Thread for Marc39: Jordanians and Torture

How much sugar do you take in your camel milk? One hump or two?

non, i use honey.....

what is your problem with camel melk?
its not like your kitchen isnt strange to others.

Camelmilk was the perfect milk for bedoines for example.
 
non, i use honey.....

what is your problem with camel melk?
its not like your kitchen isnt strange to others.

Camelmilk was the perfect milk for bedoines for example.

I wonder if camel milk can be a last request if you're set for a public beheading in Saudi Arabia.
 
I wonder if camel milk can be a last request if you're set for a public beheading in Saudi Arabia.

Edited by Tricky: 
Rule 12 violation edited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by tricky: 
Edited to remove quote and response to of modded post.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You should start with yourself. The unwarranted self-importance is flowing like a river out of your mouth, each time you mention critical thinking or skepticism.

If there's any place to mention critical thinking or skepticism it's here, and I think the way Marc39 posts he invites these kinds of criticisms.

I think Architect was right on in raising these issues.

And its not because I usually disagree with everything Marc says, I am perfectly happy reading opposing viewpoints. I have more respect for such viewpoints that also contain things like citations for evidence, a flow of logic and restraint.

Marc39 is usually lacking in all these respects.
 
If there's any place to mention critical thinking or skepticism it's here, and I think the way Marc39 posts he invites these kinds of criticisms.

Were a uniform rule in place requiring evidence with each and every post, then, I'd comply. However, posts from others, generally, do not include evidence, especially, the most incendiary posts. If others don't comply with the rules, why must I?
 
Were a uniform rule in place requiring evidence with each and every post, then, I'd comply. However, posts from others, generally, do not include evidence, especially, the most incendiary posts. If others don't comply with the rules, why must I?

For the satisfaction of knowing you're putting your best foot forward.

For bettering the culture of the JREF forum, instead of contributing to its blemishes.

Why wouldn't you want to take the high road?

Maybe you're just more comfortable in the gutter?
 
For the satisfaction of knowing you're putting your best foot forward.

Point taken. A review of my posts will show a balance of evidence, in certain instances, to the point of repetitiveness and nausea. At the same time, the vast, vast majority of posts in the Jew-hating and Israel-bashing threads offer nothing other than empty rhetoric, baseless allegations and vitriol. Frankly, I don't care to dignify them with my efforts to provide evidence.

For bettering the culture of the JREF forum, instead of contributing to its blemishes.

Again, another point taken, even, well taken. At my arrival, I was immediately attacked with personal insults and animus, granted, from a select few, but, the most visible few. Merely, for voicing an historical view of the Middle East and a political point of view contrary to those of others. The culture was toxic and blemished well before my arrival.

Why wouldn't you want to take the high road?

I think you're being a bit sanctimonious at this point, with all due respect.

Maybe you're just more comfortable in the gutter?

Ah, back to toxic and blemished, I see.
 
If there's any place to mention critical thinking or skepticism it's here, and I think the way Marc39 posts he invites these kinds of criticisms.

Opinions can be questioned and debated, facts cannot.

Mr. Architect's posts seem adrift in a sea of facts.

And its not because I usually disagree with everything Marc says, I am perfectly happy reading opposing viewpoints. I have more respect for such viewpoints that also contain things like citations for evidence, a flow of logic and restraint.

Marc39 is usually lacking in all these respects.

The request of evidence, when done so merely to pester and deflect, rather than in the genuine interest of edification, is a practice I've come to understand with certain posters. I choose not to indulge them.
 
To get the thread back on topic.

It's clear that Marc39 feels no need to support his two assertions:

- That torture is routinely carried out in Jordan
- That waterboarding isn't torture and that it is carried out at his university as a hazing prank

I've searched the internet for evidence of the latter and come up empty. I did find evidence of Ann Coulter saying sonething similar but I suspect that was in her role of polemicist. On the contrary, it seems that the consensus is that waterboarding is deeply unpleasant.

How about evidence of the first assertion, that torture is routine in Jordan ?

Amnesty think so : http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/MDE16/008/2006 : but they often do
Human rights watch think so : http://www.hrw.org/en/news/2008/10/08/jordan-torture-prisons-routine-and-widespread-0
Whether the UK government asking the Jordanians not to torture is tacit admission that this is the case : http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/4155806.stm
 
Marc39: The links I posted supported your assertion.

But then again you may not have read them, not wanting to derail your polemic with anything as tedious as evidence.

You're right though, I've not been to Jordan, though I do have a friend who is Jordanian (or more precisely a Palestinian Christian whose family was displaced to Jordan) so I suspect he may have a little more insight into the situation than you. Unless I've got it all wrong and you're a native born Jordanian who still lives there (although describing her as a babe indicates perhaps not)
 
Marc39: The links I posted supported your assertion.

But then again you may not have read them, not wanting to derail your polemic with anything as tedious as evidence.

I'm well beyond needing evidence of torture and human rights abuses in Jordan and the other Arab states.

I've not been to Jordan, though I do have a friend who is Jordanian (or more precisely a Palestinian Christian whose family was displaced to Jordan) so I suspect he may have a little more insight into the situation than you.

As a Jordanian Christian, he's fortunate not to have been deported from Jordan, a common practice, given the persecution of Christians in Jordan, especially against Christian missionaries who are threatened with arrest if they do not quit their jobs.

Ask him to tell you about other aspects of life in Jordan, which are not atypical of the Arab-Muslim worlds, in general, from denial of due process to restrictions on the freedom of expression and censorship of the media, to cases of forced labor of Southeast Asian and Arab migrant workers, to 17 people sentenced to death the past couple years. Honor killings of women and girls remain legal, and in 2008, at least 16 women were killed in Jordan under the guise of “family honor”.
 
Last edited:
I'm so what at odds with the reasoning behind this thread regarding one of the premises (not that of waterboarding seen as a form of torture).

What exactly are we looking for in terms of evidence? An internal memo as seen by the CIA as their modus operandi with respect to certain detainees? A lack of history of torture by the Hashemites? Seljuks? Or simply allegations and calls for investigation into torture by the Jordanians?

If the latter, then its not really that difficult to find it. Take for instance the following link:

Rights group urges gov’t to investigate claims of arbitrary arrests, abuse of detainees.

This is from the Dutch Jordanian embassy website.

What are we calling a 'routine' form of torture? Every tuesday? Post-tea torture?

This only adds to The Don's post. So how about we cease with the mudslinging...
 
The UAE also has a torture case ongoing, raising consternation that the American government maybe shouldn't be having nuclear cooperation with a country where there are problems of "rule of law" and "human rights". I like Greenwald's take:

The videos in questions involve torture by a single individual citizen of the UAE, not an entire government. The individual torturer isn't even part of the UAE's government: he never worked in its Justice Department, doesn't currently sit as a judge on a high-level court, doesn't teach law in a prestigious university, doesn't have his torture-defending speeches broadcast on national television by UAE news networks, isn't constantly defended by admiring journalists any time he's criticized, and doesn't have hordes of TV pundits demanding that nothing be done to him. Also, the UAE legislature never passed any laws on a bipartisan basis retroactively immunizing him from the consequences of his torture.​
Those backwards Arabs! Can't they crane their necks to gaze upon the "city on the hill", with its upstanding committment to the rule of law and human rights?

The individual in question has been arrested while a criminal investigation takes place. Note also that the UAE didn't destroy the videotape of the torture.
 
Last edited:
As a Jordanian Christian, he's fortunate not to have been deported from Jordan, a common practice, given the persecution of Christians in Jordan, especially against Christian missionaries who are threatened with arrest if they do not quit their jobs.

Yes, life for Christians in Jordan appears to be absolutely hellish. The oppression of the Christian minority is beyond absurd. You'd think they'd at least be allowed to gather publicly.
 
I'm so what at odds with the reasoning behind this thread regarding one of the premises (not that of waterboarding seen as a form of torture).

What exactly are we looking for in terms of evidence? An internal memo as seen by the CIA as their modus operandi with respect to certain detainees? A lack of history of torture by the Hashemites? Seljuks? Or simply allegations and calls for investigation into torture by the Jordanians?

If the latter, then its not really that difficult to find it. Take for instance the following link:

Rights group urges gov’t to investigate claims of arbitrary arrests, abuse of detainees.

This is from the Dutch Jordanian embassy website.

What are we calling a 'routine' form of torture? Every tuesday? Post-tea torture?

This only adds to The Don's post. So how about we cease with the mudslinging...

Exactly. Amnesty, for example, also highlight torture of political opponents of the Jordanian regime....but, of course, Marc has said here that he doesn't consider them to be a reliable expert source (he refused to name an alternative source). This might be because Amnesty have a lot to say about some other regimes, perhaps some he's a lot more friendly too, but we'll never know.

Turning to waterboarding, the trouble is that we all know that it is torture. Hell, even the current US president said so when he ordered its cessation. So I can only conclude that Marc made this bit up. And that's why he's refusing to respond.

So let's ask ourselves, which bit of "scepticism" and "critical thinking" the lad considers applicable? Or is he just indulging in some anti-arab, probably racist soundbites where he gets to mention camel milk ice cream?
 
. Amnesty, for example, also highlight torture of political opponents of the Jordanian regime....but, of course, Marc has said here that he doesn't consider them to be a reliable expert source (he refused to name an alternative source).

What I have stated is AI's practice of using "expert witnesses" to provide "evidence" of alleged war-related violations is inherently unreliable, and, AI has demonstrated a bias in focusing their efforts disproportionately on Israel vis-a-vis other countries, especially, those in the region.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom