Treadmill physics

It helps enormously if you're running, because the bounce allows you to recover energy that would otherwise be lost with each "landing".
I'd wouldn't be surprised if running and slow walking turned out to be almost completely different activities mechanically; perhaps as much different as walking versus standing. I'm not prepared to address running.

I note that you were talking about a slow walk though. In that case I would guess that a lot more muscle energy is needed for stabilization and shock absorption on the track than on the treadmill.
I don't see why (asuming that we're not hanging on to the bar of the treadmill). If anything, I'd think it would be the other way around. I'm very aware of the amount of muscle activity involved in maintaining balance, because that's something I work on. Stand on one foot, see how high you can count, watch what your feet and lower legs are doing -- a lot of micro-correction going on there; maintaining balance is really a matter of recovering from small losses of balance. For an extra challenge, try it with your eyes closed. When I first started that regimen, I got sore feet out of the deal. On the track, you are free to adjust the pace if necessary to recover from a small loss of balance, whereas on the treadmill, any necessary recovery has to be done at the treadmill's pace (or else).

I don't think a rubberized track will give you anywhere near the cushioning you get on a typical treadmill.
Again, I don't see why. The treadmill's got what, half an inch of rubber? If that -- and pretty solid rubber, too. I'll bet there's at least as much on the track, and with some amount of air spaces between the particles. You can definitely feel the springyness of it.
 
I made a slow motion video(210 fps) comparing my walk on a flat treadmill vs a 15 degree angle side by side. The speed is 3 mph in both cases. I am holding on to the treadmill so you don't see any arm motion. The video is just a couple of steps and is 8 seconds long.
I can't honestly say I can see much of a difference in my motions but maybe one of you will get something out of it.


Here are two frames from the video.
 

Attachments

  • Walk_video.jpg
    Walk_video.jpg
    22.2 KB · Views: 3
  • Walk_video1.jpg
    Walk_video1.jpg
    22.2 KB · Views: 3
I made a slow motion video(210 fps) comparing my walk on a flat treadmill vs a 15 degree angle side by side. The speed is 3 mph in both cases. I am holding on to the treadmill so you don't see any arm motion. The video is just a couple of steps and is 8 seconds long.
I can't honestly say I can see much of a difference in my motions but maybe one of you will get something out of it.

If you are holding on to the treadmill there's a big difference with walking on a track.
 
Maybe this is the source of my not feeling the incline.

If you're using your arms to support your weight, sure. Think about what this looks like in the top-belt-is-stationary coordinate system. If the top belt is stationary like the surface of a hill, then the treadmill handlebars are gliding up the hill like a ski lift. And obviously ascending a hill by pushing against it with your feet requires work from your legs, while leaning on a T-bar and getting dragged up does not.
 
It helps enormously if you're running, because the bounce allows you to recover energy that would otherwise be lost with each "landing".

I'm not really convinced that is helping. Surely the whole point of a treadmill is to do exercise (since if you're trying to get somewhere, a treadmill is kind of an odd choice). If it reduces the amount of exercise you do by allowing you to recover some of the energy that would otherwise be lost, that's pretty much the exact opposite of helping.
 
I'm not really convinced that is helping. Surely the whole point of a treadmill is to do exercise (since if you're trying to get somewhere, a treadmill is kind of an odd choice). If it reduces the amount of exercise you do by allowing you to recover some of the energy that would otherwise be lost, that's pretty much the exact opposite of helping.

Absolutely true. My experiments with hyper-efficiency were born entirely of wondering about the physics. :)

If you're using your arms to support your weight, sure. Think about what this looks like in the top-belt-is-stationary coordinate system. If the top belt is stationary like the surface of a hill, then the treadmill handlebars are gliding up the hill like a ski lift. And obviously ascending a hill by pushing against it with your feet requires work from your legs, while leaning on a T-bar and getting dragged up does not.

That makes a hell of a lot of sense.
 
I would have thought that it would go without saying that we all consider holding on to the bar to be a form of cheating that would confound all attempts at analyzing the physics. Introducing incline into the equation also seems to confuse things.

I am not persuaded by the frames of reference argument (openly admitting that I am taking a strictly intuitive approach). It seems to me that walking on a treadmill is a little like walking downhill. Speaking of hills.

Think of the game "wheelbarrow". Somebody grabs your ankles and pushes you forward while you "walk" on your hands -- in quotes because that's not really what you're doing; you're just picking them up and putting them down. You don't have to push back against the ground at all, because your partner is providing all of the energy required for the forward movement. This seems to me to be similar to what's happening on the treadmill (again, as long as we're talking about walking rather than running, and also, keeping it flat).

I'm not saying that the treadmill does all of the work, just some of it. You're not depending entirely on muscle power for your part; you're also exploiting gravity. Keep your upper body balanced just right (that is, tilted forward slightly), and your stationary leg just moves back under you via treadmill power. On flat ground, I can walk forward while leaning backward -- some (though it's just as awkward as the strict "falling forward" technique I mentioned above). I'd like to see video of someone doing that on a treadmill.
 
Think of the game "wheelbarrow". Somebody grabs your ankles and pushes you forward while you "walk" on your hands -- in quotes because that's not really what you're doing; you're just picking them up and putting them down. You don't have to push back against the ground at all, because your partner is providing all of the energy required for the forward movement. This seems to me to be similar to what's happening on the treadmill (again, as long as we're talking about walking rather than running, and also, keeping it flat).

In the wheelbarrow game someone is pushing you. If you were to put each hand in a roller skate, you could just just keep the same position, do no work at all, and let yourself be pushed forward.

On the treadmill nobody is pushing you. If you were to put each foot in a roller skate, you wouldn't hold your place on the treadmill (unless you held on to the bar, which of course changes things).

You could indeed play the classical wheelbarrow game on a treadmill: somebody stands on the ground behind the treadmill holding your ankles while you "walk" your hands along the treadmill. Something holding you still on the treadmill is equivalent to something pushing you along the ground.
 
IAgain, I don't see why. The treadmill's got what, half an inch of rubber? If that -- and pretty solid rubber, too. I'll bet there's at least as much on the track, and with some amount of air spaces between the particles. You can definitely feel the springyness of it.

When walking, a lot of effort is requited to recover from the destabilization caused by each impact with the ground.

A treadmill has shocks and/or springs. I have an almost-gym-quality treadmill here in the room with me. Because one of the shocks is squeaky, I'm very aware of them absorbing a lot of the impact when running or walking. After a bit of testing just now, I'm changing my mind. The real benefit is not the bounce, but that the front has good shock absorption and the back does not. You get the best of both worlds: a soft landing and a firm push-off.
 
If you are holding the bar while walking on the treadmill, it's equivalent to holding on to a bar fixed to the back of a moving vehicle when you're walking on the track.

Except for the exhaust fumes, in case of a normal car, which probably make breathing a bit uncomfortable again and causing the blood oxygen levels to fall ;)

Greetings,

Chris
 
I am not persuaded by the frames of reference argument (openly admitting that I am taking a strictly intuitive approach).

You can use your intuition to convince yourself of the validity of frames of reference. As has been mentioned several times, the earth is very much a giant treadmill beneath your feet, moving much faster than you could run, yet it is no easier to walk east than to walk west.
 
Maybe this is the source of my not feeling the incline.

When you're not holding the treadmill you have to use your core muscles more for balance. It is much harder to keep up the pace/incline if you discipline yourself to not touch the treadmill. I use a half-measure, barely touching the treadmill, but it still seems to take a lot of the strain out of the movement. Which I think to some extent defeats the purpose of being on a treadmill.

It is much harder for me to keep the pace walking outdoors as I do on the treadmill, but if I can get close I'm sure outdoor walking is a more rounded exercise in that strength and balance come into play more than they do on a treadmill.

Also, getting a balance of up-and-down inclines does more for the strength of your legs that just the incline up. That's great for cardio, but walking downhill requires more strength that walking level. I've read that treadmills are insufficient training for marathons because typically they have an "up" slant but not a downward one (though some do have a downhill mode). For full strength conditioning of legs you need the downhill training as well.
 
Last edited:
Hadn't thought about it not training down. Having hiked down 2.5 miles at one time, I know how tough it can be going down. I was quite surprised, expecting that up was always going to be harder.

But I was doing treadmill for cardio, not strength training. Glad to know I had the use right. ;)
 
You can use your intuition to convince yourself of the validity of frames of reference. As has been mentioned several times, the earth is very much a giant treadmill beneath your feet, moving much faster than you could run, yet it is no easier to walk east than to walk west.
I can't very well deny the validity of frames of reference, but I'm still left with the discrepancy I mentioned above. After giving it some more thought (including yet another thought experiment which I myself was forced to reject as flawed), I've decided that while I must concede to your superior logic -- even including the bit about stability -- I can still stand on my claim, though I have to admit to being right for the wrong reason.

The treadmill does do some of the work, and the leg does get a free ride. It's just that the reason is simpler than I realized: One does hang on to the bar at least some of the time, whether one wants to admit it or not.
 
The treadmill does do some of the work, and the leg does get a free ride. It's just that the reason is simpler than I realized: One does hang on to the bar at least some of the time, whether one wants to admit it or not.

I still think there is more impetus required to walk outside. I may be making a frame of reference mistake. Pushing off from the ground is harder than a treadmill IMO - the ground is not moving away from you as you attempt to gain clearance to take the next step.

Just a hunch.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom