Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

So they push Paul's cross-state-lines wet dream and find out, the insurers and state insurance commissions were left out of the discussion. Ooops.

So much for putting health insurance into States hands. This is effectively a way to remove the right for people to even vote on who gets to make regulations for their State. Instead, regulations regarding health insurance for their State are being enacted by leaders in other States that they do not get to vote for or against.
 
So much for putting health insurance into States hands. This is effectively a way to remove the right for people to even vote on who gets to make regulations for their State. Instead, regulations regarding health insurance for their State are being enacted by leaders in other States that they do not get to vote for or against.

I asked a question earlier but didn't get an answer. What's to prevent states from forcing insurance companies trading across state lines to only offer policies that conform to their standards?

In one respect this could be a win for people in states with less protection. Polices might get standardized for the state with the most comprehensive coverage, in the same way motor vehicles are manufactured to come up to California's standards. I understand California has some of the strictest vehicle standards in the States. Rather than produce two sets of vehicles—one for California and another for the other 49 states—vehicle manufacturers build to California's rules.
 
I asked a question earlier but didn't get an answer. What's to prevent states from forcing insurance companies trading across state lines to only offer policies that conform to their standards?

There's nothing to stop it because that's already what it is.

Many insurers provide nationwide coverage already, but only through employer benefits. So if an employer covers a large nationwide company like Boeing, for instance, then the employees of Boeing (and their dependents) can all received the same benefits, regardless of where those employees actually live. The state insurance rules that apply in those cases are the rules of the state in which the employer's official headquarters are. Thus the insurer must file the appropriate documents with that state's insurance department, and where applicable receive approval.

As you can see, there are limitations. Since Boeing is headquartered in Washington, they can't buy insurance that conforms to the rules of Tennessee. The same is essentially true for individual purchasers - they can only purchase insurance that is filed and approved for sale where that purchaser resides. Thus a person who lives in Texas can't buy coverage that is sold in Colorado.

I'm not entirely certain that I understood your question. I hope I've provided an appropriate response, but if not, please let me know.
 
I asked a question earlier but didn't get an answer. What's to prevent states from forcing insurance companies trading across state lines to only offer policies that conform to their standards?

If the policy conforms to the regulations of that State why not just sell it in that State right now? The whole idea behind the policy is to allow people to by cheaper, inferior plans that would not otherwise be available in a particular State.
From the article in the post I responded to
http://money.cnn.com/2017/09/27/news/economy/trump-executive-order-health-care/index.html
The concept of letting insurers sell policies in other states has been very popular among Republicans and much less popular among insurers, state regulators and consumer advocates. The basic idea is that insurers would be able to sell policies in multiple states but only have to adhere to the regulations of their home state. So an insurer from a lightly regulated state, where policies may offer skimpier benefits and lower premiums, could start marketing its plans in a highly regulated state, where premiums tend to be higher.
 

CSR payments guaranteed for a forseeable future perhaps? Would go an awful long way to ensure some stability, at lest for the providers.

Now they just need to ge the DHHS to stop running anti-ACA scare ads, stop sabotaging ACA education programs, and reestablish the 3 month enrollment period (it was cut to 1½ month), and things might start to brighten a bit again.
 
Twitter won't let me view it but I can't imagine Trump would sign it.
I can. He can present it as a triumph, and as his emergence as a Third Force, neither Republican nor Democratic.

Trump doesn't think he owes the Republican Party anything, and indeed thinks they owe him for their success in Congress.
 
As with everything else he promised in the campaign, Trump had not the slightest clue of how "repeal and replace" was going to happen, beyond thinking he could just say "Make it so" and it would be so.
Who knew it was complicated? Nobody, that's who, until Trump found out and tweeted about it.
 
There's nothing to stop it because that's already what it is. (respectful snip) Thus a person who lives in Texas can't buy coverage that is sold in Colorado.

If the policy conforms to the regulations of that State why not just sell it in that State right now? The whole idea behind the policy is to allow people to by cheaper, inferior plans that would not otherwise be available in a particular State. From the article in the post I responded to
http://money.cnn.com/2017/09/27/news/economy/trump-executive-order-health-care/index.html

:eye-poppi Now I get it. The whole idea here is to do an end-run around an individual state's mandated requirements by allowing, as Emily's Cat put it, a Texan to buy insurance from a Colorado provider that conforms to Colorado's rules. As if hospital billing departments didn't have enough work on their hands already ...

God what a screwed-up mess is the American health insurance system.
 
Last edited:
.....
God what a screwed-up mess is the American health insurance system.

The thing is that it works pretty well IF you get group insurance through a large employer or union. Federal government employees have great insurance. The ACA is an attempt to create groups for the small percentage of consumers in the individual market, and it could have worked pretty well if the Republicans hadn't actively sabotaged it.
 
Remember the buzzwords of the failed Graham-Cassidy bill: "innovation" and "flexibility"? It was supposed to allow state governments to not only keep the number of people who have healthcare insurance in their states but also expand coverage at a lower cost, but now the the Trump administration apparently doesn't want Oklahoma to innovate in order to lower premiums...

Oklahoma officials are blaming the Trump administration for rising health-care premiums in the state after the administration missed a deadline to approve a key waiver for the state under ObamaCare.

In a letter addressed to Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Tom Price, Oklahoma's health commissioner rips the administration for missing a final deadline for a State Innovation Waiver, which would be used to lower premiums around the state.

The waivers provide federal funds "to implement innovative ways to provide access to quality health care that is at least as comprehensive and affordable as would be provided absent the waiver," according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

The Oklahoma health commissioner's letter said that approving the waiver would have helped more than 130,000 Oklahoma residents and reduced premiums by 30 percent.

"After months of development, negotiation, and near-daily communication over the past six weeks, the State and your departments agreed that waiver approval must be received no later than September 25, 2017," the letter from Oklahoma's Commissioner of Health Terry Cline reads.

http://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/353205-oklahoma-blames-trump-admin-for-higher-premiums

I thought Trump and other Republicans couldn't keep themselves from bitching and moaning about premiums yet when given the option of actually lowering the premiums they simply refuse to act.
 
The thing is that it works pretty well IF you get group insurance through a large employer or union. Federal government employees have great insurance. The ACA is an attempt to create groups for the small percentage of consumers in the individual market, and it could have worked pretty well if the Republicans hadn't actively sabotaged it.
So true. Before Obamacare us self-employed people were pretty much SOL. It's still working well at the moment for me.
 
Remember the buzzwords of the failed Graham-Cassidy bill: "innovation" and "flexibility"? It was supposed to allow state governments to not only keep the number of people who have healthcare insurance in their states but also expand coverage at a lower cost, but now the the Trump administration apparently doesn't want Oklahoma to innovate in order to lower premiums...



http://thehill.com/policy/healthcare/353205-oklahoma-blames-trump-admin-for-higher-premiums

I thought Trump and other Republicans couldn't keep themselves from bitching and moaning about premiums yet when given the option of actually lowering the premiums they simply refuse to act.

Same thing happened with Minnesota, I believe
 
Did they ever get around to renewing funding for CHIP or did their zeal to repeal the ACA blind them?
 

Unbelievable.

And Ron Johnson, a Republican senator, calls health care, food, and shelter a ‘privilege’.

Also, he is not a fan of people with pre-existing conditions:

In an interview in June of this year, Johnson compared people with pre-existing conditions to drivers that have been in a car accident, arguing that the Affordable Care Act’s protections for people with pre-existing conditions is tantamount to requiring auto insurers to sell insurance to people that have crashed their car.

Ron Johnson says health care is a privilege
 
Johnson seems to be making a pretty apt comparison. It's absolutely bonkers to use insurance as the economic model for providing health care for folks with preexisting conditions. Just because it's what we have to work with doesn't mean it makes any sense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom