Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

I had launched a topic about squaring my Christianity with Evolution.
The answer seemed to be that this was not possible.
Yet most non-Evangelical Christians manage it.

Discarding my Christianity would make me an atheist.
Or a different kind of Christian, or a different kind of religious person such as a Deist. Your Christianity is neither ancient nor globally popular.
 
Many of @Rusty Tyler's posts, in this as in a variety of other threads, triggered my laughter.
I'm not laughing with him/her/it/them...

Arrogantly foolish ignorance and idiocy are a staple of scripted comedy, as illustrated by much of what Monty Python gave to the world. But it's even funnier when the comedy is organic, delivered by someone who thinks he's serious.

Deliberate own goals aren't all that funny. Accidental own goals are funnier. When the scorer of an own goal celebrates the accomplishment with dancing and whoops of triumph, it's comedy gold.

That's not to say @Rusty Tyler can't improve his shtick. So far, almost all of his exertions consist of unintentional parody and mocking of fundamentalist Christians (as in this thread), with occasional excursions (in other threads) into self-parodic mockery of right-wing Americans or bigots. Even the best jokes become tiresome with repetition.

Although I'd like to see Rusty expand his range of inadvertent satire, I do still laugh at his efforts.
 
Interesting that any person of a religion that takes their scriptures seriously are considered extremists.

As if religious texts are not to be taken seriously as a follower of a religion.
All the available evidence shows that the vast majority of those who pretend to take their scripture seriously actually do not, since they obviously pick and choose the parts they like and discard the rest.
 
Why is it only religionistas of the fundy variety who use the term "evolutionist"?

I presume it's intended to be some class of an insult, but I don't understand how.
To be fair, its pretty common for groups to be named by their opponents when they don't necessarily have a name for themselves. There weren't a lot of folks calling them selves capitalists prior to Marx. I've never heard of a Christian dominionist calling themselves that either. Probably because of the narcissism of small differences. From the inside it's usually easier to see the differences within your group than it is to see the similarities.

That being said, I think calling the big bang a myth is not unreasonable. As someone else mentioned, myths aren't always false. Abiogenis and the emergence of consciousness. As far as I know the scientific consensus on both is, "we don't know how it happened". How is that a myth?

Abiogenisis, unless you think there has always been life, then at some point life clearly began. So, what's the atheists' myth there?
Same for consciousness. At some point human ancestors and possibly those of other extant species became conscious but weren't before. Unless you think consciousness is a myth or that all life is conscious, where's the myth?
 
That being said, I think calling the big bang a myth is not unreasonable.
"The Big Bang" is basically just shorthand for "If we extrapolate the size of the universe backwards in time, there is a point at which it goes to zero." That's an observation, not a myth, and it's been rigorously derived. We don't need any particular belief as to what happened at the point in time when that occurred to note that the extrapolation is valid.

Dave
 
Not every open question in science is a myth. I can draw a bright line between a creation myth such as than in Genesis and the open question of the precise nature of the Big Bang. The Genesis myth is an oral tradition with no clear connection to any sort of testable observation. Nevertheless it is believed by many, in one form or another. Some believe it as incontrovertible fact. A few believed it in contravention of fact—men do not have fewer ribs than women.

In contrast, the Big Bang is not properly believed as anything more than a theory. It is a hypothesis that explains a great deal of observation and manages a great deal of consistency and consilience, but as with any happenstance event we can't conceive of a way to test its keystone principle directly. That doesn't stop it from being eminently predictive. Once that theory stops being predictive, it will be unceremoniously replaced by a new one that is, but only on the basis of new observations.
 
Last edited:
"The Big Bang" is basically just shorthand for "If we extrapolate the size of the universe backwards in time, there is a point at which it goes to zero." That's an observation, not a myth, and it's been rigorously derived. We don't need any particular belief as to what happened at the point in time when that occurred to note that the extrapolation is valid.

Dave
I was thinking more along the lines of a foundational myth for a certain set of sciency types. Not as in a think that never happened. But, I see your point.

ETA: That's why there was a TV show about a bunch of scientists called the big bang theory and not abiogenesis.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom