Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Access is there, but you still have to pay for it. My daughter went to the ER last year, they did some tests, she was released in 3 hours. The bill was $5500.

ERs are obligated to provide stabilizing care regardless of ability to pay.

That doesn't mean they won't bill you. Asking for ER care to be free to everyone is different from asking that ER care be available to everyone.
 
Sure it does - you pull the plug when all the patient's assets have been stripped.

In a capitalist system you need to make money to survive. If you run out of money then you are dead, and there's a limited supply so... people don't become doctors to help others, they do it because doctors make more money. Why do they make more money? Because sick people will give up all their money to avoid dying. There is nothing anomalous about this - it's how Capitalism works!

The only alternative is Socialism, but that is un-American so it is no solution. The answer is for everyone to become a doctor, then we can all make enough money to pay for our own healthcare. So what should Republicans do to replace Obamacare? Simply eliminate all regulations that prevent anyone from becoming a doctor!

This site really needs a like button.

As for the bit I bolded, didn't some republican on here complain about licenses to work the other day but not name the ones so hated?
Perhaps this is what they alluded to.
 
ERs are obligated to provide stabilizing care regardless of ability to pay.

That doesn't mean they won't bill you. Asking for ER care to be free to everyone is different from asking that ER care be available to everyone.

And it's the difference between some people losing their homes because of an accident.
 
I wonder what Stephen Hawking's lifetime expenses have been?

Or how well he would have fared if he had been an American?

I've seen that little ****** roll around here like he owns the place. Go back to England! And brush your teeth!!
 
ERs are obligated to provide stabilizing care regardless of ability to pay.

That doesn't mean they won't bill you. Asking for ER care to be free to everyone is different from asking that ER care be available to everyone.

I did not want it to be free but a single payer type of service you woukd pay monthly for. Once you are stable you have some health options. Many problems can be treated as outpatient service. When you are dead you have no options. You would have a card like a social security card that would cover all ER for all US residents or students with visa on a 1 year basis.
 
This site really needs a like button.

As for the bit I bolded, didn't some republican on here complain about licenses to work the other day but not name the ones so hated?
Perhaps this is what they alluded to.

If Ryan and co. are serious about freedom and personal responsiblility, this is exactly the solution. Let the free market sort out who's good enough to practice and how much they can charge. I'll save tons by getting treatment from some guy at the mall who's watched some medical videos on youtube and be laughing all the way to the bank.
 
Access is there, but you still have to pay for it. My daughter went to the ER last year, they did some tests, she was released in 3 hours. The bill was $5500.

But if you have health insurance, the insurer paid most of the bill, probably at a discounted rate, right? If you don't have insurance and got hit with a full retail bill, that's really the issue, isn't it? Under a Medicare-for-All single payer system, everybody's basic care, including ER visits, would be covered, paid for by a tax that would replace insurance premiums.
 
And it's the difference between some people losing their homes because of an accident.

Yes it is.

That's why we need a different discussion. Simply saying that ERs should be accessible to everyone doesn't accomplish anything. Accessibility isn't the issue - affordability is. Affordability is a barrier to care, but not a barrier to accessibility.

It's the cost of care that needs to be looked at. Not the cost of insurance, and not accessibility. It's the actual underlying cost of services that needs the most attention in my opinion.
 
I did not want it to be free but a single payer type of service you woukd pay monthly for. Once you are stable you have some health options. Many problems can be treated as outpatient service. When you are dead you have no options. You would have a card like a social security card that would cover all ER for all US residents or students with visa on a 1 year basis.

Again, ER isn't sufficient. ER doesn't provide outpatient coverage, they provide stabilization for emergency conditions. We need a solution that addresses a broad spectrum of treatments, not only emergency care.
 
If Ryan and co. are serious about freedom and personal responsiblility, this is exactly the solution. Let the free market sort out who's good enough to practice and how much they can charge. I'll save tons by getting treatment from some guy at the mall who's watched some medical videos on youtube and be laughing all the way to the bank.

It's a horrible idea :(
 
Yes it is.

That's why we need a different discussion. Simply saying that ERs should be accessible to everyone doesn't accomplish anything. Accessibility isn't the issue - affordability is. Affordability is a barrier to care, but not a barrier to accessibility.

It's the cost of care that needs to be looked at. Not the cost of insurance, and not accessibility. It's the actual underlying cost of services that needs the most attention in my opinion.



They're fairly intertwined, I think, but mostly, I'd agree. I think doctors in the US are probably grossly overpaid*. Add into that that you run every test you can or risk litigation and the enormous admin costs brought about by actually having to have a decline process and generally deal with insurance companies and it's all a bit of a mess.





*Although mostly they need to be to be able to keep up the payments on their education they paid a fortune for.
 
They're fairly intertwined, I think, but mostly, I'd agree. I think doctors in the US are probably grossly overpaid*. Add into that that you run every test you can or risk litigation and the enormous admin costs brought about by actually having to have a decline process and generally deal with insurance companies and it's all a bit of a mess.





*Although mostly they need to be to be able to keep up the payments on their education they paid a fortune for.

*** And their brand new Mercedes and their 4000 sf house in a gated community and their membership fees for the highly exclusive country club so they can golf 3 days a week ;)

Obviously not every doctor... but an awful lot of them. It's not like most docs are just scraping by because of their crippling educational debt. They're in the same boat I am: I had a lot of debt from college, but it got me a very well-paying job, so the $400+ per month going to pay off my student loans just isn't that big a deal. I don't really have much sympathy for the cost of a medical degree, given the income level that is a result of that investment.
 
*** And their brand new Mercedes and their 4000 sf house in a gated community and their membership fees for the highly exclusive country club so they can golf 3 days a week ;)

Obviously not every doctor... but an awful lot of them. It's not like most docs are just scraping by because of their crippling educational debt. They're in the same boat I am: I had a lot of debt from college, but it got me a very well-paying job, so the $400+ per month going to pay off my student loans just isn't that big a deal. I don't really have much sympathy for the cost of a medical degree, given the income level that is a result of that investment.


Your point is well taken. I suspect they'd argue that they deserve large rewards for taking a massive risk (All that debt without the diploma to back it up would pretty much end one's life prospects, I would guess?) and the massive amount of work they've had to do to end up a doctor.

Whether the above is a valid argument I don't know.

Any solution one implements is going to be opposed at every turn by those who have already climbed the mountain.
 
It's a horrible idea :(

It would be the wrong kind of fun, I'll grant that.
On a more serous note along similar lines, I've heard it suggested that a certain amount of medical work that is currently done by doctors could be done by less expensive medical professionals (nurse-practitioners, nurses, physician's assistants and such) without significantly damaging the quality of patient care. Sounds reasonable to me, but I just don't know enough about the industry to know if it really makes sense.
 
Yes it is.

That's why we need a different discussion. Simply saying that ERs should be accessible to everyone doesn't accomplish anything. Accessibility isn't the issue - affordability is. Affordability is a barrier to care, but not a barrier to accessibility.

It's the cost of care that needs to be looked at. Not the cost of insurance, and not accessibility. It's the actual underlying cost of services that needs the most attention in my opinion.

Affordability goes hand in hand with accessibility.
 
It would be the wrong kind of fun, I'll grant that.
On a more serous note along similar lines, I've heard it suggested that a certain amount of medical work that is currently done by doctors could be done by less expensive medical professionals (nurse-practitioners, nurses, physician's assistants and such) without significantly damaging the quality of patient care. Sounds reasonable to me, but I just don't know enough about the industry to know if it really makes sense.

It's absolultey true that much of the work could be done by nurses or PAs... it's also true that there's a lot of industry opposition to that. Lots from doctors, some from insurance companies. I can only speak very broadly to the insurance side, as it's not my area of expertise. My understanding is that it gets complicated when the insurer is trying to balance their obligation to the safety and quality of care that is being accessed by their policyholders against the cost being charged to their policyholders. When there are doctors in the mix opposing that shift and arguing that the quality of care might suffer and that the risk to the patient is too great, it becomes a really difficult position.

Of course, my knowledge on this is only from within the insurance industry. And since it's not my particular area, I'm likely to be missing many other elements of the issue. Please assume that my response is both incomplete and likely to reflect some industry bias.
 
Not that I want to see our friend EC out on the street, but the fact that we have this massive health insurance industry in the US that eclipses similar industries in other western nations is our biggest problem. People don't need health insurance, they need health care.

Obamacare's bigger fault was in not offering a medicare for all option alongside the insurance options. We need to take out the middle man.
 
Not that I want to see our friend EC out on the street, but the fact that we have this massive health insurance industry in the US that eclipses similar industries in other western nations is our biggest problem. People don't need health insurance, they need health care.

Obamacare's bigger fault was in not offering a medicare for all option alongside the insurance options. We need to take out the middle man.

Even at the risk of my career, I happen to agree.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom