Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Has anyone noticed in Harrit's paper that photos in Figs 23 and 26 are of the same chunk of Silvery-gray spheroids, being both Residue of red chip subjected to flame test and are seen after the ignition test of red/gray chip? Well, which is it, from a red chip, or from a red/gray chip? Let's see what they use for their flame test..... a small oxyacetylene flame (oxyacetylene is capable of temperatures above 6000F). Well, that is a surprise that the gray (iron) melted and formed sheroids at 6000F.
If that isn't proof of thermite, I don't know what is.
 
Has anyone noticed in Harrit's paper that photos in Figs 23 and 26 are of the same chunk of Silvery-gray spheroids, being both Residue of red chip subjected to flame test and are seen after the ignition test of red/gray chip? Well, which is it, from a red chip, or from a red/gray chip? Let's see what they use for their flame test..... a small oxyacetylene flame (oxyacetylene is capable of temperatures above 6000F). Well, that is a surprise that the gray (iron) melted and formed sheroids at 6000F.
If that isn't proof of thermite, I don't know what is.

Even more interesting is the comparison of the EDX spectra in Fig. 21, Fig. 25 and Fig. 26. Harrit claims that the spectra in Fig. 21 and Fig. 25 are both of "post-DSC residues". But those two spectra are quite different. In contrast the spectra in Fig. 25 and Fig. 26 are very similar. My conclusion is that the spectrum in Fig. 25 is not the spectrum of a "post-DSC residue" but of a "high temperature residue".
 
Let's see what they use for their flame test..... a small oxyacetylene flame (oxyacetylene is capable of temperatures above 6000F). Well, that is a surprise that the gray (iron) melted and formed sheroids at 6000F.
If that isn't proof of thermite, I don't know what is.

That part always bothered me. I have been looking for an oxyacetylene torch small enough to be used, as the giggling old doofus stated, to repair eyeglasses.

:eye-poppi

I have seen people use butane torches that small to solder eyeglass frames.

Is it possible that the blithering idiot doesn't know the difference between a welding torch and a soldering torch?

Is it possible that these cretins actually used butane torches for all the tests, thus invalidating all of their conclusions?

(Hint: they are not all that bright and they do not pay a lot of attention to detail.)

I want to see video of them performing their alleged "tests."
 
Hey, apologies if this has been explained already in the Jones/Harrit therm*te discussions, but the thought only now occurred to me. I know that J and H have gone to great pains to mention that some of the dust in which they believe they've identified thermite came from an apartment window frame some distance away from the WTC. They use this to answer the charge that the dust could have been collected during or after cleanup from GZ, and been contaminated by thermite used in beam disassembly.

But, I haven't heard anyone address the question of where on GZ samples were collected, AND if any were collected at WTC7?
 
Hey, apologies if this has been explained already in the Jones/Harrit therm*te discussions, but the thought only now occurred to me. I know that J and H have gone to great pains to mention that some of the dust in which they believe they've identified thermite came from an apartment window frame some distance away from the WTC. They use this to answer the charge that the dust could have been collected during or after cleanup from GZ, and been contaminated by thermite used in beam disassembly.

But, I haven't heard anyone address the question of where on GZ samples were collected, AND if any were collected at WTC7?

The Bentham article
explains the provenance of the four samples used. The results from the window-sill sample were apparently not published.
 
Hey, apologies if this has been explained already in the Jones/Harrit therm*te discussions, but the thought only now occurred to me. I know that J and H have gone to great pains to mention that some of the dust in which they believe they've identified thermite came from an apartment window frame some distance away from the WTC. They use this to answer the charge that the dust could have been collected during or after cleanup from GZ, and been contaminated by thermite used in beam disassembly.

But, I haven't heard anyone address the question of where on GZ samples were collected, AND if any were collected at WTC7?

First of all, I never heard anyone, let alone a debunker, claim or suspect that thermite was used in the clean-up operations. Thermite ist sometimes used to weld steel, sometimes to destroy machinery, but I am not aware that it is useful or even superior for cutting up debris. Do you have a source on that?


Secondly, the four samples that H and J used were (ordered by time of collection):
  • 2/b - Delessio: Brooklyn Bridge handrail, just after second tower fell, and long before WTC7 fell and any clean-up began
  • 4/d - White: 8th floor apartment about 5 blocks away from GZ, near open window, on morning of 9/12. Very little cutting of debris yet, if any at all
  • 3/c - Intermont: Loft about 5 blocks away from GZ (near 4/d), on 9/12 after lunch
  • 1/a - MacKinlay: Apartment across from GZ, collected a week later. Contamination with clean-up materials possible
They tell of a fifth sample that was analysed but not included in the study:
  • 5 - undisclosed source: Window sill, "Potter Street", undisclosed date.
Unfortunately, there seems to be no Potter Street in NYC. There is a Potter Avenue in Staten Island, about 9 miles south-west of GZ. As the prevailing winds blew dust to east-south east that morning, I doubt that this the correct location, only miniscule amounts of WTC dust would have made it to S.I.
So I don't understand how this (lack of) information answers in any way any claims of any contamination. If it was collected a long way away from GZ, it is probably mostly anything but GZ stuff. Do you have a source for the claim that Jones and Harrit used this sample for anything?



Thirdly, as the list above shows, none of the samples were from GZ, and it is impossible to track them to any individual building. However sample 2/b was collected before WTC7 fell, so that rules out contamination by either WTC7 material or clean-up procedures.


Fourthly, while I am not aware that the provenance of the samples has been discussed anywhere in great analytical depth, other than mention of the obvious problem that none were collected by experts, were expertly stored, and seamlessly protocolled. It is hard to assess the individual validity of the samples. I know however of now good reason to question and dismiss the provenance. I think it is best to assume good faith until reasons are found to be more than generally skeptical.


Lastly, you may want to check out my thread "Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?". There, we present what we think is a much better explanation for the data of J and H, namely that the red-gray chips are the the standard primer of LaClede steel company on oxidized, flaked-off LaClede steel surface from twin tower floor joists.
 
MIX

United States Patent 5,505,799


Makowiecki April 9, 1996
Nanoengineered explosives

Primary Examiner: Nelson; Peter A.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Sartorio; Henry P. Carnahan; L. E.

Abstract

A complex modulated structure of reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives while generating a working fluid or gas. The explosive and method of fabricating same involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. The separator material not only separates the reactive materials, but it reacts therewith when detonated to generate higher temperatures. The various layers of material, thickness of 10 to 10,000 angstroms, can be deposited by magnetron sputter deposition. The explosive detonates and combusts a high velocity generating a gas, such as CO, and high temperatures.

...

Edited by LashL: 
Snipped for compliance with Rule 4, and added link to source. Please, do not copy & paste lengthy tracts of text available elsewhere. Instead, quote a short passage and provide the source from whence it came.


http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5505799.PN.&OS=PN/5505799&RS=PN/5505799
 
Last edited by a moderator:
United States Patent 5,505,799

Makowiecki April 9, 1996
Nanoengineered explosives

Primary Examiner: Nelson; Peter A.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Sartorio; Henry P. Carnahan; L. E.

Abstract

... involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. ...

http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5505799.PN.&OS=PN/5505799&RS=PN/5505799

Hi Remo,

I see that you have been spamming this patent at 911Blogger, which was found by Dirk Gerhardt aka Sitting-Bull (a leading German truther with whom I had an agreeable conversation oover dinner this april) and presented by Dirk at 911Blogger in its own blog post.

This patent describes alternating layers of
  • an elemental metal (titanium, beryllium, aluminum, lithium, calcium, zirconium or yttrium)
  • a metal oxide (copper oxide, gallium oxide, zinc oxide, molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide, cobalt oxide, tin oxide or germanium oxide)
  • an organic material (only example given is carbon, which, if elemental, is NOT an organic material)
Each layer 10 to 10,000 angstroms thick (1 nm to 1 µm), and built up by magnetron sputtering.
(the patent also mentions iron oxide and manganese oxides as typical materials in thermites)

Sitting-Bull thinks this patent is interesting because it talks of "layers", "multiple layers" even, and believes it can explain in particular the multi-layered chip that Harrit e.al. show in Fig. 31.


It is very stupid to think that the red-gray chips somehow are an application of that patent or a similar technology! Many reasons why:

  1. The layer thickness of the patent is at most 1 µm thick. The layers of the chips are at least 10 µm thick
  2. The layers in the patent consists of (more or less) pure materials, in particular the metal layer is really just pure metal, and the organic layer just organic material. In the red gray chips, there is no layer of pure light metal
  3. The invention posits that layers of metal and metal oxide be separated by a layer of carbon. There is no carbon layer between any two other layers in Harrit's e.al. study
  4. The multi-layered Chip from Fig 31 is characterized, according to Harrit e.al. in their text, by a significant lead (Pb) content. The patent mentions 17 different canditate metals or metal oxides; lead or lead oxide are not among them. Its layers are 20-90 µm thick

As you can see, Remo, the material described by the patent has only the mpst superficial similarity with any of the red-gray chips, but really the chips cannpt be an implementation of the invention, or even react in the way the invention describes.


It takes a truther to be gullible enough to consider this patent "a great find".
 
United States Patent 5,505,799


Makowiecki April 9, 1996
Nanoengineered explosives

Primary Examiner: Nelson; Peter A.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Sartorio; Henry P. Carnahan; L. E.

Abstract

A complex modulated structure of reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives while generating a working fluid or gas. The explosive and method of fabricating same involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. The separator material not only separates the reactive materials, but it reacts therewith when detonated to generate higher temperatures. The various layers of material, thickness of 10 to 10,000 angstroms, can be deposited by magnetron sputter deposition. The explosive detonates and combusts a high velocity generating a gas, such as CO, and high temperatures.

.
http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsrchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5505799.PN.&OS=PN/5505799&RS=PN/5505799

Aha. So according to Sitting Bull and Steven Jones, perhaps nor Bentham chips (a) to (d) neither MEK chip were nanothermite for sure, but the strange "multilayered" chip depicted in Fig. 31 was indeed nanothermite! Since truthers have found patent on such multilayered thermitic systems!:D

Any single proof/hint for this brand new hypothesis?

Do you understand that in the cited patent, multilayered thermitic systems metal/carbon/metal oxides were prepared by magnetron sputtering? Do you know, how this method work and that it requires a complex device using e.g. evacuation to be functional? (See e.g. here).

Are truthers trying now to claim that multilayered thermite was somehow "secretly" (sic!) applied by such machines on the WTC steel?
Or do truthers think that such multilayered nanothermite was prepared in advance and then somehow "stuck" on the steel?

It really does not matter what patents truthers cite in their desperation to show that thermitic CD of WTC was possible. If they think that chip in Fig. 31 can be nanothermite, they simply must bring some proofs:cool:
 
Last edited:
In the houses of shadow.

Patent filed Sept.19.1993.
Patent filing Concludes:

"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims."

7 years between patent filed and WTC demolitions.

Those 'skilled in the art' were 'not limited' by the 'principles of this invention'.
You are arguing limitations of this particular patent, as it applies to the energetic material identified by Harrit/Jones, while not the CONCEPT, the complexity, the PROBABILITY of Nanoengineered explosives R&D being able to achieve exactly what we saw happen on 911.
Sputtering was the method in 1993 but those are 'processing procedures [are] not intended to be limiting' and 'limited by the scope of the appended claims' circa 1993.
This patent proves material OF THE KIND identified by Harrit/Jones was known and recorded by Government and LLNL in 1993. That multi-layered highly engineered energetic material 'of the kind' was being developed at the highest levels of secrecy, and that "Modifications and Changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art".
An expression of that continued development became apparent on 911.
 
So you're saying.. because it was around prior to 9/11, no further evidence is required because it therefore must have been used, regardless of its realistically impossible application, and complete lack of residue, or evidence at all for that matter..
 
Patent filed Sept.19.1993.
Patent filing Concludes:

"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims."

7 years between patent filed and WTC demolitions.

Those 'skilled in the art' were 'not limited' by the 'principles of this invention'.
You are arguing limitations of this particular patent, as it applies to the energetic material identified by Harrit/Jones, while not the CONCEPT, the complexity, the PROBABILITY of Nanoengineered explosives R&D being able to achieve exactly what we saw happen on 911.
Sputtering was the method in 1993 but those are 'processing procedures [are] not intended to be limiting' and 'limited by the scope of the appended claims' circa 1993.
This patent proves material OF THE KIND identified by Harrit/Jones was known and recorded by Government and LLNL in 1993. That multi-layered highly engineered energetic material 'of the kind' was being developed at the highest levels of secrecy, and that "Modifications and Changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art".
An expression of that continued development became apparent on 911.
I'll quote your own patent.

2. The explosive of claim 1, wherein the organic material is carbon.

3. The explosive of claim 1, wherein the reactive material is a metal selected from the group of titanium, beryllium, aluminum, lithium, calcium, zirconium and yttrium.

4. The explosive of claim 1, wherein the inorganic oxide is selected from the group consisting of copper oxide, gallium oxide, zinc oxide, molybdenum oxide, nickle oxide, cobalt oxide, tin oxide and germanium oxide.

5. The explosive of claim 1, wherein the organic material is carbon, the reactive material is a light metal selected from aluminum, beryllium, and titanium; and the inorganic oxide is a copper oxide.
Now go through the Harrit et al paper and quote from that paper the matching reactive metal and metal oxide materials.

Do they match your patent?
No they don't.


Anyone can google the terms nano-thermite and explosive and then post the result at JREF. Unfortunately you aren't bright enough to work out that your found result doesn't match what is described in Harrit et al.

1/10 Fail - must try harder.
 
Patent filing Concludes:

"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims."

Pretty much any patent concludes the same way. It's standard boilerplate test saying "This patent covers any damned thing we can persuade you it covers, even if we have to stretch it out of shape to prove it." Hardly surprisingly, people who've gone to the trouble and expense of filing a patent would like it to cover obvious variations, like using a left-handed blivet and a right-handed widget instead of a right-handed blivet and a left-handed widget, so they put a paragraph like this at the end to try to help lawyers fool judges into thinking the patent covers everything remotely related to its subject. Since judges are usually pretty smart and even it sometimes even works on them, it's hardly surprising how well it works on conspiracy theorists.

Dave
 
First of all, Jones and Harrit didn't identify thermite; Sunstealer demonstrated that conclusively. Second, there's a parallel line of evidence that demonstrates that no incendiaries, thermite or otherwise, were even used; the state of the recovered steel is recorded in NCSTAR 1-3C and no melting was observed. Furthermore, the "melting" that conspiracy advocates do forward as "proof" was the same corroded steel studied by the Worcester Polytechnic team, and that was shown definitively to be sulfidation corrosion, not melting from thermite use.

Two separate lines of evidence contradict the claim, with the ultimate irony being that one of them was provided by Jones and Harrit themselves. In the light of this, why would people even think that a patent with no known commercial product is any sort of evidence that needs to be considered? Offering that for discussion is not informed debate, it's abject ignorance of what's already known about the subject.
 
Patent filed Sept.19.1993.
Patent filing Concludes:

...
An expression of that continued development became apparent on 911.

You make a giant leap where there is no actual connection. So your argument is fallacious.

As Sunstealer points out, the material in the patent is not even remotely related to the red/grey paint chips in the WTC dust; and as others point out, the WTC dust chips are not chemically thermitic, despite the false claims of the authors of the 'Active Thermic Material' paper.

In case you want to discuss the chemistry specifically you have several knowledgeable people on this forum who can do that with you. HOpefully you will take the time to actually understand the issues rather than flailing about ignorantly.
 
...
This patent proves material OF THE KIND identified by Harrit/Jones was known and recorded by Government and LLNL in 1993. ...

Please explain by what properties you have decided that the material described in the patent is "of the kind identified by Harrit/Jones"!

In my last post, upthread, I gave reasons why these materials are of DIFFERENT kinds:

  1. The layer thickness of the patent is at most 1 µm thick. The layers of the chips are at least 10 µm thick
  2. The layers in the patent consists of (more or less) pure materials, in particular the metal layer is really just pure metal, and the organic layer just organic material. In the red gray chips, there is no layer of pure light metal
  3. The invention posits that layers of metal and metal oxide be separated by a layer of carbon. There is no carbon layer between any two other layers in Harrit's e.al. study
  4. The multi-layered Chip from Fig 31 is characterized, according to Harrit e.al. in their text, by a significant lead (Pb) content. The patent mentions 17 different canditate metals or metal oxides; lead or lead oxide are not among them. Its layers are 20-90 µm thick

Now your arguments, please!
 
Why aren't demolition companies routinely using Miracle Nanothermite? No danger of damaging adjoining property, at least in its Hush-A-Boom (TM) mode. If a demolition engineer in China uses nanothermite, will he be assassinated by Mossad agents for revealing the secret to the world?
 
Pretty much any patent concludes the same way. It's standard boilerplate test saying "This patent covers any damned thing we can persuade you it covers, even if we have to stretch it out of shape to prove it." Hardly surprisingly, people who've gone to the trouble and expense of filing a patent would like it to cover obvious variations, like using a left-handed blivet and a right-handed widget instead of a right-handed blivet and a left-handed widget, so they put a paragraph like this at the end to try to help lawyers fool judges into thinking the patent covers everything remotely related to its subject. Since judges are usually pretty smart and even it sometimes even works on them, it's hardly surprising how well it works on conspiracy theorists.

Dave

Is that like trying to use the small print, legal disclaimer at the bottom of an ad to justify why you bought a particular car?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom