Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

The term creation ex nihilo has been around since the 2nd century.
The Bible hasn't budged an inch as long as I have been around.
So some dude in the second century decided your god had existed forever? Before then no one knew that?

Your selective interpretations of your bible are all over the map and frequently have no connection to what is actually written. Perhaps you don't realize that posters in this thread can read and remember what you have written in your copious other threads.
 
So some dude in the second century decided your god had existed forever? Before then no one knew that?

Your selective interpretations of your bible are all over the map and frequently have no connection to what is actually written. Perhaps you don't realize that posters in this thread can read and remember what you have written in your copious other threads.

That's not right. It had to be way earlier than that.

I'm pretty sure it was Aristotle who first posited that God must be eternal. The ancient Hebrews might have already been believing in an eternal god, but Aristotle was the first to formulate it as a logical argument.
.
 
Last edited:
God is the Creator, He was not created.

creation ex nihilo

created out of nothing

Once again: either the concept of something existing without having been created is acceptable or it isn't. If you're willing to entertain the idea of god existing without being created you can't simply dismiss the idea of the universe existing without being created because the two ideas are logically identical. Conversely if you refuse to accept the idea of the universe existing without being created you have no grounds for insisting god can exist without being created.

This is one of the two major problems with the First Cause argument: the argument itself violates the assumption on which it's based.

[The other is that that assumption is now known to be false. But you've got a lot to learn before you're ready for quantum mechanics].
 
Why?

Why?
I will entertain this even though it is quite obvious. One thing is just a word for what must have happened. It says nothing about how or why, just that it happened. Again, I suppose if you are of the opinion that there was never a time prior to life existing then there was no abiogenesis. I think there was almost certainly a time when life did not exist and now life exists so that change happened and the name we give it is abiogenesis. The other is an attempt to explain the why and how. To some degree the genesis story is a story about how abiogenesis happened.

Now there some scientific hypotheses as to how life started, to my knowledge none have gotten past the hypothesis stage. As to why, there is no need for a why. There may be a why but that isn't something most atheists think is a thing in the cases of any of your three myths. That is one of the assumptions of the naturalist world view, the universe nor nature have intent.
 
God is the Creator, He was not created.

creation ex nihilo

created out of nothing

So it's Christians, not atheists, who actually believe in "something from nothing."

Meanwhile, nothing about atheism requires a belief that anything "came from nothing."

How exceedingly dishonest of all those apologist ding dongs who accuse atheists of believing the very thing that the Christians themselves actually believe as a matter of doctrine.

Typical right-wing projection tactics. Y'all don't know how to argue honestly or how to think critically.
.
 
Last edited:
The term creation ex nihilo has been around since the 2nd century.
The Bible hasn't budged an inch as long as I have been around.

Yeah, some of us studied Latin, so we know what it means.

And you still haven't told me what you mean by "triggered"; I told you I understand it in terms of my work with bairns suffering PTSD, i.e. how someone with PTSD might react to certain situations, words, people etc.

What exactly do you mean?
 
Like the lizards that you have been linked to before?

*Cough* Darwin's finches *Cough*

And I'm not going to mention the utter morass of the genera Salix nor Dactylorhiza and trying to sort out any sort of speciation from that lot and, blow me, but I seriously tried with Dactylorhiza...

Just to point out that speciation can be very, very, very , very complicated indeed, even with DNA analysis.
 
Last edited:
The Universe exists. Created out of nothing. No god required. QED

(Thank you Mr Ockham!)
I think you can go one step further, the universe exists, the universe has always existed. It may not have always looked like it does to us today, it may look very different in another 16 billion years and a trillion year from now intelligence may have evolved.
 
I think you can go one step further, the universe exists, the universe has always existed. It may not have always looked like it does to us today, it may look very different in another 16 billion years and a trillion year from now intelligence may have evolved.
Ah, the Pulsating Steady State Universe model.
 
Abiogenesis is one of this thread's three original examples of an accepted fact that @Rusty Tyler does not accept as fact.

The following exchange is an excellent example of @Rusty Tyler rejecting that rather obvious fact simply because @Rusty Tyler doesn't want to understand why it is an obvious fact.
Life exists therefore it must have started, abiogenesis.
I will entertain this even though it is quite obvious. One thing is just a word for what must have happened. It says nothing about how or why, just that it happened. Again, I suppose if you are of the opinion that there was never a time prior to life existing then there was no abiogenesis. I think there was almost certainly a time when life did not exist and now life exists so that change happened and the name we give it is abiogenesis.
Expanding upon that, because science is far more interesting than @Rusty Tyler's ignorance of science, abiogenesis is implied by these two observations:
  1. Life exists.
  2. Life did not always exist.
If anyone is capable of denying the first of those observations, it would be @Rusty Tyler, but I doubt whether even he disputes that first fact.

Which leads us to conclude that @Rusty Tyler's objection to abiogenesis must be rooted in his denial of that second observation: that life did not always exist.

Which is curious, because both of the Biblical creation accounts begin when there was no life as we know it. In the first account, the first form of life (plants) didn't arrive until the third day. The second account is less specific about the timing, but does say (according to the KJV) that "in the day that the LORD God made the earth and the heavens," He/She/It also made "every plant of the field before it was in the earth." I emphasize the word "before" because, although the KJV is a bit ambiguous as to when those plants were created, the KJV does say there was a time before plants were in the earth.
Other translations are a bit clearer about this, as in "When the LORD God made the universe, there were no plants on the earth..."

So the second fact I listed is supported by the plain text of the creation story @Rusty Tyler is so desperate to believe, yet he cannot reject abiogenesis without rejecting that second fact.

We can imagine various creative ways in which a desperate Bible-thumper might seek to deny the second fact while insisting upon a literal reading of the two creation accounts in Genesis. One is to say something like "well, God already existed, and God is life." The obvious problem with that dodge is that abiogenesis is concerned with life as we know it, and the two numbered facts are also referring to life as we know it, so any attempt to slither out of abiogenesis by saying God was a pre-existing form of life would be nothing more than dishonest equivocation.

Another possible dodge would be to say the creation accounts in Genesis should not be taken so literally.

Rather than try to imagine how a desperate Bible-thumper might try to wriggle out of that second numbered fact, I leave that task to @Rusty Tyler.

The scientific basis for those two numbered facts is more interesting.

The first numbered fact is quite interesting of itself, but is seldom disputed so we can move on to the second numbered fact.

The second numbered fact is a little bit ambiguous with respect to whether we're talking about life on earth or life in the universe in general. When we talk about abiogenesis, however, we are usually discussing life on earth, so I'll stick with that for now. The scientific evidence for that second numbered fact comes down to this:
  1. The earth has been around for a little over 4.5 billion years.
  2. There is solid evidence for life on earth about 3.5 billion years ago, with less reliable indications of life that might push that back further, and some have speculated life could have begun as far back as 4.3 billion years ago.
  3. The earth's first half-billion years are known as the Hadean eon, because the earth was a hellish place during those years.
  4. For the first couple of million years of that Hadean eon, the earth was covered by molten lava, which is decidedly inhospitable to life as we know it.
So there was no life on earth. Now there is. Which means abiogenesis is a thing.

Well, not so fast. There's this panspermia idea, where life as we know it on earth came from Mars or some other extraterrestrial source, but that doesn't get rid of abiogenesis. It just shifts abiogenesis to some other extraterrestrial source.

Unless, of course, life as we know it has existed in our universe ever since the Big Bang. The problem with that dodge is that we have a pretty good idea of what the universe was like during the first half hour following the Big Bang, and life as we know it is incompatible with the creation of light elements during nucleosynthesis.

So abiogenesis was a thing, unless we're badly wrong about the history of the earth and the universe.

As for HOW abiogenesis occurred, that's a great deal more uncertain than the simple fact of abiogenesis:
Now there some scientific hypotheses as to how life started, to my knowledge none have gotten past the hypothesis stage. As to why, there is no need for a why. There may be a why but that isn't something most atheists think is a thing in the cases of any of your three myths. That is one of the assumptions of the naturalist world view, the universe nor nature have intent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom