Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

Equating the stages of scientific inquiry with myth?
What a juvenile thing to do!
It reminds me of when I was a pseudointellectual, sophomore college youngster and declared, "Science is just another form of superstition!"
Has Ehrman become a social media blowhard, where to keep up the sensation you must blow harder?
 
I'm late to the party. What are the 3 myths that atheists believe?

And if I can find one atheist that doesn't believe all 3 "myths" then does that mean that the entire premise of this thread is false or does it mean that the person is not an atheist?
 
Last edited:
Equating the stages of scientific inquiry with myth?
What a juvenile thing to do!
It reminds me of when I was a pseudointellectual, sophomore college youngster and declared, "Science is just another form of superstition!"
Has Ehrman become a social media blowhard, where to keep up the sensation you must blow harder?
Not sure what you are talking about here. Unless I missed it, Ehrman didn't say anything about 'the stages of scientific inquiry'. Here's what he did say:-
"So it's a religious myth. But I think there are atheist myths as well, things that people heartily believe or they just assume to be true, and... that's not empirically verifible, that nontheless we base our understanding of the world on it"
"You cannot empirically demonstrate where life came from"
"There are all sorts of theories of [how consciousness came about] which shows again that it's not something which is empirically demonstrable at this point"
And he's right. Bart Ehrman says he believes in the Big Bang because he trusts scientists who say they have some evidence for it. I don't. I think the Big Bang is a narrative which had a scientific theory fitted onto it because its creators wanted an origin story - IOW a myth.

Perhaps the Big Bang theory is 100% accurate, but science works better when we question the narrative. Michelson and Morley questioned the luminiferous aether myth, leading Einstein to develop his theory of relativity. This skepticism dramatically advanced the science of physics.

The abiogenesis of life on Earth is another 'myth' because scientists currently have no definite explanation for how it happened - if it did. One day we may figure it out, and then the myth will align with reality.

How consciuosness emerged or even what it is is hard to define. The list of organisms that are 'self-aware' keeps growing, and now includes some fish and insects - questioning our conveniently held beliefs about 'lower' animals.

Ehrman says:- "Your belief that you don't belive in myths is a myth".

Everybody believes in myths because that's how the human mind functions. We create a narrative from what we perceive and what we are told. That narrative is at best a very simplified and incomplete version of reality, chock full of assumptions about every element. This is necessary for our brains to make sense of the data.

To understand Ehrman's position you have to understand where the bible stands in historicism. This isn't about whether the myths are true or not, but how they evolved and influenced cultures. This is of particular interest to anyone who has been exposed to them via Christianity, but may also be of general interest. Atheists who simply dismiss them for being 'unscientific' are missing the point. Those who insist that they don't believe in any myths shouldn't be surprised when theists use that false belief against them.
 
Last edited:
Not sure what you are talking about here. Unless I missed it, Ehrman didn't say anything about 'the stages of scientific inquiry'. Here's what he did say:-

And he's right. Bart Ehrman says he believes in the Big Bang because he trusts scientists who say they have some evidence for it. I don't.
I think the Big Bang is a narrative which had a scientific theory fitted onto it because its creators wanted an origin story - IOW a myth
…snip…
No, the big bang (named by someone who didn’t agree with it) theory came first - it is one of the solutions to the mathematics, the narratives e.g. naming it the “big bang” theory came afterwards.
 
Like pulling teeth around here.
There was a Bert and Ernie sketch on Sesame Street where Ernie is upset to discover that his ice cube collection has disappeared after being left out over night. When Bert points out the puddle of water where the collection had been, Ernie jumps to the conclusion that a fish stole his ice cubes.

Don't be an Ernie.

We can trace back the universe back to within a fraction of a second of its origin. Don't insist that a magical fish is the best explanation to fill that gap.
 
Not sure what you are talking about here. Unless I missed it, Ehrman didn't say anything about 'the stages of scientific inquiry'. Here's what he did say:-

And he's right. Bart Ehrman says he believes in the Big Bang because he trusts scientists who say they have some evidence for it. I don't. I think the Big Bang is a narrative which had a scientific theory fitted onto it because its creators wanted an origin story - IOW a myth.

Perhaps the Big Bang theory is 100% accurate, but science works better when we question the narrative. Michelson and Morley questioned the luminiferous aether myth, leading Einstein to develop his theory of relativity. This skepticism dramatically advanced the science of physics.

The abiogenesis of life on Earth is another 'myth' because scientists currently have no definite explanation for how it happened - if it did. One day we may figure it out, and then the myth will align with reality.

How consciuosness emerged or even what it is is hard to define. The list of organisms that are 'self-aware' keeps growing, and now includes some fish and insects - questioning our conveniently held beliefs about 'lower' animals.

Ehrman says:- "Your belief that you don't belive in myths is a myth".

Everybody believes in myths because that's how the human mind functions. We create a narrative from what we perceive and what we are told. That narrative is at best a very simplified and incomplete version of reality, chock full of assumptions about every element. This is necessary for our brains to make sense of the data.

To understand Ehrman's position you have to understand where the bible stands in historicism. This isn't about whether the myths are true or not, but how they evolved and influenced cultures. This is of particular interest to anyone who has been exposed to them via Christianity, but may also be of general interest. Atheists who simply dismiss them for being 'unscientific' are missing the point. Those who insist that they don't believe in any myths shouldn't be surprised when theists use that false belief against them.
Now that's a better way to put it than saying science is just a refined sort of superstition. :wackygrin:
 
No, the big bang (named by someone who didn’t agree with it) theory came first - it is one of the solutions to the mathematics, the narratives e.g. naming it the “big bang” theory came afterwards.
Big Bang: before the name
in 1927, Georges Lemaître, a Belgian physicist and Roman Catholic priest, proposed that the recession of the nebulae was due to the expansion of the universe... In 1931, went further and suggested that the evident expansion of the universe, if projected back in time, meant that the further in the past the smaller the universe was, until at some finite time in the past all the mass of the universe was concentrated into a single point, a "primeval atom" where and when the fabric of time and space came into existence.
This wasn't a theory based on observed evidence, it was a narrative. Other cosmologists were rightly skeptical.
In the 1920s and 1930s, almost every major cosmologist preferred an eternal steady-state universe, and several complained that the beginning of time implied by an expanding universe imported religious concepts into physics;
The 'inflationists' then developed theories purporting to give the narrative credence.
Before the development of inflationary cosmology, the Big Bang model was extrapolated backwards in time to a Big Bang singularity. It was then followed by the Planck epoch, where the universe was extremely hot and dense... Even the very concept of a particle breaks down in these conditions. A proper understanding of this period awaits the development of a theory of quantum gravity. The initial singularity may be absent in a theory of quantum gravity; it arises from an extrapolation of general relativity.
The original idea was that the Universe gradually expanded from a singularity. The modern version is rather different, having a rapid inflationary period followed by a much slower expansion. Why? Because they can't make the math fit a gradual expansion. However there's no guarantee that the math matches reality. It's just one possible solution - a myth narrated with math.
 
Last edited:
It's just one possible solution - a myth narrated with math.
I still think that the word myth is misused here. A myth is something that is not true, or pure fiction presented as something real. A scientific conjecture only becomes a myth if it is highly unlikely to be true. I wouldn’t even put the unlikely string theories in that category.
 
Big Bang: before the name

This wasn't a theory based on observed evidence, it was a narrative. Other cosmologists were rightly skeptical.

The 'inflationists' then developed theories purporting to give the narrative credence.

The original idea was that the Universe gradually expanded from a singularity. The modern version is rather different, having a rapid inflationary period followed by a much slower expansion. Why? Because they can't make the math fit a gradual expansion. However there's no guarantee that the math matches reality. It's just one possible solution - a myth narrated with math.
It seems you want to substitute the word myth for hypothesis and theory.
 
Big Bang: before the name

This wasn't a theory based on observed evidence, it was a narrative. Other cosmologists were rightly skeptical.
It wasn't a theory based on a narrative. It was based on Einstein's general theory of relativity, combined with the empirical evidence that led Lemaître to formulate the Hubble-Lemaître law.

Einstein and quite a few others, notably Alexander Friedmann, had been exploring exact solutions of Einstein's field equations that could model what was known about the universe. Einstein and most others were hampered by their ideological prejudice that the universe must be unchanging (in a steady state). Friedmann derived his Friedmann equations from Einstein's field equations, thereby providing a precise mathematical account of how the universe might be expanding or contracting.

Friedmann died before Edwin Hubble and Georges Lemaître summarized the accumulating empirical evidence for expansion in (what is now known as) the Hubble-Lemaître law. Friedmann, Lemaître, Howard Robertson, and Arthur Geoffrey Walker are now given joint credit for the FLRW family of exact solutions to the field equations. The FLRW family contains models that are compatible with an expanding, contracting, or (in a couple of very special cases) a steady-state universe. It was the empirical evidence leading to the Hubble-Lemaître law that decided in favor of an expanding universe (together with the decisive fact that all of the competing steady-state models were unstable or empty of matter or had other outstanding defects).

Lemaître was the first to observe that extrapolation of FLRW models for an expanding universe backwards in time were inevitably cut off by a mathematical singularity. Lemaître observed that the mathematics and empirical evidence favored an expanding universe that began at or near that singularity. Lemaître called this idea the "hypothesis of the primeval atom".

Lemaître's hypothesis of the primeval atom is now more familiarly known as the Big Bang, which is the name invented for it in 1949 by Fred Hoyle, who was promoting his own steady state theories.

The 'inflationists' then developed theories purporting to give the narrative credence.
That's ridiculous. What we now know as the Big Bang was based on a well-attested theory (general relativity) plus empirical evidence. It was the Big Bang that overcame the then-prevailing narrative that led Einstein and most of his contemporaries to assume a steady-state universe.

The 'inflationists' didn't give credence to that steady-state narrative. Furthermore, the idea of inflation was not developed to give credence to the Big Bang theory either. It was developed as a possible explanation for the accumulation of solid empirical evidence indicating the universe had (at one time) expanded faster than could be explained by a pure FLRW model. In that sense, inflation was developed to overcome the prevailing narrative told by pure FLRW models.

The original idea was that the Universe gradually expanded from a singularity. The modern version is rather different, having a rapid inflationary period followed by a much slower expansion. Why? Because they can't make the math fit a gradual expansion. However there's no guarantee that the math matches reality. It's just one possible solution - a myth narrated with math.
The sentence I highlighted is completely wrong. The FLRW math fits a gradual expansion just fine, as has been known ever since Friedmann developed the Friedmann equations in 1922. The FLRW math also fits an accelerating expansion due to dark energy (the cosmological constant).

The rapid inflationary period was proposed (starting in the 1970s) because the FLRW math for an expanding universe could not explain certain empirical evidence that pointed toward a rather sudden and brief (so not gradual!) expansion early in the evolution of the universe.

It is of course true that there is no guarantee that the math matches reality. That is why numerous mathematical models of the universe have been rejected and are no longer taken seriously, or have been modified to provide a better fit to empirical evidence. The FLRW models, for example, have been modified (not rejected) by taking the cosmological constant seriously and by postulating a period of rapid inflation.

Your claim that all of the above is "a myth narrated with math" is about as wrong as it can be.
 
I still think that the word myth is misused here. A myth is something that is not true, or pure fiction presented as something real. A scientific conjecture only becomes a myth if it is highly unlikely to be true. I wouldn’t even put the unlikely string theories in that category.
We shouldn't have to go over this again. A myth is a story which has an influence on how people see the world. It doesn't have to be 'pure fiction', it just isn't currently known to be totally factual. The defining characteristic is the narrative, not how 'true' it is.

This is the scientific definition of myth that historians use when studying them. The definition you are using is the colloquial one, which should not be used in logical debates. To give an example, some atheists say that Jesus is a myth, ie. pure fiction - because there is no physical evidence for his existence and the stories about him are obvious fiction. But that's not how historians see it. Yes, the stories are myth, but the person who inspired those stories probably did exist. Furthermore they accept that at least some of those stories could be partially or even wholly 'factual' - ie. the narrative (such as it is) matches fact. But it will always be a narrative.

Scientists use narratives all the time too, "At the beginning of Time the Universe was a singularity" is a narrative. That math was used to create this narrative doesn't make it any less so. Cosmologists today don't talk about a singularity because it's currently unverifiable and probably just an artifact of the math, but this didn't stop Lemaître from invoking it. Why did he? Perhaps because his religious belief favored such a 'beginning'. So he created the myth of the Big Bang. That's not saying a 'big bang' didn't happen, but its purported origin wasn't based on observed facts.
 
Last edited:
The sentence I highlighted is completely wrong. The FLRW math fits a gradual expansion just fine, as has been known ever since Friedmann developed the Friedmann equations in 1922. The FLRW math also fits an accelerating expansion due to dark energy (the cosmological constant).

The rapid inflationary period was proposed (starting in the 1970s) because the FLRW math for an expanding universe could not explain certain empirical evidence that pointed toward a rather sudden and brief (so not gradual!) expansion early in the evolution of the universe.
You contradict yourself. The math which was used to create the narrative of a gradually expanding Universe turned out to not match reality. So the math was changed. That's fine, this is how science works. But it doesn't mean the Big Bang theory wasn't a myth - in fact it proves that it was a myth. The current Big Bang theory is a different one that proposes a rapid expansion before the period that is visible to us. In the future we may have to change that math too, which makes it also a myth. We don't know what actually happened, and are just presuming that the math is right.

It is of course true that there is no guarantee that the math matches reality. That is why numerous mathematical models of the universe have been rejected and are no longer taken seriously, or have been modified to provide a better fit to empirical evidence. The FLRW models, for example, have been modified (not rejected) by taking the cosmological constant seriously and by postulating a period of rapid inflation.
Weasel words. This is like saying that Aristotle's math describing falling bodies wasn't rejected, it was just 'modified'. The interesting thing here is that Aristotle could easily have tested his theory, and then he would have found that it was very wrong. But he preferred to perpetuate the popular myth that heavier things fall faster.
 
Last edited:
We shouldn't have to go over this again. A myth is a story which has an influence on how people see the world. It doesn't have to be 'pure fiction', it just isn't currently known to be totally factual. The defining characteristic is the narrative, not how 'true' it is.
That means that most actual history is just myths, at least if it is not known to be purely factual. For instance, the life and death of Caesar must be a myth because it has inspired the world view of many people – particularly military men, and nobles – but it is probably not entirely factual.
 
You contradict yourself. The math which was used to create the narrative of a gradually expanding Universe turned out to not match reality. So the math was changed. That's fine, this is how science works. But it doesn't mean the Big Bang theory wasn't a myth - in fact it proves that it was a myth. The current Big Bang theory is a different one that proposes a rapid expansion before the period that is visible to us. In the future we may have to change that math too , which makes it also a myth. We don't know what actually happened, and are just presuming that the math is right .
You're talking as though you don't understand the relationship between mathematics and physical theories.

There is absolutely no doubt concerning whether the FLRW models are exact solutions of Einstein's field equations. They are. There is an infinite number of other solutions to those field equations as well, although a vanishingly small proportion of those other solutions can be expressed in closed form. All of that math is right. The math hasn't been changed, and won't be changed.

What could change, and what has been changed, and what will be changed, is which mathematical models we believe best fit our knowledge of the universe. (Note that the word "models" is plural, because we seldom find that any one model is best for all purposes; throughout science, we generally use a model that's a good fit for some specific purpose, and are willing to use a slightly different model for some related purpose.)

We know, for example, that Einstein's general theory of relativity can't give us a perfect model of the universe, because that theory leads to mathematical singularities, which means the theory can't possibly be a completely correct model of reality. On the other hand, the theory of general relativity has passed every experimental and empirical test we've been able to throw at it, which is why it is considered one of the most successful theories in the history of physics.

We also know that FLRW models are (at best) approximations to physical reality, because they are based on several very explicit assumptions about the universe that we know to be true only approximately. It is those approximations that made it possible to express the FLRW models as exact solutions of the field equstions in closed form.

Everyone who understands the relationship between mathematics and physical theories, and is at all familiar with general relativity and modern cosmology, is perfectly aware and has been perfectly aware that the FLRW models are useful primarily because they are simple enough to be mathematically tractable. Everyone who understands this subject is aware, and has been aware, that seeking an even better fit between mathematical models and physical reality involves trading the simplicity and exactness of the FLRW models for more complicated models that are either inexact solutions of the field equations or too complicated to be expressed in closed form.

Adding an inflationary period to the model is an example of that tradeoff.

That is how science works. If that turns the Big Bang into a myth, then all of science is a myth.


I wrote those words in 2015. I strongly recommend you follow the link, and read the three paragraphs that precede those words.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom