Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Johnson seems to be making a pretty apt comparison. It's absolutely bonkers to use insurance as the economic model for providing health care for folks with preexisting conditions. Just because it's what we have to work with doesn't mean it makes any sense.

Speaking as a person with a pre-existing condition, I ask what you suggest as the answer?

I've been kept alive for the past 5 years by some excellent medical care and my luck in having very good health insurance at my work to pay for it. After 35 years of paying into the insurance pool (extra premiums for a higher end policy) I ended up needing to use that insurance.

Overall my medical bills in the past few years have probably come to > $500,000. "Unfortunately" medicine can probably keep me alive quite a bit longer- but it's going to cost. If I were to retire, change jobs, or be forced to quit as a result of progression of my illness I would lose my current insurance. Without requiring coverage of pre-existing conditions no insurance company would voluntarily cover me. The economics would be bonkers, right? My choices at that point before Obamacare would be to bankrupt my family or just refuse medical care and die.

What would you suggest would be the correct way for a society to handle this issue because I am far from the only one on this type of situation?
 
What would you suggest would be the correct way for a society to handle this issue because I am far from the only one on this type of situation?

That's a very fair question. My preference would be for the government to subsidize your healthcare using taxpayer dollars collected through progressive taxation. I quite like the idea of socialist healthcare. Single payer would probably be fine with me. I accept that this is politically unrealistic which is why I describe using insurance as "what we have to work with". As a result, I support the ACA approach as better than the likely alternatives, but I won't pretend that it's ideal.
 
Johnson seems to be making a pretty apt comparison. It's absolutely bonkers to use insurance as the economic model for providing health care for folks with preexisting conditions. Just because it's what we have to work with doesn't mean it makes any sense.

My second point is that the "pure" economic goal of all insurance is to only cover people who will nevr need it. Allow only the people whose houses will never burn down to have fire insurance. Permit only the people who will never become ill to have health insurance. Given that is not possible in practice, insurance does the next "best" thing by creating risk pools and adjusting premiums to match, such that the companies can still take in more money than they pay out. Okay, a company has to make a profit and most of us are okay with charging someone who refuses to install smoke detectors more for fire insurance than someone who has them. But there are limits to this type of stratification, especially when it comes to health. Risks are much harder to define or control: my own disease is not linked to life style at all. And people can choose to buy a car or not. I guess I could choose if I wanted to stay alive or not but somehow that feels to me like a fundamentally different issue.

Insurance is a way of socializing risks. Everyone is at risk for an unexpected serious disease or accident, treatment of which might be beyond the financial resources of any one person. So we pay in our premiums and hope we aren't the guy who needs the payout. At least we can sleep better knowing the payout will be there if we are unfortunate enough to be the unlucky guy who needs it. But we will not stop needing the money if we lose or change our jobs.

Of course no insurance can work if people only buy insurance only after they have incurred the risk: a house fire, or a diagnosis of cancer. But Obamacare tries to deal with that very issue by fining people who do not enroll. Imperfect, but the repeal plans have no solution except to lose coverage for 10s of millions of people. The ideal IMO: universal enrollment and universal coverage (and I am happy if that translates into taxes and government payouts).
 
That's a very fair question. My preference would be for the government to subsidize your healthcare using taxpayer dollars collected through progressive taxation. I quite like the idea of socialist healthcare. Single payer would probably be fine with me. I accept that this is politically unrealistic which is why I describe using insurance as "what we have to work with". As a result, I support the ACA approach as better than the likely alternatives, but I won't pretend that it's ideal.

Man, you got me all excited and I flipped into my old codger rant mode only to find we agree. Please ignore my rant! Sorry.
 
Johnson seems to be making a pretty apt comparison. It's absolutely bonkers to use insurance as the economic model for providing health care for folks with preexisting conditions. Just because it's what we have to work with doesn't mean it makes any sense.

It is not an apt comparison. A pre-existing condition vs crashing your car? How are those a good comparison?
 
It is not an apt comparison. A pre-existing condition vs crashing your car? How are those a good comparison?

There are a lot of problems with the analogy (e.g. whose fault it is if you get sick and the difference between a broken car and a broken body), but if anything, it illustrates why car insurance is required by law.
 
Last edited:
It is not an apt comparison. A pre-existing condition vs crashing your car? How are those a good comparison?

It's a good comparison because both situations involve using a risk management model to handle a know, preexisting cost. Just because our society refuses to use other, better models to handle preexisting condition expenses doesn't make a risk management model a good fit.
 
It's a good comparison because both situations involve using a risk management model to handle a know, preexisting cost. Just because our society refuses to use other, better models to handle preexisting condition expenses doesn't make a risk management model a good fit.

Yes, the fundamental problem is that we're trying to impose a paradigm of universal health care onto an industry where insurance is a profitable commodity and the dominant model is corporations providing shared risk programs for their employees, while also protecting those profits.

If you also get hurt when you crash your car, you will be taken to a hospital and cared for, possibly saving your life, even if you don't have insurance and even if the accident was entirely your fault. We do that because we, as a society, feel that it's the "right thing to do." If you don't have insurance, then the hospital is obliged to absorb the cost and pass it along. But saying that you have a right to such care is entirely different from saying that you have a right to have your car repaired, so the analogy breaks down.
 
It's a good comparison because both situations involve using a risk management model to handle a know, preexisting cost. Just because our society refuses to use other, better models to handle preexisting condition expenses doesn't make a risk management model a good fit.

For any large group, insurers can estimate pretty accurately what their costs will be. They don't know who will get lung cancer or wreck a truck, but they know roughly how many will. There's no reason why the same model can't work in the individual market: Treat all policyholders as members of the same large group, with subsidies for lower-income people and maybe government reimbursements to insurers for exceptional costs, which is more or less how the ACA could have worked if it had been allowed to.

Other countries, including Germany and Japan, have universal coverage systems through private insurers that are closely regulated. Private insurance is not itself the problem.
 
Speaking as a person with a pre-existing condition, I ask what you suggest as the answer?

I've been kept alive for the past 5 years by some excellent medical care and my luck in having very good health insurance at my work to pay for it. After 35 years of paying into the insurance pool (extra premiums for a higher end policy) I ended up needing to use that insurance.

Overall my medical bills in the past few years have probably come to > $500,000. "Unfortunately" medicine can probably keep me alive quite a bit longer- but it's going to cost. If I were to retire, change jobs, or be forced to quit as a result of progression of my illness I would lose my current insurance. Without requiring coverage of pre-existing conditions no insurance company would voluntarily cover me. The economics would be bonkers, right? My choices at that point before Obamacare would be to bankrupt my family or just refuse medical care and die.

What would you suggest would be the correct way for a society to handle this issue because I am far from the only one on this type of situation?

If it ever comes up, you should be entitled to a group conversion policy. While I'm not 100% certain, I believe this is the case throughout the US. It might be expensive, but you cant' be denied a continuation of coverage from an employer policy.

Hopefully you won't have to face that situation until our government manages to sort this mess out to some satisfactory end.
 
If you don't have insurance, then the hospital is obliged to absorb the cost and pass it along.

Actually... they don't have to absorb the cost. At last not at first. They can bill you for the care, and if you don't pay they can send you to collections. Medical bankruptcy isn't just for people with insurance.
 
For any large group, insurers can estimate pretty accurately what their costs will be. They don't know who will get lung cancer or wreck a truck, but they know roughly how many will. There's no reason why the same model can't work in the individual market: Treat all policyholders as members of the same large group, with subsidies for lower-income people and maybe government reimbursements to insurers for exceptional costs, which is more or less how the ACA could have worked if it had been allowed to.

The largest difference here is adverse selection. In a large employer group, most employees are only going to have a choice between one or two plans, generally provided by the same carrier. In the individual market, the individual has a selection of dozens or even hundreds of plans, from multiple carriers. The individual knows more about their health status than the insurer does, and will select the plan that gives them the biggest bang for their buck (a perfectly rational thing to do). But this sets up a much less stable pool than for a large employer. Adverse selection can cause some pretty dramatic swings in pricing, and has long been a source of instability in the Individual market. ACA helps a little bit, but doesn't actually alleviate that dynamic.
 
The largest difference here is adverse selection. In a large employer group, most employees are only going to have a choice between one or two plans, generally provided by the same carrier. In the individual market, the individual has a selection of dozens or even hundreds of plans, from multiple carriers. The individual knows more about their health status than the insurer does, and will select the plan that gives them the biggest bang for their buck (a perfectly rational thing to do). But this sets up a much less stable pool than for a large employer. Adverse selection can cause some pretty dramatic swings in pricing, and has long been a source of instability in the Individual market. ACA helps a little bit, but doesn't actually alleviate that dynamic.

But those are not insurmountable problems. For one thing, most consumers in the individual market cannot choose from "dozens or even hundreds" of plans. One complaint about the ACA is that in a few counties, consumers had access to no policies at all, and in some counties only one policy was available. A solution would be to forget about counties and require carriers to offer the same policy/policies to everyone in a state, maybe dividing the largest states into two or three regions. That would create much larger groups whose overall costs should be predictable. And I dunno know about getting more "bang for the buck." Under the ACA, to a large degree policies have been standardized. A "bronze" or "silver" policy offered by one company in one place is not much different from a "bronze" or "silver" policy offered by another. The carriers compete on the basis of price and service. Or at least that's the way it's supposed to be. If there are still substantial differences among plans, that's something that could be adjusted by regulation.

These are practical issues that lend themselves to practical solutions. And of course, a "a public option" would be a non-profit plan available to everyone in the country who wanted it.
 
Last edited:
It's probably an issue of facilities available. In a county with a small population, few doctors and perhaps no hospitals are available. People would be reluctant to buy a plan where the care is 300 miles away.
 
It's probably an issue of facilities available. In a county with a small population, few doctors and perhaps no hospitals are available. People would be reluctant to buy a plan where the care is 300 miles away.

I doubt that too many people have to travel 300 miles. But if the only place patients can get care is a long drive away, that's what they'll have to do, and their choice is either to buy insurance or pay for care out of pocket. Whether a plan is county-based or state-based doesn't affect the availability of providers. Someone living in a rural area will still be eligible for his employer's or union's group plan if there is one, or for Medicaid or Medicare if he qualifies.
 
Last edited:
If it ever comes up, you should be entitled to a group conversion policy. While I'm not 100% certain, I believe this is the case throughout the US. It might be expensive, but you cant' be denied a continuation of coverage from an employer policy.

Hopefully you won't have to face that situation until our government manages to sort this mess out to some satisfactory end.

Thank you for the suggestion. I suspect that I will not have to face the worse case scenario given the length of time that will play out and my current hope to stay in my job (which I love and which confers continued membership in my current health plan). Although awkward for my colleagues I would be happy to die while still working.

Nonetheless the idea of Congress weakening or killing the pre-existing conditions proviso of Obamacare both sends a chill up my own spine and deeply angers me because I so easily empathize with others who are in less fortunate circumstances than my own. For example I am employed by a great employer who has worked around my hospitalizations. And I don't need to be in strong physical condition for my job, so I can still work and continue with my existing insurance. But what of a house painter, or someone on an assembly line? "Oh, you're too sick to work? Then I guess you are too sick to continue your old group insurance policy (not an employee not a member of the group) and too sick to get a new one. Too bad! Your should have thought of that before you decided to get sick!"
 
Thank you for the suggestion. I suspect that I will not have to face the worse case scenario given the length of time that will play out and my current hope to stay in my job (which I love and which confers continued membership in my current health plan).
....


Is that the same as COBRA? If you were to leave your job your employer would be obligated to extend your current coverage for 18 months as long as you pay the premiums. That would at least give you time to find another employer or other coverage.
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/cobra-continuing-health-insurance-after-job-loss.html
 
Thank you for the suggestion. I suspect that I will not have to face the worse case scenario given the length of time that will play out and my current hope to stay in my job (which I love and which confers continued membership in my current health plan). Although awkward for my colleagues I would be happy to die while still working.
Reminds me of a joke I heard years ago:

Wife Dear, you look terrible! Did something happen?

Husband Yeah, we were playing a round of golf when Harry had a heart attack and died on the tenth hole.

Wife Oh no! That must have been awful.

Husband Pretty bad. For the rest of the round it was hit the ball, carry Harry, hit the ball, carry Harry ...
 
Reminds me of a joke I heard years ago:

Wife Dear, you look terrible! Did something happen?

Husband Yeah, we were playing a round of golf when Harry had a heart attack and died on the tenth hole.

Wife Oh no! That must have been awful.

Husband Pretty bad. For the rest of the round it was hit the ball, carry Harry, hit the ball, carry Harry ...


I hope you don't mind if I borrow this. It needs to be cross-posted to a thread where it is very relevant at this moment.
 
Reminds me of a joke I heard years ago:

Wife Dear, you look terrible! Did something happen?

Husband Yeah, we were playing a round of golf when Harry had a heart attack and died on the tenth hole.

Wife Oh no! That must have been awful.

Husband Pretty bad. For the rest of the round it was hit the ball, carry Harry, hit the ball, carry Harry ...
Wow, this joke is practically unchanged from when I heard it 45 years ago.

The only difference: "Hit the ball, drag Harry. Hit the ball, drag Harry.

Thanks for the memories and smile.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom