Thread for Marc39: Jordanians and Torture

I'll give you a second chance.

Oh, how generous of you. What are you going to do, waterboard me?

Anything of substance related to the topic at hand?
No, aside from the very simple fact that, of the countries in the Middle East, Jordan is relatively liberal and modern. Perfect, not at all, but not the bastion of oppression and tyranny that you are portraying.
 
Last edited:
Marc39 will NOT provide evidence for his claim. He doesn't need to.

I'll imagine you wish I had not been able to provide evidence supporting the legality of Jewish settlements in Judea and Samaria, eh, which has pretty much stolen your entire raison d'etre. Don't wish too hard for something...
 
What I have stated is AI's practice of using "expert witnesses" to provide "evidence" of alleged war-related violations is inherently unreliable, and, AI has demonstrated a bias in focusing their efforts disproportionately on Israel vis-a-vis other countries, especially, those in the region.

Actually, and with respect, that's not true. You discounted them for being agenda-driven and refused to name your preferred alternative source. This is, I very much suspect, because they don't stint in criticism of Israel - who I assume you're sympathetic to - and that any credible alternative is likely to get stuck into Israel too.

So who do you consider to be an appropriate expert witness or source, then?
 
Last edited:
You discounted them for being agenda-driven...

Which they are.

and refused to name your preferred alternative source.

Refused? I don't recall being asked. There are no NGOs, at least, none that have come to my attention, that I trust.

This is, I very much suspect, because they don't stint in criticism of Israel - who I assume you're sympathetic to - and that any credible alternative is likely to get stuck into Israel too.

Your suspicions would have served you much better if your suspicions had told you that I don't trust the NGOs because of faulty information-gathering techniques and a Left-leaning bias, due, in large part, to Left-leaning funders.

So who do you consider to be an appropriate expert witness or source, then?

As I just said, I don't trust any of them.
 
Refused? I don't recall being asked.

Oh really?

I see. You don't consider Amnesty International to be experts in subjects such as torture. How peculiar. Feel free to cite an alternative source then.

I look forward to your apology. Now, what was next?

There are no NGOs, at least, none that have come to my attention, that I trust ... your suspicions would have served you much better if your suspicions had told you that I don't trust the NGOs because of faulty information-gathering techniques and a Left-leaning bias, due, in large part, to Left-leaning funders ... as I just said, I don't trust any of them.

So basically, you don't trust ANY NGOs whatsever? At all? Your own lay opinion is to be preferred to these groups? And we are, presumably, to place your own personal opinion on a par with these bodies and their detailed reports?

Or do you have another preferred source then?
 
Oh really?

No, I'm really engaging in subterfuge, in an Internet chat board.

So basically, you don't trust ANY NGOs whatsever?

No.


I just responded I don't trust any of them.

Your own lay opinion is to be preferred to these groups?

Did I make such a suggestion? That's your own [wrong] inference.

And we are, presumably, to place your own personal opinion on a par with these bodies and their detailed reports?

You presume a lot. No.

Or do you have another preferred source then?

I have already said I do not have a preferred NGO.
 
No, I'm really engaging in subterfuge, in an Internet chat board.

I'm sorry, but you were caught lying. You denied having been asked to name an alternative source, and when faced with the evidence come out with this response.

No I have already said I do not have a preferred NGO.

Reread the post. You were invited to name any source, not just an NGO.

Come on Marcus, put up or shut up. Incidentally, got that "waterboarding isn't torture" evidence yet? Or still struggling there?
 
I'm sorry, but you were caught lying.

And, you are the self-appointed honesty guard?

You denied having been asked to name an alternative source, and when faced with the evidence come out with this response.

You can't possibly be serious.

Reread the post. You were invited to name any source, not just an NGO.

I'd rather not. It's bad enough I read it the first time. Let's not double the pain.

Come on Marcus, put up or shut up.

I'd like to see you do the latter.

Incidentally, got that "waterboarding isn't torture" evidence yet? Or still struggling there?

I have someone in mind who I'd like to try it out on, and, see.
 
So let's just recap, ladies and gentlemen.

Marc39 has claimed that (1) the Jordanian regime indulges, as a matter of course, in torture of prisoners and (2) that waterboarding is not, in itself, an unduly onerous form of torture...

This thread was set up for Marc to substantiate that position through the posting of evidence including, for example, links.

In actual fact, it was Scissorhands who first provided a link to a HRW article. Marcus latterly provided a single link to a piece authored by one of HRW's directors. This latter document related to the torture of terrorist suspects and was the sole source cited to support a very sweeping statement about Jordanian prisoner policy.

We then turned to the issue of waterboarding and I cited a couple of pieces, notably one by Amnesty, which identified this as torture. However Marc intimated that he considered them to be an unreliable source as they were agenda driven. He was invited to identify an alternative expert source he would trust.

Marc has now indicated, however, that he does not in fact consider the opinion of any NGO to be suitably neutral. Well, that kinda ruins his citing of HRW in support of the Jordanian torture issue.

But it gets better still. You see, Marc refuses to cite any alternative source. He denies, in the face of the posts still visible, that he was asked to name an alternative. When queried on this, we get a complaint about "self appointed honesty guards".

Hmm. A site for scepticism and critical thinking. Or, it would appear, making unsupported statements about serious issues such as torture and then whining when you get caught out.

Readers, draw your own conclusions.
 
So in summary:

  • No evidence has been presented that waterboarding is performed as part of a hazing exercise in United States universities
  • The bulk of the evidence posed points towards waterboarding being a form of torture
  • There is evidence of torture being performed in Jordan
  • The majority of this evidence is provided by NGOs
  • None of the evidence has been provided by Marc39
  • Marc39 wants to engage in discussions where evidence should not be allowed to get in the way of beliefs or polemics
  • Anyone engaging in discussion with Marc39 should recognise this and proceed accordingly (it's quite liberating saying whatever you like without having to substantiate it in any way)
 
Am I missing something here? On the first page scissorhands provided a link from the darling of the left, HRW which contends:

Jordan should end routine and widespread torture in its prisons, Human Rights Watch said in a new report released today

Okay marc did not post this but so what?

Oh, and anyone who calls TFT "mate" while accusing another member of trolling gets full points for irony.
 
Am I missing something here? On the first page scissorhands provided a link from the darling of the left, HRW which contends:



Okay marc did not post this but so what?

Oh, and anyone who calls TFT "mate" while accusing another member of trolling gets full points for irony.

The primary failure of HRM, AI and other groups is in their bias against Israel. HRM, in fact, was a sponsor of the first Durban conference that infamously had degenerated into an antiSemitic orgy. Where HRW and AI fail, in particular, is in their flawed techniques for information-gathering for alleged violations during armed conflict. Their use of "eyewitnesses" is highly unreliable as those so-called witnesses are pressured to provide pro-Arab, anti-Israeli information since Hamas will label anyone who does not do so an Israeli collaborator and traitor, placing their lives in jeopardy. The notorious Jenin massacre, which turned out to not be a massacre, was the result of such unreliable and propaganda-tainted witness-generated information.
 
Okay marc did not post this but so what?

Because the only evidence of turture we have is NGO (HRW) information which Marc refuses to accept because he doesn't consider them reliable or impartial. You can see the logical flaw in his position here.

But in actual fact this thread is much more about demonstrating that Marc refuses to substantiate his arguments, which is very telling.
 
Last edited:
Because the only evidence of turture we have is O information which Marc refuses to accept because he doesn't consider them reliable or impartial. You can see the logical flaw in his position here.

But in actual fact this thread is much more about demonstrating that Marc refuses to substantiate his arguments, which is very telling.

For your convenience, I have reposted my previous post regarding my position on NGOs. It's not very dififcult to comprehend...
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4752272&postcount=132
 
Marc

With respect, I'm not interested in hand-waving and half-truths. The position is quite clear. You made allegations about torture in Jordan and waterboarding, both of which you failed to substantiate. The only posts in support of these arguments cite HRW, an organisation which YOU refuse to accept as reliable. You were invited to cite an alternative but failed to do so AND subsequently denied having been offered the opportunity.

I really think you've rather lost the whole debate.
 
Last edited:
Marc

With respect, I'm not interested in hand-waving and half-truths. The position is quite clear. You made allegations about torture in Jordan...

False.

...and waterboarding

What are you talking about? I've long since lost interest in what obsesses you.

The only posts in support of these arguments cite HRW, an organisation which YOU refuse to accept as reliable.

I and many others.

You were invited to cite an alternative but failed to do so AND subsequently denied having been offered the opportunity.

I'm not aware of credible alternatives. If you send me an invitation to dinner at Per Se, I might entertain that invitation.

I really think you've rather lost the whole debate.

Boo hoo hoo.
 
Marc

I appreciate that you're perhaps feeling under a little pressure here, but playing loose with the facts just don't help. What you in fact said was that:

Marc39 said:
Haha, you mean, like, water-boarding? Ooooh, rough stuff. My fraternity did it for hazing. No, in Jordan they hang you by your ankles and beat you to death. Not that King Abdullah does the beatings, mind you, he wouldn't want to get blood all over his nice Ivy League suit.


You were subsequently challenged to support this assertion. I think it's thus more than a little difficult for you to deny, as you have in your most recent post, that you made any such comments and feign confusion at the waterboarding queries coming your way.

Likewise you have quoted HRW as your sole source of evidence for torture, but don't consider it credible and refuse to name alternatives:

Marc39 said:
I'm not aware of credible alternatives.

It really doesn't inspire confidence, I have to say.
 
Last edited:
Marc

I appreciate that you're perhaps feeling under a little pressure here...

You're joking, right?

...but playing loose with the facts just don't help. What you in fact said was that: You were subsequently challenged to support this assertion. I think it's thus more than a little difficult for you to deny, as you have in your most recent post, that you made any such comments and feign confusion it the waterboarding queries coming your way.

Likewise you have quoted HRW as your sole source of evidence for torture, but don't consider it credible and refuse to name alternatives:



It really doesn't inspire confidence, I have to say.

Your posts inspire confidence? A Google search of torture in Jordan generates nearly 3,000,000 articles. Seems like I have provided a good start for an intellectually curious person who is nevertheless hampered in being clueless about what is common knowledge in the Middle East, and, indeed, throughout the world.
 
Your posts inspire confidence? A Google search of torture in Jordan generates nearly 3,000,000 articles. Seems like I have provided a good start for an intellectually curious person who is nevertheless hampered in being clueless about what is common knowledge in the Middle East, and, indeed, throughout the world.

Argument by Google doesn't work. For a start many of the sites returned are sites you don't consider to be reliable sources. Then consider that the phrase "Everyone agrees there's no torture in Jordan" would be retured in your search. Finally I searched for "Torture in Narnia", it returned 275,000 results, perhaps HRW could start work there too ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom