Johnson seems to be making a pretty apt comparison. It's absolutely bonkers to use insurance as the economic model for providing health care for folks with preexisting conditions. Just because it's what we have to work with doesn't mean it makes any sense.
Speaking as a person with a pre-existing condition, I ask what you suggest as the answer?
I've been kept alive for the past 5 years by some excellent medical care and my luck in having very good health insurance at my work to pay for it. After 35 years of paying into the insurance pool (extra premiums for a higher end policy) I ended up needing to use that insurance.
Overall my medical bills in the past few years have probably come to > $500,000. "Unfortunately" medicine can probably keep me alive quite a bit longer- but it's going to cost. If I were to retire, change jobs, or be forced to quit as a result of progression of my illness I would lose my current insurance. Without requiring coverage of pre-existing conditions no insurance company would voluntarily cover me. The economics would be bonkers, right? My choices at that point before Obamacare would be to bankrupt my family or just refuse medical care and die.
What would you suggest would be the correct way for a society to handle this issue because I am far from the only one on this type of situation?