Almo
Masterblazer
Hi!
I was on a treadmill the other day, walking at a brisk pace. I cranked the incline to 10 or 15%. I didn't feel much of a difference,though there was some. But I was walking efficiently, keeping my center of mass as motionless as I could. This got me to thinking about the physics.
If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not increasing my potential energy. All I'm doing is spending energy to keep my legs moving with the belt. My thought is that the extra effort is just for lifting my feet from closer to the floor to further from the floor because of the incline.
But I'm not the only one to wonder this. I've seen huge arguments where people say "But the forces are exactly the same on the treadmill or on the ground, so there's no difference."
My approach to complex physics problems is always to consider energy, since working from forces is hard. There's a reason we invented Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The problems you can solve with those (like a sphere rolling without slipping down a cylindrical tube with larger radius than the ball) can be an absolute nightmare working from the forces.
I imagine people who really feel the difference with the incline on with the treadmill are letting their center of mass move a bit forward and backward relative to the front of the machine, and that means each step has to add potential energy when going back up the incline.
I'm wondering if some of the many really smart physics people hanging around here could shed some light on this, and tell me if I'm missing something.
I was on a treadmill the other day, walking at a brisk pace. I cranked the incline to 10 or 15%. I didn't feel much of a difference,though there was some. But I was walking efficiently, keeping my center of mass as motionless as I could. This got me to thinking about the physics.
If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not increasing my potential energy. All I'm doing is spending energy to keep my legs moving with the belt. My thought is that the extra effort is just for lifting my feet from closer to the floor to further from the floor because of the incline.
But I'm not the only one to wonder this. I've seen huge arguments where people say "But the forces are exactly the same on the treadmill or on the ground, so there's no difference."
My approach to complex physics problems is always to consider energy, since working from forces is hard. There's a reason we invented Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The problems you can solve with those (like a sphere rolling without slipping down a cylindrical tube with larger radius than the ball) can be an absolute nightmare working from the forces.
I imagine people who really feel the difference with the incline on with the treadmill are letting their center of mass move a bit forward and backward relative to the front of the machine, and that means each step has to add potential energy when going back up the incline.
I'm wondering if some of the many really smart physics people hanging around here could shed some light on this, and tell me if I'm missing something.