Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
My son needs a root canal and the dentist wants $1300 up front. In America that isn't "health care", yet it directly effects his health.

You don't say the price is a problem, but if it is most university dental schools have low-cost clinics where advanced students perform procedures under close supervision. Quality is generally considered pretty good because a lot of eyes are watching.
 
There was alrrerady insurance for everybody before Obamacare, they just had to pay for it. That'll be the new plan.

No. Insurers wouldn't sell policies to people with pre-existing conditions.
 
ahhh, there's the rub. In the Canadian province of Ontario dental procedures are also not covered, UNLESS, there is a danger to life involved. Not sure if root canal qualifies.

But they would pull it if need be, wouldn't they? Even if that's the case, if I didn't have to pay $700 a month of healthcare I could probably shrug my shoulders at the bill. It's not going to bankrupt me now, but I think it's entirely too much for 45 minutes of work.

Not that I expect our healthcare would completely alleviate me of any form of monthly bill, obviously there would be an increase in taxes. That being said, even $200 more per paycheck in taxes would put extra money in my pocket. That doesn't include any of the bonuses of not having a doctor bill.

You don't say the price is a problem, but if it is most university dental schools have low-cost clinics where advanced students perform procedures under close supervision. Quality is generally considered pretty good because a lot of eyes are watching.

Yeah, we don't really have that option where I live. North Dakota isn't well known for our dental schools. I could check and see if the University of North Dakota does something like that, but even that's a pain.
 
Please give us the full explanation then.

I'll pass. The level of discourse here is going downhill fast, and I think it's long past time to invest elsewhere. I guess it's one of the downsides of Trump getting elected. At first, it was quite enjoyable to see liberal heads explode. Now it's just depressing.
 
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-obamacare-idUSKBN15005C

The ACA requires you have health insurance.

Remember the cries of "SOCIALISM!"

Looks like Mr. Trump might be a socialist as well.

Trump vows 'insurance for everybody' in replacing Obamacare.

"“We’re going to have insurance for everybody,” Trump said. “There was a philosophy in some circles that if you can’t pay for it, you don’t get it. That’s not going to happen with us.” Mr. Trump said.
That's a good idea,

it's from Trump?

.........****..need to reassess........
 
To Trump, explaining himself to the media is torture. The extent to which Donald Trump believes anything he says to the press and/or intends to actually make it policy is the same as the extent to which a torture victim actually committed whatever crime he confesses to.

Besides, the US is currently being driven by Paul Ryan. Trump will have as much power over policy as Maggie does playing with her steering wheel during the credits of the Simpsons.
 
The point is that the U.S spends enormous amount of money on health care now. Plans for a single-payer system would transfer the money now being spent on insurance premiums, deductibles and co-pays, uncompensated care, administrative expenses, etc. to the public purse. If your taxes went up to pay for Medicare-for-All or something like that, but you no longer had to pay insurance premiums or big deductibles, would it really be more money, and would you be better off or worse?

But they don't think about that. "Oh, may taxes will go up!" I mean, this could mean taxes go up $5000/year! How awful!

Of course, that comes with a savings of maybe $6000 in premiums and other costs, but that doesn't matter, just don't raise taxes.
 
I think what's changed, and what will remain changed, is the idea that health insurance is the proper target, not just for federal oversight, but for federal policy - policy directed at shaping the landscape. That's a distinct difference from a few decades ago. Health insurance has become "a thing."
 
I love how people say Trump can't provide health-care for everyone. These are the same naysayers who said he "couldn't" win. He's going to prove so many of you wrong again and again and again that eventually you're going to get tired of being proven wrong.
Different things. It was not that hard to win as these presidencies go back and forth, and there was no other Republican who had a fan base.

Being president is entirely different. Watch a few episodes of West Wing.

We have a record of Trump saying pretty much anything so until there is a concrete plan there is nothing.

Trump healthcare and Trump tax plan are not compatible.
 
Last edited:
I'll pass. The level of discourse here is going downhill fast, and I think it's long past time to invest elsewhere. I guess it's one of the downsides of Trump getting elected. At first, it was quite enjoyable to see liberal heads explode. Now it's just depressing.

In other word you don't want to back up your claim. I am not impressed, neither am I surprised.
 
dental is also not covered in Australia, except for certain conditions.
But what happens to people with no insurance? what on earth do you do?
 
dental is also not covered in Australia, except for certain conditions.
But what happens to people with no insurance? what on earth do you do?

Same thing you do - we do without.

In any of these systems there is a ceiling, above which no one will pay the bill. If the patient has the resources and the will, they can pay. If they don't have the money, they go without.

The difference is that, in a publicly funded program, those limits extend equally to all patients (varying, perhaps by condition or medical judgements), while in a looser system the limits are distributed throughout the system - I may hit mine before you hit yours and vice versa.

An example will help illustrate this: Suppose you are prescribed a drug that comes in a brand named version and a generic. The publicly funded plan may only pay for the generic. That's a limit. In the US, some plans may pay for the brand and some only for the generic. Presumably, any patient may pay the higher price and buy the brand name drug. Some can't afford it. There are still limits, but they vary by circumstances.
 
dental is also not covered in Australia, except for certain conditions.
But what happens to people with no insurance? what on earth do you do?

Are you talking about just dental insurance, or medical insurance too? In the U.S., at least, dental insurance isn't that great a deal. Coverage limits are pretty low. People who don't have dental insurance or money to pay the bills usually end up not getting routine cleanings or services for minor issues, then having teeth pulled when more expensive treatments might have saved them.

People who don't have medical insurance often ignore problems as long as possible, then try to find charity care, or they go to emergency rooms, or they put care on plastic and wreck their credit when they're not able to pay. Often they die from problems that might have been controlled with earlier care. That's something the ACA was intended to solve.

This operation was originally created to deliver free care in third-world countries. Then they found out that the demand in the U.S. was so great that they had to do many of their clinics here.
https://ramusa.org/
http://www.newsweek.com/remote-area...ricas-uninsured-go-through-health-care-287507
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom