Hey, apologies if this has been explained already in the Jones/Harrit therm*te discussions, but the thought only now occurred to me. I know that J and H have gone to great pains to mention that some of the dust in which they believe they've identified thermite came from an apartment window frame some distance away from the WTC. They use this to answer the charge that the dust could have been collected during or after cleanup from GZ, and been contaminated by thermite used in beam disassembly.
But, I haven't heard anyone address the question of where on GZ samples were collected, AND if any were collected at WTC7?
First of all, I never heard anyone, let alone a debunker, claim or suspect that thermite was used in the clean-up operations. Thermite ist sometimes used to weld steel, sometimes to destroy machinery, but I am not aware that it is useful or even superior for cutting up debris. Do you have a source on that?
Secondly, the four samples that H and J used were (ordered by time of collection):
- 2/b - Delessio: Brooklyn Bridge handrail, just after second tower fell, and long before WTC7 fell and any clean-up began
- 4/d - White: 8th floor apartment about 5 blocks away from GZ, near open window, on morning of 9/12. Very little cutting of debris yet, if any at all
- 3/c - Intermont: Loft about 5 blocks away from GZ (near 4/d), on 9/12 after lunch
- 1/a - MacKinlay: Apartment across from GZ, collected a week later. Contamination with clean-up materials possible
They tell of a fifth sample that was analysed but not included in the study:
- 5 - undisclosed source: Window sill, "Potter Street", undisclosed date.
Unfortunately, there seems to be no Potter
Street in NYC. There is a Potter
Avenue in Staten Island, about 9 miles south-west of GZ. As the prevailing winds blew dust to east-south east that morning, I doubt that this the correct location, only miniscule amounts of WTC dust would have made it to S.I.
So I don't understand how this (lack of) information answers in any way any claims of any contamination. If it was collected a long way away from GZ, it is probably mostly anything but GZ stuff. Do you have a source for the claim that Jones and Harrit used this sample for anything?
Thirdly, as the list above shows, none of the samples were from GZ, and it is impossible to track them to any individual building. However sample 2/b was collected before WTC7 fell, so that rules out contamination by either WTC7 material or clean-up procedures.
Fourthly, while I am not aware that the provenance of the samples has been discussed anywhere in great analytical depth, other than mention of the obvious problem that none were collected by experts, were expertly stored, and seamlessly protocolled. It is hard to assess the individual validity of the samples. I know however of now good reason to question and dismiss the provenance. I think it is best to assume good faith until reasons are found to be more than generally skeptical.
Lastly, you may want to check out my thread "
Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?". There, we present what we think is a much better explanation for the data of J and H, namely that the red-gray chips are the the standard primer of LaClede steel company on oxidized, flaked-off LaClede steel surface from twin tower floor joists.