Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Jono: IF there was somewhere in the rubble a sufficient amount and concentration of Al powder, then yes, sure, it could have reacted violently, depending on circumstances.

Is there any reason to assume there was anywhere within the pile a sufficient amount and concentration of Al powder? That would be, as far as I can tell, pure speculation.

Was there a group of midgets with saws? Unlikely, but possible. One could speculate that there was.

If we had actually identified within the pile either a sufficient amount and concentration of Al powder, or the remains of a group of midgets with saws, would we then consider it likely that Al powder, or the midgets, played an important role in the destruction of the towers? I'd say that would be a giant leap of faith without any strong corroboration that such a mechanism was in fact at work.
 
Can someone tell me the answer to this question.

If you were to press aluminium and red primer coated steel together in a heavy aggressive manner. Would you find traces aluminium in the paint ?
 
Can someone tell me the answer to this question.

If you were to press aluminium and red primer coated steel together in a heavy aggressive manner. Would you find traces aluminium in the paint ?

Empirical testing beats armchair speculation every time. I'm sure that a local high school or community college has a metal shop with a hydraulic press that one could use for a test. I'm pretty sure you would, but I don't really see the point of this. (I assume you mean granulated aluminum, not bulk aluminum.)
 
Empirical testing beats armchair speculation every time. I'm sure that a local high school or community college has a metal shop with a hydraulic press that one could use for a test. I'm pretty sure you would, but I don't really see the point of this. (I assume you mean granulated aluminum, not bulk aluminum.)

Thanks for the reply.

Please correct me if I am wrong. I understand that Millette did not find aluminium in his chips ? Yet Jones found aluminium in some of his chips ?
 
Thanks for the reply.

Please correct me if I am wrong. I understand that Millette did not find aluminium in his chips ? Yet Jones found aluminium in some of his chips ?

Millette didn't find any hint of elemental aluminium, that's correct.

Jones found a hint of elemental Al in precisely one chip: The MEK-soaked one. On this, the the facts are:
  • Before he bathed that chip in MEK solvent, he scanned its uncleaned red layer surface and found a mix of many elements, of which Al represented only a very small fraction of probably under 1% (my best estimate is 0.6%)
  • After the MEK soak, when, plausibly, some surface contamination was washed away, he first did an "XEDS" map on the swollen red layer, which shows for 5 elements (Al, Si, O, C and Fe) regions where they are present above some unknown thresholds. It turns out that Al seemed concentrated the most on the extrem edge of the chip. Since the chip has a 3D surface, and is "roundish", that edge is oriented the farthest from perpendicular to the scanning electron beam
  • He then focused the electron beam on an unspecified spot, quite possibly very near said edge, and got a spectrum where the Al:O ratio appeard such that there was too little O to oxidize all the Al, so apparently at least some significant portion of the Al in that spot would be elemental

So keep in mind: He found just one spot on one chip with apparently some elemental Al. he did not try to quantify that in any way, but with Al being only <1% of the total chip, it's a far stretch to declare that chip "thermitic".

I see several things that are fishy with that data: There is no ready explanation why the Al should be so concentrated in the rim of the chip, as seen from the SEM microscope's vantage point, which is also the farthest from perpendicular - an orientation that is abything but ideal to get good SEM-XEDS readings. Also, that particular spectrum that shows much Al, little O seems cut off to the right of the Al-signal, where there should be more noise. I wonder if that spectrum is not somehow truncated - I would have expected to see some Calcium in the part of the spectrum that's strangely flat. Also, I wonder if its possible that the Al-signal at the edge of the chip is not really at least in part from the aluminium pedestal that the chip is mounted on.

Summary: Jones's data indicates one tiny spot of Al in one chip, but from sonewhat questionable data. Even if the data is good*), it speaks foor only a tiny proportion of elemental Al in the material, much too little to make it "thermitic".




*) I am not insinuating fraud or conscious manipulation of data. My impression is that these SEM-tests were inexpertly done, a result of inapt handling. The images seem unfocused, showl little detail, the XEDS measurements were done with different beam energies, without explanation. I believe that these experiments on the MEK chip were done by Jones himselfm, or possibly Farnsworth, a grad student, while most of the other SEM-worl in the paper, which is of much better quality, was done by Jeff Farrer, the TEM (and SEM) lab manager, who surely has a lot more experience with these machines.
 
Thanks Oystein

I was thinking Al could have been present due to the aluminium cladding being compressed against the primer coated steel during the collapse.

It is possible that the rear of the cladding could have suffered from pitting corrosion and would have helped particles of Al impregnate the paint ?

If Al was found on the edge of a chip it could explain it's presence from a heavy blow ?

I've often wonder why soaking the chips in flammable substance and igniting it is a valid test, could you explain it to me
 
Last edited:
Thanks Oystein

I was thinking Al could have been present due to the aluminium cladding being compressed against the primer coated steel during the collapse.

It is possible that the rear of the cladding could have suffered from pitting corrosion and would have helped particles of Al impregnate the paint ?

If Al was found on the edge of a chip it could explain it's presence from a heavy blow ?
That's difficult to assess, I lack the tools to speak confidently on this. materials have a lot of properties that influence how they behave under different sorts of contacts: They can be brittle or elastic, they can resist deformation, torque, fracture, shearing, push, pull or cutting in different degrees, etc. You got cohesion, adhesion...

But that's speculative, isn't it?

I've often wonder why soaking the chips in flammable substance and igniting it is a valid test, could you explain it to me
Jones says they didn't do any test involving ignition with the chip or chips the soaked in MEK or any other solvent ;)
The chips they ignited in the DSC or under a flame were different specimens.
 
I agree

My post are only speculation.

I think there is no suprise in finding a trace of Al in the chips, the cladding was bolted to the primer coated steel beams.

I think if I carried out the test of rubbing a piece of pitted aluminium over a rusty painted surface I would find some trace of Al in the paint. (but I could be wrong)

Who knows, if I carried out the above test looking for explosives I could find thermite ?
 
Last edited:
Hi, Spanx:cool:

Aluminium is a soft metal (Mohr hardness 2.5-3), therefore it can release some portion e.g. when scratched over so many harder materials. I have just proven it "experimentally": I took a piece of aluminium foil in my lab, went to our yard and scratched the wrapped foil over the old steel with the rest of red primer on it. Silvery/gray traces of aluminium were visible on the primer/steel.

As for primer paints in such contact with Al, hardness of the polymer binder is probably not so important during such friction processes. More important are hardnesses of pigments, and, e.g., hematite should have Mohr hardness 5-6; therefore, aluminium can be easily "dissintegrated" when scratched over the paint with hematite in it.

Therefore I think that no pressing or hammering with extreme forces/pressures is necessary, just "ordinary" scratching/friction suffices to contaminate primer surface with aluminium.
 
Last edited:
Spanx: And now back for the Fig. 15 (Bentham paper) which allegedly shows some areas richer in aluminium in swollen MEK chip:

picture.php


After some debate with Poseidon on Oystein's blog, I'd like to comment it again here, considering that this chip was Tnemec primer with several pigments containing Si and one pigment containg Al ("calcium aluminate", according to specification). I will also suppose that pigment particles were mixed/distributed evenly in this chip before swelling.

This chip was swollen in MEK solvent and increased its volume ca 5 times during this process, forming polymer gel, which allows some migration of particles in it. We can expect that the most of pigments particles were of micron sizes or smaller, basically their dimensions were similar to the "grains" visible on Fig. 15. It can be that particles of the same/similar pigments can aggregate during this migration, creating areas with the increased concentration of these pigments. This can be perhaps valid for some silicon pigment(s), judging from the Fig. 15 d and e, since oxygen and silicon rich areas nicely coincide here.

But it seems that areas rich in aluminium (according to XEDS) mostly coincide with the areas not perpendicular to the beam direction (compare Fig. 15 c and a). We do not why, but the geometry seems to be much more important than e.g. possible aggregation of Al stuff(s) here. (And why should aluminium (or aluminium stuffs) concentrate just on the "slopes" of the chip anyway?)
Also, carbon-rich areas (Fig. 15 f) should not be detected only in some parts of the chip, since carbon-based polymer binder should be basically "everywhere" even after swelling and drying of the chip.

Therefore, I still do think that XEDS maps on Fig. 15 do not reflect the structure/elemental composition of swollen/dried MEK chip in realistic way (except the map of Fe, which is considerably "heavier" element than Si, Al, O and C).:cool:
 
Last edited:
Hi Ivan

Thank you for carrying out the above mentioned experiment.

As you are probably aware, I am not the most scientific person :o however I have looked at fig 15 and in my opinion for what it's worth. I can only describe that the Al looks like a Brass rubbing effect.

I wonder if this coincides with your experiment Results ?
 
Spanx: Hehe, I did not do any real experiment with some closer examination of Al traces on that old primer paint. I just noticed some metallic smears of Al using my plain eyes, that's all. There is a perfect weather here in Prague today, so I enjoyed one cigarette and went back to my lab. But you are probably right that when inspecting such an aluminium smear in detail, I should observe a a kind of "brass rubbing effect" (aluminium traces should be most apparent on the "hills" and other exserted parts of the primer surface).

Oystein: (Provided that pigments in swollen MEK/Tnemec chip are still distributed more or less evenly and almost all XEDS maps are more or less unrealistic.) What is the main difference between Al and other elements measured in Fig. 15 (Fe, O, C and Si)? According to XEDS of MEK chip before soaking in MEK (Fig. 14), Al is by far the rarest element among them. This is of course just "optimal" for mighty thermitic weapon:D, but anyway... Could it be that a strange XEDS map of Al (illusory concentration of Al at chip's "slopes") is somehow connected with the very low concentration of aluminium in the chip?

Still, as you noted several times, Al signals in Tnemec red primer should be accompanied by some calcium signals (since only source of Al should be calcium aluminate). I just read in Wiki that there is a whole "spectrum" of such aluminates available and some of them contain only one Ca atom per 6 Al atoms, which might perhaps explain missing Ca in Fig. 17 at least partially (if this chip is Tnemec). But I know, this is more "wishfull thinking" than acceptable explanation:cool: A completely "flat line" over ca 2 KeV in Fig. 17 is anyway rather "suspicious", as you noted.
 
Last edited:
Bumping this image analysis I did of Figure 15 for Ivan et al. It raises questions I have not seen answered.

(From message #466 in page 12 of this thread)

It's not a mere 'feeling'. The first sentence in page 19 reads:

"Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)"
​

That is blatantly false. Let's do some math. First, let's show the Fe layer minus the O layer, to see how much unoxidized Fe there is. Note that the subtraction operator I'm using in GIMP clamps at zero.

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O.jpg


That alone would suffice as a rebuttal to that sentence. However, as I noted before, there's a strong correlation of O with Si. If the O is really chemically bound to the Si, as I suspect, the following image, showing the O minus the Si, shows how much O is left for everything else:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-O-Si.jpg


Granted, that's probably exaggerated because the Si probably obscures too much of the O, but since the Si is very localized, it gives us an overview of how much O there is that is not related to the Si.

Now let's see the [Fe-[O-Si]] (the [] denote clamping):


MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Fe-O-Si.jpg


So, what's the basis to assert that "[o]xygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron" according to Fig. 15?

Where's the thermite's source of oxygen, if Si is at best a combustible in thermite-like compounds? (*)

Now, if we go to Fig. 18 we find all kinds of things in there, yet the last image shows very little Fe overlapping with O. Is there a reason to think that that XEDS spectrum has been cherry-picked, or not?

And that's not all. This is the addition of all of the elements shown:

MEK-chip-XEDS-map-Al+Si+O+Fe+C.jpg


What are the black areas? Why aren't we shown?
​


(*) I corrected this in a later message:
I made a mistake when I said:

"Where's the thermite's source of oxygen, if Si is at best a combustible in thermite-like compounds?"

SiO2 can also be used as an oxidizer. Still, there's too little oxygen in my view. And we're not shown other elements also present in the sample which could also be bound to the Si and the O.​
 
Of course you are not butting, Spanx, we are glad for any reader:cool: Just your link above is irrelevant since there is no silicon (as an element) in question here, both in paints and thermites. All silicon stuffs considered are compounds, always with some oxygen.

Interesting figures, pgimeno:cool: I think that they show (among others) why XEDS maps in Fig. 15 are unrealistic, namely it is shown by your "superposition" of signals of all elements in the last figure. Indeed, there is really no reason why they should be black areas without any C, Al, Fe, Si and O(:blush:) This is simply chemical nonsense.

To be honest, I have no idea how and to which extent various pigments can migrate in the swollen chip during 55 hours of swelling. I just think/feel that such migration is basically random process (a kind of Brownian motion), but as I already wrote: a formation of some areas rich in one pigment could not be excluded, because of aggregation and similar processes.
 
Oystein: (Provided that pigments in swollen MEK/Tnemec chip are still distributed more or less evenly and almost all XEDS maps are more or less unrealistic.) What is the main difference between Al and other elements measured in Fig. 15 (Fe, O, C and Si)? According to XEDS of MEK chip before soaking in MEK (Fig. 14), Al is by far the rarest element among them. This is of course just "optimal" for mighty thermitic weapon:D, but anyway... Could it be that a strange XEDS map of Al (illusory concentration of Al at chip's "slopes") is somehow connected with the very low concentration of aluminium in the chip?
Difficult to say...

The Almond has several times explained that EDS spectra can be bitches, as some frequencies may be more muted by absorption by matrix material than others, and that this depends on the matrix material. In particular, he said, Nitrogen is notoriously difficult to detect in such materials. So who is to say how different peaks for different elements are affected by the unidentified matrix material, and the geometry of the probe?

Imagine the Al was found only on the surface of the red material, in small concentration. Then looking perperndicularly at the surface, you have only few Al-atoms per pixel, but looking on edge, down a steep slope, you have more per pixel (which is a square of some spatial angle). This would be a theoretical explanation for why we get lots of signal on the slopes, and little in the "plains". If the Al were evenly distributed throught the 3D depth, inclination shouldn't make such a difference.

Unless it's not the Al that has a gradient perpendicular to the surface, but the matrix material: Perhaps the matrix material strongly blocks the Al signal, but the MEK soak has changed the surface of the chip such that it doesn't block Al-rays as thoroughly? Then we'd see the same effect: More Al-signal get through per pixel at the slopes.

So here I have two different explanations; none particularly probable, if you ask me, but also none outrageous, and none ruled out. It boils down to speculation.

Still, as you noted several times, Al signals in Tnemec red primer should be accompanied by some calcium signals (since only source of Al should be calcium aluminate). I just read in Wiki that there is a whole "spectrum" of such aluminates available and some of them contain only one Ca atom per 6 Al atoms, which might perhaps explain missing Ca in Fig. 17 at least partially (if this chip is Tnemec). But I know, this is more "wishfull thinking" than acceptable explanation:cool: A completely "flat line" over ca 2 KeV in Fig. 17 is anyway rather "suspicious", as you noted.
Fig. 14 shows a very high concentration of Ca - which other ingredients of Tnemec contain Ca? Are there Ca-Silicates? Carbonates?

Jones and Harrit aren't totally wrong when they are concerned about the effects of possible surface contamination before the MEK-wash. They haven't demonstrated it, so it is not valid of them to simply dismiss all the Ca and S as contamination, but it is also not implausible that some of the signal in Fig 14 is due to contamination, and gypsum surely is one of the more plausible candidates.

But as I have shown, only a part, at most half of the Ca, can be explained with gypsum contamination. Then Ca is still much more plentiful (by a factor of 3 and more by atom count) than Al, so I'd put more money on Tricalcium aluminate (Ca:Al ratio 3:2), which WP describes as "...the most basic of the calcium aluminates. It does not occur in nature, but is an important mineral phase in Portland cement." (Although Monocalcium aluminate would be the best candidate, with Ca:Al = 1:2)

Of course, the spectrum of Tnemec, as shown by Jones in Sydney, has a very dominant Ca-peak and a small Al-peak, and an even smaller S-peak, so there has to be another main source of Ca in Tnemec, other than aluminate. And I suspect Jones picked his graphs such that Ca remains hidden.

This whole section on the MEK-chip in the Jones paper suffers from a combination of lack of focus and plan, inexpertly done work on the machinery, cherry-picked results, speculative dismissals and, possibly, altered data. Tnemec is still the most plausible explanation, but I am not as sure about that as I am about chips a-d being LaClede.
 
Before you overlay XEDS maps, you need to think about how they are created in the first place.

Here is my understanding of the process:

- You scan the total area of the specimen by focusing your SEM beam on each "pixel" in turn.
- For each spot, you generate an XEDS spectrum, that means you count the X-ray returns for each energy/wave-length.
- You associate each counted X-ray with an element
- Then, in the map/image, you put a colored pixel if your element exceeds some threshold count, or leave it black if it doesn't

If you have an XEDS graph such as Fig 14, then perhaps 16% of the ray count represent C, 26% are O, 16.5% are Ca, 10% are Fe (K-Alpha), 7% are Si, 3.5% are Al, and so forth.

If your threshold value is, say, 10%, then in XEDS maps, you would have a colored pixel for C, O and Ca, perhaps one for Fe (it's right at the threshold) but none for Si or Al.

Probably all compounds in the mix have oxygen, so whereever you look, if your threshold is 10% of the ray count, you'd probably score O, and your O-map would turn out almost entirely green throughout.
Similarly, carbon should be pretty ubiquitious.
They aren't, so I'd guess that the threshold for O and C is somewhat higher.

On the other hand, With only 3.5% of the total count coming from Al, less than 1/3 of the area should light up in purple, if the threshold were 10% - it looks to me that it is perhaps that much. Since it is unrealistic that most purple pixels represent just over 10% (and not much more), it would follow that the threshold here is lower.


Such a consideration would lead to much more drastic differences in thresholds if the thresholds were not defined by some equal ray count but by a quantification of the elements, in terms of weight-% or mol-%.


I conclude: The 5 XEDS-maps presented in Fig. 15 have been calibrated with significantly different thresholds for the different elements.
Corrolary: Each element may appear more or less abundant than it actually is.


So you can't simply add or subtract pixels from one another. An O-pixel might represent 100,000 or more O-atoms, and Al-pixel may at the same time represent only 100 Al-atoms or more.
 
Thanks for that explanation, Oystein. Still, I think that:

(1) The diagrams prove this sentence at the start of page 19 false:

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)
​

There's a better basis to say that about the aluminium, given the figure!

(2) The black areas remain unexplained, even if each element was taken with different intensities. In my opinion that confirms that the various elements shown in Fig. 14 are not merely contamination. Compare with the BSE map. Any explanation of why the BSE map shows such a clear image while the combined image shows black areas?
 
Thanks for that explanation, Oystein. Still, I think that:

(1) The diagrams prove this sentence at the start of page 19 false:

Oxygen is very consistently found in high concentration with the iron in the red material even after soaking in MEK solvent (Fig. 15)
​

There's a better basis to say that about the aluminium, given the figure!
I wouldn't say the sentence is false, it just doesn't follow from the XEDS maps as shown.

I have close to zero doubt that Oxygen is in fact consistently present with iron in the red material - it is almost certainly mostly Fe2O3, the substance that gives it the red color - but that the thresholds that determine whether or not O is shown has been chosen higher for O (so it appears there is less O) and lower for Fe (so it appears there is more Fe).

(2) The black areas remain unexplained, even if each element was taken with different intensities. In my opinion that confirms that the various elements shown in Fig. 14 are not merely contamination. Compare with the BSE map. Any explanation of why the BSE map shows such a clear image while the combined image shows black areas?

These images have been made with a SEM-machine - a Scanning Electron Microscope

The BSE map show the result of detecting back-scattered electrons, i.e. electrons originally emitted by the SEM and shot at the specimen at some angle that get reflected from atoms via elastic scattering. The heavier the atom, the less energy the electron loses in that collision, and the stronger the signal. So bright areas in the BSE image indicate the presence of heavier elements, darker areas indicate lighter elements.
The directions to which the electrons get scattered is not random. The position of BSE detector influences contrast. It often is a ring concentric around the elecron emitter, a set-up that maximizes detected electrons and also gives the best results to contrast elements by atomic weight. A BSE detector placed away from the electron spource gives some of the contrast a nice 3D-effect.

For the XEDS maps, something different is measured: X-rays emitted by atoms that got excited by inelastic collisions with electrons. These X-rays can be emitted to all directions, so placement of the detector is probably less influential.


Now remember that brightnbess/intensity in the BSE image corelates with atomic weight, and that Fe is the heaviest element among the five on which we have EDS maps: Bright areas in the Fe-map should coincide with bright areas in the BSE image. They mostly do, but there is a bright BSE region left of center and above the equator of the BSE image with no corresponding Fe (and also relatively devoid of the four others). This could be a concentration of Ca (atomic weight: 40. Fe is 56, Si 28, the others lower) and perhaps Zinc (65).

Now not that the darkest region in the BSE image has the highest Al-density - that is weird. Al (26) has almost the same atomic weight as Si (28). Si-rich areas typically show medium-grey. If that left-hand slope was really rich in All, it, too, would appear medium gray, and not as dark as it is. The BSE-image doesn't have a clear 3D-appearance, so I think they used a detector centered around the electron source, and that, I think, should allow for the detection of enough electrons scattered from Al even in the slope, if it were plentiful. Instead, the dark gray indicates that this region is dominated by the light elements, C and O, even though it gives an overall low X-ray count, due to the slope.


Sooo it's all inconsistent somehow. You see a lot of Al-signal far outside the specimen, and some, but less, O and C. I still have a slight suspicion that the sample holder, which is usually made of aluminum, along with some carbon tape and perhaps a thin oxide layer, is responsible for those erroneus signals - and might even be a major source for such Al-signal on the left-hand slope!
 
The MIX

On the one hand you argue the found traces of elemental Al so necessary for this composite to be considered 'thermitic material' or not, was due to 'mis-reading' data due to angles, vantage points, orientation - "at least in part from the aluminum pedestal that the chip is mounted on", data gained by 'inexperienced technicians' where "ordinary" scratching/friction [can] contaminate[ing] primer surface with aluminum".

On the other, you freely acknowledge that 'different specimens' tested by Harrit/Jones WERE ignited:["The chips they ignited in the DSC or under a flame were different specimens."] Which were reported by Harrit/Jones as energetic ignitions [ejections] producing iron rich spheroids. A known material result of thermitic reaction.

The question remains now as it ever did.

What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom