Treadmill physics

I don't agree. Remember my box example. If the center of mass is not moving, then you're not putting energy in. You are doing something to keep the energy the same. I expend energy to move my legs, not raise my center of mass.

Your center of mass is moving relative to the belt of the treadmill.
 
Could you elaborate on the highlighted please? The last thread I read which had a lot of stuff about treadmills, the (in)famous faster than downwind cart thread, led me to believe that moving on a (moving) treadmill was the same as moving on a stationary road. I'm probably misunderstanding something, but as someone who runs on both a treadmill and a road, I don't notice any free ride at all.
Due to severe COPD, my running days are over, but I've spent a lot of time walking -- on treadmills, as well as on sidewalks, tracks, etc (I usually try to stay out of the road). I long ago noticed a discrepancy between my performance on a treadmill and on level real-world ground, measured by a purely objective (if not very precise) method: oxygen saturation. In conversation with other COPD patients, I've learned that this experience is almost universal among those COPD patients who become accustomed to spending time on a treadmill at X miles per hour (most often as participants in a pulmonary rehabilitation program) and then go out in the real world and find themselves unable to maintain anything like that same speed without their sats crashing, even on level and even ground. So it's something I've been thinking about for a while. The "free ride" hypothesis is the best explanation I've been able to come up with, but if there's a better, I'd love to hear it.

Walking has been described as "a series of controlled falls". Swinging the one leg out shifts the center of gravity forward, and -- push or no push -- everything but the stationary foot IS going to move in that direction. Now, if you go out and try doing it just like that -- literally falling over forward partway and then planting that foot out in front just in time to catch yourself -- it looks and feels rather strange, because there is ordinarily more involved. One is pushing back against the ground in addition to falling forward and all that, and more so as speed increases from a gradual walk to a full run (which would explain why a person focused on "running" might not notice the difference). But it is possible to locomote in this fashion, and I propose that it would be possible even if one were deprived of the use of the muscles in the thighs, calves, and feet (say through application of a cast) -- as long as the legs were free to do that forward swing.
 
I don't agree. Remember my box example. If the center of mass is not moving, then you're not putting energy in. You are doing something to keep the energy the same. I expend energy to move my legs, not raise my center of mass.

I think this is incorrect. If I hold my arm outstretched with a lead ball in it and keep the system from moving, under your explanation, I am doing no work. Yet, I am burning calories and cannot sustain the effort.
 
The "free ride" hypothesis is the best explanation I've been able to come up with, but if there's a better, I'd love to hear it.

Anything is better than something which is clearly wrong.

I'd be willing to bet that the main difference is that most treadmills have shocks or springs so you get much more bounce than on the road. They also give you a tailwind that always matches your speed, allow you to maintain a perfectly even pace, give you a perfectly even surface you won't find outside except on a track, and are generally in an environment with a comfortable temperature.
 
What makes you think that your center of mass isn't moving? It's always moving when you are walking.

On a flat surface (treadmill or otherwise) it is bobbing up and down in close to a sinusoidal fashion such that you are constantly interchanging kinetic and potential energy to keep yourself going. Our bodies are incredibly good at this. Pretend that during each stride you lift your c.o.m. 10 centimeters. (I don't know what the actual value is, just making up a number.) At the beginning and end of your strides you have fallen 5 centimeters from the mean value and in the center you have risen 5 centimeters above it. In this case it is possible for you to retain most of the energy you put into lifting your body through a whole bunch of physical and biological means. In essence though, you bounce.

When the treadmill is inclined or when you walk up a hill, you put energy into your body to lift it up at the beginning of your stride as usual, but that potential energy is not able to be recovered in the second half of the stride because it was used to move you upward with respect to that point on the hill or treadmill. In other words, you can't fall an equal distance downward on the second half of your foot and regain the position that you had at the beginning of the stride. In this case, the step forward does not allow you to fall into it (from the mean position of your c.o.m.) and instead you have to actually step upward 10 centimeters just to start your stride. By the time your foot has reached the center of its path, it has reached the new mean position (5 centimeters) due to the action of the treadmill. By the time your foot reaches the back of your step, it has fallen 5 centimeters more and you are back where you started. Your other foot must now lift you 10 centimeters again in order to keep your stride going normally. The treadmill uses the potential energy you are continuously putting into your body in order to drive itself, partially, by decreasing the output of the motors. If you were able to increase the incline sufficiently, you'd be falling down the slope so fast that the motors wouldn't have to work at all, and perhaps fast enough that the speed would increase until you couldn't keep up.

Note: In the second example I picked a slope that causes the step forward to require an increase in height of 10cm. There's no particular reason that this should be so short of continuity in the examples.
 
Last edited:
I did not intend to provide a non-applicable analogy. Could you tell me in what way it isn't useful here?

Money and energy do not obey the same rules. They aren't analogous in many ways. So any analogy to an energy problem using money will be suspect in potentially subtle ways.

What makes you think that your center of mass isn't moving? It's always moving when you are walking.

There's a huge difference between normal walking where you bounce a bit, and the kind of walking I was doing on the treadmill an attempt to stay as steady as possible for maximum efficiency. When you bounce up and down, you spend more energy repeatedly replenishing the potential energy you lose going down on each step.

Watch the race-walker in this vid; he doesn't bounce:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wct-I9UgOpg
 
Last edited:
I think this is incorrect. If I hold my arm outstretched with a lead ball in it and keep the system from moving, under your explanation, I am doing no work. Yet, I am burning calories and cannot sustain the effort.

That's perfectly true. That's because the physics definition of "work", force exerted through a difference, is not the same as the colloquial sense of "work" (anything that's hard to do.) Your muscles need to burn energy just to exert a force; they're unusual in that regard. A spring, or a lever, or a float, could replace your arm and keep this lead ball in place indefinitely, without tiring out or warming up or accomplishing anything.

It's important to make this distinction. If your muscles do physical work (dW = F.dx) they get tired. However, the converse is not true---it is not true that "if your muscles get tired, they must be doing physical work."
 
Almo, it might help to imagine a huge treadmill, very wide and very long, tilted at some angle. Now transform to the frame where the top surface of the treadmill belt is at rest. That transformation doesn't do anything to gravity (it's still pointed straight down) and it leaves all laws of physics invariant - so now you've got a perfectly normal tilted surface, at rest.

Walking up that surface is exactly like walking up any other incline or hill.
 
Anything is better than something which is clearly wrong.
Unless it turns out to be even wronger.

I'd be willing to bet that the main difference is that most treadmills have shocks or springs so you get much more bounce than on the road.

The track I use is surfaced with pulverized rubber and it's bouncier than all get-out. Not that I can see how that would help (other than to reduce the risk of joint injury).

They also give you a tailwind that always matches your speed,
A tailwind? On a treadmill?

...and are generally in an environment with a comfortable temperature.
My reason for rejecting that idea is that the discrepancy is consistant across a range of temperatures.
 
If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not putting energy in. I am doing something that keeps the energy the same. That's not the same as putting energy in.

Energy is Frame Of Reference dependent- keeping the same KE in one frame changes it in another.
 
A tailwind? On a treadmill?

If you are running outside when there's no wind, you'll be running into the still air, and thus experience a wind equal to your running speed and in the opposite direction.

If you have a tailwind that is exactly equal to your running speed (and in the same direction) then the air will be still relative to you as you run.

The latter is the situation you have when you run on a treadmill.
 
This isn't a rigorous use of the word energy. If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not putting energy in. I am doing something that keeps the energy the same. That's not the same as putting energy in.

You are putting in energy. The belt is taking energy away from you (transporting you downwards) and to stay at the same elevation you need to replace that energy by essentially walking back up.

The example is a box sitting on a table. If the table didn't stop the box from falling, it would lose potential energy and (temporarily) gain kinetic energy. The table doesn't put energy into the box to keep it stationary. It exerts a force opposite the force of gravity which keeps the potential energy the same and the kinetic energy zero.

However, that is not the same as the inclined belt.

Neither the table nor the box does any work.

Because the system is stationary. Take a different situation: A hovering helicopter. As it stays the same hight, it should need no energy, and the reason it does in fact consume energy is because it uses a somewhat inefficient method (essentially pushing down air). However, if you place the helicopter in a down-draft (e.g. from another helicopter above), you will need more energy to hover.

Where I lose energy on the treadmill is from moving my legs to remain stationary. This gives my legs kinetic energy, and expends chemical energy.

On a flat belt, you should ideally not spend any energy, but because walking is somewhat inefficient you still do. Just like the helicopter.

But it puts no net kinetic or potential energy into me as a whole, since my velocity and height remain the same.

On the inclined belt, the belt transports you down. It takes potential energy away from you, and inaddition to the energy you spend walking, you must also replace that potential energy.

So my argument is that yes, I lose energy on the treadmill. Yes, that is due to exerting forces on the belt. But when I increase the incline, it only makes it a little harder to lift my legs, but I don't have to do all the extra work to increase my potential energy like I would on a real slope.

Wrong. In essence, the situation is exactly as on a real slope. The reason it may not feel as hard is probably that a 10-15 degree slope is not really that steep for walking, plus you have no air resistance.


I am going to, but I will not try to move. I will try to remain stationary. If that's less work than climbing stairs, then I'm right about the potential energy thing.

Staying in the same place on a downward escalator is the same as climbing stairs. (sans air resistance)

On where the energy goes: Threadmills and escalators are driven by electric motors. Most electric motors are are intrinsically fixed speed; if you try to push them faster, they will act as generators and produce energy, which will be dissipated in various ways.

Hans
 
Almo, it might help to imagine a huge treadmill, very wide and very long, tilted at some angle. Now transform to the frame where the top surface of the treadmill belt is at rest. That transformation doesn't do anything to gravity (it's still pointed straight down) and it leaves all laws of physics invariant - so now you've got a perfectly normal tilted surface, at rest.

Walking up that surface is exactly like walking up any other incline or hill.


Good analogy.

Isn't being on the Earth kind of like that analogy as well? People don't usually imagine themselves walking with, or against, the rotation of the Earth. :D
 
If you are running outside when there's no wind, you'll be running into the still air, and thus experience a wind equal to your running speed and in the opposite direction.
Point taken. Still, it doesn't seem to go very far toward explaining the discrepancy I'm talking about. On a treadmill, I'm hard pressed to maintain 2.5 mph without watching my O2 sats drop below 90 percent. Outside, it's more like 1.5 mph. That's really more strolling than walking. I can't see wind resistance being much of a factor.
 
The reference frame arguments are the ones I find most convincing, since they simplify the problem in the most straight-forward way. Good discussion, and thanks for the help. I sometimes get stuck on first-principles issues because I have a tendency to deconstruct everything. :)
 
The track I use is surfaced with pulverized rubber and it's bouncier than all get-out. Not that I can see how that would help (other than to reduce the risk of joint injury).

It helps enormously if you're running, because the bounce allows you to recover energy that would otherwise be lost with each "landing". I note that you were talking about a slow walk though. In that case I would guess that a lot more muscle energy is needed for stabilization and shock absorption on the track than on the treadmill. I don't think a rubberized track will give you anywhere near the cushioning you get on a typical treadmill.
 
The reference frame arguments are the ones I find most convincing, since they simplify the problem in the most straight-forward way. Good discussion, and thanks for the help. I sometimes get stuck on first-principles issues because I have a tendency to deconstruct everything. :)

Sure. And remember that even if you were moving at a constant velocity relative to the ground, your energy STILL wouldn't be changing. That requires acceleration, so moving at a constant speed reference the ground, or reference a treadmill belt have the same change in energy- zero.

What ARE accelerating are your legs- first forward then backward, constantly changing velocity. THAT requires energy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom