Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Top Republicans, however, also indicated they have little interest in shoring up the existing insurance market operating under the 2010 law. Instead, they suggested, the ongoing instability would backfire on Democrats and build momentum for the ACA’s eventual repeal.

Translation: We're going to break Obamacare and blame Democrats for it.

Typical abusive relationship Republicans have with America. "Look at what you made me do!"
 
https://www.washingtonpost.com/powe...41773cd5a14_story.html?utm_term=.40e95dd2e758

Senate GOP abandons latest effort to unwind the Affordable Care Act


In deciding not to take up the latest proposal, authored by Sens. Lindsey O. Graham (S.C.) and Bill Cassidy (La.), their fellow Republicans are abandoning achieve the policy goal that has animated their party for more than seven years.

Top Republicans, however, also indicated they have little interest in shoring up the existing insurance market operating under the 2010 law. Instead, they suggested, the ongoing instability would backfire on Democrats and build momentum for the ACA’s eventual repeal.

Instead of having their goal be a big legislative win, perhaps they should have the goal to actually do something to serve the American people?

There are a couple of republicans who have said things like that, but the others are like Chuck Grasseley, who think they need to pass something for the sake of passing something.
 
Awww. What a shame.

After wasting a blatant, transparent attempt to buy off Alaska and Maine.

Interestingly, even Ted Cruz objected, despite the fact that Texas was to be the biggest beneficiary (basically, the bill was going to screw over all the states (coincidentally, largely democratic states) that accepted the Medicaid expansion of the ACA and benefit the states that held out and didn't (again, coincidentally, largely republican).
 
Instead of having their goal be a big legislative win, perhaps they should have the goal to actually do something to serve the American people?


I thought they were trying to serve the American people. Specifically, the wealthy American people who contribute to their campaigns.
 
Price's hubris seems to have him set up to be the perfect fall guy for the failure of ACA repeal.

Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price took a government-funded private jet in August to get to St. Simons Island, an exclusive Georgia resort where he and his wife own land, a day and a half before he addressed a group of local doctors at a medical conference that he and his wife have long attended.

The St. Simons Island trip was one of two taxpayer-funded flights on private jets in which Price traveled to places where he owns property, and paired official visits with meetings with longtime colleagues and family members. On June 6, HHS chartered a jet to fly Price to Nashville, Tennessee, where he owns a condominium and where his son resides. Price toured a medicine dispensary and spoke to a local health summit organized by a longtime friend. He also had lunch with his son, an HHS official confirmed.

...

Richard Painter, who served as the top ethics official for President George W. Bush, said that Price’s trips may have been legal but were ethically dubious.

“To use a charter flight on something that combines personal and government business, I think it’s highly unprofessional and really inappropriate,” Painter said – especially if personal business represented and disproportionate part of the trip.

Swampy.
 
The way insurance works:
Put in Obamacare: raise insurance rates. Too many sick patients.
Repeal Obamacare: Raise rates, too few patients, still having to keep a staff for the public (not corporate) option.
Put half the country on Medicare: Raise rates for corporate clients. Too few patients now.
Any other change: raise insurance rates. No particular reason.

I could become a CEO! I know all the tricks.
 
Translation: We're going to break Obamacare and blame Democrats for it.

It's already broken. They're declining to fix it. Not a great decision in my book, but still a bit different from actively trying to break it.

If they just leave it alone, there's some possibility for state-level solutions that could be adopted widespread to address some of the problems in it right now. And there's the possibility of piecemeal suggestions being adopted over time.
 
It's already broken. They're declining to fix it. Not a great decision in my book, but still a bit different from actively trying to break it.

If they just leave it alone, there's some possibility for state-level solutions that could be adopted widespread to address some of the problems in it right now. And there's the possibility of piecemeal suggestions being adopted over time.

You can't be serious - how many times over the last 8 years did the Republicans vote to repeal? They haven't had a real replacement in mind.
 
It's already broken. They're declining to fix it. Not a great decision in my book, but still a bit different from actively trying to break it.
If they just leave it alone, there's some possibility for state-level solutions that could be adopted widespread to address some of the problems in it right now. And there's the possibility of piecemeal suggestions being adopted over time.

I do not understand how their actions over the last 8 years are NOT actively trying to break the ACA.

I understand the part about the state level solutions, but in my state that is pretty much hopeless.
 
Don't worry... Trump to the rescue!

What could possibly go wrong?

From: http://money.cnn.com/2017/09/27/news/economy/trump-executive-order-health-care/index.html
A day after Congress' last-ditch attempt to repeal Obamacare failed, Trump said he may soon sign an executive order on health care that would affect millions of people
...
Instead, Trump now seems to be backing health insurance reforms pushed by Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky..."I believe President Trump can legalize on his own the ability of individuals to join a group or health association across state lines to buy insurance," Paul said on MSNBC Wednesday.
 
I do not understand how their actions over the last 8 years are NOT actively trying to break the ACA.

I understand the part about the state level solutions, but in my state that is pretty much hopeless.

:D Thanks for expanding. My response was a reply following a specific statement that TheL8Elvis quoted:
Top Republicans, however, also indicated they have little interest in shoring up the existing insurance market operating under the 2010 law. Instead, they suggested, the ongoing instability would backfire on Democrats and build momentum for the ACA’s eventual repeal.
jnelso99's response to TheL8Elvis was that Republicans were going to break ACA:
Translation: We're going to break Obamacare and blame Democrats for it.
My response was to that - to what 'Top Republicans' are going to do going forward, not what they've done in the past. So my response was basically trying to say that Republicans not trying to break it any more is better than them continuing to try to break it (which they've done in the past). Not as good a choice as trying to fix it, but still better than what we've seen in the past.
It's already broken. They're declining to fix it. Not a great decision in my book, but still a bit different from actively trying to break it.
 
I do not understand how their actions over the last 8 years are NOT actively trying to break the ACA.
Let alone the actions of the Trump administration post January 20th. For one, his continuing dithering every month, whether he's going to release CSR funds, is having an overwhelmingly negative effect on the program.
 
Don't worry... Trump to the rescue!

What could possibly go wrong?

From: http://money.cnn.com/2017/09/27/news/economy/trump-executive-order-health-care/index.html
A day after Congress' last-ditch attempt to repeal Obamacare failed, Trump said he may soon sign an executive order on health care that would affect millions of people
...
Instead, Trump now seems to be backing health insurance reforms pushed by Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky..."I believe President Trump can legalize on his own the ability of individuals to join a group or health association across state lines to buy insurance," Paul said on MSNBC Wednesday.
So they push Paul's cross-state-lines wet dream and find out, the insurers and state insurance commissions were left out of the discussion. Ooops.
 
As with everything else he promised in the campaign, Trump had not the slightest clue of how "repeal and replace" was going to happen, beyond thinking he could just say "Make it so" and it would be so.

And doesn't he know that executive orders are evil, because Obama issued tens of thousands of them? R's spent eight years accusing Obama of being a "dictator". Now that they've got one of their own who actually WANTS to be one, what do they do? Dither.
 
And doesn't he know that executive orders are evil, because Obama a Democrat issued tens of thousands of them? R's spent eight years accusing Obama a Democrat of being a "dictator".
ftfy.

Now that they've got one of their own who actually WANTS to be one, what do they do? Dither.
Perfectly consistent. It was never about being a "dictator".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom