Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
The problem the Republican trash have with healthcare is that they are trying to figure out a way to make a bill that conforms to their extremist ideology while at the same time not being wildly unpopular. But it is literally impossible for them to pass a bill that will be more popular than the ACA and still conform to their extremist ideology. Most people don't want to cut taxes for the rich at the expense of taking healthcare away from tens of millions of people.
It's not even that complicated.

Bill to lower premiums: Pipe dream.
Eliminate the mandate yet cover pre-existing conditions: Pipe dream.
Lower taxes on the rich and the magical Laffer Curve shows us tax revenue will increase: Evidence these idiots have a magical belief and don't have a clue about the economy.

There is a demand problem, not a supply problem. How is it these Libertarians don't understand the free market? Wealth is concentrated at the top. They can make widgets to their hearts content. Who on the bottom of that wealth divide has the money to buy widgets?
 
Sounds reasonable? States that want Obama care can keep it, fine. But what about this impossible claim?It's bullcrap, pure campaign promise fantasy.

If it were actually possible, they could have just introduced the legislation long before Obama's term was up. Why would Democrats turn down such a magical promise were it actually real?

Sounds reasonable that any GOP plan should have to meet that bar. If they can't find one that fits the bill, then back to work.
 
The fact there are some markets insurers are withdrawing from could have easily been fixed...

Partisanship aside, I don't think it's an easy fix.

There are two major elements prompting the withdrawals (among several other smaller elements). One of them is embedded, and the other is new.

The embedded problem is the cost problem. Nothing in the ACA addresses the actual cost of care. It addresses the cost of access to care somewhat, but only by setting completely artificial requirements around rate increases. It does nothing at all to address the amounts being charged by the delivery services - doctors, hospitals, pharmaceuticals, device & supply manufacturers. That problem will continue to be a problem until it is explicitly and directly addressed. Even changing to single payer won't fix that problem.

The new problem is the removal of the reimbursements for cost-share reduced plans. And that was in process well before the republicans took office.
 
The new problem is the removal of the reimbursements for cost-share reduced plans. And that was in process well before the republicans took office.
Pure fiction, unless the only office you're talking about is the Oval Office. Just how long do the ****-eating Republicans get to have control of Congress before they can be held accountable?
 
Pure fiction, unless the only office you're talking about is the Oval Office.

Just because you weren't aware of it doesn't make it fiction. Maybe think about doing some research before you toss out accusations like that.

http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2016/11/22/house-seeks-pause-in-cost-sharing-reduction-litigation/

It came up in May of 2016, with a suit claiming that the CSR payments weren't funded and were therefore illegal. It occurred AFTER rates for 2017 were already filed. This has been a topic of interest for my company for a year now.
 
Just because you weren't aware of it doesn't make it fiction. Maybe think about doing some research before you toss out accusations like that.

http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2016/11/22/house-seeks-pause-in-cost-sharing-reduction-litigation/

It came up in May of 2016, with a suit claiming that the CSR payments weren't funded and were therefore illegal. It occurred AFTER rates for 2017 were already filed. This has been a topic of interest for my company for a year now.
And you could have read my post for comprehension as well. The House has been under Republican control since 2011. In other words, what you're describing occurred long after the Republicans took office. So again I ask: How long do they have to be in office before they get assigned some *********** responsibility for the pursestrings of which they are supposed to be in control?
 
And you could have read my post for comprehension as well. The House has been under Republican control since 2011. In other words, what you're describing occurred long after the Republicans took office. So again I ask: How long do they have to be in office before they get assigned some *********** responsibility for the pursestrings of which they are supposed to be in control?

Ahh, I see. Fair point. My point was that this can't be laid at Trump's feet, it was in process well before. I should have been more clear and explicit.
 
Partisanship aside, I don't think it's an easy fix.

There are two major elements prompting the withdrawals (among several other smaller elements). One of them is embedded, and the other is new.

The embedded problem is the cost problem. Nothing in the ACA addresses the actual cost of care. It addresses the cost of access to care somewhat, but only by setting completely artificial requirements around rate increases. It does nothing at all to address the amounts being charged by the delivery services - doctors, hospitals, pharmaceuticals, device & supply manufacturers. That problem will continue to be a problem until it is explicitly and directly addressed. Even changing to single payer won't fix that problem.


The ACA addressed the problem of access to health care. That part was working as well as it could with the sabotage Republicans had stuck into the bill.

Rising cost will always be a problem.

However, the evidence presented by the existence of single payer type plans in other countries that manage to provide as much or better care, with far better access, all while costing significantly less than anything we have done in the U.S. clearly shows that rising costs are an entirely different problem.

The new problem is the removal of the reimbursements for cost-share reduced plans. And that was in process well before the republicans took office.


I think you meant to say "before the Republicans took the White House."

The removal of reimbursements has been a goal of a Republican dominated House and Senate for years.
 
At what point do they admit it's pure bull? :rolleyes:


When has any Republican ever admitted anything like that about anything at all? They can't admit they were wrong. They can't admit that they might have made a mistake. They can't admit that they ever screwed anything up.

Do you think they would ever admit they were lying the entire time?

In public, that is. They seem to get caught admitting it when they don't think they'll get caught plenty of times.
 
http://www.cnn.com/2017/06/06/health/immunodeficiency-disease-insurance-treatment-partner/index.html

I think it belong to this thread and clearly show why private health insurance as a primary system is stupid. Once a diagnosis of a genetic deffect is done... it makes no sense whatsoever to ask to stop a treatment , make a bloodwork, and to prove that the treatment is still required.

it reeks as if insurance company found a cheap way to "eliminate" a few costly undesirable (stopping treatment could lead to severe effect and death for immune problem) while still staying within the bound of law...
 
However, the evidence presented by the existence of single payer type plans in other countries that manage to provide as much or better care, with far better access, all while costing significantly less than anything we have done in the U.S. clearly shows that rising costs are an entirely different problem.
Yes, it is a different problem.

I'll reiterate that the payer isn't the solution. If we do nothing other than turn our system into single payer, that won't reduce the cost per capita in any meaningful way. There's a reasonable likelihood that it will increase cost per capita due to increased utilization. In order to address the ridiculous cost per capita that the US has going on... we need to actually address the cost of care, not who is paying the bills.
 
Yes, it is a different problem.

I'll reiterate that the payer isn't the solution. If we do nothing other than turn our system into single payer, that won't reduce the cost per capita in any meaningful way. There's a reasonable likelihood that it will increase cost per capita due to increased utilization. In order to address the ridiculous cost per capita that the US has going on... we need to actually address the cost of care, not who is paying the bills.

Do you not think a single payor for most patients would have some bargaining power?

(I know the federal government ceded that power for drugs, but I think everyone not holding Pharma stock agrees that was a bad decision and should be reversed and never imitated.)
 
Do you not think a single payor for most patients would have some bargaining power?
It *should* have, but it isn't necessarily the case. The method of payment is independent of the price setting function.

A rational plan would address the cost-side problems either through collective bargaining with all 50 gazillion physician and hospital groups... or more likely take a Medicare fee-schedule sort of an approach and basically set prices by mandate. Then again... a rational plan would be pretty much anything other than what we've got right now. What we've got right now is at best "as rational as possible given the circumstances". :p

(I know the federal government ceded that power for drugs, but I think everyone not holding Pharma stock agrees that was a bad decision and should be reversed and never imitated.)
Everyone except the federal government...
 
It *should* have, but it isn't necessarily the case. The method of payment is independent of the price setting function.

A rational plan would address the cost-side problems either through collective bargaining with all 50 gazillion physician and hospital groups... or more likely take a Medicare fee-schedule sort of an approach and basically set prices by mandate. Then again... a rational plan would be pretty much anything other than what we've got right now. What we've got right now is at best "as rational as possible given the circumstances". :p


Everyone except the federal government...

We agree except that the only reason the Medicare fee schedule has any power is that it it represents so many patients. Imagine how much more weight it would cary if anyone without employer covered health insurance or private health insurance were automatically enrolled in medicare.

Who pays matters as a part of the price setting function.
 
We agree except that the only reason the Medicare fee schedule has any power is that it it represents so many patients. Imagine how much more weight it would cary if anyone without employer covered health insurance or private health insurance were automatically enrolled in medicare.
Sure... but doctors already complain that the Medicare schedule is too low, and that they risk losing money. Lots of doctors don't contract with Medicare, or take only very limited numbers of Medicare patients.

Who pays matters as a part of the price setting function.
I agree that a monolithic power can set prices. I don't agree that single payer necessarily means lower prices. It needs to explicitly include both elements to get it done - single payer AND price setting. And at the end of the day, it's the price setting that matters most. It would be entirely possible to have a substantially private market for health insurance with a government price-setting arrangement for providers. Not very reasonable, definitely not likely, but certainly possible. ;)
 
Last edited:
Republicans are now damned if they do change the ACA because they can only screw it up for millions of people, and damned if they don't because they promised they would.
 
I looked at what's available in our state for 2018. All the players are there under "short term insurance." The ones that pulled out of Obamacare 2017 or 2018. These plans all exclude pre-existing conditions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom