Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Bottom line my dear, Harrit et al NEVER said the layers are "about the same", like you tried to say.
Does he say any object is 10x larger than any other object? Did Harrit say it? Or did you make that up when you wrote "When someone says object X is 10 times as large as object Y... "? :)

...
You keep making silly assumptions, even if you have a gray layer that is 10% the thickness of the red layer, that does not mean this gray layer covers the whole area of the red layer, it could be just a tiny gray layer covering 10% of the area, cutting down your assumption of mass by a factor of 10.
Now you are making silly assumptions :)

There is nothing peculiar about this energy given organic matrix and air ignition. And there is also no point arguing about whether the proposed embedded nanothermite provided 25% of the energy or some other number. As long as a thermite reaction provides some of the energy, the hypothesis of a "thermitic material" is valid.
It's your prerogative to think such silly thoughts.

Except that doesn't coincide with what Harrit, Jones, Griscom... think. They think the large peaks in the DSC curves were made by thermite.
When thermite provides less than 25% of the energy - and it definitely does - then the peaks are made by mere organic combustion on air. Which isn't explosive, and which doesn't get very hot. And that little bit of hypothetical thermite heat also can't make the products particularly hot. Hence, this material cannot cut through steel.
 
Oystein: They think the large peaks in the DSC curves were made by thermite.

No they don´t, they actually go to considerable trouble to explain the difference between traditional thermite and these new hybrid materials or
"superthermites", but since you all have not understood in 4 years, you never will. But keep displaying your ignorance, it is amusing.

Over and out, this is pointless.
 
No they don´t, they actually go to considerable trouble to explain the difference between traditional thermite and these new hybrid materials or
"superthermites", but since you all have not understood in 4 years, you never will. But keep displaying your ignorance, it is amusing.

Over and out, this is pointless.

In respect to what Oystein is pointing out, what exact characteristics of this SuperThermite would lead it to "large peaks in the DSC curves" when tested in air?


I hear it was "military grade". Maybe you could check the MILSPEC on it. Good luck!
 
jtl: Dids Harrit et al say any object is 10x larger than any other object? Or did you make that up when you wrote "When someone says object X is 10 times as large as object Y... "? :)

No they don´t, they actually go to considerable trouble to explain the difference between traditional thermite and these new hybrid materials or
"superthermites", but since you all have not understood in 4 years, you never will. But keep displaying your ignorance, it is amusing.

Over and out, this is pointless.

Do any of these new hybrid materials or "superthermites" derive 75% and more of their energy output from organic polymers burning on ambient air?
 
Last edited:
No they don´t, they actually go to considerable trouble to explain the difference between traditional thermite and these new hybrid materials or
"superthermites", but since you all have not understood in 4 years, you never will. But keep displaying your ignorance, it is amusing.

Over and out, this is pointless.
6 2 and even, over and out?

Jones paper shows DSC for thermite and it does not match the DSC for the dust. The DSC for the dust in Jones paper looks like a DSC for soil, why? Discuss. The DSC for the dust in Jones paper looks like a DSC for carbonized wood, why? Discuss.

The spectrum found in the paper looks a lot like clay. Why? Discuss.

You can't, you have not presented any evidence, you repeat what you were fed by 911 truth and the failed paper which never will be on 60 Minutes to expose the big inside job that is a fantasy in Jones and Harrit's minds. Unless 60 minutes does a story on Crazy Claims about 911, Is It Insanity Or Fraud?, your claims, your fantasies no 911 will not make prime time.

It is funny watching Jones lie about 911. He first came up with thermite in Sept 2005, late to the crazy 911 truth movement. He was using his university to spread lies about 911, fired, he moved on to the paranoid conspiracy theory circuit. Then Gage saw the potential to skim the cream off top of the 911 truth followers and has taken in over a million dollars by plagiarizing the most cool sounding 911 truth lies. Lies so stupid, paranoid conspiracy theorists love it, send money to support Gage asking for more money.

Jones' paper is fodder for Gage to make money. Follow the money and you see 911 truth is a carnival side show selling fantasy to people who refuse to think for themselves. Followers, not doers, cult members repeating lies and not asking for evidence, believing the claims.

What did 60 Minutes tell you ? Have you tried to get the media to publish your inside job, your thermite is real efforts? When will you take action? Have you compared the DSCs yet? Notice they are not the same? How does Jones explain this?

Why did they fire Jones?

Jones was saying crazy stuff, and he never timed the collapse of the WTC.
My own analysis of the "pancaking" floors model (the FEMA/NIST model) combined with Conservation of Momentum considerations gives a much longer time for the fall (over 10 seconds) - Jones 2205
A simple CoM model give 12.08 seconds, which models the crush front closely, but he lies about it.

It looks like Jones does shallow analysis, shallow research.
On WTC7
the likelihood of near-symmetrical collapse of the building due to fires (the "government" theory) -- requiring as it does near-simultaneous failure of many support columns -- is infinitesimal. - Jones 2005
He ignores the fact the interior collapsed before the part he could see. Ignore reality to make up woo.

Then insanity. Broken windows are called squibs. Silent squibs?
Squibs (horizontal puffs of smoke and debris) are observed emerging from WTC-7 - Jones 2005
A lie about WTC 7, not surprising he makes up the lie in his paper of thermite.

Then he goes bonkers, offer no math, just says so, made it up.
The pulverization of concrete to powder and the horizontal ejection of steel beams for hundreds of yards, observed clearly in the collapses of the WTC towers, requires much more energy than is available from gravitational potential energy alone. Explosives will give the observed features.
No math, no physics, just talk. Oops, explosives, silent ones.
No Dr Jones, explosives would not do what you saw. The energy released during the collapse was more than enough to do what was seen; 130 TONS of TNT in kinetic energy because of the collapse. 130 2,000 pounds bombs, for each tower. Physics debunks the insane claims of Jones. No math at all, just talk.

Then more insanity, as a 1300 foot collapse with tons of steel is compared to a lone cinder block...
I conducted simple experiments on the "pancaking" theory, by dropping cement blocks from approximately 12 feet onto other cement blocks.
Wow, 12 feet is to 1300 feet as...
You can't make up stuff this stupid, but Jones did.

Then he makes up thermite did it.
The observations of molten metal (I did not say molten steel!) in the basements of all three buildings, WTC 1, 2 and 7 is consistent with the use of the extremely high-temperature thermite reaction: iron oxide + aluminum powder --> Al2O3 + molten iron. Falling buildings are not observed to generate melting of large quantities of molten metal -- this requires a concentrated heat source such as explosives. Even the government reports admit that the fires were insufficient to melt steel beams (they argue for heating and warping then failure of these beams) -- but these reports do not mention the observed molten metal in the basements of WTC1, 2 and 7. Again we have a glaring omission of critical data in the FEMA, NIST and 9-11 Commission reports. - Jones 2005
There was no melted steel. The metals melted would be those that melt in office fires. Jones lost touch with reality as he went crazy about some political bias. Later he implies the US caused the earthquake in Haiti. Jones was fired for going nuts on 911.

Like a decent into madness, Jones has to make up his conclusion, and the evidence does not support thermite, he claims it does, and he fools people who can't do research, fools people who are gullible.
 
Do any of these new hybrid materials or "superthermites" derive 75% and more of their energy output from organic polymers burning on ambient air?
Do any of these super-thermites have less than 2% Al by weight? roflmao.
 
I am not a chemist, so let me know if I go off the rails at any point.

I am confused about jtl's claims about superthermite. Thermite is a combination of iron oxide and aluminum, and the thermite reaction is a redox reaction between those two (apparently other combinations qualify as thermite, but the thermite truthers focus on the iron-aluminum one).

It appears jtl accepts that by energy, mass, and volume the organic matrix is much more abundant in the chips than thermite, by a large margin. It appears he accepts that the matrix releases energy through combustion in air. But he claims the matrix is energetic and makes the thermite super. I am confused by the proposed role of the matrix. How does it make thermite super? Am I correct that it would not do so by taking part in the thermite reaction? The thermite reaction remains iron oxide + aluminum to aluminum oxide + iron, there are no intermediate steps that include the matrix, the matrix does not catalyze the thermite reaction or anything. Then to me it seems like such a high ratio of matrix to thermite would hinder the thermite reaction by making it less likely that the thermite components come together and react.

If the role of the matrix is to burn or explode while the thermite is thermiting, would this mean that the energy from the thermite would actually be spent in igniting the matrix or would the two reactions go on "side by side" independently? If it is the former, that would imply that the mix is an explosive in which thermite plays a role, but is not in any sense a variety of thermite. In the latter case, I would suspect the matrix burning/exploding would prevent the thermite from heating and melting whatever the target was. Expanding gases fling the thermite away, so to speak.

Of course, not being a chemist, I cannot tell whether it is even possible that the matrix is an explosive, or anything that could play a major role in demolition.

At any rate, it seems to me that no matter how I try to understand the proposal, the properties of the matrix are the most significant. It cannot just be something more or less inert to hold the thermitic materials, since there is way too much and there is nothing super about that (though it could be nano). The matrix has to be some kind of explosive or magic slicing goo or something. Then the issue is not thermite but the magic slicing goo.

Again, this is mostly a request for clarification.
 
Last edited:
Again, this is mostly a request for clarification.

"Super thermite" filled a need not unlike "thermate was pushed once Jones found he had sulfur in his "thermite".

They "knew" they had some sort of "thermetic" material but could not explain the fact it was thermodynamically impossible to justify the data. They had to accept the fact this was an organic compound. In stepped a paper that mixed thermite with organic components that could tailor characteristic of thermite and wallah, they found what they were looking for "Super Thermite" . Better yet, it was new and experimental so they could claim whatever they wanted.

Give it time. I predict these chips will soon be linked to cold fusion and end all our fossil fuel energy needs. That's if the evil oil companies don't step in a squash their research. :D
 
Last edited:
"Super thermite" filled a need not unlike "thermate was pushed once Jones found he had sulfur in his "thermite".

They "knew" they had some sort of "thermetic" material but could not explain the fact it was thermodynamically impossible to justify the data. They had to accept the fact this was an organic compound. In stepped a paper that mixed thermite with organic components that could tailor characteristic of thermite and wallah, they found what they were looking for "Super Thermite" . Better yet, it was new and experimental so they could claim whatever they wanted.
The argument is then that we know superthermite exists, but we don't know its composition, so we can assume that the chips in the dust are superthermite because of iron spheres. Sounds like a bad argument. Is this really their argument?

If the composition of superthermite is known, presumably we could just compare the chips to it. If it is not known, is there any way to tell whether the organic matrix in the chips could make thermite super?
 
Originally posted by BenjaminTR

I am not a chemist, so let me know if I go off the rails at any point.

I am confused about jtl's claims about superthermite. Thermite is a combination of iron oxide and aluminum, and the thermite reaction is a redox reaction between those two (apparently other combinations qualify as thermite, but the thermite truthers focus on the iron-aluminum one).

Correct.

I am confused by the proposed role of the matrix. How does it make thermite super?

It can't. The only "super" qualities come from the aluminum metal being of smaller size, making it easier to initiate and to react faster, at the cost of reduced energy output. This is analogous to different grades of traditional black powder. Powder for priming flintlock rifles is very fine-grained, initiates very readily, and burns quickly. Cannon powder is the opposite. (One difference between thermite and black powder is that black powder's energy is the same, regardless of granulation. Another is that black powder is a low explosive, while thermite isn't at all.)

Am I correct that it would not do so by taking part in the thermite reaction? The thermite reaction remains iron oxide + aluminum to aluminum oxide + iron, there are no intermediate steps that include the matrix, the matrix does not catalyze the thermite reaction or anything.

Correct

Then to me it seems like such a high ratio of matrix to thermite would hinder the thermite reaction by making it less likely that the thermite components come together and react.

If I were to formulate some nano-thermite, probably for purposes of micro-welding, (the only use that IMNSHO shows much promise), I would want only enough organic binder to hold the reactants, which would be aluminum spheres, not platelets, roughly in the 50nm range, and hematite. No silicon, silicates, or any other cr*p to get in the way.

If the role of the matrix is to burn or explode while the thermite is thermiting, would this mean that the energy from the thermite would actually be spent in igniting the matrix or would the two reactions go on "side by side" independently?

Heat generated by the thermite reaction would vaporize the matrix, which, if oxygen is present, would cause it to burn. This would make it, at most, a really pathetic and completely useless, expensive low explosive.

If it is the former, that would imply that the mix is an explosive in which thermite plays a role, but is not in any sense a variety of thermite. In the latter case, I would suspect the matrix burning/exploding would prevent the thermite from heating and melting whatever the target was. Expanding gases fling the thermite away, so to speak.

Yes, this would prevent it being used as was the 750 kg. or so of thermite that was used in 1937 to melt two columns of the Sky Ride tower after the Chicago Exposition closed. That involved massive containers built around the columns to hold the thermite.

Of course, not being a chemist, I cannot tell whether it is even possible that the matrix is an explosive, or anything that could play a major role in demolition.

At any rate, it seems to me that no matter how I try to understand the proposal, the properties of the matrix are the most significant. It cannot just be something more or less inert to hold the thermitic materials, since there is way too much and there is nothing super about that (though it could be nano). The matrix has to be some kind of explosive or magic slicing goo or something.

Well, one could add an oxidizing agent such as potassium chlorate to the matrix to make it into a low explosive like black powder, but the gases generated won't have the velocity necessary to cut steel like TNT or RDX or nitroglycerin can. The thermite would be irrelevant.

Again, this is mostly a request for clarification.

Hope this helps. In sum, any real-world nanothermite (never mind the paint of Harrit and Jones' fever dreams) would be useless as either an explosive, or as a melting agent.
 
If I were to formulate some nano-thermite, probably for purposes of micro-welding, (the only use that IMNSHO shows much promise), I would want only enough organic binder to hold the reactants, which would be aluminum spheres, not platelets, roughly in the 50nm range, and hematite. No silicon, silicates, or any other cr*p to get in the way.

I've also seen a listing for an Army project looking into it's use as a propellant, and last year I visited an AFRL lab that made a nifty fuel-cell type device. I'm not sure that the AFRL lab used the same formulation as being discussed.
 
The argument is then that we know superthermite exists, but we don't know its composition, so we can assume that the chips in the dust are superthermite because of iron spheres. Sounds like a bad argument. Is this really their argument?
They don't sell it that way. They are breaking new ground on something they are not supposed to know about but they stumbled upon. Remember, they are selling this to a group that wants this to be.

If the composition of superthermite is known, presumably we could just compare the chips to it. If it is not known, is there any way to tell whether the organic matrix in the chips could make thermite super?

Not with the super secret military grade. This stuff is super secret ;)

Think of the intended market. They could show them dog crap and tell them it's some super secret form of c-4.
 
Last edited:
I've also seen a listing for an Army project looking into it's use as a propellant, and last year I visited an AFRL lab that made a nifty fuel-cell type device. I'm not sure that the AFRL lab used the same formulation as being discussed.

Solid-fuel rockets typically use ammonium perchlorate in a sort of gel which can be cast into the rocket, the same as TNT can be melted in a hot-water bath and cast into munitions. No packing problems as with powders. (Ammonium perchlorate is actually more stable than ammonium chlorate, despite its higher oxidation state. Perchlorates are kinda funny.)

Aluminum granules are commonly added to generate extra energy. Smaller aluminum particles will burn more quickly, and this may be of use in some formulations. (I'm not a rocket engineer) N.B. Not thermite. Combusion of aluminum with oxygen and chlorine generated by the decomposition of NH4Cl04 will generate MORE energy than reacting with Fe2O3. Ferric oxide (hematite) is a crummy oxidizing agent! I can't emphasize this enough: the purpose of thermite is to generate iron, not energy!
 
Solid-fuel rockets typically use ammonium perchlorate in a sort of gel which can be cast into the rocket, the same as TNT can be melted in a hot-water bath and cast into munitions. No packing problems as with powders. (Ammonium perchlorate is actually more stable than ammonium chlorate, despite its higher oxidation state. Perchlorates are kinda funny.)

Aluminum granules are commonly added to generate extra energy. Smaller aluminum particles will burn more quickly, and this may be of use in some formulations. (I'm not a rocket engineer) N.B. Not thermite. Combusion of aluminum with oxygen and chlorine generated by the decomposition of NH4Cl04 will generate MORE energy than reacting with Fe2O3. Ferric oxide (hematite) is a crummy oxidizing agent! I can't emphasize this enough: the purpose of thermite is to generate iron, not energy!

Rocket fuel composites with ammonium perchlorate (AP) typically contain 70+ wt-% AP and less than 30% fuel (organic binder and Al). This is the reason why the energy output is so limited, compared to fuels without on-board oxidizer. And that is why 7.5 kJ/g cannot be reached by a material that also contains excess (and thus inert) iron oxide and inert silicon compounds (silica or silicate). And anyway, Harrit et al have not observed any oxiduzer other than iron oxide - no chlorine for perchlorates, no manganese for permanganates, etc.
 
Do any of these new hybrid materials or "superthermites" derive 75% and more of their energy output from organic polymers burning on ambient air?
What temperature is reasonable for such a mix to reach?

I ask because IIRC the whole point of using thermite (alone) in the first place was the 2500+ °C it could reach, so it could melt steel, but it seems to me that that point becomes moot with this mix.
 
Rocket fuel composites with ammonium perchlorate (AP) typically contain 70+ wt-% AP and less than 30% fuel (organic binder and Al). This is the reason why the energy output is so limited, compared to fuels without on-board oxidizer. And that is why 7.5 kJ/g cannot be reached by a material that also contains excess (and thus inert) iron oxide and inert silicon compounds (silica or silicate). And anyway, Harrit et al have not observed any oxiduzer other than iron oxide - no chlorine for perchlorates, no manganese for permanganates, etc.

And, rocket fuel isn't explosive! At least, it had better not be! You can use chlorates or perchlorates to make explosive mixtures - but they work more like black powder than TNT. You could use them to destroy structures, in the manner of the Battle of the Crater (1864) or the Siege of Kazan (1552), but that's very loud, very messy, very obvious, and leaves a big hole in the ground. Shape charges with high explosives are much more efficient, which is why they're used in CDs. But they're really loud, too! There's just no way to destroy a building with explosives, and cover up the evidence!
 
What temperature is reasonable for such a mix to reach?

I ask because IIRC the whole point of using thermite (alone) in the first place was the 2500+ °C it could reach, so it could melt steel, but it seems to me that that point becomes moot with this mix.

Although thermite generates less energy than the combustion of organic materials, it doesn't lose any energy by having it carried away by the combustion products, which allows it to attain high temperatures. This, plus the greater efficiency of heat transfer by liquid than by gas, allows it to melt metals.

The "problem" with thermite gels, if you want to put them to nefarious use, is that the combustion/vaporization of the gel carries away much of the energy, and makes it difficult to confine a large quantity. (But it won't make it explosive!) Kevin Ryan's backyard-brewed nanothermite gel was able to lift the plastic lid off the reaction beaker, and scorch it, but the beaker itself was undamaged, and it doesn't appear that the iron generated was even liquid, just red-hot. Watching that video, all I can think is "Pariunt montes, nascitur mus ridiculus!"
 
What temperature is reasonable for such a mix to reach?

I ask because IIRC the whole point of using thermite (alone) in the first place was the 2500+ °C it could reach, so it could melt steel, but it seems to me that that point becomes moot with this mix.

That's pretty difficult to predict, as you'd get a lot of reactions occurring concurrently. The first (after some low-impact things like crystallisation of the polymer or dehydration of the gray layer) would be decomposition of the polymer, often immediately followed by its ignition. If you have more than one organic substance, you get these spread out over time. At some later point, with increased temperature, the thermite reaction kicks in, but hard to predict how far organic decompoition and combustion have advanced by then, already carrying off some of that material. The nano-thermite would presumably be much faster than the polymer burns, but again it is nigh impossible to predict how fast, and what the polymer is doing in the meantime. As long as the thermite has a chance to impact the polymer, i.e. heat it, cause it to decompose, or heat its product gasses, its heat gets diluted and whisked away, limiting the maximum attainable temperature. If the thermite is spent before the polymer is, all of its heat will be absorbed by the matrix, and no large temperature increase can occur.

I have computed this with somewhat different starting assumptions: Taking Basile's value of 1.7% Al by weight, and >70% C, I found that the thermite couldn't even heat epoxy by more than 270 °C. That is for the hypothetical case that you could get the thermite to ignite without heating the epoxy first. But the argument wouldn't change very much for epoxy that is already decomposing: This little thermite could not heat that much polymer by much, and since it is in intimate contact with huge surface-to-volume ratiom, it would itself be very limited in temperature.

If you assume that the organic vaporizes on its own power before the thermite kicks in, then it might get the Al to melt and perhaps also lead to liquid iron micro-droplets - but it would still be so depleted, so diiluted, that it could not do much work at all on its environment. A 25-micron layer of that stuff could very probably not even melt one micron of steel that it is directly attached to.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom