Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Holy ****! Leaked report suggests millions could lose coverage under GOP health proposal.

The report estimates what would happen in a hypothetical state with 300,000 people in the individual market that has also expanded Medicaid. In the individual market, enrollment would fall 30 percent and 90,000 people would become uninsured.

An additional 115,000 people in that hypothetical state may also lose coverage because they are enrolled in Medicaid and cannot find an affordable private plan.

The report estimates that coverage declines would be even higher in states that did not expand Medicaid — largely those run by Republican governors. There, the report presents an example of a state with 235,000 in the individual market. It estimates that coverage would decline by 120,000 people, about 50 percent.

:eye-poppi

Gotta get those tax cuts for the rich.
 
Here we ask our insurance company if it is covered. They either allow or deny the procedure with almost no insight into why. Most normal stuff is covered most of the time. If it is denied the patient can appeal the decision within the insurance company if the doctor is willing to go to bat for them and say it is necessary. If it is still denied I would assume you go to arbitration. I don't think these cases often make it into court because the insurance companies don't want them to.


Interestingly, some doctors make the case that a high percentage of medical procedures don't really help the patient and may well cause harm, even death:
http://www.theatlantic.com/please-s...ence-says-no-but-doctors-say-yes/517368/#seen
 
Interestingly, some doctors make the case that a high percentage of medical procedures don't really help the patient and may well cause harm, even death:
http://www.theatlantic.com/please-s...ence-says-no-but-doctors-say-yes/517368/#seen
From that Atlantic article, one of the most pertinent quotes:
They would never know they had a tear if not for medical imaging, but once they have the imaging, they may well end up having surgery that doesn’t work for a problem they don’t have.
Patients who had sham surgery and physical therapy did just as well as patients who only had physical therapy.

The imaging is an issue, I just went through this with my 92-year-old mom who was on the bubble for needing a stint (straw-like devices that prop open arteries). I authorized it and made sure the hospital had her living will on file. It might have done her no good.

There is one stint she got that seemed very effective and that was to a renal artery. It dramatically reduced her blood pressure. But per the article, that didn't necessarily make her healthier. Bodies are complicated organic systems. Blood vessels aren't faucets. Bones aren't just scaffolding. Things that seem to make intuitive sense don't necessarily improve health.
 
That article was incredibly disturbing. My guy at the mall with some YouTube and Wikipedia training scenario is starting to look more reasonable.

Chances are your guy at the mall wouldn't attempt heart surgery, and you'd likely be better off for it.
 
My son needs a root canal and the dentist wants $1300 up front. In America that isn't "health care", yet it directly effects his health.

I'm in Canada 🇨🇦 ... poster boy of free Health Care ... I was eating hard candy from my kids Halloween treats on All Hallows' Eve' .. cracked an old repaired molar (about one fourth of the tooth on the distal side is missing, second tooth from the back, on my left side)

It's almost March and it's not fixed yet ... have to save up cash as dental work is not covered here for working families (have to be on welfare for free dental care)

I also pay for all my prescription drugs, three different concoctions to keep my blood pressure out of the stratosphere, that's also not covered here, unless you're old or on welfare.
 
The Obamacare repeal is dying a slow, conservative death.

Two prominent House conservatives said Monday that they would vote against a draft of the Republican Obamacare repeal bill that was leaked last week, presenting a serious roadblock to the GOP's increasingly complicated efforts to dismantle the Affordable Care Act.

Republican Rep. Mark Meadows, the chairman of the conservative House Freedom Caucus, told CNN on Monday that he cannot support a draft of the GOP Obamacare repeal bill unless substantial changes are made.
Hours later, Rep. Mark Walker, the chairman of the Republican Study Committee, announced that he, too, could not support the leaked version of the legislation.

The comments come as top House Republicans are preparing to unveil legislation to repeal major portions of Obamacare and are struggling to bridge deep divisions within their own conference.
 
Trump just realized that the health care issue is complex.....projects that "no one knew."
 

But please note that their objections aren't that millions of Americans in the direst need will lose their health insurance but rather that the provisions are far too generous:

Meadows told CNN that what is unacceptable to him are the refundable tax credits included in the draft of the bill. Those tax credits, the North Carolina congressman said, are nothing short of an "entitlement program."
 
But please note that their objections aren't that millions of Americans in the direst need will lose their health insurance but rather that the provisions are far too generous:
Tax cuts are for the rich, what's the point of giving the less well off say 10 bucks a week? That won't even buy a well done steak!
 
Tax cuts are for the rich, what's the point of giving the less well off say 10 bucks a week? That won't even buy a well done steak!

'Less well off "people should not eat steak ... it's too expensive for their "income'
 
My impression of UHC countries is that they evaluate a treatment and when and how it should be administered. Then that evaluation applies to everyone equally. So, if the patient falls into these guidelines then it is determined that treatment X would be an effective treatment, but if patient does not fall within the guidelines then treatment X would not be considered effective.

I could be completely wrong, since I'm not in any way associated with medicine or medical policy.

But that doesn't fit her narrative so she is ignoring what life time maximums really mean by changing it to a cost benefit analysis of a particular treatment.
 
I don't understand your post. The snippet of discussion here was specifically about lifetime maximums.

No you moved the goalpost from life time maximums to specific cost benefit analysis of one condition. You totally ignored past expenditures(ie the things that would add up to a lifetime maximum) in your discussion of if a treatment would be administered to save a life or not.
 
Not that I want to see our friend EC out on the street, but the fact that we have this massive health insurance industry in the US that eclipses similar industries in other western nations is our biggest problem. People don't need health insurance, they need health care.

Obamacare's bigger fault was in not offering a medicare for all option alongside the insurance options. We need to take out the middle man.

It is too big to fix. Think of all the people who would be put out of work. We need to view it as the massive jobs program that it really is. Tons of white collar make work jobs.
 
Tax cuts are for the rich, what's the point of giving the less well off say 10 bucks a week? That won't even buy a well done steak!

At least they have ketchup to make it almost as if they are eating a dry aged well done steak.
 
:rolleyes: Nope, nobody knows that!

There is really no way they could know.

He really had to dig into it to find out. Glad he didn't do that before the election, he may have had to employ a more nuanced take on the situation than "Repeal Obamacare!" and "Lock her up!"
 
There is really no way they could know.

He really had to dig into it to find out. Glad he didn't do that before the election, he may have had to employ a more nuanced take on the situation than "Repeal Obamacare!" and "Lock her up!"

How could he know that Obama made ACA an extra complicated disaster, leaving him a total super mess. Obama is after him. Best to lock him up too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom