Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

When someone rejects a scientific theory that has come to be widely accepted, precisely because there is a wealth of experimental and observational evidence in its favor, it is fair to ask whether that person can give a better explanation for the empirical evidence supporting the theory he/she rejects.

And so, I hereby ask @Rusty Tyler to give us his own explanation of the cosmic microwave background.
The HOW and WHY for all three have no empirical evidence.
There are lots of very real things you accept as real without having any idea of their HOW or WHY. In this thread, you are rejecting real things for which there is overwhelming empirical evidence. When challenged to give your own alternative explanation(s) of that evidence, you run away from the challenge by hiding behind your near-universal ignorance of the HOW and WHY of everyday things.
By way of discussing science rather than foolish denials of science, here is a list of real things whose HOW and WHY @Rusty Tyler is unable to explain.
  • Evolution is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • The Big Bang is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • GPS is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Fluorescent lights are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Neon signs are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • LED monitors and television displays are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • USB drives are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • DVD and Blu-ray players are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Solar cells are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Sunlight is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Solar cells are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • MRI scanners are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Quantum key distribution is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Transistors are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Digital cameras are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
An epistemologist might ask how I know the originator of this thread doesn't know the HOW or WHY of those things. (That is of course a HOW question in its own right.) Well, we know from another thread that he doesn't even realize evolution is a real thing. From this thread, we know he doesn't realize the Big Bang is (Fred Hoyle's jocular name for) the very real scientific theory that unifies a wide variety of incontrovertibly real things ranging from the Lemaître-Hubble expansion to the abundance ratios of light nuclei to the cosmic microwave radiation. We know he doesn't know the HOW or WHY of GPS because GPS relies on the same theory that predicted the Big Bang.

All of the other things I listed are real things whose HOW and WHY involve quantum mechanics. Given @Rusty Tyler's evident ignorance of science in general, it is safe to say he doesn't understand quantum mechanics.
 
  • Evolution is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • The Big Bang is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • GPS is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Fluorescent lights are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Neon signs are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • LED monitors and television displays are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • USB drives are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • DVD and Blu-ray players are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Solar cells are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Sunlight is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Solar cells are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • MRI scanners are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Quantum key distribution is a real thing whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Transistors are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
  • Digital cameras are real things whose HOW and WHY are not known by @Rusty Tyler.
Are you planning to tell me why?

Or how for that matter.
 
Didn't bother doing more than skimming the thread, but it seems someone has gone full pizza cutter.
 
Are you planning to tell me why?

Or how for that matter.
No. Many people, in numerous threads, have tried to educate you concerning various matters of science, notably evolution. You have proved ineducable, mainly because your religious beliefs rely upon the ignorance you preserve through your unceasing efforts to avoid learning anything.
 
... someone has gone full pizza cutter.
Reminds me of the scene in the Orphan Black series where Helena emerges from Pouchy's lair with the paper cutter blade.
She recovered Donnie's money and her "babies" leaving a blood bath in her wake.

We are spared the actual violence which is left to the imagination in her blood soaked clothing.
 
The HOW and WHY for all three have no empirical evidence.
And? That does not make them myths. If I'm walking through the woods and see a fallen tree, I don't know the how and why but the tree has still fallen, its not a myth in any way. Nor is Abiogenesis, the Big Bang, nor the advent of consciousness. They are things that happened, that is observable. My not knowing how or why doesn't change that and it doesn't make a myth. London exists, the reality that I don't know how or way it was started does not make the founding of London a myth. The list of things in the universe that I don't understand is boundless, that does not make them myths.

This all seems to be a non sequitur to me.
 
Reminds me of the scene in the Orphan Black series where Helena emerges from Pouchy's lair with the paper cutter blade.
She recovered Donnie's money and her "babies" leaving a blood bath in her wake.

We are spared the actual violence which is left to the imagination in her blood soaked clothing.
Something that always bugged me about that show. The clones were secret illegal experiment, but they also managed to patent the results of their illegal experiment.
 
Like I said...
Your questions took us off topic.
Don't blame me.

OK, to be polite for a moment, would you care to repeat the actual science bits which you say I went away from, as I am struggling to see any science in what you posted.

Explain it gently for me, just to stop me being triggered, eh?
 
Or would make you one of the many other types of Christian. Perhaps one which, like most of the world's Christians, don't have any problem reconciling their faith with science.

Reconciling faith with science would require learning at least the basics of tne science. We've seen that isn't going to happen.
 
No worries.
But don't tell me that you're not triggered.

Why do you want me to lie?

I'm not "triggered" in any sense that I understand, and I worked with bairns suffering PTSD. You must be using some weird definition of the term if you think that your drivel could be "triggering".

Pro tip: use terms in a way which other people will clearly understand your meaning, rather than having to mind read?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom