schoolteacher-lady said too loudly that we should not, and we don't want to look like we're under the schoolteacher-lady's thumb.
 
But those words did incite the violence and/or riots. It's a simple fact. Indeed, the same words have incited violence multiple times, historically, meaning that the speakers could not have been unaware of the consequences. I would say its reasonable to say that they fully anticipated those consequences. We can't simply choose to pretend that's not true in order to avoid making it sound like we're attacking "free speech".

Unfortunately, it is an assault on freedom of expression if we decide that you can say what you want, as long as it doesn't upset the delicate feelings of violent fanatics halfway around the world. It's easy enough to defend the principle of free speech when nothing's at stake, but if we want to have it in our society then we'll have to accept that it can be risky sometimes.
 
I agree that everyone is responsible for his own actions, even when those actions are reactions.
Great. Then the speaker's responsibility, assuming he did not engage in an incitement, ends as soon as someone also chooses to react.

Except that incitement itself can be a crime, too. I can't imagine that this film was created without knowing how Muslims tend to react to such insults.
That's not incitement. If a war protestor burns a flag knowing that people out there will be so incensed that they beat him up, he is not to blame for that beating. The person who chose to beat him up is solely to blame.

So? :boggled: The point's the same.
It's not the same. I chose "blame" specifically. It is an assignation of responsibility. You are trying to hold the filmmaker responsible for the reactions that others chose to engage in. He is not responsible for other people's choices.

How do you know what the cleric told his followers? Were you there and you speak Arabic? What's your source for that imagined evidence?
"Well first of all remember from the United States who is speaking with experience, our main enemies here are the Americans, they use their military against us. Then it is the Zionist, they use the media perception management. Then the Saudi Arabians who use their wealth and power and influence amongst Muslims... In other words when these people come out against Islam and us, we should choose our time and place of the battle. Therefore we should have institutions ready here inside the West and outside to challenge Zionism on our terms and in our way."
-Imam Abdul Alim Musa, of Libya, interviewed by the Iranian news service in the day after the attack about his involvement in planning and coordinating the riots

"Hours before the Benghazi attack, hundreds of mainly ultraconservative Islamist protesters in Egypt marched to the U.S. Embassy in downtown Cairo, gathering outside its walls and chanting against the movie and the U.S."
-CBS News

So, are you are certain your opinion, whatever it is on these 4 men, is clear, absolute and any opinion that disagrees with you just can't see the obvious?
I am saying that the line between incitement and speech is clear and has been for a century. The fact that you want there to be ambiguity doesn't create ambiguity.

I hope for your sake that if you're ever in a foreign country surrounded by scores of furious and ostensibly armed rioters demanding an explanation from you that you don't attempt to lecture them about how the world all needs to just be tolerant of offensive speech like America is.
Why on Earth would you think I would do something like that?
 
We, the lawful non-thug people, however, can control what we say.

So instead of an external censor, we "must" apply an internal censor - or suffer the consequences?


(Don't get me wrong, I believe in not being gratuitously offensive. But I also... and more strongly... believe that I don't get to make a call on what is "gratuitously offensive" and that the limits of public discourse should not be influenced by threats of violence).
 
Unfortunately, it is an assault on freedom of expression if we decide that you can say what you want, as long as it doesn't upset the delicate feelings of violent fanatics halfway around the world. It's easy enough to defend the principle of free speech when nothing's at stake, but if we want to have it in our society then we'll have to accept that it can be risky sometimes.

Nobody said that anybody couldn't say anything.
 
I don't get the objections.

Yes, speech has consequences. This is trivially true. The question is that such a deepity leaves the unanswered statement "and ....". Some people are filling in their head that we should censor free speech. Some are trying to say there should be a middle ground but don't elaborate.

So please elaborate.


If I tell my wife she looks bad in an outfit, that has obvious consequences. Should I be blamed if she decides to grab a gun and shoot me? After all I did incite by saying yes. Would her action be disproportional? What if I was more abusive with my speech? Is she justified at any point to kill me? If yes, why?
 
Last edited:
So like the King of Siam, we allegorically now must continue to order executions because the English schoolteacher-lady said too loudly that we should not, and we don't want to look like we're under the schoolteacher-lady's thumb.
We're not ordering executions. We're protecting free speech.

The alternative is limiting what free citizens can say, and fining them or jailing them if they say something they shouldn't. I prefer the current response, when speech is met by more speech.

"Here's my movie."

"I don't like your movie."
 
It's time for Muslims to drag the troglodytes among them into the 21st century. If you're going to throw a tantrum every time someone says something you don't like [...]


We in the "civilized world" throw tantrums all the time. Have you watched any of the cable news shows in first-world nations lately? From protests, to pundits reacting emotionally, to people shooting other people over what most of us would consider pathetic reasons, most of us handle disagreement terribly.

If you're going to throw a tantrum every time someone says something you don't like there are people who will be only too happy to say things you don't like, so your actions can demonstrate what they've been saying all along -- that Islam is a violent, hateful religion.


The "proving my point" aspect of the situation isn't lost on me. It's frustratingly facepalm-worthy. However, antagonizing someone you know to have anger management issues just to remind others that this person has anger management issues is hardly a noble or blameless endeavor.
 
Last edited:
Possibly the most interesting comment I've seen so far on all of this is from a distinctly right-of-center blog where the author makes the following comment after watching the film:

RETHINK: the supposed purpose of the movie was to educate people about Mohammad. But it seems reasonably clear that the purpose was to annoy Muslims.
(Bolding Mine)

http://up-ship.com/blog/?p=16522
 
So instead of an external censor, we "must" apply an internal censor - or suffer the consequences?

No; you're perfectly allowed to say what you want and then try to separate yourself from the direct consequences.

But no, you don't get to demand that nobody says anything to remind you that when you say these particular things, people will die because of it. Of course, you are perfectly free to respond with "that's not the way it should be" or "that's not my problem" or "I really don't care" and say it anyway; that's your choice.

But people will die if you make that choice. Live with it.
 
I prefer the current response, when speech is met by more speech.

"Here's my movie."

"I don't like your movie."


In most modern countries you can be taken to court by others for the things you say, because the things you say can have very real effects. Free speech literalists seem to either ignore this fact or don't see it as all that important.

"You raped me."
"No I didn't."

What's wrong? They're just words...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom