Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
It would be the wrong kind of fun, I'll grant that.
On a more serous note along similar lines, I've heard it suggested that a certain amount of medical work that is currently done by doctors could be done by less expensive medical professionals (nurse-practitioners, nurses, physician's assistants and such) without significantly damaging the quality of patient care. Sounds reasonable to me, but I just don't know enough about the industry to know if it really makes sense.

Actually they may do it better as they are more likely to follow guidelines.

Conversely in the US anaesthetics are often given by nurses, something always done by physicians in the UK (and any suggestion that they could be made redundant and replaced by nurses is not popular with anaesthetists!).

The NHS has a pay structure that grades pay by responsibility, skills etc. So nurses like to do doctor-like jobs as they are well paid. Doctors are excluded from that pay structure because it would mean they would need be paid more than they already are!
 
I imagine any country with UHC has a system to limit expenditure. It simply has to happen in any reasonable system.

https://www.nice.org.uk/

Agreed, though this is what the Republicans call death panels.

If health care is supposed to be paid for from a third party, whether public or private, in the end we have to make choices about how much money is too much for the benefit. That's how it goes.
 
Agreed, though this is what the Republicans call death panels.

If health care is supposed to be paid for from a third party, whether public or private, in the end we have to make choices about how much money is too much for the benefit. That's how it goes.
Called, back when it was Obama's plan. The new death panels will be "budgetary review boards."
 
A dog can't choose it's food; they eat what's available. Dogs in the wild aren't fat and I don't think it's possible for wild dogs to get fat.
"Dogs in the wild" is kind of an oxymoron, IMO. Coyotes and wolves aren't fat. Dogs are domesticated creatures. People eat what's available too. But availability has gone through the roof.

Wild humans, on the other hand . . . well, we see where we are now. Humans have choices. We choose to make our lives easier so we don't have to move around much to get things done and we are capable of creating food that is tasty.
I could be doing my laundry on a washboard with soap made of lye and bacon fat, true. I could chop the wood to build the fire to heat the water, but modern detergents mean the water doesn't need to be hot. I could at least put it on the line instead of tossing it in the dryer, but why? If evolution has favored conserving our energy, many if not most Americans face an uphill battle to lose weight. If there's famine, people carrying extra fat have an edge. Famines have been the norm around the world and through history.

Those are our choices.
Are they, though? People are animals too. There's no evolved off-switch (AFAIK). People who binged while they could survived to breed. Evolution favors binging on fat, salt, refined carbs while we can. Middle age barely existed.

We have information, and can act on it, but overweight people can still feel famished, and can easily feel too fatigued to exercise. That's why I mentioned barometric surgery: It builds discomfort into overeating.

I don't read the way the article uses the word "environment" as meaning some natural habitat we have no choice but to succumb to. We do have choice, we just make bad ones.
It's not a natural habitat, but humans (Americans, but others) have created an environment that might as well be our natural habitat if that's all we've ever known. How many fat parents have fat kids? Is that the kids' fault?

Mike Pence agrees with you on the responsibility thing, and maybe it's better to just cut everyone loose. If we make the right choices we won't get sick. Aging, for example, is a terrible habit.
 
Last edited:
However I think real data would be better than our somewhat abstract philosophizing. Anecdotes not so much.
 
My impression of UHC countries is that they evaluate a treatment and when and how it should be administered. Then that evaluation applies to everyone equally. So, if the patient falls into these guidelines then it is determined that treatment X would be an effective treatment, but if patient does not fall within the guidelines then treatment X would not be considered effective.

I could be completely wrong, since I'm not in any way associated with medicine or medical policy.

In the UK NICE has a role in determining which treatments are worth paying for.

There is also a judgement based on Quality of life adjusted life years. trying to make the inevitable rationing as fair as possible.
 
In the UK NICE has a role in determining which treatments are worth paying for.

There is also a judgement based on Quality of life adjusted life years. trying to make the inevitable rationing as fair as possible.

That's what I thought, but I don't know the specifics, so I didn't want to venture too deep.

The point is that the determinations aren't made on a case by case basis (is this person worth this treatment) but on a treatment by treatment basis (when is this treatment worth the expense, if ever).
 
I don't know how it works in other countries, though
 
I don't know how it works in other countries, though

Here we ask our insurance company if it is covered. They either allow or deny the procedure with almost no insight into why. Most normal stuff is covered most of the time. If it is denied the patient can appeal the decision within the insurance company if the doctor is willing to go to bat for them and say it is necessary. If it is still denied I would assume you go to arbitration. I don't think these cases often make it into court because the insurance companies don't want them to.
 
That's what I thought, but I don't know the specifics, so I didn't want to venture too deep.

The point is that the determinations aren't made on a case by case basis (is this person worth this treatment) but on a treatment by treatment basis (when is this treatment worth the expense, if ever).

In principle what you say is true. In practice there remains one doctor and the patient in front of her. Excepting very expensive treatments, the doctor can give any treatment. They may be queried on it, but if there is some justification, e.g. the patient will not take any blue tablet, then it will go through.

Most of NICE guidance is more about what the health service should supply, e.g. that hospitals should have thrombolytic service for patients presenting within four hours of a stroke. This then means having an infrastructure of 24 hour emergency brain scans and people to report them. This may mean the scan reported at a neuroscience centre or diverting the patients to the neuroscience centre (depending on time for transfer). The major cost here is not the clot buster drug, but the infra structure. Some individuals will do very well, some will be killed by the treatment, so the QUALY is an average for a population, not an individual gain.

FWIW NICE defines cost effective treatment as < £20,000 per QUALY, and >£30,000 as not cost effective. There is obvious wiggle room. A Qualy is a quality adjusted life year, so if a treatment gives you one year of perfect life that is a QUALY, two years but with significant disability might be a QUALY.

Average expenditure per person on the NHS is about £2,100 / year.

Although much of the headlines focus on NICE saying a new cancer treatment is too expensive (which usually results in a back room deal; the NHS is a big purchaser, and the cost of production of a drug is low, the real cost is the investment in getting to market; so any sale is worthwhile), what is missed is the permissive drive from NICE saying that certain things must be delivered. NICE also sets standards that services should achieve.
 
In principle what you say is true. In practice there remains one doctor and the patient in front of her. Excepting very expensive treatments, the doctor can give any treatment. They may be queried on it, but if there is some justification, e.g. the patient will not take any blue tablet, then it will go through.

Most of NICE guidance is more about what the health service should supply, e.g. that hospitals should have thrombolytic service for patients presenting within four hours of a stroke. This then means having an infrastructure of 24 hour emergency brain scans and people to report them. This may mean the scan reported at a neuroscience centre or diverting the patients to the neuroscience centre (depending on time for transfer). The major cost here is not the clot buster drug, but the infra structure. Some individuals will do very well, some will be killed by the treatment, so the QUALY is an average for a population, not an individual gain.

FWIW NICE defines cost effective treatment as < £20,000 per QUALY, and >£30,000 as not cost effective. There is obvious wiggle room. A Qualy is a quality adjusted life year, so if a treatment gives you one year of perfect life that is a QUALY, two years but with significant disability might be a QUALY.

Average expenditure per person on the NHS is about £2,100 / year.

Although much of the headlines focus on NICE saying a new cancer treatment is too expensive (which usually results in a back room deal; the NHS is a big purchaser, and the cost of production of a drug is low, the real cost is the investment in getting to market; so any sale is worthwhile), what is missed is the permissive drive from NICE saying that certain things must be delivered. NICE also sets standards that services should achieve.

I love NICE's standards. Mostly, I love that they exist. I so wish the US had that same approach.
 
I love NICE's standards. Mostly, I love that they exist. I so wish the US had that same approach.

It does seem like a dream system compared to ours.

Why people trust an insurance company that slow paid them on their clearly covered car repair and haggled over the hail damage to their greenhouse to be fair when it comes to determine whether they get very expensive cancer treatment is beyond me.
 
It does seem like a dream system compared to ours.
I've seen several arguments against NHS that are reasonable. I don't necessarily agree with them, but the arguments themselves were valid. But I've never seen a valid and reasonable argument against NICE. NICE is nice.

Why people trust an insurance company that slow paid them on their clearly covered car repair and haggled over the hail damage to their greenhouse to be fair when it comes to determine whether they get very expensive cancer treatment is beyond me.

See, now we're stepping into grounds where I'm going to end up getting pedantic :p.

First off, Property, Auto, and Health insurance are all completely different entities, with different standards of practice, different rules, and different regulations. Lumping them all together in your comparison is kind of (but not exactly!) like lumping credit unions, banks, and investment firms in the same bucket. Sure they all deal with money... but they're not interchangeable.

Beyond that... Most of the time (not all the time!) health insurers are quite fair when they come to their determinations. They are fair to the contractual obligations that they and the policyholder are both bound by. The insurer has an obligation to the policyholder receiving treatment, but they also have an obligation to all of the other policyholders that are paying for that treatment. They have a duty to be a prudent and ethical steward of their policyholders' finances. Insurance is first and foremost a vehicle for financial protection. It is NOT a vehicle for delivery of care (with the exception of staff-model HMOs, an entirely different topic). Insurers do not provide care; they contract with providers of care to ensure access and discounted rates for their policyholders. An insurer will (and should) deny care that violates the terms of the insurance contract - failure to do so would disadvantage their other customers by imposing a financial burden to which they did not agree.

Now... that said... it is also absolutely true that in the past, some insurers have taken their obligations waaaay to far to one side or the other. The ones who take it too far in support of the patients using high-cost services tend to become insolvent and go out of business. The ones who take it too far in support of the policyholders not using services tend to be universally hated by the small number of patients for whom they've denied care who are often quite vocal and outrages... and they also go out of business because nobody buys their product. It's a really skinny fence to sit on. Insurance companies have a lot of splinters in really uncomfortable places.
 
And even if I don't read the rest of your post I hope you know I appreciate it. :D
I know you do :hug3

And those splinters seem to pay pretty well, no?
Well, they pay **me** pretty well. But if you're talking about the industry as a whole... those splinters are surprisingly mediocre. The average profit margin in the health insurance industry is around 5%. And it's only that high because there are a very few national for-profit companies that skew the averages. Humana, Aetna, and United tend to run at a slightly higher margin - around 8% IIRC. But most of the regional and/or not-for-profit insurers tend to run closer to 2%.

In just about any other industry, a consistently low 2% profit margin would be considered ridiculously low.

Heck, even hospitals, pharmaceuticals, and medical device/supply companies have significantly higher margins than insurers do.
 
I know you do :hug3


Well, they pay **me** pretty well. But if you're talking about the industry as a whole... those splinters are surprisingly mediocre. The average profit margin in the health insurance industry is around 5%. And it's only that high because there are a very few national for-profit companies that skew the averages. Humana, Aetna, and United tend to run at a slightly higher margin - around 8% IIRC. But most of the regional and/or not-for-profit insurers tend to run closer to 2%.

In just about any other industry, a consistently low 2% profit margin would be considered ridiculously low.

Heck, even hospitals, pharmaceuticals, and medical device/supply companies have significantly higher margins than insurers do.

Exactly why I wouldn't want to be an investor in a health insurance company but I wouldn't mind working for one. They really aren't investor friendly, they are more executive friendly.
 
They're fairly intertwined, I think, but mostly, I'd agree. I think doctors in the US are probably grossly overpaid*. Add into that that you run every test you can or risk litigation and the enormous admin costs brought about by actually having to have a decline process and generally deal with insurance companies and it's all a bit of a mess.





*Although mostly they need to be to be able to keep up the payments on their education they paid a fortune for.

Median doctor pay 170 to 200K for their education, and the median GP get 200K per year. Specialist can earn more than the double.
https://thedoctorweighsin.com/how-much-money-do-us-doctors-make/

I doubt the median doctor will be long saddled by debt.
 
Last edited:
Exactly why I wouldn't want to be an investor in a health insurance company but I wouldn't mind working for one. They really aren't investor friendly, they are more executive friendly.

Most companies are pretty executive friendly... but most of them are investor friendly as well.

Maybe some day I'll be an executive. Still not there yet.

ETA: On second thought, I'm not sure I really want the headaches and the responsibility that comes with that job. Manager is sufficiently exhausting and gray-hair-ifying already.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom