Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Trump personally ordered his administration to reject a state's request to stabilize its insurance market.

For months, officials in Republican-controlled Iowa had sought federal permission to revitalize their ailing health-insurance marketplace. Then President Trump read about the request in a newspaper story and called the federal director weighing the application.

Trump's message in late August was clear, according to individuals who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss private conversations: Tell Iowa no.

Supporters of the Affordable Care Act see the president's opposition even to changes sought by conservative states as part of a broader campaign by his administration to undermine the 2010 health-care law. In addition to trying to cut funding for the ACA, the Trump administration also is hampering state efforts to control premiums. In the case of Iowa, that involved a highly unusual intervention by the president himself.
 
Is that the same as COBRA? If you were to leave your job your employer would be obligated to extend your current coverage for 18 months as long as you pay the premiums. That would at least give you time to find another employer or other coverage.
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/cobra-continuing-health-insurance-after-job-loss.html


As I recall from when I used it a couple decades ago, COBRA usually costs a small fortune. When I was laid off from New York State in 2010, they maintained my health insurance for up to 18 months with payments that were the same as what had previously been deducted from my paycheck every month.
 
COBRA simply continues the same plan at the same price. The only difference is that you pay for all of it instead of your employer paying a portion.

That's when you get a good idea of how much your employer provided health insurance REALLY costs.

So for all the people that complain about having to pay way more taxes for a single payer universal health insurance, they aren't considering the savings of their employer not having to foot a large amount of the health insurance bill anymore.
 
COBRA simply continues the same plan at the same price. The only difference is that you pay for all of it instead of your employer paying a portion.


That's what I thought, but I wasn't sure. Like I said, it's been a long time since I used it, and the last time I lost my job my former employer continued to cover their portion of the insurance.
 
That's what I thought, but I wasn't sure. Like I said, it's been a long time since I used it, and the last time I lost my job my former employer continued to cover their portion of the insurance.

That's great for an employer to do that. I have to pay all of my insurance for COBRA, which runs out at the end of the year. The individual marketplace will cost me MORE money for a comparable plan if you can even find it.
 
That's great for an employer to do that. I have to pay all of my insurance for COBRA, which runs out at the end of the year. The individual marketplace will cost me MORE money for a comparable plan if you can even find it.


I was in one of those evil, Communist unions that have destroyed America, and the requirement to maintain insurance in the event of layoffs was in our contract. The layoff of 900 state employees happened so the Governor could intimidate the union before the next contract negotiation... I mean... it was done to help balance the state budget.
 
As I recall from when I used it a couple decades ago, COBRA usually costs a small fortune. When I was laid off from New York State in 2010, they maintained my health insurance for up to 18 months with payments that were the same as what had previously been deducted from my paycheck every month.

COBRA simply continues the same plan at the same price. The only difference is that you pay for all of it instead of your employer paying a portion.

COBRA and Group Conversion are similar, but aren't the same things. COBRA allows you to continue the exact same plan you had with your employer, paying the full fare that your employer pays, with a time limit of 18 months. Group Conversion allows you to continue into a specific plan, on a guaranteed issue, guaranteed renewable basis. You transition your group plan into another plan that you pay for independently. The benefits won't be exactly the same, but it is generally comprehensive coverage. Group Conversion pre-dates ACA, and was intended to provide an option for continued coverage for people with pre-existing conditions.

Both COBRA and Group Conversion tend to be quite expensive. COBRA is expensive because most employer benefits are expensive (employees usually see only a small portion of the cost). Group Conversion is expensive because it's generally adopted only by people with considerable medical need who wouldn't pass underwriting in the Individual market. Group Conversion only still exists because it hasn't been done away with. I may be missing some nuances (it's not a coverage I work with on a regular basis), but it would seem to be unnecessary given ACA's removal of pre-existing condition limitations.
 
Iowa's request was to let them pretty substantially rewrite the rules of ACA for that state alone.


Yeah? And ...?

If there are special circumstances which can be addressed beneficially by such a request is it a bad thing to ask?

Doesn't the process have to start somewhere?

We have been told that the ACA is not perfect. Are there no provisions to make accommodations for unusual conditions?
 
Last edited:
Yeah? And ...?

If there are special circumstances which can be addressed beneficially by such a request is it a bad thing to ask?

Doesn't the process have to start somewhere?

We have been told that the ACA is not perfect. Are there no provisions to make accommodations for unusual conditions?

ACA isn't perfect. It just seems a bit misleading to imply that Trump is busy being a horrible irrational person because he declined to let one state make substantial changes to the rules of ACA for them alone. Many other states have faced large swaths of areas that would have no individual coverage, and have managed to come up with other solutions that don't involve re-inventing a federal law that is supposed to apply to everyone the same.

Seriously, there are plenty, many, a plethora of reasons to imply (or outright say) that Trump is busy being a horrible irrational person. This is just not really one of those reasons :p
 
And he may have failed at 'Repeal and Replace' so far but Trump is determined to do his damnedest to inflict needless misery:

Trump rolls back access to free birth control

Because magic sky fairy beliefs should absolutely supersede the health and welfare of millions of women.

:confused: Obama made that concession for employers several years ago. What's different than what Obama already allowed, as for Hobby Lobby?
 
:confused: Obama made that concession for employers several years ago. What's different than what Obama already allowed, as for Hobby Lobby?

And like clockwork you leap to Trump's defence, I do hope your on a retainer. Maybe this one time you could own up to this being a bad decision by Trump carried out for the pettiest of reasons?
 
Last edited:
And like clockwork you leap to Trump's defence, I do hope your on a retainer. Maybe this one time you could own up to this being a bad decision by Trump carried out for the pettiest of reasons?

I'll happily acknowledge Trump's bad decision, if someone would kindly explain what decision he made?
 
:confused: Obama made that concession for employers several years ago. What's different than what Obama already allowed, as for Hobby Lobby?

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/06/opinion/trumps-birth-control-contraception.html

In 2014, the Supreme Court ruled 5 to 4 that closely held for-profit companies could also deny contraceptive coverage to employees on religious grounds, in a case brought by Hobby Lobby, the arts and crafts retailer.

The new Trump rules go much further than the Hobby Lobby ruling by effectively allowing any business, university or other organization to opt out, without having to notify the government that it is doing so. That puts hundreds of thousands of women at risk of losing benefits. Under the system created by the Obama administration, when an employer chose not to pay for birth control, employees were provided coverage directly by insurance companies at no cost to the beneficiary. That system will now become optional for employers.
 

Thank you.

It's a sucky decision. Most oral contraceptives are quite inexpensive, I don't think this is necessarily a huge barrer... but when you combine it with the rather systematic destruction of planned parenthood by the religious right over the past several years, it's becoming a bit idiotic. At some point, we women might have to go all Lysistrata on this country. No nookie until you knock off trying to own our reproduction.
 
Last edited:
Thank you.

It's a sucky decision. Most oral contraceptives are quite inexpensive, I don't think this is necessarily a huge barrer... but when you combine it with the rather systematic destruction of planned parenthood by the religious right over the past several years, it's becoming a bit idiotic. At some point, we women might have to go all Lysistrata on this country. No nookie until you knock off trying to own our reproduction.

Don't you know your bodily autonomy ends where white male opinions start?
 
You'd think by my age I would've caught on... but somehow I just keep thinking that my body belongs to me. Must be because I'm a girl, and thinking is hard *tee-hee* :p

Also thinking too much will give you wrinkles. Best to leave that to the men while you make up sandwiches.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom