Treadmill physics

I still think there is more impetus required to walk outside. I may be making a frame of reference mistake. Pushing off from the ground is harder than a treadmill IMO - the ground is not moving away from you as you attempt to gain clearance to take the next step.

Just a hunch.

So, you are saying that the earth stands still? And then, what is your absolute reference frame to decide that?

What if the treadmill belt was 100 miles long and 20 miles wide?

See how your line of reasoning is, uh, problematic here?

;)

Greetings,

Chris
 
Pushing off from the ground is harder than a treadmill IMO - the ground is not moving away from you as you attempt to gain clearance to take the next step.

Just a hunch.

No. The relative speed and motion between the ground and your center of mass is the same whether that ground is solid earth or the belt on a treadmill.

Steve S
 
...Having hiked down 2.5 miles at one time, I know how tough it can be going down.

Did in this in the Grand Canyon with out enough toe room in my shoes. It was agony. Hiked back up barefoot, my toes were so hurting so bad.

I have access to a 'mill with 2 percent downgrade but if I'm going for strength there are better ways.

I've developed isometric triceps at times from leaning so hard on the 'mill
 
If you want to train downwards on a mill, you can hold on to the bar and lean backwards, so you are trying to resist the belt with your feet.

Hans
 
A friend recently bought a treadmill. I was amazed that it has a 3.25 hp motor.
The walking probably amounts to 1/4 hp, if that. What an extraordinary waste of energy.
Too bad they don't come with a sand-paper belt for some alternate usage.
 
A friend recently bought a treadmill. I was amazed that it has a 3.25 hp motor.
The walking probably amounts to 1/4 hp, if that. What an extraordinary waste of energy.
Too bad they don't come with a sand-paper belt for some alternate usage.

I suspect that threadmill motor wattages, like PC speakers, are grossly exaggatated. Most exercise machines run on a single-phase outlet, which means that in most places, the maximum available power is 2,300W (230V, 10A). This is only a little over 3hp, even in the ideal case.

However, no need to worry about energy consumption: The energy consumption of an electric motor is proportional to the load, so even if it is a ~3hp motor, it will only consume the power you draw from it, plus losses.

ETA: Even allowing for some hype, the motors are quite powerful. This is very likely because even though the average load is not so high, it is very uneven, so you either need a lot of extra power or a big flywheel to keep the speed constant. Other machines like spinning bikes and rowing machines use a flywheel, but the threadmill needs to be able to stop quickly, for safety reasons, so they fit a strong motor that has the power to absorb the varying load.

Hans
 
Last edited:
I suspect that threadmill motor wattages, like PC speakers, are grossly exaggatated. Most exercise machines run on a single-phase outlet, which means that in most places, the maximum available power is 2,300W (230V, 10A). This is only a little over 3hp, even in the ideal case.

However, no need to worry about energy consumption: The energy consumption of an electric motor is proportional to the load, so even if it is a ~3hp motor, it will only consume the power you draw from it, plus losses.

ETA: Even allowing for some hype, the motors are quite powerful. This is very likely because even though the average load is not so high, it is very uneven, so you either need a lot of extra power or a big flywheel to keep the speed constant. Other machines like spinning bikes and rowing machines use a flywheel, but the threadmill needs to be able to stop quickly, for safety reasons, so they fit a strong motor that has the power to absorb the varying load.

Hans


Makes sense.

Though, there is something metaphorically disturbing about the treadmill.
Even a hamster wheel would be less desperate looking.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom