Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Peter May: If you don’t know the specific working conditions for the EDX, and how it was applied, you are really out on a limb as it where

The understatement of the month, maybe the year. Little old Harrit Chemistry PhD, with Max Planck Institute under his belt and decades of experience, says after actually doing the research(including all the little tests that are done for checks)that the XEDS will not detect the fluorine because they also have iron.

But oh no, Oystein and Sunstealer, two blokes who have no chemistry expertise, have not done the work in the lab, and dare not say anything using their real names, claim that Harrit is just wrong because he is an amateur poo-poo head.

After all, Oystein can get his signal using a computer simulation, and with all his expertise, he does not have to consider that the real world could present challenges, and without actual experiments he can give "the word of God" in this matter.:p

And what has happened to their old mantra of FTIR being the conclusive and competent test, while Harrits methods are "incompetent"? Of course now that they have Harrit FTIR that matches superthermite with fluorine, they ignore the FTIR and use the old "incompetent" XEDS to prove the FTIR wrong!:D

For God´s sake, you guys are impossible, but very funny in a tragic sort of way.
 
... For God´s sake, you guys are impossible, but very funny in a tragic sort of way.

Harrit lied about thermite (his fantasy). He says there were hundreds of tons of thermite used on 911. An insane lie. Do you believe lies? You are missing the Big E in JREF.

Gullible people believe Harrit's claims. 11 years of failure; what is stopping 911 truth from the Big Pulitzer? lol, you have fantasy, a fake paper, and nuts like Jones and Harrit.

Have you tried 60 minutes? Don't show them the graphs that don't match; that was funny. Do all 911 truth believers need to take pattern recognition courses?
 
4 years since the paper was published and they still haven't published the FTIR data. Frauds.
 
"4 years since the paper was published and they still haven't published the FTIR data. Frauds."

The ball is really in Dr. Millette's court.

Dr. Millette claimed his WTC dust red/gray chip samples were isolated by following the selection methods described by Dr. Jones and Dr. Harrit et al in the 2009 Bentham Paper.

Since his work was referenced to the sample selection methods used by Dr. Harrit et al, it is reasonable to assume that Dr. Millette conscientiously read the 2009 Bentham Report before he undertook using its methods for finding red/gray chips of interest.

Dr. Jones even posted his surprise about Dr. Millette not bothering to expedite the isolation process by using the described resistivity findings clearly described in the Bentham paper.

It begs the question as to whether Dr. Millette ever bothered to read any further than, "red/gray chips attracted to a magnet"?

Which means he sorted visually from a larger pile of chips.

Anyone who has ever drawn a strong magnet through sand or fine demolition debris has see how many chips are quickly collected.

The potential for collecting and testing red/gray chips that were actually primer paint was quite high using Dr. Millette's limited sorting method.

But primer paint chips were found to have very high electrical resistance compared to the very low electrical resistance of the chips that were found to be thermitic.

By only using chips that showed very low resistance, the chance of isolating thermitic red/gray chips is greatly enhanced.

And even if Dr. Millette steadfastly refuses to heat his chips to 430C, he could still repeat his original test method but instead use chips that have the similar low electrical resistance of those found to be thermitic.

It is not the more conclusive 430C heat test but at least we would have more agreement that Dr. Millette was likely looking at some of the right chips. Keeping in mind that there are likely red/gray chips showing low electrical resistivity that are not thermitic.

But we do not know why Dr. Millette, chooses not to check-off resistivity test box?

So to answer your question Sunstealer.

Until Dr. Millette bothers to get his paper approved for publication, there is no reason for Dr. Jones and Dr. Harrit et al to make further argument by investing in published updates.

MM
 
Last edited:
Until Dr. Millette bothers to get his paper approved for publication, there is no reason for Dr. Jones and Dr. Harrit et al to make further argument by investing in published updates.

MM

So, MM, you are perfectly content to ignore all the things that Jones and his crew said they were going to do, but never did and never will?

That is convenient.

I used to say that "thermite" was the punch line to Jones' failed career, but I hear he has recently gone even further off the rails so... Yay, MM?
 
The ball is really in Dr. Millette's court.

MM

As much as you like to pretend this is true, we all know it's not. The Harrit paper is only known in conspiracy circles (it's audience).

Perhaps you could show us the impact this has had outside of this venue? :rolleyes:

ETA: To be fair, I think it was cited once outside in a study of fraud in "pay to publish" journals.
 
Last edited:
The ball is really in Dr. Millette's court.
Not really, there has never been a game. The Harrit et al paper has had zero effect in the scientific world.

Dr. Millette claimed his WTC dust red/gray chip samples were isolated by following the selection methods described by Dr. Jones and Dr. Harrit et al in the 2009 Bentham Paper.
Yes, and there is direct evidence that he did exactly that.

You obviously haven't read Dr Millette's progress report. https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/64959841/9119ProgressReport022912_rev1_030112webHiRes.pdf

Since his work was referenced to the sample selection methods used by Dr. Harrit et al, it is reasonable to assume that Dr. Millette conscientiously read the 2009 Bentham Report before he undertook using its methods for finding red/gray chips of interest.
Yes he did.

Dr. Jones even posted his surprise about Dr. Millette not bothering to expedite the isolation process by using the described resistivity findings clearly described in the Bentham paper.
You know the answer to this because it's already been aluded to several times in the other thread. You are simply being facetious and dishonest by ignoring the fact that resistivity testing was not part of the methodology for isolating chips. Stop lying. Jones is squirming because he knows he has been found out. He'll pull anything from his behind because he knows any competent study will show Harrit/Jones/Farrer etc for the incompetents they are.

It begs the question as to whether Dr. Millette ever bothered to read any further than, "red/gray chips attracted to a magnet"?
Stop lying. He obviously did. If you had read the progress report thoruoughly and understood the words therein you would know that Millette specifies a criteria based solely on the Harrit et al paper. How come Millette knows to look for EDX spectra containing Al/SiFe if he didn't read past the isolation by magnet?

Here it is:

Methods

In order to confirm that the samples chosen had the characteristics of WTC dust, the samples were examined by stereomicroscope and by polarized light microscopy (PLM) according to the procedures described in Turner et al., 20054 (Figures 2 and 3). The analytical procedures used to characterize the red/gray chips were based on the criteria for the particles of interest in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives5 and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison.6 The criteria for the particles of interest as described by Harrit et al.1 are: small red/gray chips attracted by a magnet and showing an elemental composition primarily of aluminum, silicon and iron as determined by scanning electron microscopy and x-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) (Figure 4). The spectrum may also contain small peaks related to other elements. To that end, the following protocol was performed on each of the four WTC dust samples.

1. The dust sample particles contained in a plastic bag were drawn across a
magnet and those attracted to the magnet were collected (Figure 5).

2.Using a stereomicroscope, particle chips showing the characteristic red/gray were removed and washed in clean water.

3. The particles were dried and mounted on a carbon adhesive film on an SEM stub and photographed (Figure 6).

4. Analysis of the surfaces of the chips was done by SEM-EDS at 20 kV without any added conductive coating (Figures 7 and 8).

Red/gray particles that matched the criteria (attracted to a magnet) and an
EDS Al-Si-Fe spectrum) were then considered particles of interest and subjected to additional analytical testing.
It's all there MM but for some reason you are choosing to ignore Millette's own words written in black and white and instead chose to build a strawman.

This is wilfully dishonest.

Which means he sorted visually from a larger pile of chips.
A lie. See above. He used a very specific criteria. Stop lying.

Anyone who has ever drawn a strong magnet through sand or fine demolition debris has see how many chips are quickly collected.
Yes, funny how the Harrit et al paper never mentions any other material other than red/gray thermite chips being separated by magnet.

The potential for collecting and testing red/gray chips that were actually primer paint was quite high using Dr. Millette's limited sorting method.
You mean the exact same sorting method that Harrit et al used. The fact that Harrit et al found paint chips. :rolleyes: Again you have been categorically schooled on this subject, but you aren't big enough to admit that you got it wrong.

But primer paint chips were found to have very high electrical resistance compared to the very low electrical resistance of the chips that were found to be thermitic.
Stop lying. You can't help it can you. No chips in the Harrit et al paper were considered to be paint and no paint chips were tested for their electrical resistivity in the paper.

Why do you continually lie? You know you'll be found out so why do you do it?

What the authors did was compare their resistivity reading from a single chip with data from a small number of paints.

By only using chips that showed very low resistance, the chance of isolating thermitic red/gray chips is greatly enhanced.
Another lie. Stop it.

There is absolutely no indication in Harrit et al that concludes that the red/gray chips or any other material separated by magnet isn't thermite.

What you are doing is trying to confuse matters because you know full well that Millette's study completely and utterly backs my initial analysis 4 years ago and debunks Harrit and the truth movement's silly nano-thermite nonsense.

And even if Dr. Millette steadfastly refuses to heat his chips to 430C, he could still repeat his original test method but instead use chips that have the similar low electrical resistance of those found to be thermitic.
No one has heated their chips to 430°C only. Again you have been told this over and over yet you steadfastly refuse to acknowledge this fact.

Again you use the red-herring of electrical resistivity testing that you made up in your head. Stop doing it. You have already been shown to be wrong by the very authors of the paper!

It is not the more conclusive 430C heat test but at least we would have more agreement that Dr. Millette was likely looking at some of the right chips. Keeping in mind that there are likely red/gray chips showing low electrical resistivity that are not thermitic.
Let's see if you will answer some simple questions. I'll start with only one because there is no point in asking more than one simple question when your record of refusing to answer is so complete.

In the Harrit et al paper fig 7 has EDX spectrums of the red layers for samples a-d.

Do you agree with the paper's authors that the red material in samples a-d is the same? yes/no.

I predict that you will refuse to answer this.

But we do not know why Dr. Millette, chooses not to check-off resistivity test box?
I know and everyone who has read his progress report along with the Harrit paper knows.

It simply isn't required and was never a stipulation for isolating red/gray chips.

You make yourself look very childish, stubborn and silly by continuing to push this non-existent resistivity testing meme that you have simply made up and that Jones uses to try and deflect the truth. It doesn't wash - drop it.

So to answer your question Sunstealer.

Until Dr. Millette bothers to get his paper approved for publication, there is no reason for Dr. Jones and Dr. Harrit et al to make further argument by investing in published updates.
MM
No that is not what my post is about. It has nothing to do with Dr Millette. It was a simple statement of fact.

MM - Has Harrit or any other author reported the FTIR results? yes/no

You will ignore this as well because you know the answer is no.

The authors promise to do so and that was expressly stated in their own paper.

From the Harrit et al paper, Page 26, paragraph 4, 3rd sentence:

The Gash report describes FTIR spectra which characterize this energetic material. We have performed these same tests and will report the results elsewhere.

So 4 years later and they haven't reported the FTIR data anywhere. My statement stands.

When will they do that and why aren't you asking them to release the data?

What have they got to hide? I predict that we will never see the data.
 
Posters in this thread may be interested to know that Dr. Jones is scheduled to talk about 9/11 research on 22 April (3pm-6pm), on K-talk, 630AM radio.
 
Hit and run, no comment? Jones on LDS myths and 911 truth myths - a pattern of woo

Posters in this thread may be interested to know that Dr. Jones is scheduled to talk about 9/11 research on 22 April (3pm-6pm), on K-talk, 630AM radio.
LDS myths and thermite? The radio might esplode. Is it ethical to make up science to support LDS myths? Jones faked the thermite study, is he faking the LDS myth stuff too? Is Jones insane, or what?
 
Last edited:
Sunstealer:
So 4 years later and they haven't reported the FTIR data anywhere. My statement stands.

When will they do that and why aren't you asking them to release the data?

What have they got to hide? I predict that we will never see the data.

They did release their data, and even you have seen it and commented on it on this very thread. But you go on acting like Clinton; deny; deny; deny
It is so funny to watch:D

4 years since the paper was published and they still haven't published the FTIR data. Frauds

Oh so publishing does matter after all. It is good seeing you admitting that fact Sunstealer, and maybe you can now demand in public that Millette validates his paper by publishing it, or obviously he is a fraud by your own standard.

In the Harrit et al paper fig 7 has EDX spectrums of the red layers for samples a-d.

Do you agree with the paper's authors that the red material in samples a-d is the same?

OH really? You mean the EDX is actually used to identify the chips? :rolleyes:
Oh gosh, but haven´t you heard, your buddies all say this fancy smancy EDX is not relevant at all, and NOT used to identify the chips, so why are you asking?:covereyes
 
Sunstealer:

Oh so publishing does matter after all. It is good seeing you admitting that fact Sunstealer, and maybe you can now demand in public that Millette validates his paper by publishing it, or obviously he is a fraud by your own standard.

You do know that the word "publish" can have more than one meaning, right? Publish means "make it available to the public."

Cool use of bolding though, champ, that way people just scanning the thread can easily note where you **** the bed.
 
It's a Sin to Tell a Lie.

Sunstealer

So 4 years later and they haven't reported the FTIR data anywhere. My statement stands.

When will they do that and why aren't you asking them to release the data?

What have they got to hide? I predict that we will never see the data.

Sunstealer:

They did release their data, and even you have seen it and commented on it on this very thread. But you go on acting like Clinton; deny; deny; deny
It is so funny to watch:D

I call meadow muffins on you, JTL. Show us where Harrit or Jones have published their FTIR data, and I will retract. But for now, I'm calling you a liar. (Show us that you credulously believed someone else who said that the data had been published, and I'll retract "liar" for "fool".
 
Sunstealer:

They did release their [FTIR] data,
Liar.

...seeing you admitting that fact Sunstealer
Liar.

Oh gosh, but haven´t you heard, your buddies all say this fancy smancy EDX is not relevant at all,
Liar

and NOT used to identify the chips,
Liar


What do you hope to achieve by lying?


so why are you asking?
Just answer the question: Do you agree with the paper's authors that the red material in samples a-d is the same, based on the similarity of their EDS spectra and everything else?
 
......

MM - Has Harrit or any other author reported the FTIR results? yes/no

You will ignore this as well because you know the answer is no.
The authors promise to do so and that was expressly stated in their own paper.

From the Harrit et al paper, Page 26, paragraph 4, 3rd sentence:
Quote:
The Gash report describes FTIR spectra which characterize this energetic material. We have performed these same tests and will report the results elsewhere.

So 4 years later and they haven't reported the FTIR data anywhere. My statement stands.
When will they do that and why aren't you asking them to release the data?
What have they got to hide? I predict that we will never see the data.
My hilite
[FONT=&quot]Forms of scientific misconduct

The U.S. National Science Foundation defines three types of research misconduct: fabrication,[/FONT] falsification[FONT=&quot], and plagiarism[9][10][/FONT]

  • [FONT=&quot]Falsification[/FONT][FONT=&quot] is manipulating research materials, equipment, or processes or changing or omitting data or results such that the research is not accurately represented in the research record.[/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]Suppression/non-publication of data[/FONT]
· [FONT=&quot]A related issue concerns the deliberate suppression, [/FONT]
failure to publish[FONT=&quot], or selective release of the findings of scientific studies. [/FONT][FONT=&quot]Such cases may not be strictly definable as scientific misconduct as the deliberate falsification of results is not present. However,[/FONT] in such cases the intent may nevertheless be to deliberately deceive. Studies may be suppressed or remain unpublished because the findings are perceived to undermine the commercial, political or other interests of the sponsoring agent or because they fail to support the ideological goals of the researcher. ....
· [FONT=&quot]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_misconduct[/FONT]
 
Studies may be suppressed or remain unpublished because the findings are perceived to undermine the commercial, political or other interests of the sponsoring agent or because they fail to support the ideological goals of the researcher. ...

This is the perfect description of Millette´s situation. Mohr had announced that the paper was about to get published, but then Jones and others tear it to shreds, and Millette won´t publish because it would undermine the sponor´s(JREF) desire to debunk. And as Sunstealer has indicated, the guy is a fraud if he does not publish, which is true. But Sunstealer can´t demand that Millette publishes and clears his name, because he knows the paper is bunk.
 
This is the perfect description of Millette´s situation. Mohr had announced that the paper was about to get published, but then Jones and others tear it to shreds, and Millette won´t publish because it would undermine the sponor´s(JREF) desire to debunk. And as Sunstealer has indicated, the guy is a fraud if he does not publish, which is true. But Sunstealer can´t demand that Millette publishes and clears his name, because he knows the paper is bunk.

God you come out with some ****
 
Originally Posted by Redwood
Is Jtl another "suicide by mod"?


I guess he must have got to close to the truth and the mod must have seen his/her bonus going out the window.;)

Maybe he was about to provide a link to Harrit's published FTIR data:

Originally Posted by Redwood
Show us where Harrit or Jones have published their FTIR data, and I will retract. But for now, I'm calling you a liar. (Show us that you credulously believed someone else who said that the data had been published, and I'll retract "liar" for "fool".

NOT!
 
Not really, there has never been a game. The Harrit et al paper has had zero effect in the scientific world.

Yes, and there is direct evidence that he did exactly that.

You obviously haven't read Dr Millette's progress report. https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/64959841/9119ProgressReport022912_rev1_030112webHiRes.pdf

Yes he did.

You know the answer to this because it's already been aluded to several times in the other thread. You are simply being facetious and dishonest by ignoring the fact that resistivity testing was not part of the methodology for isolating chips. Stop lying. Jones is squirming because he knows he has been found out. He'll pull anything from his behind because he knows any competent study will show Harrit/Jones/Farrer etc for the incompetents they are.

Stop lying. He obviously did. If you had read the progress report thoruoughly and understood the words therein you would know that Millette specifies a criteria based solely on the Harrit et al paper. How come Millette knows to look for EDX spectra containing Al/SiFe if he didn't read past the isolation by magnet?

Here it is:

It's all there MM but for some reason you are choosing to ignore Millette's own words written in black and white and instead chose to build a strawman.

This is wilfully dishonest.

A lie. See above. He used a very specific criteria. Stop lying.

Yes, funny how the Harrit et al paper never mentions any other material other than red/gray thermite chips being separated by magnet.

You mean the exact same sorting method that Harrit et al used. The fact that Harrit et al found paint chips. :rolleyes: Again you have been categorically schooled on this subject, but you aren't big enough to admit that you got it wrong.

Stop lying. You can't help it can you. No chips in the Harrit et al paper were considered to be paint and no paint chips were tested for their electrical resistivity in the paper.

Why do you continually lie? You know you'll be found out so why do you do it?

What the authors did was compare their resistivity reading from a single chip with data from a small number of paints.

Another lie. Stop it.

There is absolutely no indication in Harrit et al that concludes that the red/gray chips or any other material separated by magnet isn't thermite.

What you are doing is trying to confuse matters because you know full well that Millette's study completely and utterly backs my initial analysis 4 years ago and debunks Harrit and the truth movement's silly nano-thermite nonsense.

No one has heated their chips to 430°C only. Again you have been told this over and over yet you steadfastly refuse to acknowledge this fact.

Again you use the red-herring of electrical resistivity testing that you made up in your head. Stop doing it. You have already been shown to be wrong by the very authors of the paper!

Let's see if you will answer some simple questions. I'll start with only one because there is no point in asking more than one simple question when your record of refusing to answer is so complete.

In the Harrit et al paper fig 7 has EDX spectrums of the red layers for samples a-d.

Do you agree with the paper's authors that the red material in samples a-d is the same? yes/no.

I predict that you will refuse to answer this.

I know and everyone who has read his progress report along with the Harrit paper knows.

It simply isn't required and was never a stipulation for isolating red/gray chips.

You make yourself look very childish, stubborn and silly by continuing to push this non-existent resistivity testing meme that you have simply made up and that Jones uses to try and deflect the truth. It doesn't wash - drop it.

No that is not what my post is about. It has nothing to do with Dr Millette. It was a simple statement of fact.

MM - Has Harrit or any other author reported the FTIR results? yes/no

You will ignore this as well because you know the answer is no.

The authors promise to do so and that was expressly stated in their own paper.

From the Harrit et al paper, Page 26, paragraph 4, 3rd sentence:



So 4 years later and they haven't reported the FTIR data anywhere. My statement stands.

When will they do that and why aren't you asking them to release the data?

What have they got to hide? I predict that we will never see the data.

Do you really expect a reply to such raving?

I am not lying.

Dr. Harrit et al, to the best of my knowledge, are not lying, and I see no motivation for them to misrepresent their work by lying.

But why should I waste my time thoughtfully replying to garbage.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom