Thread for Marc39: Jordanians and Torture

If you're not going to back up your claims, you're on the wrong forum. Trust me, even in Politics you'll get beaten down. IPU knows I did. :D


I don't think that Marc quite gets the whole "sceptic" thing, which is pretty unfortunate on a site specifically set up to promote scepticism and critical thinking.

What Marc did was single out the Jordanians - who Amnesty identify do have a bad record on torture - without any context, for example to other Middle Eastern regimes, and at the same time on another thread he lambasts Palestinians for not migrating there en-masse. Then, to cap it all, he claims that water-boarding isn't torture but an absolute walk in the park.

Aye mind tae engage brain afore mooth, as they say here.
 
Last edited:
You're joking, right? Hang out for a while in the I Hate Israel Fan Club and you'll see some of the most outlandish claims made with no "back up" Give me a break.

And if the IHIFC jumped off a bridge, would you do so too? Honestly, I'm trying to help you here. Those guys (and the I Think Israel Can Do No Wrong Ever Fan Club) I just ignore as lost causes.

I don't think that Marc quite gets the whole "sceptic" thing, which is pretty unfortunate on a site specifically set up to promote scepticism and critical thinking.

What Marc did was single out the Jordanians - who Amnesty identify do have a bad record on torture - without any context, for example to other Middle Eastern regimes, and at the same time on another thread he lambasts Palestinians for not migrating there en-masse. Then, to cap it all, he claims that water-boarding isn't torture but an absolute walk in the park.

Aye mind tae engage brain afore mooth, as they say here.

I don't even know anything about Jordan's record in regards to torture. Being in the area of the world it is, I imagine it isn't very good but that's just me working off a stereotype. But it's not like I have any proof.

Last time I said something without proof, I at least admitted I didn't have any!

But the "water-boarding" is nothing thing cracks me up. Ask Mancow and Hitchens what they think about it now that they've both been waterboarded. "Simulated drowning" my ass. More like "recoverable drowing, usually".
 
Like I said, the poor chap doesn't quite seem to get the "sceptic" and "critical thinking" bit of JREF.
 
I think they'll settle for "a couple sources" rather than "voluminous amount of evidence".

So far, I see one provided by you and one provided by someone else. See, that wasn't hard!

Actually they are from the same source -- Joanne Mariner / Human Rights Watch.


Just sayin' -- to keep the record straight.
 
Like I said, the poor chap doesn't quite seem to get the "sceptic" and "critical thinking" bit of JREF.

I have done more critical thinking on the Middle East than most. My role in life is not to educate the uninformed.
 
And if the IHIFC jumped off a bridge, would you do so too? Honestly, I'm trying to help you here. Those guys (and the I Think Israel Can Do No Wrong Ever Fan Club) I just ignore as lost causes.

Thanks for watching my back, man. I can't believe I made it this far in life without you.

I don't even know anything about Jordan's record in regards to torture. Being in the area of the world it is, I imagine it isn't very good but that's just me working off a stereotype. But it's not like I have any proof.

Well, I do know, so, there ya go.

Last time I said something without proof, I at least admitted I didn't have any!

That doesn't mean proof is nonexistent.

But the "water-boarding" is nothing thing cracks me up. Ask Mancow and Hitchens what they think about it now that they've both been waterboarded. "Simulated drowning" my ass. More like "recoverable drowing, usually".

Water-boarding is unpleasant. At the same time, it's not torture. Don't be a wuss, we're dealing with mass murderers.
 
Water-boarding is unpleasant. At the same time, it's not torture. Don't be a wuss, we're dealing with mass murderers.

Firstly, let's look at what expert sources say about waterboarding:

http://www.amnestyusa.org/document.php?id=ENGUSA20090429003&lang=e

http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2008/apr/22/advertising.humanrights

So, erm, bit of a fail for you there.

Secondly, why do you assume that they're "mass murderers"? What happened to innocent until proven guilty?

But last of all, we have your answer when asked to cite sources and evidence:

Well, I do know, so, there ya go.

That's right, we've to believe you because you said so. Great bit of critical thinking there, Marc. Absolutely fantastic.
 
Last edited:

I don't accept Amnesty Int'l nor the London Guardian as expert witnesses.

So, erm, bit of a fail for you there.

Ya think? That's the best you can do?

Secondly, why do you assume that they're "mass murderers"? What happened to innocent until proven guilty?

Jihadists are not accorded the rights of habeas corpus.
 
I don't accept Amnesty Int'l nor the London Guardian as expert witnesses.

I see. You don't consider Amnesty International to be experts in subjects such as torture. How peculiar. Feel free to cite an alternative source then.

Jihadists are not accorded the rights of habeas corpus.

Legal source? Where does the US criminal system make this exception?
 
I see. You don't consider Amnesty International to be experts in subjects such as torture. How peculiar. Feel free to cite an alternative source then.

AI are agenda driven. They are not unbiased witnesses.

Legal source? Where does the US criminal system make this exception?

Jihadists, for the most part, are not US citizens.
 
AI are agenda driven. They are not unbiased witnesses.

So you say. But really, cite your preferred alternative source(s) then. Put up, or shut up.

Jihadists, for the most part, are not US citizens.

You've not answered the point put to you in any substantive manner. I suggest you reread my post.
 
So you say. But really, cite your preferred alternative source(s) then. Put up, or shut up.



You've not answered the point put to you in any substantive manner. I suggest you reread my post.

Point? There's a point?
 
Then prove it. Cite sources and evidence.

You do realize this request is a waste of time. I have Marc on ignore because he never, ever, provides evidence, links, quotes, citations, paraphrases, etc.

His posts are just full of arrogance, hot air, condescension, know-it-all, and pure crappola.
 
You do realize this request is a waste of time. I have Marc on ignore because he never, ever, provides evidence, links, quotes, citations, paraphrases, etc.

His posts are just full of arrogance, hot air, condescension, know-it-all, and pure crappola.

Still upset I pointed out the several UN resolutions you had suggested invalidated Jewish settlement in the WestBank are not legally binding? Sorry about that one.
 
You do realize this request is a waste of time. I have Marc on ignore because he never, ever, provides evidence, links, quotes, citations, paraphrases, etc.

His posts are just full of arrogance, hot air, condescension, know-it-all, and pure crappola.

I've found that such threads are very useful for casting back in the face of such trolls at later stages. I am minded of DDs thread about parents being allowed to kill their children without any punishment, or just about anything posted by those who oppose state organised universal healthcare.
 
There is a college or university in the United States that uses waterboarding as a means of hazing?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom