Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Where did the Harrit paper and its journal go??

Where did the Harrit paper and its journal go?? I had not looked at the paper and the whole issue in over a year until some days ago, and now find that the paper - is gone? Here is the original link to this online publication:


...
I also think it's essential that a link to Jones' ... paper is in order otherwise we won't know what we are talking about, eh 16.5? ;) :p

http://www.bentham-open.org/pages/content.php?TOCPJ/2009/00000002/00000001/7TOCPJ.SGM

I suggest people download it and open it whenever they wish to comment because it's going to get referenced alot. When people quote from the paper it helps immensely if the page number, the chip sample (*see below) and/or the diagram or graph (Fig #) is also stated so that it can be referenced quickly. ...

The link to bentham-open.org is dead, i.e. you get a message that the domain is for sale.

However, there still is the domain http://benthamopen.com
The Harrit paper was published in a journal called "The Open Chemical Physics Journal" (hence "TOCPJ" in the URL), that's how I always cite it, but I can't find that Journal any more on the Bentham Publishers website, and a search for "Harrit" in that domain comes up empty.

What happened??

Does anyone have an alternative download link?
 
Last edited:
To beat a dead horse even deader, and accuse it of crime on top of it, I have upon re-reading the Harrit e.al. paper discovered a detail of semantics worth mentioning:


As far as I can see, there are only three observations that Harrit's team ascribes to all the chips they studied:
  1. Attracted to a magnet
  2. Overall appearance of being red-gray chips
  3. Containing small (100 nm order of magnitude) grains with high average atomic number - iron oxide crystals, it turns out
(The first two are of course the well-known, and only, selection criteria, the thirs is a result that applies to all)

Here's how they word this:

1.+2.: "All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a red layer and were attracted by a magnet." (Page 10)
3.: "The BSE images illustrate the finding that all of the red layers studied contained small bright particles or grains characterized by a high average atomic number. The size and presence of the particles was found to be consistent throughout the layers, but the concentration of the particles was found to vary locally, as can be seen from the images."

Searching for the word "all" as a qualifier applied to "chips" yields two more sentences:

4. Page 19: "The data shown in Fig. (19) demonstrate that the red/gray chips from different WTC samples all ignited in the range 415-435 °C."
-> As this references Fig. 19, ot is not clear whether "all" means "all of those four (but possible not all of those we tested with DSC)" or "all the chips we tested in the DSC (including, but not limited to, those four)".

5. Page 11: "These four cross sections are representative of all the red/gray chips studied from the dust samples."
-> Here, the main reference is to four cross sections of four specimens shown in Fig. 5, but the findings in Fig. 5 are said to be only "representative" of "all" chips. What does "being representative" mean? Have all chips all the characteristics revealed in Fig 5? Or some have all, all have some?

Three more uses of the "representative" ploy:
- Page 12: "X-ray energy-dispersive spectroscopy (XEDS) analyses of both the red and gray layers from cross sections prepared from the four dust samples were performed and representative spectra are shown in Figs. (6, 7)."
- Page 12: "At still higher magnifications, BSE imaging of the red layer illustrates the similarity between the different dust samples. BSE images of small but representative portions of each red-layer cross section are shown in Fig. (8)."
- Page 25: "We show spheres found in the WTC dust (Fig. 27) and a representative XEDS spectrum from such a sphere (Fig. 28); we invite the reader to compare these results with those found for ignition of commercial thermite and for ignition of red/gray chips (above)."

I can't help it, but it seems to me that Harrit e.al. chose their wording very carefully and deliberately. They boldly speak of "all chips studied" when they really mean "all chips studied", i.e. "there is no exception", but present examples of chips or data "representative for all" when they do NOT mean "strictly all, no exception".

Hence, they say that the red layers of all chips contain 100 nm iron oxide grains aka red iron oxide pigment. We perfectly understand why: They are obviously all red because of red pigment.
But they do NOT say that "all" contain Al/Si platelets, or any of the other properties truther like to belabor. It isn't even explicitly stated that all ignited chips showed iron-rich spheroids in the residue!
This is not to say that no further property applies to all chips - just that Harrit e.al. were quite careful about what to attribute to all.

If my reading is true, then I further can't help feeling that they chose their wording very carefully with an intent to deceive readers into believing that all chips contain Al/Si-plates, all ignite around 425 °C, all produce iron-rich spheres, in all of them Al can be separated from Si, etc., even though they state none of this explicitly.



(The other day I had spotted another such detail of semantics, but can't recall now what it was; hope I will later)
 
If my reading is true, then I further can't help feeling that they chose their wording very carefully with an intent to deceive readers into believing that all chips contain Al/Si-plates, all ignite around 425 °C, all produce iron-rich spheres, in all of them Al can be separated from Si, etc., even though they state none of this explicitly.
Agree 100%!

Harrit and his group separated out their chips of interest using the magnet and red/gray layer criteria. They then tested these separated chips and deliberately decided to publish ONLY the results that supported their preconceived notions of demolition and thermite.

Furthermore, they DID NOT perform all tests in the paper on any single chip, but instead performed a few (in some cases, just one test) random tests per chip, and then applied these single chip test results as a whole to the entire pile of chips separated per above. With some clever writing, this gives the impression that all the chips they separated were some form of thermite.

This is why certain folks here in this forum who support the thermite and demolition nonsense have never come up with a concrete list of tests from Harrit's paper that anyone could use to positively identify a thermitic chip out of the dust.

A perfect example of this is the chip (single) used in the paper that had the resitivity test done on it. That chip is not shown to have been tested any other way, yet that resistivity test result is deceptively used to decieve the reader to think that it applies to ALL of the magnetically attracted red/gray chips of interest and that ALL chips studied in the paper had that test performed on it. This is why the resistivity test was picked out by some to be an important test in determining a thermtic chip even though it was performed on only one chip in according to Harrit's paper.

For the reasons stated above, this is why both Harrit and Jones refused to answer my email questions asking if they found any chips in their separated pile that were NOT thermitic or if they performed all tests in the paper on every chip.

They balked at both questions.
 
Agree 100%!

Harrit and his group separated out their chips of interest using the magnet and red/gray layer criteria. They then tested these separated chips and deliberately decided to publish ONLY the results that supported their preconceived notions of demolition and thermite.

Furthermore, they DID NOT perform all tests in the paper on any single chip, but instead performed a few (in some cases, just one test) random tests per chip, and then applied these single chip test results as a whole to the entire pile of chips separated per above. With some clever writing, this gives the impression that all the chips they separated were some form of thermite.

This is why certain folks here in this forum who support the thermite and demolition nonsense have never come up with a concrete list of tests from Harrit's paper that anyone could use to positively identify a thermitic chip out of the dust.

A perfect example of this is the chip (single) used in the paper that had the resitivity test done on it. That chip is not shown to have been tested any other way, yet that resistivity test result is deceptively used to decieve the reader to think that it applies to ALL of the magnetically attracted red/gray chips of interest and that ALL chips studied in the paper had that test performed on it. This is why the resistivity test was picked out by some to be an important test in determining a thermtic chip even though it was performed on only one chip in according to Harrit's paper.

For the reasons stated above, this is why both Harrit and Jones refused to answer my email questions asking if they found any chips in their separated pile that were NOT thermitic or if they performed all tests in the paper on every chip.

They balked at both questions.

That is the same method that he.used in
The microspheres debate.

Convince the ignorant that all micro spheres
Are of thermitic origin.

Remember he has to prove malace and intent
He will want people believing that all his
Chips are energetic not just a few.

He is on a witch hunt.and calling it science.
 
The next time someone says Jones' paper was published in a "peer reviewed journal", show them this.

http://www.vox.com/2014/11/21/7259207/scientific-paper-scam

The paper above, titled "Get me off your *********** mailing list," has been accepted by the International Journal of Advanced Computer Technology.

Let us explain.

The journal, despite its distinguished name, is a predatory open-access journal, as noted by io9. These sorts of low-quality journals spam thousands of scientists, offering to publish their work for a fee.

In 2005, computer scientists David Mazières and Eddie Kohler created this highly profane ten-page paper as a joke, to send in replying to unwanted conference invitations. It literally just contains that seven-word phrase over and over, along with a nice flow chart and scatter-plot graph

Click for the lulz.
 
And did anyone notice that the Bentham Open Chemical Physics Journal (where Jones was published) is now defunct?

http://benthamopen.com/tocpj/

"The Open Chemical Physics Journal (Discontinued Title)"

(ETA: oops, I see that was back in 2011)
 
Last edited:
Orphia,

1. Bentham Publishers may be in the same class of "predatory" open access journals as the one that accepted the "get me off your splendid mailing list" paper, but it isn't the same publisher!

2. "The Open Chemical Physics Journal" and Betham sure had no proper peer-review process - but you can't claim the Harrit paper wasn't peer-reviewed. I actually read the review by David Griscom, it was 12 pages long and had lots of brief comments, many of them concerning figures and images that didn't make it into the final paper, so the Harrit team apparently did pay heed to some of Griscom's hints. Griscom claims (I asked him directly via e-mail) he doesn't know who chose him to be peer-reviewer, and I had the impression from his responses that he was communicating with someone on the publisher's side. The problem of course is the choice of Griscom - "Chemical Physics" doesn't seem to be his main field, he is more into geology. He had previously published at Steven Jones's own "journal" and is a truther. So Griscom really is a "peer" - and wasn't anonymous to the authors, and therein lies the problem.

3. Yes, I had noticed that the journal is discontinued - a strange thing indeed!
 
Oystein
I just tested nano thermites with ceramic binder,
and organic binder.
Anything with a carbon based binder
Will not work if Finely divided and ignited in air.

The resulting carbon dust explosion ignites prior
To the nanothermites.
Below the oxidation ignition temperature
Of the nano thermites.
True nano thermites with inorganic binder
Are almost ten time more energetic when the material
Is used to heat a gas generating compound.
Fe 3O4 plasma vaporized works best as the oxidant.
 
A few years ago I collected $1000 and got an excellent but nonpublished study of the red-grey chips from Jim Millette. Gosh, if someone had $150 or so, they could put out an excellent peer-reviewed paper reviewing the Harrit/Jones paper point by point, summarizing experiments done by Ivan, Crazy Chainsaw, Jim Millette and Dave Thomas, to name a few. Throw in some of Oystein and Sunstealer's analyses. It would need to be well-written, not one of those bizarre cancer-treatments-from-Mars type papers. Preferably by a chemist. Anyone want to give it a try? We'd want to be sure it is as peer reviewed as the Harrit/Jones paper. For example, Dave Thomas could co-write it with a chemist and Oystein could peer review it. I'd do it myself but I'm pretty broke these days!
 
911 truth fail part n+1...

This is where we can discuss the fantasy of Jones' folly. Thermite did 911.

Fact; no steel on 911 showed signs of damage from thermite.

end of thermite being used on 911, it is was a silly lie mad up by Jones out of the blue. Not sure if this is as insane as his claiming the Haiti earthquake was caused by the USA, and his current BS about over unity circuits. Looks like insane claims are a continuing trend in Jones life and BS artist nature.

Why did Jones have to pay to have a fake conclusion paper published? ...


...
* Elemental iron found AFTER IGNITION
[... e.

A lie, it was iron oxide. Why list lies to support the fantasy of thermite.

For all those who want evidence for thermite...

***** No steel found at the WTC showed signs of thermite damage. That is zero evidence of damage by thermite. *****

Jones made up thermite out of the blue and fooled a fringe few. With no evidence Jones faked a conclusion of thermite in a paper which presents evidence they did not find thermite.

Not a single sample of the fake thermite had the heat energy of thermite, some had more, some had less. How do you get less heat from the fake thermite; why put proof of not thermite in the paper which claims to find thermite.

Then they take DSC from the dust and claim it is thermite, and it does not match thermite, and they include more proof it was not thermite in the paper.

This is why they had to pay to have the paper published.
In addition, conspiracy theorist were the peer reviewers; one of them says the passengers are still alive.

The thermite lie is debunked because no steel had damage from thermite. Thus the Gish Gallop of fake evidence from 911 truth is silly, and only dumbed down claptrap to fool people; now used by Gage to earn 500k in donations each year, which is not used for more than travel, suit, gadgets, and other BS. I would not be surprised if AE911T was a front for tax fraud, which some non-profits are. A scam which refunds most donations, to beat the tax on large portions of income.

Not sure how you can support lies, except how you are doing it, with the more lies.



BTW, you can ignore posts, and post your BS, you can use the ignore button, do it, and don't worry about the evidence of no steel damaged by thermite, you can't debunk the fact no steel was damaged by thermite, so ignore it.
 
Last edited:
just found some interesting pieces of research a few days ago:

Abstract:
Aluminum (Al) has an energy density (-31.05 kJ/g) nearly three times higher than most molecular high explosives and its combustion yields an exothermic release of energy ("'Hf (Al2O3) = -1676.8 kJ/mol) but is limited by surface diffusion, therefore an increase in surface area yields a direct increase on the reaction rate. Aluminum nanopowders (nano-Al) possess surface areas on the order of 20-40 m2/g and have attracted interest throughout the energetics community for propellant and metallization applications. Unpassivated nano-Al powders are highly pyrophoric and require stabilization through formation of a nascent oxide layer (2-6 nm), however, this process accounts for a 14-38% loss of reactive aluminum. To optimize the reactive Al content in nano-Al powders, UES proposes the use of silicon, deposited through a modified chemical vapor deposition process, as an innovative passivation strategy for stabilizing nano-Al. Silicon has an energy density (-32.42 kJ/g) essentially equivalent to Al and also expresses high reactivity on the nano-scale, although passivation of silicon is achieved through a 34% less dense, 1-2 nm nascent oxide, or the use of organic coatings. Therefore, passivation of nano-Al through deposition of silicon has the potential to eliminate undesirable Sdead weight and replace it with additional reactive fuel.

Passivation of Aluminum Particles with Silicon
UES is currently working with the US Army to develop new passivation technologies for aluminum nanoparticles, which serve as fuel in energetic materials. As produced, aluminum nanoparticles are pyrophoric and will combust upon exposure to air. To enhance their stability, the particles are passivated by the use of a thin aluminum oxide layer at the particle surface. This approach, however, leads to significant losses in the amount of reactive aluminum. To optimize the amount of reactive aluminum, UES is investigating the use of silicon, an additional reactive fuel, to passivate aluminum nanoparticles. Silicon passivation has the potential to eliminate any nonreactive material, such as an inert aluminum oxide, and replace it with additional reactive material thereby improving the total energy content. UES was notified June 7, 2012 of our Phase II win.
 
I wonder what those passivated AL with silicon particles would look like under XEDS?
 
and what would MEK do to those silicon coated AL particles?

Why is no steel from the WTC damaged by thermite? 13 years and no evidence for 911 truth failed CD claims, and super secret inside job. Who planted the explosives in 911 truth fantasy CD, who murdered thousands on 911 with magical thermite and silent explosives? What, you got nothing? As expected, zero evidence from 911 truth. 13 years of zero evidence.
 
just found some interesting pieces of research a few days ago:

Abstract:
Aluminum (Al) has an energy density (-31.05 kJ/g) nearly three times higher than most molecular high explosives and its combustion yields an exothermic release of energy ("'Hf (Al2O3) = -1676.8 kJ/mol) but is limited by surface diffusion, therefore an increase in surface area yields a direct increase on the reaction rate. Aluminum nanopowders (nano-Al) possess surface areas on the order of 20-40 m2/g and have attracted interest throughout the energetics community for propellant and metallization applications. Unpassivated nano-Al powders are highly pyrophoric and require stabilization through formation of a nascent oxide layer (2-6 nm), however, this process accounts for a 14-38% loss of reactive aluminum. To optimize the reactive Al content in nano-Al powders, UES proposes the use of silicon, deposited through a modified chemical vapor deposition process, as an innovative passivation strategy for stabilizing nano-Al. Silicon has an energy density (-32.42 kJ/g) essentially equivalent to Al and also expresses high reactivity on the nano-scale, although passivation of silicon is achieved through a 34% less dense, 1-2 nm nascent oxide, or the use of organic coatings. Therefore, passivation of nano-Al through deposition of silicon has the potential to eliminate undesirable Sdead weight and replace it with additional reactive fuel.

Passivation of Aluminum Particles with Silicon
UES is currently working with the US Army to develop new passivation technologies for aluminum nanoparticles, which serve as fuel in energetic materials. As produced, aluminum nanoparticles are pyrophoric and will combust upon exposure to air. To enhance their stability, the particles are passivated by the use of a thin aluminum oxide layer at the particle surface. This approach, however, leads to significant losses in the amount of reactive aluminum. To optimize the amount of reactive aluminum, UES is investigating the use of silicon, an additional reactive fuel, to passivate aluminum nanoparticles. Silicon passivation has the potential to eliminate any nonreactive material, such as an inert aluminum oxide, and replace it with additional reactive material thereby improving the total energy content. UES was notified June 7, 2012 of our Phase II win.

Wow, you're making progress in uncovering new fuels research. I'm glad that you've come to see it is useless for painted on controlled demolition or in any case without containment vessels, especially back in 2001 without a time machine.

If you want, the Air Force has a fuels lab at Wright Pat that has been working on this very thing. Just make contact with the AFRL in Dayton, I'm sure their willing to talk to you about serious, non-fantasy applications of their work.
 
I wonder what those passivated AL with silicon particles would look like under XEDS?

Small nano spheres of Aluminum embedded in silicon chips, the big advantage is reduced wear on nano particle fuel injection components, aluminum oxide is almost as hard as diamond, causes a lot of wear on the fuel injectors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom